Discussion Locked

What do you think about cities and towns becoming broadband providers?

0 helpful
45 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Is this a positive development in the spread of broadband or should these governments leave broadband in the hands of private companies?

45 replies

by oz_media

If it makes money the government will take it. I am sure many Canadians feel this way.

Oh well, it sure is purdy outside! :)

by sullyman

All three levels of government in Canada have bought into a wired philosophy, and have campaigned on a wired high speed Canada ( I think the target rate is around 80% by 2015 ). So I do expect government to stiff arm or subsidize high speed internet access into rural communities, and that would include becoming carriers and ISP's themselves. Crown Corporations here in Canada have become very successful nationally and internationally over the last 30 years, so a ISP CC might not be such a bad idea.

by oz_media

BC is strnge in that respect. Crown corporatuions are disapearing in BC and becoming MASSIVE privately ownd companies, these companis soon realize just how expensive providing public services really is and they soon start looking back to the government for subsidies. Oh well, they try.

IN Vancouver a few years back, there was a few wireslss hotspot test sits setup that were prety cool as I lived in the downtown area.

I don't really care either way, it's just the goverment after all and we simply live here at a cost. I still think it's worth the extra taxation money though considering what I get out of it. :)

by bigboss

Governments are there to govern. If we ever confuse them with a service provider role, on top of the rule making,rule policing role, we are asking for trouble. Beside, most companies won't like it if governments get involved in areas business may make money.

There will be isolated instances of government involvement in bootstrapping the development, especially in rural and remote areas where population density do not support quick deployment (until we have broadband satellite internet feed that's affordable). Some are even stupid enough to get into the operational side of tbe business. But these government bodies will soon find out they are actually very bad at doing this.

Since there is no way the government can make broadband service into a monopoly (there are too many business playing in the sand box now), and they will not be able to compete, even if they are more efficient and effective than the private firms. It's just because they have to make the people happy. And for voters, "free" is happy. With that kind of pressure, they will loose money, and loose it big. The other problem is "universallity". When government do things, people expect everyone will have access, regardless of location. That's how you can send mail from Toronto to Whitehorse for the same price as you send on accross the street. They cannot provide service to people who are easy to provision, and ignore the difficult cases, or even to charge more for it. That's not true for private business. They can choose where and with who they want to do business. Private business can implement services where they make money, and no where else.

So, it is a bad idea to have governments to provide broadband service.

by bluelinecms

In Philly, they are in the process of cutting their budget which is resulting in the possible closing a a few fire department stations.

I'd much rather the city spend these millions on public safety as opposed to a city-wide wireless network that will require additional staff to maintain and monitor network usage to ensure the network's integrity.

In short, it's a good idea if your local government can afford it without cutting costs from critical services elsewhere.

by tomsal

Well not actually, Philly is over the Walt Whitman bridge from me ... about 25 minutes.

Anyway the other poster to this mentioned they are cutting Fire Departments in order to afford this, this is news to me...I didn't hear they are killing any critical services for paying for it.

by helpdescu

I think it is a good ideea especialy in places where the state owned or ex state owned telecom provider has no real competition. It will definitelly drive the price down.

by jackie

The small city that I live in Newnan, GA has been providing this very service since around 1998. Cable modems with 1.5mb for $27.50 per month. It's great. They also have a partner in the phone business that provides phone over the hybird cable plant as well.

by wateradm

Currently the charge is around (advertised for $75/month) $50/month for a cable connection. I have waited over 40 minutes on hold (Adelphia) and ended up fixing the problem before getting any feedback from tech line. For service work it was necessary to go to the local office and request a service call to check line feed problems. Competition couldn't hurt at this point.

by jay_h

Being monopolies that they are, cities often provide the poorest and least responsive quality service, especially in areas far removed from their core competency. Back in the early days of cable TV, municipal provided services were often among the worst.

While concerns about privacy and intrusive government behavior are always a problem, there is a natural barrier between a private broadband provider and the local administration/police that simply wouldn't exist in a city owned system. The temptation for privacy invading 'fishing expeditions' would certainly come to fruition in at least some places.

Governmental functions tend to be mired in regulations, including unfortunately, regulations of technical issues, making rapid response to new developments far more unlikely. Government employee contracts also tend to be very highly padded, and restrictive, which will certainly increase operating costs (ever try to get prompt service out of a civil servant type).

by cranss

Here is finally the government's opportunity to tax the Internet. Oh it won't be very much at first, but just wait a few years when 25% of your ISP bill goes to taxes, and you reminisce about the good old days.

by bkwade

...your city has a ring of fiber already in-ground that is being underutilized but the citizens are paying for anyway.

Our city is planning a FTTH push and I am all for it. Our local oposition is from BellSouth (our major DSL provider) and Cox Communications (our only cable provider) both of whom are already in the FTTH business elsewhere.

Before you poo-poo those municipal plans, I suggest you do some homework and find out what your copper providers are doing. You may be surprised. I sure as hell was.

by joe_in_florida

In Moultrie, Ga., the service is run by the cable company and the internet provider but through the city so the billing is on your utitilites. Also the rate is lower because the city gets a better price.

by rick_fowler

In rural communities, there is ususally not enough market for a commercial entity to make enough profit to build a broadband network. But broadband can help provide the econonic means for a small town to stay alive. For this reason, it's a great idea for the local government to get involved.

by johnmcgrew

...government started providing "universal" Internet access in 1992.

A dozen years later, we'd still likely be using 28.8k modems, upgraded from 14.4k in 1998. Private competition does not exist, because it is locked out both legally (as to not compete with the government monopoly) as well as economically. (tax subsidized access is impossible to compete against)

Meanwhile, bloggers are prohibited against competing against the pliant television press. Dreamers who speak of ?risky? schemes such as DSL, Cable and wireless access with speeds of over 1m, are regarded as crackpot anarchists.

The government says it is on the verge of implementing 56k access. This is lauded as a massive success, as this literally doubles speed since 1998, and quadruples the speed of the original access in 1992. Ceremonies are held, and Al Gore gets another Nobel Prize.

No thanks.

by magpiper

The communications market is overly competitive and profits are almost non-existent. I do not want my local utility company competing in this market. Not "if" but "when" the local utility comopany goes belly up with broadband, the consumers will pick up the tab.

Utility companies also lack the funding to purchase quality equipment and personnell. They can not be a serious provider when they always know they have an out, by increasing rates on other utilities.

by curtis1001

I believe this is a great idea in rural america. Most of rural america is ignored by the major US telecomm carriers.

by wallowamichael

I run the technology department for 5 rural school districts. We have centralized servers and Internet access over 3 T1 lines. There are no other alternatives here, and the state picks up the tab already for 99% of the T1 costs.
Recently, a number of non-profit and other government agencies have come to us to have us bid on providing broadband service, since no large telcos are going to be providing anything until at least 2007.
Here I am, a pseudo-municipality (state funded broadband) providing service to local clients.
I still am not sure whether it's a good idea or not. Our firewalls block gambling, pornography, and most IM/IRC, etc., so the functionality is not 100%, and no matter how much they pay us, I won't let those services onto the school's network.
Besides satellite access (still only 56k upload) we are the only broadband available in town.

by jsloan1223

Small towns creating their own broadband network is not about the money. It's about providing service. Getting themselves on the internet at higher speeds than dialup (which in ND is often less than 56K, more like 14.4 or 28K). The residents work together, maybe thru the school, maybe not, and start their own ISP. I say, GOOD FOR THEM.

Many of those small towns wouldn't have anything except that they work together and get it going for themselves. The telcos don't have time for cities with "only" 50 customers, so those customers do it themselves.

by josh

Do you really want the govt controlling your internet connection?
Look, it is very easy to set up a simple wireless point to point (or multipoint) network. It is not as cheap as it is easy. Write up a business plan, find out who is selling internet somewhere close (20 miles or so) and put a radio there. Put one at your place and you are done. Want to make some extra money (or at least get you internet connection free)? Get all of you neighbors set up on your network for a small monthly fee. Heck, you could even set it up as a nonprofit.
Something to think about.

by josh

I live in the Lafayette, LA area. The Lafayette Utilities Service provides internet access to VARs, ISPs, etc., out here. It's at wholesale pricing and it is good, fully redundant access on the LUS fiber network.
However, there has been a recent push for LUS to get into the retail business. This will (not a might) turn into what nearly every ISP has had to face foing up against the Bells to find and get customers. With one big difference-- LUS would physically run fiber to every home and business in the city limits. So much for competition. There are no line sharing requirements for a power company selling internet access. So every business out here that relies in part on revenue from resale of internet access would lose that income. Many computer businesses in the area would shut down.
The worst part of this plan -- LUS would never expand it's network to the outlying areas. So if you live in the city limits, you would be on the fiber backbone, if you are on the other side of the street, you are out of luck.
It is a very bad idea for govt to get into a business that the private sector knows more about. All you will get from a govt entity running a retail internet business is more invasion of privacy, higher taxes and more red tape.
If you live in an area that doesn't have broadband, don't look to the govt to solve it for you. Get a business plan together and build the network. Take a risk. Build something great, dont expect the govt to take care of you.

by oliver.brown

In most cases I believe government intervention is not the best practice. But, if we (collectively speaking) are trying to create a society that is equal in all respects, the availability of technology to areas urban and rural becomes a requirement. As in other areas, society waits for private enterprise to "fill the gaps". When this does not occur, it is the obligation of society (government) to take up the mantle. In this case, the Telcos cannot see a financial gain from uplifting rural communities to highspeed internet access and could care less about the social implications...just the shareholders. Novel idea, the town creates the customer base and attracts the Telco with the thought of monetary gain with established customers.

by josh

This country was made great by enterprising individuals seeing a need and finding a way to fill it. It is not the government's job to provide internet access anywhere on a retail level. I am sure that in these rural areas there is at least one tech savvy person. If they had any desire approacing the level of their great-grand parents, they might just go out and bring broadband or wireless to their area.

by ken lillemo

The conclusion that we should pay for someone else's internet access, like many other social solutions, is predicated on the assumption that creating equality should be the responsibility of society. If we follow this logic then we worship at the temple of mediocrity. Frankly, I want to encourage greatness, not mediocrity.
Residents in underserved areas make a choice and should realize they will be the last to get services from anyone. The upside is that they enjoy a small town lifestyle or large wooded lots, and any other numerous benefits of remote life. Freedom always provides a cost/benefit decision. Compelling others to pay for my benefit strips them of freedom.
For my part, I am the one who choose to live on the other side of the lake from the phone switch. Had I known this would be relevant 18 years ago I might have chosen to live elsewhere. Today?s regret does not invalidate my responsibility in the outcome of decisions I have made in the past. I champion Freedom over equality everyday.

by montgomery gator

While we are on the subject, we need to repeal the extra Federal taxes on our telephone and cable bills that are intended to pay as a subsidy to get broadband internet access to areas that do not have it. For the reasons given by Ken, the Government should not be in that business. Let private enterprise handle it, and let the people who currently do not have it pay for it to get it, like everyone else. Broadband is not a necessity, even though it is a good thing, it is still a luxury. Although I live in a city with broadband access, I still use dialup, since I do not want to pay the extra money for broadband or cable internet, and that is my choice.

by ken lillemo

The conclusion that we should pay for someone else's internet access, like many other social solutions, is predicated on the assumption that creating equality should be the responsibility of society. If we follow this logic then we worship at the temple of mediocrity. Frankly, I want to encourage greatness, not mediocrity.
Residents in underserved areas make a choice and should realize they will be the last to get services from anyone. The upside is that they enjoy a small town lifestyle or large wooded lots, and any other numerous benefits of remote life. Freedom always provides a cost/benefit decision. Compelling others to pay for my benefit strips them of freedom.
For my part, I am the one who choose to live on the other side of the lake from the phone switch. Had I known this would be relevant 18 years ago I might have chosen to live elsewhere. Today?s regret does not invalidate my responsibility in the outcome of decisions I have made in the past. I champion Freedom over equality everyday.

by leonard_aj

Most people are unaware that the internet is actually a government communications system paid for with hard-earned tax dollars. What does this mean to us? We, United States citizens, own it. Enter local government. A light comes on in the income resource department- broadband service, taxes for providing the service, taxes for using the internet, taxes for those taxes, tax levies to pay for installation and maintenance. It is endless. Don't forget about new, needless regulation. Our income is finite. The feds have allready determined that use of the internet can not be taxed. Come on people, don't let desire overcome intelect. There are still a lot of tax dollars being needlessly wasted. Try to make your local government "live within thier means" just as we must in our daily lives before opening doors for more waste, fraud, abuse etc... If this is ever accomplished, then consider allowing them to invent new ways to take our hard-earned dollars.

by tomsal

Do you know what FUD is? Fear. Uncertainy. Doubt. FUD. That's what the part of your post, quoted below made me immediately think of...

"Most people are unaware that the internet is actually a government communications system paid for with hard-earned tax dollars. What does this mean to us? We, United States citizens, own it."

The short answer to the quote above....ummm...no.

The internet is not owned by the american citizens, it is a global network, using global trunks, using global websites, using global carriers, using global clients, over globally diverse networks. Essentially it is owned by the collective of all the millions of companies, providers, webhosts, carriers, and yes even the "common" folks who just contribute to the Internet by posting on forums, chat rooms, sharing files, etc. That is who owns the Internet.

The reason the US government has the ability to tax the Internet is because of the FCC. The FCC regulates the communications industry (yes I'm dumbing this down a LOT, but you get my point)..they can apply taxes to US carriers/telecom service providers and call it an "Internet" tax. In true form though, no single government can actually -- legally, tax that which they don't own.

Your theory on the tax payers own the Internet...I know where that comes from...the ARPANET days when the DOD was working on the development of a redundant communications system that could survive catastrophic events like nuclear war and still get comms to remote locations.

Like the horse and carriage was the seed of invention that lead to the car, the same is true of ARPANET and the modern Internet....but they are not the same thing.

Ok I'm done.

later.

;)

by straightshooter

Keep government out of privately funded communication! It will cost more and be less capable than if private enterprise does it.
They have been talking about taxing e-mail for years in order to subsidize the inefficient and costly post office system. A Post Office-like system for broadband? Imagine the efficiency of that!

by dstjulien

We are a mid-size city of about 120,000 in a county of about 400,000 and we have our own telco called iProvo.
I have been using its services since the beta test stage and there have been a number of adjustments that have been made. Before I get into that, I want to let you know that, even with the bonding that has been done, we have not seen, nor are there projections for increased taxation relative to the service. Further, it appears that the services are being provided at a rate that covers operation of the services. I will say that this is a conservative community and we have been frugal, even during the Winter Olympics that were held in our state in 2002. The community, as a whole has supported this from its inception as long as it was planned and implemented properly.
The city has constructed a fiber backbone throughout the municipal area to deliver the services. There are several service levals available. They are in the process of adding analog telephone, VOIP and video conferencing services during the next year. At the moment, I have fiber to my house with a gigabit internet connection giving me tremendous throughput, up and down, on the net. Better by several orders of magnitude than any dsl available. I have digital cable and equipment that allows for digital recording.
The city is providing excellent email services plus extra services to the home owner (personal firewalls, inernet filtering, etc). Other than some "growing pain" at the onset, there has been very little interruption of service.
Because these services are offered at competative rates, other local providers have not been shut out. As the system matures, I do see it becoming an even more attractive alternative to other providers. very shortly, there are plans to include all the services under one billing from the city. It is close now.
This community is somewhat unique. We have a 25.000+ person student population added to the permanent residents which is somewhat transient. This area has been described as the intermountain silicone valley. Consequently, there is a very high percentage of the population requiring high speed internet connectivity and services. The local wifi providers work in concert with the city to bring excellent connectivity to the growing multi-unit rental communities. I was on ATT Broadband for time but find that the current services are much more efficient. I am very satisfied with the way our city has approached this project and the services it provides.
I would suggest that any communities that are contemplating such a move, contact appopriate planners and managers at http://www.provo.org/

Just my two cents

by djstuff

There's a difference between installing the broadband lines, i.e., cable or fiberoptics, and providing the connection, content and features. Here in Provo, Utah, our city is providing fiberoptic line for every business and residence in the city. This is good. Private or public ompanies provide the internet, cable and phone service. In time, any company who wants, including Comcast and Qwest, I believe, could presumably rent the lines from the city and provide content to the end user. Providing the infrastructure is a proper role of government, in my opinion. There are too many questions regarding content for a government entity to provide those services. What if people object to improper content of TV shows and got those shows removed? Others might charge that the city is in the business of censorship, etc. Infrastructure is great! Unfortunately, it'll take over a year to build out to my neighborhood but I fully intend to sign up.

by dstjulien

I understand the relationships much better. Admittedly confused in some aspects.
By offering the infrastructure it encourages open and competitive economic opportunities for enduser services in a community while ensuring that the bandwidth is available.
Thanks again.

by mrpjb

Neat idea, but I think the private sector is doing fine expanding on broadband without government intervention.

by ballroomdancer

businesses are not as interested in providing broadband service to rural communities as they are a risk or low profit margin

Unless they can be convinced to step up to bat, the government doesn't have much choice.

Growing up in a rural community, we were often behind on receiving technology that was avaiable in the cities, etc.

Having worked for goverment at both the provincial and federal levels, I also know they are not necessarily the best to be running something like this.

But at the same time if private industry isn't interested in providing this in a timely manner, then they have no choice but to.

by maxwell edison

.
If a government becomes a provider of a utility - any utility - they will then have the power and the authority to regulate its use.

So if anyone wants the government to maintain our broadband infrastructure, be prepared to be told how and/or how much you can use it.

And to answer your question, no, I'm not in favor of such a thing.

by poobah

Its usuage is encompassing more and more of what were once regulated utilities, or "freely provided" services/entertainment. In any case it is becoming a necessity if 21st Century life. A necessity like water, electricity, natural gas; it is a victim of its own success. Having seen our local company go through three ownerships, and the upgrades/repairs done by each subsequent owner due to sub-standard work, some standardization and review of services/charges must be instituted. Each community handles it different. It is monopolistic here. I prefer private ownership with oversight, and level of service standards.

by pg122

Most cities can't even manage their own utilities and budgets. The less they have control over the better. Sure lets add more for them to raise taxes over, then tell you how your allowed to use it.

by itgirli

My contracts up friday, so I can have your job in Philly, and you can come down here and be unemployed for me. If I could find a FT job up there, I would move next week.

by david paul morgan

In my opinion, it is a Governments role to provide the 'pipelines' or infrastructure. eg highways, railways and broadband circuits. It is the role of Corporations to provide or operate services on this 'level playing field'. That way rural and iner-city communities both have free (unrestricted) access to services, both Government and Private industry.

This discussion is closed to new replies.