Question Locked

Web Design for Multiple Resolutions

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The company I work for is doing a complete re-design of our internet site. I've been asked to provide a few ideas and standards that I think should be applied and I'm after a little guidance on what is reasonable.

Something that drives me nuts are sites that don't resize and render using the full screen when I'm running higher than 1024x768 screen res.

While I accept that a design should be "optimised" for a specific resolution, that doesn't mean it can't be written in such a way as to resize intelligently and re-arrange the pages to suit other resolutions.

Is it reasonable to expect a new CSS based site to do this?

Similarly, is it reasonable to require the site to work correctly regardless of the text size I set in my browser? Many of the sites I use don't work at all well if the text size increased.

Thanks for any input.

10 replies

by beauregard t. shagnasty

Resolution is unimportant. So is browser window size.

For the content font size, use 100% instead of pixels. See:
http://k75s.home.att.net/fontsize.html
and the related links on this page.

Here is a template I like for flexible web pages:
http://www.benmeadowcroft.com/webdev/csstemplates/left-column.html

You should also use HTML 4.01 Strict doctype and be sure that your pages validate at:
http://validator.w3.org/
http://jigsaw.w3.org/css-validator/validator.html

Google for: CSS two column template

by siau89

HTML 4.01 Strict? You mean XHTML 1.1 I hope?
For font-size, use: xx-small, x-small, small, medium, large, x-large or xx-large.
If you make a site with absolute positioning, it won't be scalable.

by beauregard t. shagnasty

No, I don't mean XHTML (any version). IE6 cannot render XHTML. HTML 4.01 Strict is what you want for a public web site. If you doubt me, ask this question in alt.html or comp.infosystems.www.authoring.html, or search google groups where the same question is asked every week, and the answer is always "don't use XHTML."

You also don't want to use the "xx-small" etc words for similar reasons. Did you read the link I posted: http://k75s.home.att.net/fontsize.html ?

by pixelsurge

HTML 4.01 Strict is the latest HTML standard. When HTML 5.0 comes out I will use HTML 5.0. If you use XHTML 1.0 or 1.1, you have to serve it as text/html because IE doesn't understand XHTML. So if you're serving it as HTML, there's no point in using XHTML anyway. It offers no advantages over HTML at that point. I follow XHTML's rules (lowercase, closing tags) with HTML anyway.

by phalacee

Until CSS/XHTML has an equivalent attribute to the XUL 'flex', making a website that resizes to fix the fullsize of a browser will be very difficult.

For a long time now I have wanted to make my sites maximize to match the size of the browser, but unfortunately its not possible to do this with DIV-based markup and CSS-based styling. I used to do it all the time with my old scarey TABLE-based designs, but I can't think of any non-AJAX method of doing it now...

by marknt06

Hi gbently,

Designing for your companies audience would be the most reasonable path of development, if the majority of the audience/customers use higher resolutions then that would be the best approach. Otherwise your company may not be to happy if the customer isn't happy.

regards

by pixelsurge

I almost always use fluid layouts in order to cater to my users' very different situations. However, at a certain point it becomes a disservice to my users to continue to let the layout expand, as the line lengths will become too long to be usable. I set a max-width, as well as a min-width.

A more ideal approach, but one that would be much more expensive and only benefit a very small amount of visitors, would be to employ a JavaScript-powered resolution dependent layout. This would mean that after the maximum width where the line lengths get unwieldy, the whole layout would switch to something else where the info was arranged more horizontally. This would be much more expensive because it would require additional design work, coding time, usability testing, etc. Plus, I'm not sure I could get my clients to go for it. Nevertheless, I'd love to have the luxury of doing it some day! Perhaps I'll do it on my personal site.
http://www.themaninblue.com/writing/perspective/2006/01/19/

Personally, I have a 1920x1200 resolution on my 24" widescreen monitor at work, but I generally run my browser window at 950px wide. I find that any wider is pointless as I have to scan too far from side to side to be comfortable. I'd rather just scroll my browser window down, requiring no head or eye movement, when I'm ready to see more content.

Oh, and regarding text size -- it's absolutely reasonable to expect that designs hold up to multiple font sizes. The design doesn't have to look great, but needs to be usable and readable. This is not difficult to do if you design for it from the beginning.

by dogknees

Thanks for the responses people.

I'm now happy to insist that the layout works across a reasonable range of resolution(the people with 2560x1600 are probably still going to miss out) and regardless of the font size chosen in the browser.

This discussion is closed to new replies.