Question Locked

Vista Remote Desktop behind router problem

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have a couple Vista PCs on my local home network behind a router. Port forwarding works fine. I can externally remote to internal XP PCs fine. Internally I can remote to the Vista PCs fine using their IP addresses. But I can not remote to the Vista PCs externally. I get the "The client could not connect to the remote computer" message. I have tried 3 different routers all the same (one flashed with DD_WRT). I triwed Radmin instead of windows remote desktop and the exact same symptoms.

9 replies

by timothy_herritt

Hello;

I have the same problem you?re experiencing with remote desktop. Was wondering if you ever found a solution? If so, let me know.

by cg it

from what you said, you can remote in from outside, inside you can remote in, but you can't externally do what? Remote Desktop to multiple computers?

RDD in using port forwarding is to a single address on the LAN on consumer level routers.

if you want to RDD to multiple computers, you can't have port forwarding to a single address.

by paul

from outside i can remote to any XP pc but not any Vista pc (all using port forwarding .... setting each up individually)

from inside i can remote to any XP or vista pc just fine.

vista does not seem to like seeing remoting into any of my vista pc's via thtu router.

by rechno

I have the same problem. I've reloaded Vista (since it was a new machine) and ran all updates. It occurs with RDC / Terminal Services to Server 2000, Server 2003, and Server 2003 R2. I can connect for about 1/2 second and most icons appear, then the session locks up and eventually gives an error that I was disconnected unexpectedly.
Note: this occurs with VNC as well except that the session will last as little as 15 seconds and up to around a minute.
Also by the by, Vista with Office 2007 Outlook will not connect to a POP server on the Internet to download more than 15k-18k of data.
These 3 problems are the only (and very significant from a network admin standpoint) challenges that Vista presents.
It would do Microsoft well to respond to these posts and to the many emails that they have received. I and many others who know of these problems do not plan to "roll out" Vista until they are corrected.
Andrew - login by "you will bug-mee-n0t" - thanks

by t1gg3rt1gg3r

You mentioned that you have Vista and Outlook 2007 and that you are not able to download more than 15K-18K of data when connected to a POP server.

You must be doing something wrong, because I've rolled out vista to about 25% of my employees and they are all connecting to the POP server just fine.

Is the pop server you are trying to connect to your companies pop server or another pop server on the internet?

by t1gg3rt1gg3r

I wasn't sure whether or not I had this problem so I tried it from one of our Vista machines to a couple of our servers. I didn't have any trouble. Occasionally I do have to log in twice because it attempts to use the domain that I'm in instead of the domain that I specify at the login credentials.

Check firewalls on your two machines or between the two machines. If you want a simple test turn off the firewalls on both machines and then connect them both to the same switch and then give it a try, it will work.

by t1gg3rt1gg3r

The fact that both of these products won't connect point to that there is likely a firewall between these two or that there is firewall or security software causing the problem.

by vandy-sj

I had the same problem until today. I need to credit Mark Minasi with the helpful suggestion - that worked!

I could RDP locally using the local (LAN) IP address, but when I tried to RDP locally or remotely using one of my public Internet IPs (through a 'one-to-one NAT' assignment in my firewall) I received a ?Your credentials did not work? RDP error message (logon attempt failed).

Mark suggested I disable IPv6 (Internet Protocol 6 (TCP/IPv6) ? unchecked within Local Area Connection Properties of my NIC), and that allowed my to RDP locally and remotely using my public Internet IP.

I assume there is some conflict running Vista IPv6 protocol on a IPv4-based network, which blocks access using a IPv4 Internet address to access your Vista machine remotely. I'm not sure about my assumption, but it appears to be true.

Can anyone besides me confirm this solution? Can anyone explain why?

This discussion is closed to new replies.