Discussion Locked

VPN IPSec Satellite - Won't play nice

0 helpful
39 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a simple VPN setup for a few remote users. The purpose of the VPN is to simply allow remote access to the company LAN from one's home, and possibly from a laptop on the road. All remote clients up to now have been using either dial-up or broadband for their Internet connection.

At the office end of the VPN is a Linksys BEFVP41 router. A specific VPN tunnel is created at this router for each remote client. (As many as 70 separate tunnels are possible, but I plan to create only about 6.) At the remote client end, I'm using SSH Sentinel IPSec client software. After the SSH software is configured, the remote user opens the VPN connection and simply maps a network drive to the office LAN. It works pretty slick.

One remote user, however, is using a satellite Internet connection, and it just doesn't want to play nice with my plan. I haven't been able to confirmed this, but I suspect that the satellite ISP - DirectWay - has problems with IPSec protocol. Their tech support folks claim that it "should" work with a VPN using IPSec, but it "has to be setup correctly". (Talk about stating the obvious!) However, they can't support VPN connections and won't talk about it at all, so other than saying that it "should" work with IPSec, they aren't any help at all.

(continued in comment...)

39 replies

by maxwell edison

.....continuation of question:

I've tried using all available encryption options - DES, 3DES, and disabled. I've tried using all available authentication options - MD5, SHA, and disable. Nothing I've tried up to now will work. Why not use a protocol other than IPSec, you might ask? Well, the BEFVP41 router does not support PPTP or L2TP. Use a different ISP, you might suggest. Other than dial-up (which my last option), there are no other Internet options at this particular remote location. And a dedicated T1 line is too expensive.

My bottom line question is this. Does anyone have any ideas on how I might get this satellite remote user connected through the existing BEFVP41 router using IPSec protocol?

Additional question: Any otherideas out there? (Keep in mind that I'd hate to have to change the whole setup - including the remote clients that work - just to accommodate this one problem. But I might have to - this is an IMPORTANT remote user.)

by cactus pete

I just made a quick check for Directway and IPsec... Seems some people believe that the company closed the ports necessary for IPsec traffic.

If you can call them again [and hopefully get an engineer] see if they can confirm that ports 50/51 and500 are open.

Otherwise, just for this user perhaps, you might get a clunker PC and load Linux on it for his own VPN server... It would cost you another IP address and some space in the closet, but it would be a down and dirty project for you.

by cactus pete

OK, so my initial poking about shows you likely have a latency issue, but I haven't seen anything that allows you to account for this, or create an allowance for a slow connection.

by cactus pete

Max - It's a short 'i'.

The Linux box would sit on your lan, not at the client site, and simply would be configured as something other than an IPSec VPN server. I'll poke around some more for appliances that provide this, perhaps there's something pretty cheap.

As for learning Linux, you barely need to anymore, but that's all another story for later.

by maxwell edison

Thanks for all your comments. I've looked into every one of them, but to no avail. This Direcway satellite system just doesn't want to work with IPSec - at least not with the basic equipment. The high dollar solution I found would have probably worked, but the cost couldn't be justified for this particular location. As an alternate, I'm using a dialup adapter for this VPN connection until broadband cable is installed in the area. Yes, it's slow. but at least it's connected. Thanks again.

by oz_media

Hi Max, sounds like a bit of a headache.
From reading the last post, I understand that the satellite signal is having latency problems due to the intense distance.
NEC has several VPN/ipSec accelerators available but I don't know if they will resolve and issue with latency as great as what you're facing. They are designed (similar to the routers you use now)for VoIP and WAN latency problems with a built-in accelerator.
I have used a few of the high end products for a large VoIP network on Vancouver Island but would recommend contacting NEC's engineers regarding your specifics.

you may also want to look at NEC's QOS products. They will connect ONLY if bandwidth and latency meet configurable specifications, this is generaly used onlyfor voice (VoIP)but are also rated as the best QOS products available.

NEC's routers have become the industry leader for consistent VoIP and IPSec networking.

It is worth sending their techs an email stating your situation and seeing what solutions they offer. I know that their equipment is MUCH more robust than what other networking companies are offering.

My 2 cents. Keep the change. :-)

This is of course if the company has the budget to do so, and if you don't mind swapping out equipment.

by maxwell edison

dpetrak,

I've also seen the theory about certain ports being closed, but DirecWay can neither confirm or deny the truth to that. I'll be calling them again, however, to try to get a little higher up their tech support food chain for confirmation one way or the other. As far as using Linux as his own VPN server, I suppose it's possible, but two things would have to happen. First, I would have to learn Linux. I know absolutely nothing about it. (In fact, I still don't know if it's pronounced with a long or short i.) Second, this DirecWay satellite setup requires its own server already, and they have a Windows 2000 Professional (or 2000 Server) requirement. (At least that's what their "on location" tech told me.) That's not to say it couldn't work, but I'd have some big hoops to jump through.

Before I change to (or create) plan-b, I'm not yet convinced that it can't be done. (Don't ask if, ask how.) I'm still looking for an alternative IPSec client other than SSH Sentinel. I'm also looking at changing the office router to one that can handle both IPSec and PPTP, or a router-to-router possibility that uses IPSec instead of PPTP, but everything I've seen up to now indicates that may not be possible - at least not in a reasonable price range. But I'm open to ideas.

OzMedia,

I'm already over-budget and behind schedule. Changing too much would not go over very well, especially if the cost was significant. Spending a few hundred dollars on a different router or a different client software is one thing, but if I had to start adding zeros to the cost of this, it just wouldn't happen.

by joseph moore

But I think I finally found the document for you to read, from SANS:

http://www.sans.org/rr/papers/20/770.pdf

Called "Issues When Using IPSec Over Geosynchronous Satellite Links", this is your situation. Here is the first paragraph:

"Satellite based broadband data networks provide the means to convey large volumjes of TCP traffic to individuals and organizations over an enormous geographic area. Satellite based networks can also convey data for countless types of applications. However they are vulnerable to eavesdropping like any other wireless network and may be just one of many networks that user data traverses, thus employing IPsec would appear to be a logical end-to-end security solution....

by joseph moore

"However, when IPsec is used, TCP headers MAY BE encrypted (emphasis added). TCP can suffer from poor performance over networks with high latency as is the case for geosynchronous satellite links. Performance anhancing proxies serve to optimize protocol performance over satellite links by examining transport layer (TCP) headers. Since IPsec obscures the TCP headers which proxies rely upon, the two technologies seem incompatible.

by joseph moore

It then states that "A tradeoff solution and its security implications are then presented. More research in the area of IPsec used in conjunction with performance enhancing proxies is needed to meet security and performance needs of satellite network users".

Wheh!

by joseph moore

The doc then talks about satellite communications, its inherint lack of security, and a method an attacker could exploit it by getting their own VSAT connection.

Then it gets to IPsec and satellite.

From what I am seeing in this document, the technology just is not there yet to do this. The doc talks about using PEPs (performance enhancing proxies) that can speed up the transmission on both ends of the satellite link. That would seem to help out with the latency problems in satellite communications and VPN problems. But, the PEPs can't read the encrypted TCP headers (due to the IPsec tunnel), so it doesn't work.

by maxwell edison

Thanks for all your comments. I've looked into every one of them, but to no avail. This Direcway satellite system just doesn't want to work with IPSec - at least not with the basic equipment. The high dollar solution I found would have probably worked, but the cost couldn't be justified for this particular location. As an alternate, I'm using a dialup adapter for this VPN connection until broadband cable is installed in the area. Yes, it's slow. but at least it's connected. Thanks again.

by tomhass

Hi

Issues can affect this:-

1. Latency (it is well known that latency issues affecting Windows networking - you have to tweak registry/hack Windows to kinda make it work)

2. Your IP address will be encapsulated with a different return address (i.e. when you click website it will go back via DirecWay NOC, not directly to your PC).

3. Caching technology being used by satellite provider

4. Blocking (or not enabling) ports required for VPN

5. Satellite providers would like to provide their own tailored VPN services (at a premium, of course !).

Hope it helps.

Tom

by maxwell edison

Thanks for all your comments. I've looked into every one of them, but to no avail. This Direcway satellite system just doesn't want to work with IPSec - at least not with the basic equipment. The high dollar solution I found would have probably worked, but the cost couldn't be justified for this particular location. As an alternate, I'm using a dialup adapter for this VPN connection until broadband cable is installed in the area. Yes, it's slow. but at least it's connected. Thanks again.

by maxwell edison

A possible answer to my own question:

I've continued to research this thing, and found something I thought some people might be interested in seeing.

Links:

http://www.skycasters.com/

http://www.skycasters.com/broadband-satellite-compare/compare.html

http://www.skycasters.com/broadband-satellite-internet-access/index.html

http://www.skycasters.com/broadband-satellite-internet-access-about-skycasters/index.html

Talking to the sales rep from skycasters, he said - in all seriousness - that he (skycasters) was the ONLY person (only company) in America that could provide what I want, which is a VPN using IPSec through a satellite connection.

Cost - $2400 set up fee (which includes some Cisco
equipment) plus $150 month. Coordination between their main office, their field tech (an independent contractor, I presume), and myself (at both of my locations - 75 miles apart) will be necessary.

I think it may be a feasible option, and, even though I indicated that budgetrestraints was a big consideration, I may just do it. This possibility warrants a bit more research.

Any comments/opinions on this?

by maxwell edison

dpetrak,

That SnapGear router that supports BOTH IPSec AND PPTP looks promising. As I indicated (somewhere in the course of these conversations), for this particular remote user, using PPTP, even though it's slower and less secure than IPSec, would be a viable option.

Thanks for the link.

by oldefar

The issue of latency is certainly valid, and the issue of blocked ports is a real possibility. So is the NAT used by the standard (home) DirecWay ISP service. It effectively kills inbound files transfer via ICQ while having no impact on outbound files - an issue of who initiates the session and assigns ports.

The quick approach would be to convert the user to DirecWay Professional to gan the static IP and larger buffers. However, this is still guessing at the problem.

Maybe it is time to take this out of the realm of speculation? Compare the packet transmission from the remote user on DirecWay with the packet reception at your host site. For analysis purposes, first do the same with a working dialup or DSL user. In each case, do it on the path where the VPN is in place. While you won't be able to decode much, you will be able to determine the sequence of establishing the VPN and will be able to validate it if the satellite link changes the raw data.

Contact me if you want additional support. HNS used to be a partner in a former life. I still have some resources I can tap into to.

by maxwell edison

Thanks for all your comments. I've looked into every one of them, but to no avail. This Direcway satellite system just doesn't want to work with IPSec - at least not with the basic equipment. The high dollar solution I found would have probably worked, but the cost couldn't be justified for this particular location. As an alternate, I'm using a dialup adapter for this VPN connection until broadband cable is installed in the area. Yes, it's slow. but at least it's connected. Thanks again.

by riverfreight

Okay, its ugly time; Do you have Satelite send/receive authority? Check with the Navy to get to the correct people. - Do you have some kind of access interface authority? Same people. - What are your perogatory proiorities; It still could be a mainframe that is the middle man, ie the satelites computer, and you have language translation problems - the classic example that I was exposed to in school was translating to japaneese from english and then having to translate the same message that originated in Japaneese, it is worse to translate the message back to english when it originates in english especially American English. Does the customer have the authority to use the satelite? If the customer is in another country or traveling thru other countries they have different rules and authorities and your customer can end up in jail at the least with your people who go on site to solve and resolve issues - again go thru the Navy as they usually get the ugly short stick in these matters and can direct you to where you want to go.

RIVER FREIGHT

by riverfreight

In my answer #6 I omitted the most common of solutions, erk! Check to see if the customer; it might also be you - you boyh may need to have them - thus see if you have the right kinds of BIO's Chips & I/O's chips this is also a common problem.

RIVER FREIGHT

by punderwood

As far as I know VPN IPSec traffic over Satellite is not a supported solution. This is due to the latency that is introduced. However I know a few people who have some instances of it working, but it has not been stable. Bottom line is that it will never work satisfactorily.

by maxwell edison

Thanks for all your comments. I've looked into every one of them, but to no avail. This Direcway satellite system just doesn't want to work with IPSec - at least not with the basic equipment. The high dollar solution I found would have probably worked, but the cost couldn't be justified for this particular location. As an alternate, I'm using a dialup adapter for this VPN connection until broadband cable is installed in the area. Yes, it's slow. but at least it's connected. Thanks again.

by lordinfidel

Hey max....

ok... we know that your end works.... so no need to drive yourself crazy looking at your vpn server.

So let's concentrate on the remote end.

Assuming that direct way's comments are true, that they are not blocking IPSec traffic. (They sould'nt but you never know).

The question is what *are* you using on your end? Is it PPtP, IPSec using DES/3DES?

I would assume that the remote client is NAT'd thru their connection. Now if they are using a dsl router, like a netgear,they have to enable port triggers and forwarding for 500 or else the connection will not work.

That would be one of the 1st places I look.

The next place, would be to have him dial-up to the net using a dial-up account. And try to connect that way. Make sure that it is not his system first before you go blaming his dsl router or ISP.

Also is the end user using a personal firewall? That would most defintely block traffic.

And of course what does your logs say? If you see a connection attempt from him, but it fails. Then it is because GRE could not set up the tunnel back thru the NAT device.

And yes... it is short i - linux

like pin ux change p to an l

by lordinfidel

Another place to get some help is thru security-focus.

They have a vpn list also. Just go to security-focus.com go to the lists section (far right hand side near bugtraq)

Check off the box for the vpn list, and subscribe. It's not a heavy list like bugtraq or incidents. But pose the question to the list and see what comes back.

by maxwell edison

Thanks for all your comments. I've looked into every one of them, but to no avail. This Direcway satellite system just doesn't want to work with IPSec - at least not with the basic equipment. The high dollar solution I found would have probably worked, but the cost couldn't be justified for this particular location. As an alternate, I'm using a dialup adapter for this VPN connection until broadband cable is installed in the area. Yes, it's slow. but at least it's connected. Thanks again.

by maxwell edison

Question to Joseph Moore (or anyone else who can answer):

How in the heck did you get your comment posted in MY comments section? And Leopold did not post an answer to this question - in answer number 4 or elsewhere. (That was Tom in answer 4.)Did you pull a bit of magic here, of was there some kind of TR glitch?

Interesting, don't you think?

This discussion is closed to new replies.