Discussion Locked

What's your Email Client?

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Having been fed up slowly over time with our company's choice of Outlook 97 for our mail client, I'm looking into new mail client alternatives.

We use e-mail HEAVILY and I can't stress that enough. On average one of our employees will send and receive about 100 emails per day. That's not even the highest, we have a few managers who have sent as much as 250 emails in one day.

Most of the volume includes attachments, the reason for the volume is because they send work orders, invoices and spec sheets to our network of vendors (well over 25,000 - nationwide).

Anyway, Outlook apparently can't handle the volume we throw at it (some most users have over 100 meg .PST files, one salesperson had 500 megs of e-mail). Backing up the mail is another issue I know, but what do you guys use that seems to be able to handle (ie. NOT CRASH) when you throw high volumes of mail at it?

Thanks for your input.

-Tom

8 replies

by lordinfidel

I'm sure by reading all of my posts you know what I'm going to say.

So it is no wonder why my client/server of choice is Outlook 2k in conjuction with Exchange. (i use 5.5)

No matter what our feelings are against M$. Exchange is by far the most stable, robust mail server out there. It is the flagship of mail servers.

When used in it's native form, Outlook with exchange is a beautiful thing. Throw extension blocking on the gateway (trend or mccaffe). And you have a powerful antiviral resource.

Exchange is RFC compliant to the hilt and plays well with other mail gateways. And you can not beat the remote mgmt. There is nothing like opening up a users mailbox from your desktop to tell them that they are high.

I do reccommend though before even thinking of switching to exchnage, is reading this book:
Managing Exchange Server from O'reilly.

It will give you extreme insights on how to configure and install exchnage. Pay attention to the raid levels and where to put the database and logs. This makes a lot of difference on speed and reliability.

And the best thing, no more psts, and you can regulate mailbox sizes down to the individual user!

by tomsal

Hey man, nice to read your posts again.

If you read my reply to the other post it kind of explains my situation a bit better. I don't think its our mail server, I feel (quite strongly) that its our clients.

You are right Exchange is good stuff (though Gates is a greedy bastard, but that's another post). Unfortunately, at the time of us making the decision to host our own mail server our budget was *VERY* limited - in fact at first I didn't think we could find a solution for the kind of money they were giving me to go with. Then I found Imail which amazingly fell into our thin budget.

I have a hint that our mail problems could be with the version of Outlook too.. Because while every emails heavily here, 97% of the company is usingOutlook 97, while a scant few of us actually have Outlook 2000 (like me), well to date this email crash problem hasn't happened to any of the Outlook 2000 users yet. As a side note, I have applied the service patches to Outlook 97 and I did try the solutions in the MS knowledgebase as well.

Ironically enough just before I started my reply to your post another user just informed me that her email crashed. Ugh!

I appreciate your advice and am grateful for your input.

Thanks.

by lordinfidel

2K is more stable of an e-mail client, although I have seen it mysteriously crash..

But not as much as 97.

I know I don't have to say it for you, but for others who are reading here it goes.

If your mail client appears sluggish there are a few different places to look depending on the system.

1. How big is your pst file... The bigger the file, the more info your client needs to handle.

2. What other programs are running and what is your cpu speed and memory.

If it looks like mail just is not getting delivered to your e-mail client and you client is using pop. Set the check time higher. The negaitive to this, it creates more network traffic.

If you are still not getting mail, then you need to check on the mail server. Plus who knows if the other mail server has sent the e-mail to you yet.

A common misconception is thinking that e-mail is automatic. There is a lot that goes into it's transferral from client-to server-thru the net-to server-to client.

by tbragsda

A lot depends on your budget, but I say away from Outlook. What's on the back-end? Novell GroupWise is a wonderful back-end email system, the client is good, but use what you like, its the server your problem having troubles with.

How many users? How many POs? Thought about Domino?

by tomsal

Thanks for your insight. I must, respectfully, disagree with you however. I strongly do not think our problem is our mail *server*, I wholly believe its the client.

Our mail server is great its Imail v7.07. It lacks a few (but not many) of the features of Exchange but, as you've heard me babble before I'm sure - we are small, so we need the most cost effective solution. Imail is extremely affordable.

The reasons why I doubt that its our server is because a few things:

(1) Just plain obvious - The server never crashes, nothing about a crash or problem ever appears on the server logs. The clients however shoot up "Outlook messaging Interface" errors and specifically a fatal exception in MINET.DLL and MAPISP32.DLL - which if you knowor not they are part of Microsoft Messaging (which in turn is a component of Outlook 97). There are some Microsoft Knowledge Base "solutions" about this problem as well, its just that they don't appear to be a fix - but rather a bandaid. The fact that they are in the MS knowledge base leads me to believe its an Outlook problem as well.

(2) I am testing a few of the users who constantly crash with Outlook - they are using Eudora 5.1 (free version) and though its premature to judge right now, so far no problems at all.

(fingers crossed)

I do appreciate your input, and if I were given a bigger budget perhaps I would of chosen a more robust server than Imail but I kinda am stuck with what we got now and have to work with it. I can replace the clients though.

by tbragsda

Sorry I cant be of more help. I know the frustrations of budget constants. Although I have never used Eudora it in business environment, I have several developers that refuse to use the CO approved client, and swear by Calypso.

by green team

Outlook 97 is horrible...that is why there is Outlook 98. If your people are used to Outlook then you may not want to take those features away from them. I would suggest upgrading to 98 at least.

by ekb

The Outlook 97 version i'm using is 8.03

I think you can minimize the PST file size, coz i encounter some of my user's PST above 100MB are tend to crash.

Hope it helps.

This discussion is closed to new replies.