Can you provide a reference for the cases of "wardriving" in the context of this thread bieng upheld as legal? as well as references to the affirmative aspect of use of open networks whether use is known or implied to be authorized or not? Perhaps providing references to support your argument may help.
Here is a legal reference from the State of CT, and several others as well as some of the revised federal laws: (Please note that is states a person committs a computer crime when they violate and section of the statute.) Computer crime implying illegal. Also note that any action which causes harm to the network etc.. is included whether intentional or recklessly.
-------------------------------------------------
Sec. 53a-251. Computer crime.
(a) Defined. A person commits computer crime when he violates
any of the provisions of this section.
(b) Unauthorized access to a computer system. (1) A person is
guilty of the computer crime of unauthorized access to a computer
system when, knowing that he is not authorized to do so, he
accesses or causes to be accessed any computer system without
authorization.
(2) It shall be an affirmative defense to a prosecution for
unauthorized access to a computer system that: (A) The person
reasonably believed that the owner of the computer system, or a
person empowered to license access thereto, had authorized him to
access; (B) the person reasonably believed that the owner of the
computer system, or a person empowered to license access thereto,
would have authorized him to access without payment of any
consideration; or (C) the person reasonably could not have known
that his access was unauthorized.
(c) Theft of computer services. A person is guilty of the
computer crime of theft of computer services when he accesses or
causes to be accessed or otherwise uses or causes to be used a
computer system with the intent to obtain unauthorized computer
services.
(d) Interruption of computer services. A person is guilty of
the computer crime of interruption of computer services when he,
without authorization, intentionally or recklessly disrupts or
degrades or causes the disruption or degradation of computer
services or denies or causes the denial of computer services to an
authorized user of a computer system.
(e) Misuse of computer system information. A person is guilty
of the computer crime of misuse of computer system information
when: (1) As a result of his accessing or causing to be accessed a
computer system, he intentionally makes or causes to be made an
unauthorized display, use, disclosure or copy, in any form, of data
residing in, communicated by or produced by a computer system; or
(2) he intentionally or recklessly and without authorization (A)
alters, deletes, tampers with, damages, destroys or takes data
intended for use by a computer system, whether residing within or
external to a computer system, or (B) intercepts or adds data to
data residing within a computer system; or (3) he knowingly
receives or retains data obtained in violation of subdivision (1)
or (2) of this subsection; or (4) he uses or discloses any data he
knows or believes was obtained in violation of subdivision (1) or
(2) of this subsection.
(f) Destruction of computer equipment. A person is guilty of
the computer crime of destruction of computer equipment when he,
without authorization, intentionally or recklessly tampers with,
takes, transfers, conceals, alters, damages or destroys any
equipment used in a computer system or intentionally or recklessly
causes any of the foregoing to occur.
By the language of this statute one must "reasonably know" that the access is authorized with no expectation of repayment. And the owner would need to "reasonably know" that the access is authorized or unauthorized.
By this statute the definition of wardriving as in the context of this discussion would be viewed as illegal - although one could always make the argument of "ignorance of the law" or the current state of the WAP device "implies" consent. - Ignorance of the law works both ways by the way, so understanding what "authorized" and "unauthorized" access is as defined is important here as well.
-------------------------------------------------
The reason folks are still discussing this is that end users as they become more aware of the technology - and those who seek to intentionally take advantage of consumers - the consumers become angry and seek redress against opportunitistic "poachers". As consumers seek answers they look to IT professionals for answers, both technically and sometimes legall.
By your post - your open network would be ok to access as you "reasonably know" that people will access this as it was your intent to provide this to them. Now let's suppose for a moment, that for some reason the protection you enabled on your "secure", "closed" or "prviate" net became disabled (for this argument a technical issue caused the security to be disabled.) and a "wardriver" accessed this net with no intent of doing damage, but caused a DoS on the net. Was the action of the wardriver legal or illegal? you did everything reasonable that you were aware of to prevent this, but through no fault of your own your "prviate" net became "public" and as a result now incurrs damage. WIll you our your company attempt to seek redress? or call this illegal? - some points to ponder on this topic.