I am the Sr. Administrator for a mid-size company in the central U.S., and also happen to do all of the technology purchasing. How to decide upon a vendor? I am careful about what I purchase because not only do I have budgetary contraints to work within, but I am also the person who has to make it work after the equipment goes in.
I often, as you did, ask for advice from people who've been there/done that. Having said that, I find that barring a stream of horror stories from a wide variety of people all pointing at a single culprit, the answer is usually "it doesn't matter". Do an apples-to-apples comparison and pick the cheapest thing that meets your current and projected needs (including reliability and support) over its lifetime. Virtually all the time, your equipment will be obsolete before you ever experience a failure with a particular item.
Having said that, we had one department go outside the normal purchasing stream and buy a cheap desktop from Tiger Direct. I put two power supplies in it in two years...I finally tossed it in the trash and gave them a Dell. However, even that is merely anecdotal, another company might be doing fine with TD.
When I started here in 2002 we had all Unisys computer equipment (because they also provided some of our highspeed document handlers). The servers were mostly HP and one or two Dells (Unisys is a re-brander, not a manufacturer). Desktops when I got here were mostly Unisys/HP and (I'm embarrassed to say) a few EMachines.
I made the decision early on to migrate us to Dell, because the pricing was better than Unisys for the same equipment, and we would get direct parts support. We now are almost exclusively a Dell house, with a few Unisys legacy servers. Yes, Dell, like virtually all technology companies uses refurbished parts as repair parts.
(It's why they have you return bad parts--a bad 50-cent thermistor on a laser printer fuser assembly is not reason enough to toss out $100 worth of other parts attached to the assembly...they replace the thermistor, check the assembly's operation, clean it up and put it in the repair parts stream. To do otherwise would drive prices way up on both equipment and service contracts.)
I have installed approximately 25 Dell servers and 100 Dell workstations in my tenure here, and have had exactly two equipment failures (one SCSI backplane riser card went bad, and an LTO tape drive wouldn't eject its tape) so my first thought is I am very impressed with the reliability of Dell.
When we had the two problems, both times, a service person was on site within a few hours (we have 4-hour service) as well as a full array of possible repair parts (not just the one that the Dell phone tech thought might be bad). We have never had a part failure with any of the desktops, some of which which are now getting close to three years old.
This is not to say that you couldn't have the same reliability with another brand, nor is it a guarantee that your first 10 Dell boxes won't be shipped with the same bad part...stuff happens, and as long as they fix it, it doesn't make them a bad company.
Regardless of whom you choose, it might be wise to pick a brand and stick with it. Not only will it be easier to support, but it may give you a bit of leverage if you happen to find your company not performing up to your expectations. We have spent about a quarter million dollars with Dell over the last several years, and while we are certainly not in the big leagues on their customer list, it does get us noticed if we need something.
I don't go as far as insisting every machine have the same chipset or brand of hard drive. Others may have imaging issues to consider and need a common set of hardware to work with for driver compatibility, but our desktops come with everything we need already on them, we don't do image deployment. For our purposes, the differences between components are so minor that spending time worrying about how to support Seagate drives vs. WD is not relevant. A computer needs to store files and run programs, and keep working for a few years until it's time to replace it. Beyond that, the discussion becomes way too esoteric for my purposes. Others can debate those things as an intellectual exercise, but I have a business to run.
The most common objection I hear to desktop phone support is the offshore call center. Personally I don't care who I talk to or what kind of accent they have as long as long as they can move my issue along toward resolution. (They probably think you talk funny too.)
Keep in mind that I'm speaking strictly from the "I want my stuff to work" standpoint and not trying to make any kind of political statement about whether offshore tech support costs American jobs. Personally I don't care about any of that when it comes to doing my job, I just want my equipment to work.
Try not to make business decisions based upon the xenophobic philosophies of others. It will cost your company money, and they need it to pay you. (Climbing off the soapbox)
As far as brand loyalty, I find it usually boils down to a Ford/Chevy debate (Or a Microsoft/Apple debate if you will). What a person prefers depends largely upon what their preconceptions are, and what their personal experience has been, which may be completely different than another's experience.
I almost always discard advice from anyone who argues too passionately for a particular course of action, those who insist their way "is the only intelligent way and everyone who doesn't see it that way is an idiot." Their posts in the forums are usually sprinkled liberally with CAPS which tells me they're speaking from emotion and not giving me data I can use to make an intelligent business decision.
My advice is get the best deal you can and if the deals are very similar, take a deep breath and go with your gut.