Discussion Locked

What is a good router for home networking?

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Hey everyone after looking at the previous post concerning geekdom, it pointed out home networking proficiency. I am trying for the first time to network at home on DSL connection with two computers to share the bandwith, printer while maintaining decent performance. My question is this, since I'm a major noob with routers and hubs, which brand with 4 port do you trust with easy install? Their are so many on the market and so far I found a D-Link DI-704P 4-Port 10/100 Router/Print Server that is a refurb. I'm not looking to get carried away buying major top of the line but looking for quality, more bang for my buck so to speak. After reading that post many of you boast profeciency in this area and I respectfully ask you opinions that have so far netted me fantastic results. What do you people use, perks that came with, and its dependabilty, and what to stay away from? Thanks a million as always. Happy Labor Day to all this upcoming weekend "eat, drink and be merry" to quote Dave Matthews.

9 replies

by thechas

I personally will never buy another piece of D-Link gear again. I have had just too many problems with their PCI network cards.

I have nothing but praise for Linksys. The equipment works flawlessly, and their tech support is very knowledgeable.
There might be a reason why Cisco bought Linksys rather than D-Link.

NetGear is another company with good products. I have not had the need to contact their tech support.

Chas

by don_c

I own a linksys BEFSR41 4 port router and have no problems with it even after two years of use. But I have had been thinking of go wireless with the 3-com system and its priced is low and 3-com is has got a good reputation. I have got a lot of 3-com equipment and happy that i did. always remenber to do your research

by chasf01

I?m sorry; I have been using a D-Link AirPlus DI-614+ and DWL-520+ Wireless PCI Adaptor for over a year now. On the few occasions I have a question or sought assistance I found their technical staff more then helpful. Installation was a breeze and reliability has been top notch.

by boneyfish

I have used D-Link at home for years on cable connection, and is the simplest to install,(will practically install itself, and have had no problems at all. Linksys is the one I have used on a DSL system at work, and is more complicated to set up, but no touch after initial set-up. For a beginner, I highly recommend the D-Link.

by jkaras

Yes I want it to go smoothly during install but would like some manual configuration as it is a learning experience. My main thing is dependability, it can have issues at times but dont want the typical mysterious wanna work when I wanna or difficulty with lightning storms that plague ole Orlando. Also want to play with firewall security and was hoping certain routers might package a good one ranther than taking any chances off the net like zone alarm, although I've heard good things about it. There are so many brands that are name brands for routers and some say they will swear by them and others say they will just swear at them. The prices jump this and that way making it hard to determine quality vs. a bargin. Any more assistance from you guys is definitely appreciated.
On a side note I just built my first gaming box and all went well. The only thing that I'm concerned about is the temp, it's running at 47-53 degrees inside the box according to bios. I can have the other temps for info later. What is the exceptable temp or preferred compared to danger temps. The case is an aluminum Lan-Li with three stock fans (2 intake front bottom and 1 exhast out the back. The front fans still have the filter since it has a window and I have bumped the switch to high fan speed.
components are:
Lan-Li 60 case (it rocks btw can take completely apart which makes it sooo coool)
Antec 550w ps
Abit KD-7 mobo
Kingston HyperX pc3200 512 DDR (1)
Ati Radeon 9600 pro
KMD 2400/333 FSB not clocked
Maxtor 120gb HDD
1 cold light kit

by robotech

I logged on with the specific intent on getting some opinions on a good Router/Firewall/Print Server for small offices and... there was your question.

I work as an IT consultant for small to medium sized businesses and I always purchase Linksys products. They are good, tech support is knowledgeable, they have good documentation... excuse me EXCELLENT documentation, and their driver and firmware updates are always timely.

As I said I always go Linksys, but sometimes I think LINKSYS has become out of touch with SOHO users. As I mentioned before, I'm a consultant for small to medium sized business, which means that there is not a lot of money to throw around. I have to get the best value for money for my clients. Right now LINKSYS has no Router/Firewall/Print Server on the market, which means that I usually have to go with D-LINK, sometimes I may go NETGEAR.

I rarely have problems with D-LINK, their tech support is good, and if you choose to send a tech question by e-mail the answer comes back quickly. The few problems that may exist can usually be corrected by a firmware upgrade. I love their firewall, which can allow you to block computers on your LAN from accessing certain sites either by a 'key word' or the sites IP address(es). D-LINK routers/firewalls will also e-mail me the routers activities such as: attempted access to blocked sites, router resets, the MAC address of all computers connected to the LAN, hacker attempts etc. I can basically administer the client without leaving my bedroom.

I suggest the D-LINK DI-704P, in fact, I?ll be buying one tomorrow to replace the LINKSYS router that I?m currently using. If you need explanations/help configuring it, just let me know and I?ll give you a hand (free of course).

Robotech

by robotech

I had a project for a medium sized client that required upgrading the old 10Mbs 3COM switch. I decided to replace it with a LINKSYS EtherFast? 3124 24-Port 10/100 Ethernet Switch. It?s a wonderful switch, quiet, and has a fiber expansion port for a 100Mbps fiber optic card. I did that because I realized that the customer may want to replace the copper link to the other building with a much faster fiber LINK.

My guess was correct, the customer wanted to connect two other buildings, and since Florida is the lightning capital of the world, fiber would be the only option (it?s not affected by lightning). The only problem was that the LINKSYS EtherFast? 3124 24-Port 10/100 Ethernet Switch only has one fiber expansion module. But I needed to connect two buildings. I tried using a different Linksys Switch that has multiple fiber expansion modules, but they only support Gigabit (1000Mbps) fiber. In addition to that, the EtherFast? 3124 24-Port 10/100 Ethernet Switch doesn?t support a Gigabit card, only 100Mbps.

Again I turned to D-LINK, I sent an e-mail to sales, they answered, and they also copied the e-mail to engineering. In less than 4 hours my questions were answered and I proceeded to order two switches from CDW. When the switches arrived I tested them and they worked like a charm.

Linksys is good, but slip-ups like that are causing them to loose part of their market to D-LINK and NETGEAR.

No D-LINK did not pay me to write this, and if anyone would like to check the truthfulness of this story please feel free to contact me for corroborating evidence.

Robotech

by acsmith

I have some experience with both Netgear and Linksys and both have delivered expected performace up to now. I have encounter a problem with Netgear (two units)in the past week. I can't use Window Update for W2K Pro and Server through the routers. The NT4 update works fine through Netgear and the W2K machines will work through MS ICS. Anybody experience anything similar or have a solution?

by robotech

Sometimes issues are discovered that are corrected with new firmware. Try the support/download section of their website, but make sure you put the correct model number in.

This discussion is closed to new replies.