Discussion Locked

What is wrong with people?

0 helpful
79 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Often I try to maintain a humorous rapport with the users but from time-to-time end users come up with some off the wall reactions to seemingly innocent remarks or efforts. Sometimes this escalates into comments to my boss and on a few occasions greviances.

For example, recently while working on a desktop support issue, I was conversing with the woman when we began to joke. Now I have known this woman for some time and felt comfortable joking around. She was personable and generally light hearted, always calling out to me and waving.

She made a jocular remark about women being more intellectual than men and being this women have fewer computer problems than men. I chuckled and came back with, "Intellectual? Is there such a thing?" I made reference to her personally nor did I direct it towards women.

She spun around and refused to talk to me. Several days later I approached her remarking that I was joking with her and was not expecting that response. She began patting me on the cheek with her hand and told me I insulted her then gave quite another story.

For the life of me I cannot figure out how I insulted her and how she arrived at the alternate story.

My question is should I when dealing with the end user just ignor their remarks, not converse, and put distance between me and them such as not going to lunch with them or joking around.

It seems today it is all too easy to come under attack and IT people seem to always be under fire. I wonder if in some cases people are looking for something.

79 replies

by timthetoolman

I seem to remember another of your posts with grievances of IT people being treated badly but I could be wrong...

The best thing you do with people to be a people person is to uplift them.

"She made a jocular remark about women being more intellectual than men and being this women have fewer computer problems than men".

"Women are more intellectual than men? Well I have a few words to say on that one... dahhh!"

Might have been funnier.

by fluxit

I commented on this in a posting but not as a discussion in its self. The closest I came may have been why are some people stupid... but that focus was on end user skill not rapport.

by nettek

DblOhGawd,

I find it interesting that your discussion has an "us versus them" attitude. You and the "end users" are both employees of the same company. I would look at the situation as a man/woman interaction, or coworker to coworker, rather thantech/end user. It was the content of the conversation, not the fact that you are a tech, that caused an uncomfortable situation. Her reaction might have been the same if you were an accountant and you were discussing cars, and she said women are better drivers, and you said "Good women drivers, is there such a thing?"

I have seen this tech vs. end user thing both in TR discussions and in my own work experiences. It is very easy to get caught up in the "us vs. them" attitude. I am constantly reminding my staff that they, and the people they support, are both employees of the same company. Otherwise, they sometimes become defensive and feel that the way people interact with them is a result of what they do. No matter what your job title might be, you will always have the occasional negative interaction with coworkers. It has little to do with being a tech.

by packratt

Yes, we should view the people we work with as people or fellow employees... But that is not reality.

In today's society people are defined by how much they make and what their job function is. People don't matter, what you care about has little impact to others. You ARE what your job title IS, and that is the bottom line in today's materialistic world.

When you, as a tech, go into a VP's office you are not "a member of the team", you are never a "fellow employee", and you certainly cannot be an "equal". You are a tech lackey who had better do whatever you are told and be happy about it. You are a tool, a ladder rung for those who can gain by stabbing you in the back. If you even think otherwise for one second you are seriously delusional and should think about buying tickets out of fantasy land if you think that other employee sees you in any other light.

Sure, it shouldn't be that way... But it IS that way and that's why people are defensive at work.

by retro

It's just too easy to get into serious trouble in the workplace. I work in a federal gov't facility and have seen some truly crazy things get people in trouble. I could tell you some stories, but with my luck someone would recognize that I was talking about them and my next post would be from the Equal Opportunity office, lol. Better to just smile and noncomittaly agree with them. "You just might be right"

by chrisms

It happened to me aswell, i amde a jocular remark to my personnell officer about he was imagining things because he thought I had applied for 2 days holiday, when I had made no such request and it must have been a mark on his paperwork.
The next thing I know, I have his boss on the phone to me giving me an earbashing, then the General manager, then I am have a written disciplinary report in my files. Other people who heard the conversation said they knew I was joking and could not believe thereaction.
It goes to show, you can not be too careful these days.

by sheilau

In today's workplace, it is very hard to know who you can joke with, and about what. Someone who might not take offense at something you say today might be completely offended by a similar remark tomorrow. I have found that, even though I enjoy talking to the people who call and joking, I keep well clear of anything that could potentially bite me in the behind down the road!

by packratt

I have often been told that you must keep your mouth shut unless it's business related and to never, ever offer any opinion whatsoever unless it's what the other person, especially management, wants to hear.

Opinion is the death request of any employee and a joke is a form of opinion from those who actully think.

So, unless you are good at being a liar or a yes-person, keep your mouth shut and be a good little drone because that's all that is appreciated. Not real thought, innovation, unguarded discussion, honesty, or good advice.

Of course, you have a desire to socialize or to just be nice... I have that problem too, but trust me, repress it while you are at work unless you do not value your job.

by maxwell edison

All of the following are direct quotes from your postings:

You’ve asked, “What is wrong with people?” “Why are some people stupid?” You’ve “been accused of being arrogant, cocky, of having an attitude”. Things “always irritated you”. You’ve criticized others for, “discussions that were generally incoherent and rambled”. You’ve had, “annoying” tests.

You’ve thought that others, “set you up”. You've, “played the silly game dodging the answers they wanted”. You’ve suggested that, "managers, employers and business owners have no leadership or management experience”, and that they’re “interested in lining thier pockets”. You’ve said that, “business owners are clueless”. You believe, “People tend to hire only people dumber than themselves”

You think that you can, “develop global pictures and see things about a business that others have difficulty seeing”. You’ve touted your, “graduate class” experiences and your “high IQ”. You see other departments as, “an obstacle”. You have urged others to, among other things, “read a little about character, leadership, and relationships.” And, you’ve mentioned that others need character building tools such as, “7 habits of Highly Effective People”, “Win-Win Management” books, and “Dale Carnegie books and programs”.

I could go on and on, but I’m tired of cutting and pasting quotes from your many postings - all with similar themes. And now, my friend, since you’ve claimed to believe in, “honesty and openness”, I must ask you this.

Why is it that you see only the shortcomings of others, and not of yourself? Why is it that you think whatever th

by maxwell edison

(The tail end of my posting was apparently cut off. It read something similar to the following.)

Why is it that you see only the shortcomings of others, and not of yourself?

Why is it that you think whatever the problem is, it was caused only by others and is the responsibility only of others?

Why is it that you suggest others need to change, but fail to consider that you are the one who should change?

Consider this. When problems always appear outside of ourselves and with otherpeople, the only way to solve them is from within.

Regards,

Maxwell

by qba98

I don't have intimate knowledge of DblOhGawd’s posting history, so I don’t necessarily agree with what you did; but I do know that is the way to spank someone with their words. I'm impressed!

by qba98

I don't have intimate knowledge of DblOhGawd’s posting history, so I don’t necessarily agree with what you did; but I do know that is the way to spank someone with their words. I'm impressed!

by mrafrohead

That was absolutely outstanding!!! The best part of it, is there was something in there that I also can learn from.

by maxwell edison

DblOhGawd and I have both contributed to some very thought provoking discussions, some of which have had a theme similar to this one. I'd like to make sure that those involved in this discussion don't misconstrue my last message. I did not post itto "slap" anyone around, or to criticize or belittle the creator of this thread, or to otherwise come across as being malicious.

One of the most difficult things a person can do is a self-evaluation of one's self, especially when it comes to changing one's thought patterns. I know how difficult it is because I constantly have to remind myself of that very thing. One of my motives for involving myself in these kinds of discussions is for that very reason. By reminding others that all problems(of this type) can be solved from within, I'm also reminding myself.

I can't help but think that DblOhGawd realizes this as well, and that these multiple discussions on similar themes is simply his way of looking for those reminders. The last thing I wanted to do was to be offensive. I hope I didn't come across as such.

Having said that, I do truly believe that these types of problems can only be solved from within. If we keep in mind that it’s not what the other guy is doing that creates the problem, but how we respond to those things that really defines what it is. After all, if we don’t think it’s a problem, it’s not a problem. For example, if someone comes up to you and calls you a no-good, dirty, so-and-so, it’s not an insult unless you allow it to be an insult. Where’s the rule that says we have to take ownership that insult. Where’s the rule that says we have to react in a like manner? The same principle applies to complaints from others, or their actions, inactions, opinions, etc. There certainly is some truth to the maxim, "cooler heads prevail". It’s all how you think about it.

Best wishes for a

by packratt

And I agree to a substantial extent... Yet...

(yes, anyone knowing me would know there it a yet)

What is one's responsibility for those who do substantial wrongs? Do we convince ourselves that there is no problem and walk merrily along while wrongs continue or do we stop and aknowledge that there is something that must be done?

I wonder if there is a difference between optimism and complicity by failure to act...

by pc_man48322

I would just like to say I very much appreciated this posting that Max, and DblOhGawd put before us. I could so very well relate to what DblohGawd had posted, and agreed with. Then I read Max's response, I have to admit at first I thought it was alittle bit of a bashing, then I was very impressed by the followup of "So as not to be misunderstood". You are absolutly correct Max, in order to deal with such changes we must start from within. I was only disappointed that you did not take it one step further and give us the balance of "HOW" to do this. Many times I deal with very difficult politics (for lack of better terms) and wish I knew how to react differently, but my ego, pride (whatever you want to call it) gets in the way.

Thank you both for a very enlighting conversation, and I am in hopes that both of you will continue to post with such directness, and openness, because I think "themes" are very healthy for mature adults to have intelligent feedback, and who knows, maybewe all might learn something in the process.

Again Thank you both! very well done/said!
Pc_Man48322

by fluxit

How good is a book without illustrations? Perhaps what you are seeing is a chapter and not the whole book of experiences. Or you may be a player and this site is a stage. Decide for yourself.

by Former member

I completely agree with Maxwell, regarding insults and ownership of them. Maintaining control of one's perception in such matters requires effort, yes... but is that SO terrible? Often, the effort put towards keeping a cool head (or in some cases,appearing robotic) turns out to be minimal when compared to that which may be put towards rebuilding a relationship that has been broken over a misunderstanding.

And in the end, do we really NEED to make that joke? I've learned (the hard way) that sometimes it's better to keep the jokes inside...

Oh yes... and as much as it IS up to the individual to take a comment personally, I do NOT recommend ever suggesting this to the injured party! Can you imagine: "Well, Mary... I wasn't saying that I doubt YOUR intellect, are you perhaps being a bit sensitive?" NOT good!!! :o)

by mrsouthbeach

DBLOHGAWD has many valid things to say. I do not think we are seeing the total picture but a snapshot shared with us on this site. In fact, I think many of his inputs are very good.

by maxwell edison

"What is one's responsibility for those who do substantial wrongs", you ask?

Those who commit those "substantial wrongs" are the ones who should be responsible.

You further wonder, "Do we convince ourselves that there is no problem and walk merrily along while wrongs continue or do we stop and acknowledge that there is something that must be done?"

I'm not suggesting that anyone pretend nothing is wrong or walk merrily along (I like that) ignoring a harmful situation. On the contrary, I only suggest that one not take ownership of destructive thought patterns harbored by someone else. If, for example, a co-worker chooses to be adversely affected by a (self-inflicted) misunderstanding over an apparently innocent joke, then there’s no reason for the other person involved to also inherit those ill-feelings. Just learn whatever you can from it, perhaps not joke with that person again, perhaps consider the delivery and circumstances, and let the other person decide how he/shewill be affected. It simply makes no sense to worry over those things you can’t control. And the thought process of another person is certainly one of those things.

Why get angry with someone who cuts you off in traffic? What good does it do? Why let that person have a “double-whammy”? First, he cut you off. Second, he affected your mind. Why give someone that power over you? OK, so that person cut me off (and possibly flipped me off in the process). Too bad he’s having a bad day. However, I’m not going to inherit his bad day (or bad moment).

If you can do something about a situation that needs attention, then go ahead and fix it. If you can’t do anything about it, don’t worry about it. You can’t fix it anyway, so let someone else worry about it.

(As I said, I have to keep reminding myself as well.)

Maxwell

by tomsal

Hi.

After reading your posts (I agree with the others, very good writing!) you said some things that made me think of my Kwan Ji Nim (Grandmaster; Tang Soo Do).. loosely based on Taoist philosophies "Inner conflict results in outer strife." Without writing a novel and explaining the forces like Weh Gong and getting into the whole Ying and Yang thing (besides I don't how well most people can read korean..because I have trouble typing it lol) ....my Kwan Ji Nim teaches us all the time about "what matters around you doesn't matter, until you have peace from within - then it all matters".

So anyway - you just got me thinking when you said that stuff, made me think of stuff I hear and (try) to learn in martial arts all the time - insteadof the actual martial arts itself.

It was good reading your posts. You are right its hard as heck to self-evaluate (if you are incredibly honest with yourself - as am I)...I slip up a lot revealing my "short comings" - like impatience and sometimes I suffer a case of tunnel vision....

But then if we were all perfect beings, how imperfect life would be.

-Tom

by green team

I am impressed with all the posts. Nice job, there are a lot of valid points. This is a general post - not directed at anyone. I'm just throwing out my two cents.
We all struggle with handling relationships in and out of work. Unfortunately, inthe workplace we have no control who we associate with. The environment is forced upon us. It is therefore up to us to control our own attitudes about everyone - from the mailroom personnel to CEO. It is all about attitude and beliefs. If you believe to your core that all people are capable of great things (maybe they just need to apply) and are totally unique and special then it is easy to 'uplift' people. Be sure that is different than handing out empty or shallow praise. It is different because you truly believe it. How do I get that belief? What are you talking about? What I'm talking about is change and personal growth towards being a better person. It is so easy for people in our industry to have technology and that type of education/training pushed at us that we forget about being people and improving relationship/people skills. If you don't think you need improvement in that area you are wrong - it is non-negotiable and not debatable. You need to grow.
I don't believe that avoiding personality situations by either not saying anything or becoming a 'yes man' is the right answer. Learn to handle your own thought process and attitudes and you will be better for it.
Read something from a book (non-technical)every day. 15 minutes minimum.
These books are not for people in sales only, they are for anyone. There are others too - you can find them.
Dale Carnegie, 'How to Win Friends..'
Frank Bettger, How I Raised myself from failure..'
Og Mandino, 'The Greatest Salesman..'
A tomato on the vine is either growing or dying, there is no other option. The same is true for us. Which one are you doing?

by packratt

So, you're saying that the only growth that counts is the ability to sell something? That must mean that car dealers are an advanced form of life?

So many empty, materialistic people, such a waste...

by green team

I'm not sure that you read what I wrote. It looks like you saw the book titles and drew the conclusion that I admire sales people and the ability to sell. That is not what I wrote.
I believe that everyone needs good interpersonal skills. I alsosaid those are skills that we need need to grow. I also believe that it is easy for us to be buried in techno-crap so far that we can lose site of personal development in other areas.
I suggested reading 15 minutes a day of non technical material.
You can take that suggestion or not - it's your brain.

by generalist

"So, you're saying that the only growth that counts is the ability to sell something?"

I think the cynicism filter was on overdrive when the above comment was made. Using basic logic, I can't figure out how the statement could be derived from the source posting unless a lot of information got dropped along the way. It was an interesting, though inaccurate, interpretation.

The source posting, from 'green team', talked about relationships and learning. It mentioned the fact that people in our industry tend to "forget about being people and improving relationship/people skills."

It then mentioned several books that are very good at teaching people how to improve their relationship/people skills. The fact that these books are frequently read and internalized by really good salespeople indicates that they are good resources on the topic.

True personal growth involves learning from a variety of sources, especially when those sources focus on areas where skills are lacking. When you get down to it, you want to learn new skills from the best. And when it comes to applying relationship/people skills, salespeople are some of the best experts around.

I wouldn't call learning from these experts to be empty or materialstic. I'd call it applied systems analysis.

by fluxit

Thank you for your inputs. It is terrific that we are able to bring these things out and discuss a variety of things.

by maxwell edison

All the world's a stage,
And all the men and women merely players;
They have their exits and their entrances,
And one man in his time plays many parts,

-Shakespeare

by fluxit

Life at 20 was a road map and I was looking for the signs at 90 miles an hour. Life at 30 was a puzzle and I was trying to put the pieces together. Today life is a unknown and I do not define myself by a role as I would hope I am an Independent Thinker.

I guess in many ways I am like Q on Star Trek and Indiana Jones in other ways. The youthful part of me I would like think is a Johnny H.

Anyhow, let's just hope that no one is psycho analyzing our dialogues other than ourselves. I would not be surprised if some university got a hold of the chat room transcripts and evaluated our dialogues. The FBI may be doing that very thing right now for homeland defense in an attempt to profile potential threats. This may be a good discussion in itself.

by isys

I had a similar situation once where I made a comment to a woman that was taken in a wholly different context than intended. I told her that I apologized for what I had said, that I could tell from the expression on her face that she was offended by my remark, and that I had not intended to offend her. Although too late for this incident, it's something that you might think on for later. You should be aware enough of your audience to see if you have gone too far in words or actions and have the confidence in yourself to apologize for it.

by packratt

Look, all the books you mentioned ARE sales and management self-help garbage. I can't help it if that's what you think "growth as a person" is centered around. You gave the titles and by doing so as a pointer to what YOU thought was the best way to grow as a person. Now, since the titles you gave were sales oriented that means that you see sales and management ability as way a human grows.

I would suggest that there are much more meaningful ways that people SHOULD grow. There are things thathumankind should concentrate on in the way of growth that have been too long neglected.

interpersonal skills does not equal salesmanship because salesmenship is an empty and impersonal transaction where one side cares little or nothing about the other. Perhaps a better way to grow would be to BE PERSONAL with others and talk about substantive things instead of the typical inane banter that those books you mention focus on. Perhaps actually trying to listen to others and care about what they are trying to communicate would be a good method of improving interpersonal skills instead of trying to focus on the "sell".

Yes, it's my brain... but it's my concious as well and I choose not to ignore that or to divorce one from the other like agood salesperson does.

by packratt

When a salesperson does anything it's to improve his or her sales, not to better his or her self. When a salesperson talks to you, it's not because he or she cares or wants to help you with anything, he or she wants to help his or her self to your wallet and it's contents.

So...

When these books were made they were not to help people grow, or to imrprove relationship skills. They were produced to improve profits and sales skills in order to gain more money, not to improve anyone in any real sense, especially not in any interpersonal relationship sense. They were designed to help people avoid true interpersonal skills by wrapping them in salespeak and distancing the personal from the communication, just the way you did by describing relationship skills and the focus thereof as applied systems analysis... people are not machines and the subtle ways they interact and communicate is not binary nor hex.

I would suggest that salespeople are very good con artists but very poor at true relationship skills since they fail to actually care about anyone else or anything other than the sale and the money. As I suggested in a round-about way, perhaps the best way to improve your interpersonal skills is to talk with and listen to a variety of people instead of reading about the best way to make a sale or manage employees like a herd of cattle.

by maxwell edison

Packratt said, “You gave the titles and by doing so as a pointer to what YOU thought…”. Therefore we can assume that you believe the number of vagrants can be a measure a city’s employment availability. Is that what you suggested? That’s a fatuous assertion. There is simply no correlation between the two.

You further said that there were, “much more meaningful ways that people SHOULD grow”. Should grow? And how exactly “should” a persongrow? “Should” a person grow in ways defined by you? No, a person should grow in ways that are conducive to his or her own defined values, and in ways that will further enhance that person’s goals and ambitions.

You then said, “There are things that humankind should concentrate on in the way of growth that have been too long neglected“. On this point, I concur. Mankind (specifically in the United States) should indeed "grow", and start to hold people individually responsible for themselves, and dismiss the silly and destructive notion that collectivism will solve all social problems, and that it (collectivism) in any form is doomed to failure.

You think, “interpersonal skills does not equal salesmanship because salesmenship (sic) is an empty and impersonal transaction where one side cares little or nothing about the other.” I think you may want to reconsider that statement when trying to sell your ideas to anyone. Unless, of course, youbelieve that your ideas are “empty and impersonal”.

You think, “salespeople are very good con artists but very poor at true relationship”

Some of the greatest sales people were (are), in my opinion:

Martin Luther King, Jr.
Thomas Jefferson
Benjamin Franklin
Winston Churchill
The Reverend Billy Graham
Jesus Christ
Mohandas Gandhi

Selling a product, selling yourself, or selling an idea,

by maxwell edison

What are you doing spending your time on a thread like this? Shouldn't you be out there in the cruel world improving mankind, er, I mean humankind? Shouldn't you be out there "caring" for all those people you claim to care about?

Your condescending tirade is shortsighted and shallow.

A man is not defined by another man's judgement of him. But a man is defined by his need to judge others.

You are indeed doing a fine job defining yourself.

Maxwell

by packratt

So... Max... you go off on your own tirade telling me about judging others while you seem perfectly at home judging homeless people and how they are all to blame for being homeless because they are all addicts or psychotic... Do you know how to say 'hypocrit'?

Ah yes... and all of this bunk about focusing on yourself and your own flaws, all I see you doing here is focusing on everyone else's flaws yourself as well.

Something comes to mind about glass houses here...

by packratt

You don't sell ideas, you communicate ideas. If it's a good idea people will accept it, if it's a bad idea you have to sell it.

by fluxit

I think we need to look at our environment as IT professionals and what people expect of us. Other technically oriented people work in environments unlike ours. Engineers, architects, and scientist work in environments surrounded by people who are doing pretty close to the same thing and have a frame mind or reference that is alike. They are they to complete thoughts in a very close manner to thier own.

In IT we work in environments where the frame of mind / reference is dissimiliar. The IT professional has to flip-flop back and forth between technical thought and social thought processes. In sorts, others in our environments often are emotional thinkers and not logical thinkers. They have a greater need to be re-enforced positively. Ina way, many think in terms of 'if this then you are a great person' in-lieu-of 'If then that thinking'.

Dale Carnegie teaches this 'You are great' approach in general. I saw one posting where an individual commented on a series of great people inour history. While each had tremendous accomplishments in life, each also rose to a higher cause and that was thier focus.

What is our higher cause that people can rally around when most think thier employers are jokes? I have worked in several environments. I'll tell you, when I work in the DoD many rally behind the United States. There is a higher meaning to our work. However, when lining my boss's pockets in the civilian world I could care less. Likewise, the others at work have a cause for themselves and thier families.

by sysadmingov

Some days people are the last thing you want to associate with! Other days, people are the one thing you need. Same people, same situation; only your circumstances and/or feelings have changed. One difference between a child and an adult is the ability to respect another's space, physical, mental and spiritual. Maybe the person who was offended had something entirely unrelated going on in her life and you just happened to give the sore spot another jab, unintentionally. I think (not that I am an expert on interpersonal relationships or anything closely resembling that!) everyone needs to step back from time to time and assess themselves; taking note of their strengths and weaknesses, and how they affect other people. Respect is the maturemind acknowledging the right of another to have their own viewpoint, without taking offense when the views differ. too bad respect is seen as something that has to be "earned". Respect should be the modus operandi. Disrespect, on the other hand, can be earned, often far to easily.

by ins413

After reading all of the postings here, all I have to say is WOW... I may not be as verbally brilliant as all of you were in your postings, (I guess I'm one of those stupid people you were talking about) but this was a great thread. I'd like to thank DblOhGawd for starting this thread. Maxwell and Packratt, you guys make GREAT points. I can honestly say that this thread has left an impression in my mind and I might even be a better person because of it. Thank you. I will end with GREEN TEAM's conclusion on one of the post's:

A tomato on a vine is either growing or dying, there is no other option. The same is true for us. Which one are you doing?

Norm

by Former member

After reading through this thread, it seems that a large portion of the thread turned into the same sort of situation that DblOhGawd described at the beginning!

I'm not belittling the philosophy battle that has ensued - there is a whole lot of brain food in those posts (as well as the others)... I just find it interesting that the perception of the word "sale" can spawn such a dialogue!

by rusty ferrari

I always try to keep things on a professional level. I never joke with anyone unless they joke first and I never lead a conversation when I am working in a users office. If someone is mean or snappy, I simply treat them nicer and nicer until they eventually give in and realize that I am not there to make them look stupid (I also try to avoid any "techno-babble"). This is what has worked for me, I hope it makes some sense to someone.

by hmsardenberg

What do you mean by "techno-babble"? I think if a user asks what is wrong w/ their computer and what is the cause of the problem, I tell them why "techno-babble" or not. If they are asking a technical question, they should be prepared to hear a technical answer! If I don't know exactly why, I tell them I'll get back to them, and if I find the answer I'll let them know where I got it from. Of course I'm assuming they're being honest when they ask the question!

by generalist

I'm curious as to whether you have read any of the three books mentioned in any depth.

If you have, were you trying to learn from them or trying to tear them down?

by loretta_m

Homelessness, as with many other social problems in this country, derives from the major
problem in our society: the maldistribution of economic resources. That is, the fact that a small, oligarchic elite, controls the vast majority of wealth and income leads to the majority being deprived of access to such resources. Some are, of course, more deprived than others - and the homeless are certainly among the most deprived of all - but the reality is that all, except for a very narrow, exploitative elite, are disposessed, in the fullest sense of the term.

The result of this economic maldistribution is a variety of social (and psychological) disfunctions, of which homelessness is one. The way to attack homelessness, then, is to attack it at its root cause, by attempting to alleviate the economic maldistribution that is its chief cause.

Therefore, we must enact programs of massive redistribution of resources. Heavy progressive taxation must be applied to the ill-gotten
gains of the economic elite, both to income and wealth, and particuarly to inheritance (to smash the disgusting perpetuation of privilege that
goes on in this country). The proceeds from this taxation must then be redistributed to those who are without, and the homeless are first on that list. Therefore, a full scale array of programs must be initiated, from guaranteed housing, to guaranteed adequate incomes for all, full
employment, national health insurance, and a variety of other "cradle-to-grave" programs. The income and wealth distributions must be compressed, and all people guarateed full economic security, including food shelter, health care, and other necessities of life.

Economic Security for ALL

by loretta_m

Examples of selling:

----------

“Sell Yourself: Successful Job Interviewing”

http://www.filmideas.com/titlepages/pthrus/sellyourself.html

----------

“Bush must sell ideas he campaigned on”

By TOM RAUM-- Associated Press Writer

http://www.canoe.ca/CNEWSUSPolitics0102/24_bush-ap.html

----------

“How To Sell Change”

”Companies don't just have to manage change; they have to sell it.”

http://www.optimizemagazine.com/issue/002/marketing.htm

----------

“I use the "Sell Yourself" lesson after we have gone over and learned to write resumes, cover letters, etc”

“…selling yourself to a potential employer. You must include…”
http://www.successlink.org/great/g163.html

----------

“Here's how to successfully present and sell your ideas”

From the September 27, 1996 print edition
People Management

“But first, you must have rapport. The way tobuild rapport and sell your ideas is by speaking their language.”
http://charlotte.bizjournals.com/charlotte/stories/1996/09/30/smallb3.html

----------

Don't forget to remove those pesky spaces from the pasted URLs.

----------

Packrat, you haven't sold your ideas to anyone yet.

Maxwell

by loretta_m

Examples of selling:

----------

“Sell Yourself: Successful Job Interviewing”

http://www.filmideas.com/titlepages/pthrus/sellyourself.html

----------

“Bush must sell ideas he campaigned on”

By TOM RAUM-- Associated Press Writer

http://www.canoe.ca/CNEWSUSPolitics0102/24_bush-ap.html

----------

“How To Sell Change”

”Companies don't just have to manage change; they have to sell it.”

http://www.optimizemagazine.com/issue/002/marketing.htm

----------

“I use the "Sell Yourself" lesson after we have gone over and learned to write resumes, cover letters, etc”

“…selling yourself to a potential employer. You must include…”
http://www.successlink.org/great/g163.html

----------

“Here's how to successfully present and sell your ideas”

From the September 27, 1996 print edition
People Management

“But first, you must have rapport. The way tobuild rapport and sell your ideas is by speaking their language.”
http://charlotte.bizjournals.com/charlotte/stories/1996/09/30/smallb3.html

----------

Don't forget to remove those pesky spaces from the pasted URLs.

----------

Packrat, you haven't sold your ideas to anyone yet.

Maxwell

by packratt

The rampant commercialization of our society leaks into our own personalities in many subtle ways... Look at our language, or your's, I should say... Instead of sharing ideas you insist it's a sale. Instead of communicating it's selling. Instead of an exchange it's a transaction...

The subtlties of language exist for a reason, that is there are different meanings for these terms and that you must be careful about how you use them. A "sale" or "selling" is a zero sum transaction where one side gains something and the other loses something, the whole intent is to come out ahead of the person you sell to or else there is no profit. This is the zero sum transaction, or "sale".

So, instead of trading, exchanging, sharing, or even just attempting to communicate you insist on making a "sale". You even debase some great individuals and belittle their contributions to modern thought by insisting they were merely salespeople! I'm certain that they would be rather offended about that.

All your examples relate to business, and thus purely sales again and not any worthy social goal or personal growth. You just proved my own point by giving those examples, a sale has not social value, only monetary.

I don't care about selling my ideas, I share them freely. It is up to you, the individual, to accept or reject the sharing, it should never be up to me to force you or SELL you my thoughts or perspective. I share my opinion because I believe that most people refuse to see the things I have seen and most have not experienced what I have. I say what I do because I feel it needs to be said and that is my perogative and supposed right...

I know you probably cannot understand this since I'm not selling anything and that sort of transaction seems beyond your comprehension.

by packratt

Again, as allways in our discussions, you fail to deal with what I say and instead insist on deflecting the subject entirely.

Yet, I will, as usual, deal with your questions anyways.

I have read some of the books mentioned and I know of the others by reputation.

I will answer your second quasi-question this way. You and I may read the same book but glean an entirely different lesson from the same book. Also, one should analyse what one reads or experiences before determining what should be learned from that lesson. I don't know if you are familiar with memes or not, but this is where filters do come in. (I may not care enough to filter what I say, but I do care about filtering what comes the other way). Yes, one should be somewhatopen to other thoughts, but one must apply their own logic and values to what is coming in before deciding to take any lesson to heart as a truth. After all, we read and hear many things and all are not necessarily true or even healthy when acceptedas a good lesson to learn without applying some thought to the matter.

This being said, let us just agree that I obviously learned something quite different than you.

by generalist

As usual, you bring up some good points. (It's been a while since I've seen the word 'memes'...)

I have noticed over the last year or so of postings that we often have very different viewpoints on things. It has made for some interesting discussions.

I do find your comment that I fail to deal with what you say and instead insist on deflecting the subject entirely to be somewhat limiting though. While it is accurate in a narrow context, it has a few problems.

In order to effectively deal with what you say relative to the books listed earlier, it helps to understand what you have read and how you approached said books. With that understanding, I can do a better job of dealing with what you say. (Or I can do a better job when I can spare the time to do such...)

That is why I 'asked' the questions I did.

Keeping in the same vein, are there any books/media that you would recommend as being useful for helping a person develop relationship/people skills? You objected to the ones mentioned but, as far as I recall, you didn't suggest any alternatives.

by maxwell edison

Here are just a few excerpts:

“Our duty is to hold ourselves responsible to the people. Every word, every act and every policy must conform to the people's interests, and if mistakes occur, they must be corrected - that is what being responsible to the people means.”

“The unification of our country, the unity of our people and the unity of our various nationalities - these are the basic guarantees of the sure triumph of our cause.”

“The ideological and social system of capitalism…resembles a dying person who is sinking fast”

“One must act in accordance with the needs and wishes of the masses. All work done for the masses must start from their needs and not from the desire of anyindividual.”

“We should go to the masses and learn from them, synthesize their experience into better, articulated principles and methods, then do propaganda among the masses, and call upon them to put these principles and methods into practice so as to solve their problems and help them achieve liberation and happiness.”

“We should pay close attention to the well-being of the masses, from the problems of land and labor to those of fuel (housing and food). All suchproblems concerning the well being of the masses should be placed on our agenda. We should discuss them, adopt and carry out decisions and check up on the results. We should help the masses to realize that we represent their interests, that our lives are intimately bound up with theirs. We should help them to proceed from these things to an understanding of the higher tasks which we have put forward, the tasks of (this struggle), so that they will support (this struggle) and spread it throughout the country, respond to our political appeals and fight to the end for victory in (this cause).”

by nettek

What many tech's fail to realize is that they have knowledge and abilities that very few people in the company have. Did it ever occur to you that the end users that techs deal with may behave defensively or have an attitude because they feel inferior. Think about it. When you walk into a VPs office to provide support, you are doing something that he can't, even though he is a great and mighty VP. The VP probably doesn't feel that way about his administrative assistant, the maintenance staff, the mail clerk, or the office manager. Being a tech is a form of power. If you couple that with professionalism, eventually people will treat you with respect.

You said that "...you are not 'a member of the team', you are never a 'fellow employee',and you certainly cannot be an 'equal'. You are a tech lackey who had better do whatever you are told and be happy about it." I started in desktop support, and now I'm the Director of IT for my company. I sit in meetings with all the other bigwig execs. If I was never a "fellow employee" or "member of the team", then how did I get where I am?

Nothing personal, Packratt, but unless you change your attitude and point of view, you will always be a tech.

by james r linn

And am now a manager.

And sure, I've worked at companys where the attitude Packratt describes is the norm. But I've worked at many other comoanies where it isn't.

At one workplace, a 20 Billion dollar a year company, I started as desktop tech.I supported all kinds of users, from people in the mail room to the president. The president of one of the divisions was one of my most considerate users. I would have jumped through flaming hoops for him, if he'd asked. His secretary and I became good friends(she was older and happily married in case you had those thoughts). He asked me to be a tester of some new communications technology his division was working on, stopped me in the elevator to ask me how I liked it, was genuinely interestedand concerned. He became president of the whole company. He started as an engineer.

I could talk about many similar stories. I also supported the corporate CIO, and he would ask me questions, both inside my area and outside. Even though he and I have long since moved on, we still keep in touch.

At my current employer, my former staff like me enough to invite me to social events, and stop by to ask my opinions on how to handle problems, including with their new supervisor. I would think thats because I treated them with respect and cared about them as human beings. And thats the norm here, and other places I've worked.

I would say to Packratt if your current place is that bad, keep lookig for new opportunities, get training, do what it takes but get out.

James

by packratt

Maybe it's just my bad luck that I haven't been to that great company where people spend their time doing the work they enjoy without becoming pawns in someone else's backstabbing politcal plans to become boss. Maybe I just got fooled too many timesby the people who insisted that their company cared about their employees when it really didn't act that way once you bacame employed by them.

I don't know, when do you draw the line between luck and just too many coincidences to be ignored? I'm happy you found a company you can be proud of working for... Just remember that the people who worked for Enron felt the same way too.

by jam.on.toast

When working as a desktop tech I have found mayself saying things before I have thought about them (due to me concentrating on the task at hand, honest!) and I have found the best policy when you get a strong reaction to a comment is to imidiately appologise, saying 'sorry! that came out all wrong! I hope i didn't offend you and you'll accept my appologies...', thus defusing the situation before they have time to sit and brood over it.

You are then free to hide in the network room and moan to the other techs about the moody **** in accounts without fear that boss is going to get an e-mail.

by fluxit

I had an experience working on cruise ships. The hotel director was arrogant and attempted to put me under her thumb yet needed tech assistance. Everything was blowing up on me and confrontation with her was daily as she attempted to micro-manage mywork even though she had no understanding of the technology. I could not communicate anything that satisfied her other than making her feel in control.

One day she called me in to her office and cut me short everytime I tried to speak. Then escalating she slammed her fist on the desk directed that she was going to talk now. I looked at her and informed her that she can talk to the four walls and walked.

The ship could not sail without a tech guy on board for the satcoms and sat at the pier until another guy showed. There was no teamwork on her part and it cost her dearly as her pay is based on keeping cost down. Tied to the pier cost money.

The point is that everything I said was under tremendous scrutiny. Even emails to my bosswere screened or redirected back to her and she saw them which escalated the problem.

In the end I had solved the real problems on the network before leaving despite the all noise but it cost us both. I left for a new job and she lost a chunk from her paycheck plus face. What was this for? Her personal gratification that she was in control of something she knew nothing about.

by packratt

I've been there and done that, I don't like it. Who the heck said I wanted to be a manager or executive, why do you think that it's EVERYONE's ultimate dream in life to tell others what to do instead of doing it themselves?

There are already too many people aspiring to tell others what to do and how to do it. So many in fact that I am often suprised that anything ever gets done anymore.

I like my occupation, where did you hear that I didn't? Perhaps you got that confused with the fact that I don't like the occupational choices of some other people who really shouldn't be doing what they do.

by hmsardenberg

Agree w/ you post. How did you deal w/ the times when you got negative feedback from users even though you did everything you could to help them and was successful in fixing their problems? Also, what do you say when a VP or higher up contantly makes derogatory remarks about IT and the money the organization is spending in IT?

I would like to read your insights, you seem like a person that has a lot of experience in the field.

by packratt

I think this one has rigormortis already. I wouldn't suggest any books because I think people should decide for themselves what is of value to them... Yet on the opposite side I get quite perturbed about how a vast majority choose to make money the top priority in life. Catch-22 for me there, don't want to tell people what to do but their pretty dumb sometimes and need a nudge.

That brings me to Mr. Maxwell Macarthyism... Where did you get the impression that I'm some sort of communist? All you managers and executives tend to have, in general, such a narrow view of everything and yet still think you have it all figured out with just that tiny bit of knowledge to go on. You might be suprised if you found out how un-communistic I actuallyam.

But why should I bother since you have it all figured out? Typical close minded manager, try this...

"All that exists deserves perishing."

"There is nothing that a government can do that you cannot do for yourself."

by generalist

Perhaps I should have asked for a list of books/media that you consider to be valuable so I can read/view them myself and glean my own opinions from them.

While this would be functionally similar to my previous request, I'm half hoping that the philosophical difference is enough to get you to respond.

But I suspect that a dead horse is a dead horse, no matter what philosophy is involved.

by packratt

*sigh*

You just won't let this drop, will you? Fine... Here are a couple books I can remember as being somewhat interesting, yet it's not just books that a person make, but the whole of one's experience and the sum of all those he or she meets combined with the inate talents that reside within from the start.

"Marxism Freedom and the State" Michael Bakunin (thought this would be nice for Maxwell Macarthy)

"Ethics for the New Millennium" Dalai Lama

"The Third World at Home" Noam Chomsky

"Engines of Creation" K. Eric Drexler

"Lord of the Rings" series by J.R.R Tolkein as well. Yes, I've been reading those to my 7 year old son, but there are a few interesting lessons in the books.

I hope that is enough to stop this inane thread because I do not feel like having to rummage through my boxes packed from our last moves just to satisfy your curiosity about what I read.

by generalist

Thanks for the list!

I would be the first to agree that "it's not just books that a person make..."

But books are often the only feasible way that some experiences can be shared. If you know the books that a person considers somewhat interesting, you have a better insight into how the person thinks.

by ms. dos

I agree w/Generalist's interpretation of PackRatt's post. However, what I find even more intriguing that PR's cynicism (it's palpable in all posts!) is his/her broad-sweeping indictments that contain some modicum of insight.
Consider: "Perhaps a better way to grow would be to BE PERSONAL with others and talk about substantive things" [I couldn't agree more!] "...instead of the typical inane banter that those books you mention focus on."
Can't help myself, have to ask: so PackRatt are we to assume that you've read all these books and so have something substantive to base your scathing review on?
(No, I haven't read them ... but neither am I criticizing their content)

by admin

Ok, it's the first law of identity, I know. My point is... there is nothing wrong with people -this is how we are.

Everyone is stupid about some things. some people have trouble with computers which doesn't make them stupid or wrong people, just wrong about computers.

Computer people are often stupid in other ways -There would be no "Computer Guy" on a TV comedy show with people laughing at tech people if it didn't have some universal truth in it.

IMHO Bill Gates is a good example- Extremely Smart about business and marketing. Smartest person in our era about this. Not real technically brilliant though. Neither are his social skills amazing nor is he very attractive to the majority based on physical appearance. That being said.. Steve Jobs is an amazing visionary with a great sense of style. Not really good with business though, amoung other things. We are all just people. There is nothing wrong with that. I enjoy being a person and enjoy accepting others as people to.
It sounds like the person in your example does not get this and perhaps something in her triggered when you said this. Now you need to accept that it is her issue inside her, you have your own, you don't need and can't help hers. I would just give her space when she needs it (she will obviously let you know this) and remain friendly and normal around her. Usually when people are insulted or angered etc. it is because of what is in them -not you. You can't get angry about something you don't understand. The same with insults. Someone with good self esteem is not taken aback by insults. She is insulted because she believes there is something wrong with her and waits for this to be triggered. Just care about her as a person and be friendly. You don't need to change you for her or anyones sake. Why would you even think of not being who you are?

by fluxit

I can tell you I do not have esteem issues, anger, or be someone I am not. My skin is as thick as a pachyderm as I have been in trying places over the years.

In fact, today I was insulted by an one who can dish it out but cannot take it. When I shot back in kind, he became mad and attacked on a personal level.

Many are good at projection but cannot deal with thier reflection. Projection is immature. Reflection is in kind and is not accepted by people who have poor esteems which is why in the first place they projected. A vicious cycle - isn't it.

Years ago I used to get bottled up, minimized talk, and people seemed to get the better of me.
After a hard knocks and put downs I decided to use a few tactics.

1. To reflect thier behavior or a matching of the witz. People back down quickly. This guy today responded quickly with a personal attack after reflecting. I then reflected in the same tone the exact argument he was insinuating about me. He stopped, thought, then left.

2. Many times, I search for a joke or humorous story to divert the attention onto objects and stories. This is most effective and benign.

3. Maintain focus and not flinch or digress is best when in really sticky situations such as bosses whospew crap. I had one boss who insulted IT people with cross analogies and gratuitous insults. One day I was sick of it and threw it back. He went off the wall running in and out of my office screaming that he will win. He is always right. I continued working and acted as though he was not even there just letting him vent. As it turned out his wife always put him down and made a joke of him I learned.

In short, my interest is in at least determining what happens in that air gap between the two minds that bring on such different stories. Also what should I do to minimize the issue in the first place?

by packratt

1. You don't always have to be right.
2. When talking with people it does not serve your needs to talk at them.
3. Listen and find reason in what others say, sometimes you might be wrong.
4. When wrong, accept it gracefully and learn from it.
5.When someone else is wrong, sometimes you cannot teach them elsewise and you have to accept that.
6. Sometimes, it's best just to keep quiet and let people prove themselves wrong.
7. When people get emotional, it's best to back off and let hot heads cool down.
8. Accept the limitations of others by looking at your own limitations.
9. There is a difference between an argument and a fight.
10. You can always learn something from everyone, all people have value.

by admin

A viscious cycle or also an opportunity to learn and grow with the help of others. We all need mirrors :) Anyway, Thank You! I really appreciated this point and it was useful to me today already.

Those without grounds or abililty do often lash out ad hominum and this is an attack best recognized for what it is, their life challenge.
I think this is the air gap quite often, something inside them that they have not shared with you, or even often shared with themselves. This is why you cannot do anything about it. To minimize it you do not let it affect you. It's a bit like responding to terrorism, if it will change nothing then it is rendered completely ineffective. I would just be the same way as before the incident and it will most likely go away quicker than with any other response. :)

by admin

I actually wasn't referring to you nor did I mean to imply that you were angry or had esteem issues. Rather, I meant that when she was angry, that this had nothing to with you most likely. It was something that she may have understood (at some level) and you did not. She did not share this with you so you cannot be expected to understand it. Also with esteem, if her sense of self was internal, then your comments would not have affected her in the same way. What I was saying was that there may be no way that you can understand this event because it is in her and she is not sharing with you (or possibly herself) why she reacted this way. Perhaps you could let it blow over a bit then be generally nice and provide her with positive comments when possible and although this will still not guarantee that she will respond positively, this is good because you have sincerely tried :)

by hmsardenberg

I can totally understand your problem. Sometimes it's better to maintain a safe professional distance from the users. A lot of times the user may not have the necessary skills on software they need to know for their job. So, rather than ask questions or consult the manuals or help files, they blame the IT support people or the software for not working. That's a common excuse that users have for not doing their jobs. That way they can look good for their supervisor.

by hmsardenberg

That's a very paranoid attitude you have. But I cannot disagree w/ you. If you could have a dollart for each time users here have gone around my back to a VP or the CIO to report a computer problem before even calling the helpdesk or checking w/ me, I would be able to double my salary. It's very sad that people have this attitude, that's why an IT professional needs to DOCUMENT everything. That's your only protection against any allegations that will surely come up even when you DON't make mistakes.

by packratt

Not paranoid, if that were the case I would hide in my office all the time instead of part of the time. ;)

Really, if you think about the prevalent attitude carried by most executives and managers you can see the patterns of patronization and belittlement that describe the general attitude these people have towards employees.

I have heard managers and executives talk about "how far out I booted so-and-so" or "you should have seen the look on what's-his-face when I ripped him a new one" countless times and in countless companies. If you haven't seen the direct results of an employer's cavalier attitude about other people that are in direct opposition to the catch-phrase du jour of "we care" then you are either extremely lucky or just forcing yourself into denial.

It's hard to believe that people still think this isn't the norm after Enron, those executives bailed out with hundreds of millions while stepping on employees like they were something squishy they stepped in. If you think they are the exception, I've been around the block many times and I tell you it's the rule, not an exception.

You are not a member of any family as an employee, you are a stepping stone, a squishy thing, a disposable commodity, a resource, atool... Never, never ever an equal or fellow human being.

Documenting things is fine, but when it boils down to it, there is little recourse that is available to you as an employee if someone higher up decides to take a bad day out on you since it's still your word against theirs.

by packratt

If you look up a dozen posts or some such you will see that in my reply to generalist that I do indicate that I have indeed read a few of these books that we happen to be discussing.

*sigh*

This is the thread that never ends,
it just goes on and on my friend,
somebody started posting it not knowing what it was,
And they'll go on posting to it just because...

by nonamecharlie

Can't control other people's reactions. You rectified the situation later, she chose to believe something else.

Nothing you can do but smile and try not to hold a grudge.

by fluxit

I would like to hank everyone for thier inputs and efforts here.

Its time to move on. Thanks!

by rusty ferrari

Well, if they ask questions like that then they are probably expecting some good techno-babble. I just think it should be avoided as a general rule. Obviously certain circumstances require specific answers.

by xpertdragon

I think first off that many I.T. professionals get a bad rap about not being very personable in the first place. You might be a little more shook up about this situation than you need to be. I am and have been in a similar situation as you way too many times. Sure, it often the fault of the user, who feels that most of the time you are the "Go To" person for all I.T needs, including favors from time to time. The downside to all this, is that you can get caught up in a friendly office environment with all the fun and games until someone takes offense to a comment that you have made. Ultimately, this reflects porrly on you, and gets reported officially or through the grapvine to your boss or supervisor.

As an I.T. support professional you probably know each and every person within your company walls better than most of your co-workers. You know who messes with their PC settings the most, who complains about how slow their PC is the most, who is the messiest in the cubicle, on and on, etc.

I am not exactly sure what you mean by people looking for something.....do you mean as a method to get yuo fired or terminated, or do you mean something else all together. The overall advise I could give you is not to be complete tech "fish", someone without personality, and without having a little fun in the work place. Deal with each user on a case by case basis. If they have burned you in some way in the past, keep it strictly technical with them and straight to the point.Explain that you are there to fix their PC/networking problems and nothing more....They will eventaully catch on to the bigger picture and figure things out on their own.

Paul M. Chavez

by tony

So my suggestion to you would be this. You apparently meant no offense by you comments. Irregardless of whether she took it wrong, you said it wrong, whatever......she was offended so go to her with a humble attitude and say..."Please forgive me foroffending you. I didn't mean anything by what I said and I am sorry that this has gone as far as it has." That's it. Don't try to justify or explain your actions as that will only weaken your wanting to resolve her offense. Other than that don't stop being yourself. Unfortunately things like this will happen and deal with them when they come up. If your boss has any sense he will know without a question in his mind that you would never offend or say anything off color. Otherwise if you have then step up to the plate and take your licks. This lady I don't think is trying to be mean to you but ...... you have triggered something in her that is sensitive. So rather than complicating things go to her with your initial attitude which was one ofcamaraderie and let her know you meant nothing.
Good Luck!
Tony

This discussion is closed to new replies.