Discussion Locked

Why do IT people really bash Windows?

0 helpful
719 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I wrote about this in another thread in response to a comparison of windows question.

Anyway, it's a hot topic in my opinion so let me recap. Comment away. :)

Why does everyone "bash" Windows? I could sit here and bash linux, windows, mac os and anything else, but that is just pointless and pedantic.

The point is every operating system has it uses. You just need to choose what best suits your needs.

Anyone who claims to hate Microsoft Windows, Linux, Mac OS or any other operating system is not a true techie or network guru. You don't ever bash the OS, in fact if the OS crashes then it's your fault not the OS; Why didn't you make sure that it was using the right drivers, or the hardware is compatible or blah this and blah that, and so the list goes. Any OS crashes for a reason, not because it just feels like it. Compatability is there for a very good reason, why support something that is old when you need to keep moving forwards. Example, all leaded petrol car owners here in Australia can no longer purchase leaded petrol, they are forced now to use unleaded and an additive. Why? Because those cars are so old and they are few and far between now because unleaded cars are cheap enough to buy second hand as your first car. Get my point there?

719 replies

by the admiral

I think the reason that so many techies bash Microsoft products in general because of so many of the ways that they can be hacked into.

I mean, sure there are the same vulnerabilities in other operating systems, but I have only seen the one where the description added to a GIF becomes a PC's weakest link. Obsurd if you think about how silly that vulnerability is.

I think people were hit with so many patches that they told Microsoft to can it, and when they slowed down, they complainted even more. So it is all about perception.

by stress junkie

I looked at your TR profile. From what I can gather you have been working in the field about six years and you have only worked with M$ products. You have no background to support the kinds of statements that you are making regarding all operating systems. Statements like "You don't ever bash the OS..." don't make any sense.

I would recommend that you spend a few hours every week reading the following web site:

http://secunia.com/product/
http://secunia.com/advisories/

Most of the people who "bash" M$ products will readily admit that their favorite OS is not perfect. People are mostly angry about the lack of interest that M$ has consistently displayed over the years toward product quality. Most other OS products enjoy a higher dedication to quality from their creators than the M$ products experience. When other OS vendors find a problem they fix it once and it stays fixed. That is not true of M$ products.

Look up products on the Secunia web site such as Sun Microsystems' Solaris/Sun OS and IBM AIX. Compare those products to any M$ product. There is an obvious quality gap between M$ and almost everyone else. Look at the most recent problems with M$. Windows Color Management Module Buffer Overflow. Word Font Parsing Buffer Overflow. These are completely idiotic. Consider the fact that Windows REQUIRES the Remote Procedure Call service to be enabled, even on computers that aren't connected to a network. This is idiotic. Consider that all interprocess communications in Windows goes into a global buffer readable by all processes. That is a privilege separation problem. It's been a "feature" of Windows since version 1. You don't see that kind of problem on ANY other multiuser, multitasking OS. There are a lot of fundamental design problems in Windows that don't exist in any other operating system.

And now you know the rest of the story.

LSMFT

by Former member

I don't include everything in my profile. Yes officially I have been in IT since around 1999. Out side of that however I have been running around the IT scene for since 1989. Up until 1999 I considered what I was learning nothing more than a hobbie. Anyway, I have not soley worked with MS products, I also work currently with the Mac OS from 7.6 upwards and Linux.

What I am also trying to say is that while MS product "features" always get the limelight there are other OS' that also have problems as well. Yes they might be patched up quick, like Linux, because some of the other products, like Linux, are open source meaning anyone can make the fix provided it works without errors afterwards and release it. Yes MS are not releasing patches when they should, like the fact that until recently anyone using the Windows Firewall on dial-up was not actually protected at all. Yes MS are slow to remove any faults or security risks in their OS, yes until the release of Windows x64 there were hundreds of buffer overflow exploits that allowed many a virus writer to bring a system down.

The thing I a trying to point out is that in the end, it's not the OS maker but the user that causes the system to crash. I can give a customer a brand new PC and when I check up on it one month on after they bought it, they usually have problems, all associated with either software or hardware they installed after they bought the machine. Most users don't stop and think before they install any software or hardware. They just go ahead and do it. That's when the OS crashes, that's when the system has problems. You can't sit there and bash an OS if it doesn't work the way you want. Dump it and run wit another OS instead. One better suited to what your needs are. Don't complain about it.

Yes you can say there are a lot of fundamental problems in Windows, but I bet there are fundamental problems in the Mac OS, Linux, Unix, Sun OS and the myriad of other OS' out there. They just don't get the limelight because as unfortunate as it is, more than half the world's IT runs on Windows. If everyone ran open source I'm sure we wouldn't have half the OS crashes, security risks and so on that we have now.

:)

by stress junkie

All right then. I reached the wrong conclusions about the scope of your experience when I read your profile.

On another topic I was concerned that the tone of my post would be interpreted as being hostile. I wasn't clever enough to put in a note like the one in your last post "end of rant...". That was a good idea. I wish that I had thought of that when I wrote my post.

Regarding the topic at hand I don't know what more I can say. I summarized the case against M$ pretty well in my last post. Anyone is free to believe the assertions or not believe them. Those of us that are vigorously against M$ products believe that there is an essential difference between the way M$ products are designed and implemented versus products from other vendors. We believe that the attitude behind the design and implementation of M$ products is lacking in attention to security issues. Some of us are also upset that M$ requires product registration in order to get their recent products to work at all. Other issues include the problems around reinstalling and reregistering a recent M$ OS on the same machine and M$ products collecting computer usage information.

As you said in your last post, no malice intended.

LSMFT

by hal 9000

To me how this happened. I know I'm not great Windows Fanatic but I do believe that it should retain a semblance of some sort of stability.

On a clean install of XP Pro SP2 just fully patched and all the software loaded under 48 hours ago I checked my e-mail then went out for a job, 6 hours latter I got a message that Outlook was not my default E-Mail client and did I wish to allow this. Now in the intervening time no one has touched the unit and for some reason Windows changed the parameters that it was prepared to work under.

Now every bit of software on this workstation is work related not a single game of any sort not even the ones that come packaged with XP it's just a plain but powerful workstation with no frills to make it nicer to look at. The thing is full y loaded with the most powerful CPU's that the M'Board can support has as much RAM as the M'Board will support has every PCI slot filled with work related devices and the only thing that I can add more of are SCSI HDD's. Currently I only have 16 internal ones installed.

Now this unit isn't directly connected to the Internet buy runs through a Linux Gateway which is quite well locked down and then in front of that is a Router which has the latest Updates installed so by all accounts it should be safe but it still changes a basic OS function.

I'll not go into the reason for the reload as it is still a painful unnecessary experience that I'm just now beginning to recover from.

But really my biggest gripe with M$ is their business practices like here I use Volume License stuff from M$ and when I applied SP1 I had to change the Product Key and then when SP2 was installed the next time that I logged onto M$ Web Site to download something I was informed that I didn't have a "Real" version of Windows even though I know that the place that I buy this stuff from is one of 3 AU M$ Volume License suppliers and it is perfectly legal.

Now I'm lucky here as I only have 20 odd Windows Boxes that I have to change but some of my customers have a lot more and it takes a lot of time and money to change the product keys so that these units remain "Legal" according to M$. One client paid for 11 of us to work one Easter to just change all the Product Keys over on 2,500 workstations so they could push out SP1. We did manage to finish the job in under the 4 days but only just and I'll leave you to guess who paid for the privilege to be able to install SP1 but I'll give you a clue it wasn't Microsoft!

Part of the reason that I'm now using Linux Servers exclusively is the fact that the Licensing with the M$ Server products is a mess you pay through the nose for a product and then have to pay additional license fees for the excess units that are not supported by the already expensive product that you have just brought. Sure over here it is only $80.00 AU per additional License but that does add up when you are talking about 100 additional Licenses that is only $8,000.00 AU that is required.

Then once a month we are in a mad rush to test the latest M$ patches before rolling them out knowing all the time that the longer we delay in testing and making sure that nothing gets broken by the latest "Fix" the more vulnerable the system is. So like previously when we could test one patch at a time as they became available we are now rushing through tests just to get the systems as secure as possible and then fixing the broken things after-wards. In this place we call it the MS Monthly Blues, or The Wrong Time of the Month.

When I started working with computers they where Main Frames and most of the time I was sitting around watching the system working and not spending all my time constantly patching or testing patches and then running around fixing broken Apps or hardware. It then just didn't happen. We also didn't have any intrusions either and it honestly was not such a big problem we only had to worry about foreign governments trying to hack our system, now it appears that every Boy & his Dog are at it and we are now working so much harder to keep the systems secure and if there are Windows Servers involved on the wrong side of the DMZ it is only that much harder.

I actually see Windows as an easy alternative that requires nothing more than a hungry monkey to be able to use but along with that ease of use come security nightmares which really have not been addressed by M$ "Trusted Computing" they are just hidden better.

Someone used this in another discussion which I just loved {Throw a rock at a Window and it breaks! Throw a rock at a Penguin and it gets mad and attacks you!" or at least it went something like that. :D

I'll add it too "Rant finished No malice intended!" :)

Col ]:)

by tomsal

I'm sorry, and maybe I'm out of line here for a bit but from what I glean from your postings I really don't think you have that much experience with what you are talking about. Now if you read that as offensive, that isn't my intent with what I say -- I'm just not gonna coddle you with blowing sunshine up your arse on such an issue.

Windows is inherently flawed moreso than other OSes. Its memory management alone is laughable at best, though XP did greatly improve on it.

I don't update every little thing in my TR profile either, haven't in a while actually. Most of my experience has been MS based as well -- the last couple years I have deployed some Linux servers, in college for 2 years I was using Mac's in a lab environment. I really am a PC person, I don't like Apple for more reasons due to their company philosophy/management than their products though.

I more a network and hardware junkie than I am a software guy.

But as you know in this biz -- if you do networking and configure/troubleshoot the hardware you have to know what the OS does.

So in conclusion, I think to say that if the machine crashes/the os crashes that its the user's fault and not the OS is absurd.

True proper maintenance practices on our computers, security measures and policies help to keep things running in much more efficient and reliable fashion than if you ignore everything. However, I've had the OS crash on me many times over the years and I can vouch that the hardware is all very sound, the drivers up to date, the server properly configured, etc.

Simply put there is no logical reason why I should get/have gotten BSODs. For a while there I even used MS Tech Support, I searched high and low on the knowledge base, talked to the software vendors. Applications are proper version for the OS I installed them on, sys req's were well exceeded for the software, etc.

Funny on the Mandrake f/p server I have had running -- that thing never dies. Also the email server for a website I partcipate in (because there is a team of folks who work on the site -- I'm no web designer) is Linux and that thing gets pounded. It needed a restart once because of a crash -- granted that was a software config issue, it was easily solvable. But that was it.

I think MS is slowly getting there, but they still aren't "there" yet.

by rapt0r

So my Windows server that does nothing but act as a file server, and bsod yesterday, its the users fault? Which user? No one is logged on at the console. The stop error had to do with a very common, but very vague page fault in memory. Yeah, that helps a lot. The server hardware isn't white box, it's a Dell (all of it from Dell) and I know they aren't the best, but it is all run of the mill, get it anywhere gear. Nothing obscure. Let a drive fail and watch Windows die. My Linux box can have a drive failure and stay up. Same for my Solaris box. Face it, Windows has some fundamental flaws that can only be addressed with a ground up rewrite, but that isn't going to happen.

As for other OS problems, yes, others do have problems, they just don't cause the headaches and grief that Windows does. My users on other OSes have apps crash, but the OS doesn't. And security bug aren't as easily exploited on these other OSes either. When Firefox had an issue a couple of months ago, it had to be installed on Windows, any other OS - no problem. As for IT running more than half on Windows, only the on the desktop, not anywhere else. In the enterprise Windows is nowhere near being the big dog in the server room. *nix outnumbers my Windows servers and I'm slowly moving desktops to another platform (Linux or Mac OSX) as well. Not complaining or griping, just doing something about the problem - getting rid of it.

by peterjohnmurphy

Ok, you have made some good points like the fact that it is the end user that causes a system to crash by installing software/hardware, but just think for a second, all of these products being installed are obviously supposed to be M$ compatible so installing a product designed for an M$ environment should not cause problems (unless end user ignorance results in incorrect configuration). Windows Operating Systems are far too easy to break! Saying that XP in my opinion is the easiest to fix operating system that our mate Bill has brought out..but wait.. didn't that too fail on is grand unveiling??
Microsoft have obviously got the majority of the market but only because they release products that have been developed in a rush to beat the competition to the line (even if you back to the 3.* OS, which of course is DOS with a GUI designed to beat Apple)... How many more service packs need to be released before they can correct all the mistakes on each OS!!

by alarena

Thanks for the education. I'm loving the answers, but the author must think he's getting nuked. My guess was new or in a "fresh HDD baked" environment.

by daniel.muzrall

Face it, life isn't fair, and nothing out there is perfect. I would say that MS catches more flack than just about any other OS/software maker out there because of brand recognition and "popularity." Windows is pretty much ubiquitous with the the PC. How many different distributions are there for Linux? How many variants of UNIX are out there? How many users of Linux, UNIX, Mac OS, OS/2, or any other OS are there? Talk to any of those users and once they get past the fact that they aren't using Windows, they'll have their fair share of gripes about their own OS. Nothing is perfect. MS gets bashed because its market share makes it an easy and very large target.

Don't get me wrong, I've got my own gripes about MS, starting with how it gained its market share. I remember back in the old days when I was running MS Word off a single floppy disk on Mac OS 6.0.7. I remember when the OS used to fit on 3 floppies (DOS 6.2). OS and software footprint bloat is one of my gripes. Security is one of my gripes. "Undocumented" features that can cause a whole host of problems is another. The MS focus on cranking out products to generate revenue is understandable...that's business...but to do so at the the cost of security and system stability is very worrisome to me. I think if MS put in a little more time and effort up front, they could save much more time and money on the back end developing patches when they could be developing new products and features.

But I digress...no OS is perfect, no OS has 100% uptime or a lack of its own quirks. It all comes down to market share and experience... Microsoft controls more market share than anyone else in the industry, therefore more people are exposed to its products, therefore there are more people poking it with a stick, and therefore finding more problems with it. That's just how it goes.

For the record, I've been working in IT since 1994 and have supported Mac OS 6.0 on, DOS 5.0 on, Windows 3.11 on, and have dabled in UNIX and Linux.

by hal 9000

Is that MS themselves accept the flack that they cop and while not totally ignoring it as I've had a few phone calls about how I feel they are going as both a company and OS maker. They not only want constructive criticism but demand it.

Then there are the M$ users out there who seem to think that any criticism of their preferred OS is an attack upon them personally, they are the ones caring the fight and getting worked up with any faults within Windows being pointed out.

Perhaps M$ rings every one of their Partners and asks them how we feel they are doing as a company but from my experience when I have mentioned some things that I think need improving they seem to listen and I do get call backs asking for more information. I can see a lot of the suggestions that I made and no doubt countless others as well being implemented in XP and no Doubt Longhorn as well as 2003.

I don't need to jump up & down screaming at MS for their products which need improving but I can see that they are improving them admittedly at a some what slow rate but then again I can't see how they could go any faster.

The very last question that I'm always asked is "Do I think MS is trying to address their Problems?" and I always answer Yes as they are and with each new OS being released they do get it better but they are not making the Giant Leaps forward that they are capable of making but small incremental steps forward.

So while they are trying they could try harder and at least I know that some of the input that I provide is acted upon even if I'm only one small voice in the wilderness. What I do find extremely interesting is at the Partners Meetings or Software briefings that MS run and I attend I always end up with one of the developers talking shop and improving OS's over drinks long after the meeting has finished so at the very least the developers that I meet seem interested and I don't just do it for the "Free Booze" as I really don't drink all that much now days I do it for the interesting conversation and the way that we just talk shop and they listen and take notes of suggestions on improvements. As far as I'm concerned that could tape the conversations I wouldn't be the slightest bit concerned.

Col ]:)

by mllwyd

I can't speak for why anyone who bashes Windows does so, but I came from a MacOS and Unix background into Windows. Windows is getting better (I first encountered it with Windows 95), but on the consumer side, MacOS is much more stable and reliable, and on the server side, Unix is far more powerful for the administrator. There are tools I took for granted on Unix that you still can't do on Windows servers. The people I know who love Windows usually haven't used anything else extensively.

by djameson

It is simply a numbers game. A standard network is 80-90% windows 4% hardware(routers etc) and ~6% linux. I spend just about as much time making sure my BSD machines are patched as I do updating my windows boxes. You just have to have the right TOOLS. it is the perception that there is more work involved becuase there are more systems involved but per machine, a system is a system.

by jbaker

You know, as much as people bash the M$ OSs, they could simply look on the bright side, and count it as job security. Think about it this way, if all of the OSs worked perfectly, and were perectly secured, what need would companies have for large IT staffs? They would be able to get away with one person to manage the networks, and some people to work on hardware issues.

Thankfully, there are no perfect OSs. Even the beloved pinguin is not totally secure, and a properly installed, and configured M$ machine os a fairly stable thing (there will ALWAYS be hardware that does not like to play nicely with other hardware and software that is the same way).

by hal 9000

That the IT staff could be doing their real work instead of playing Nurse Maid or Wet Nurse to the Windows Boxes which are constantly in need of attention.

The one good thing with most of my customers is that they turn off their workstations every day so they do not run into memory leeks and the like that do happen to Windows when left running 24/7.

Col ]:)

by jaqui

since I detest being lied to by both the os and the company that made it, and I detest having optons stolen from me by them I bash windows.
and ms

when ms gets a version that has all the same options as linux during install, that allows for console only use of system, that doesn't require 48 hours to install software ( never mind configuration time )

where you can site down with 3 cdroms and have everything you need for either a desktop worksttion or server then I'll stop bashing the imbeciles.

by jbaker

If it is taking you 48 hours to install Winders, you are doing something wrong. I can have a system reinstalled and deployed in just under 1 hour, and if the machine is a new, clean install, it takes about 2.5 hours, and that includes all of our special software, drivers, etc.

by too old for it

At the place where I am contracting at present, it takes the best part of 4~5 hours, but I suspect that is largely due to the fact (a) our local ghostcast "server" is an older piii rehabbed desktop PC, and (b) it's sending to a lot of workstations.

by djameson

BootP off Linux box pushes XP image specific to MAC to system can have it up in as little as 10 minutes. including the time to replace the HDD.

by jaqui

I'm refering to installing 15 to 20 apps on top of windows, and configuring them as well. each app on it's own cd. each taking about 1 hour to install and one hour to customise.

( graphics apps are not quick installs, some are 3 cdroms for one app )

if this is a workstation, then it's a 48 hour install and config to get it running.
( I've seen some that are a month long for the end user to finalise the configuration )

by amcol

People bash Windows for the same reason they bash Linux or Mac OS. For the same reason they bash SUV's, or abortion, or Clint Eastwood movies, or whatever. Because everyone's entitled to their opinion, and because those opinions always run the gamut from one extreme to the other.

I take umbrage at your statement "Anyone who claims to hate Microsoft Windows, Linux, Mac OS or any other operating system is not a true techie or network guru." While you're entitled to YOUR opinion, your statement is entirely dismissive. To me it's the same as saying "Anyone who doesn't worship as I do is not truly religious." Hogwash, and it's principally what's wrong with the world today.

There's room in all things for all different points of view. Radical fundamentalism in any form is just another way of saying "I'm right, you're wrong, and that's just all there is to it.". Check, please.

by brandon.aiken

I bash it for a few reasons:

1. I dislike MS's anti-competitive business practices. Makes great sense for them, but harms me as a consumer.

2. As an IT professional, I see Windows-based systems requiring inordinate amounts of management. A good Linux or Unix system acts like an appliance. Windows is needy and demanding of constant attention.

by tpernas

I'll admit that Wintel solutions are needy, however it is that reason that helps keep me employed! I'm the type of nerd that wants to know all OS's so that no matter what environment I work in, I can be an assett. My current environment is almost exclusive to Solaris. They are mistakenly introducing M$, and I will be there to help clean up!!!!!

by markand

I second HAL9000 comments. I don't run nearly as big a shop as HAL9000 does, but I agree with 98% of what he says, and I'll comp him the other 2%.

Even in a prefect world of new hardware and clean installations, it take about 10% of my time to monitor and patch Microsoft Windows and Office products. This does not include the Microsoft Antispyware beta and a host of other product, like Symantec Antivirus, Ad-Aware and SpyBot.

By contrast our hardware is very reliable. In a 70 PC, 9 server shop, I lose 1 or 2 machines a year because a hard disk fails. Those machines vary between 3 and 10 years old. That's not a bad loss considering the age of the machines.

So, conservatively, I spend 4 hours a week or 200+ hours a year on basic maintenance only. That is a lot of time, and time is money. I haven't penciled out the cost of replacing those machines with newer gear, or some magic machine that doesn't need to be patched as much. Unfortunately, I doubt I'd save enough money to justify replacing Windows boxes with machines that need to be patched less; any model I create would have to include the cost of other lost staff time.

Another issue is that my employer is in a very vertical market - behavioral health. There is exactly ONE vendor with a software package that meets most of our needs and generates billing files in a very specific format. That package runs on Windows, so that is that (and anybody who suggests writing code for another platform will quickly discover the end of my patience).

Mainframe and minicomputers had their very real problems, mostly cost. Fundamental reliability was not one of those problems. It just goes to show that you get what you pay for.

by too old for it

"There is exactly ONE vendor with a software package that meets most of our needs and generates billing files in a very specific format. That package runs on Windows, so that is that ..."

I think Markand has backed into the reason for the bashing. Most MS bashers have never had the dubious pleasure (or taken the opportunity) to go up to the executive suite and replace the Admin to the CEO's PC with a linux box over lunch, and then take the rest of the afternoon off. They would finally get to hear some real heartfelt (and colorful!!) linux bashing, and realize just how silly the MS basing generally sounds.

I got seriously burned out on the MS bashing when I worked for a guy who programmed in C for a SCO Unix OS 3 system, using vi. His stock answer for any other OS, any other editor, any other anything was "Why would you want to do that?" which roughly translated into english was "I don't want to change." No one outside the IT department of most firms wants to migrate away from MS Windows (or MAC OS or whatever gets the job done).

I have a couple of linux projects on the back burner here, but none of them will replace frontline MS Windows installs.

by hal 9000

That the techs are sick and tied of caring the Can for M$ products as we are the ones who get the blame where some computer illiterate CEO, CIO or whoever messes things up and we have to fix them.

Have you ever noticed that these people are the last to admit that they did anything wrong but expect us to have it fixed in 1 nanosecond as it only took them 3 minutes to totally hose out the OS?

Tomorrow I'm going down to a business to program up an I-Pod so that the CEO can play tunes while he is overseas with his Acer Note Book holding all the music. Of course he has messed up the entire installation and there are over 3K of files that he wants transfered into the I Tunes Program all of which he has already moved in there and are not recognized.

As I constantly work with this technology :D I really don't have a clue as I've never actually touched any of it anywhere at all so that should be a day well spent but it has to be done tomorrow so he can have his play toys on his overseas trip the next day. :(

They constantly leave it to the last minute and then expect miracle's performed particularly on equipment that they don't allow in the office environment but expect you to know inside out. ;)

Col ]:)

by tony hopkinson

If we don't highlight faults in the OS, why would they bother fixing them ?

Half my career has been spent on windows boxes, and given the general business environment I still recommend using them. That doesn't mean for one moment, that I can't point out it's technical shortcomings even in the areas where it's meant to be at it's strongest.

I don't hate windows, it's not important enough, don't even hate MS or even good ol' Bill.

Someone telling ms is so sucessful in the market place therefore it must be technically sound and when it goes wrong it must have been my fault takes me for an idiot though, and I do hate that.

I'd be the first to admit I've made one or two mistakes that have crashed a windows system, I've also crashed DOS, Linux, HP MPE/XL and VMS as well, not to mention various PLCs 8 bit processors and even my son's playstation. Nowhere near as often though.

To convince me you are correct and I'm some sort of naff amateur all you have to do is answer the following questions in a sensible fashion that adds value to to my use of windows as an OS

Where (consistently !) exactly is the coding error when you get the message 'Unknown OLE Error(5)' or 'Access Violation 000000000 at Address 0000000'

Why do I have to reboot after patching the OS

Why do I have to have a browser installed to have an OS, even when said browser is a horribly insecure and gets used even if I don't use it.

Why did my sound card on my brand new XP SP2 installation stop working after a round of windows update.

Why is relying on error code returns in Windows APIs a really bad idea

Why are profiles better than user privileges

Why is MSN Messenger a default install in my OS

I've got plenty more, if you successfully answer these.

by jaqui

it took me 6 months of concentrated effort to crash a mandrake 6.1 system.*
what did you do to crash yours?
and after how much concentrated effort?

* yes, I actually put the effort in to crash linux, to see how hard / easy it would be.
this is going back to a 1998 version of linux to do this with even.

by too old for it

Back in the day we had a terrible problem with Pre-Caldera SCO UNIX OS3 on Pentium 3 machines. I think P3-800 or so was the current chip, and OS3 would kernel panic about 9 boot out of 10. But if you could hit that 10th boot and it didn't panic, it would be up until the UPS failed.

FWIW, I did get my old Caldera Linux to lock too, but silly me, I was trying to use KDE on a P75 at the time.

by tony hopkinson

command and managed to disappear the root contents. It didn't crash as in ctrl_alt_del but it took a more knowledgable person than I to realise where all the files had gone and get them back.
The only time I've had a reboot to fix problem with linux was with Mandrake 9 installer, it put the wrong NIC diver on to give intermittent lockups. Fortunately I got in in between the machine dropping off the network and then completely locking up. A bit of searching about and installing intel's driver as opposed to the one on the CD fixed it for good. Something to do with it messing up duplex mode apparently. Easy to fix, but I had to get lucky as there were no reported errors in any logging that I could find and cycling the power solved the problem. Total newbie with linux at the time so I spent a lot of time trying to figure out what I'd done wrong this time.
Experience has taught me to believe that initially I'm always the prime suspect.
LOL

by Former member

I'm not saying that Windows is the most perfect operating system in the world. I am trying to say that you shouldn't bash Windows when it doesn't work your way after installing updates or hardware or whatever.

The end user market with hardware and software is the short comming of the Windows operating system. Microsoft do their best, I'm sure, to make Windows compatable across the board as much as possible but in the end there is only so much they can do. If the PC crashes, don't look to the OS, look to the additional software installed afterwards or the hardware within the machine.

Just recently I setup ghost 9 server on an XP box to test it out. After restarting the XP machine kept rebooting 5 seconds into logging into the OS. Even in Safe Mode. Conclusion, ghost 9 made a bad registry change. Action, replace the registry. Result machine worked fine from then on. Installed ghost 9 on another XP machine, no problems at all. Only major difference between the two machines, one was intel based, the othr AMD based. Install on AMD system again, same issue. See what I am getting at.

Granted I'd also like to know where that coding error is, and if you ever ask an MS representative, you'll either get a blank look or the brush off. I have, twice. :) I think only Bill knows.

What's the one thing the OS relys on that tells it how the system should function on startup? The registry. Not knowing the registry that well I am going to theorise that since the HKEY_CURRENT_USER is usually who ever is logged on, any changes to that wouldn't require a restart since they could just be re-applied next log off/log on. Theoretically, you don't need to restart the machine after installing anything, practically some extra installtion probably takes place during the loading of the files that bring up the OS.

You can remove the browser. I don't have IE on my machine because of said security issues. I use Firefox. That's all thanks to the wonderfully helpfull way of accessing the Windows Update site, Automatic Updates. :) I also use Netscape as a backup when sites have issues with Firefox.

Who knows why your sound card stopped working. Most likely problem, sound driver doesn't support that chipset version. Other likely issues, wrong driver, sound card finally died, there's a resource conflict and so on.

API issue thingy. You got me. I don't claim to know everything about computers, and this is one of them. If I did know everything about them, I would be a genius. :)

Profiles and priveleges. Can't think right now... got a paper round here somewhere on that issue specifically. Haven't read up on it yet coz I've got tonnes of other stuff to get through first.

MSN messenger can be a real pain. Especially to remove. Did you know that even if you uninstall it it still remains? True. I tried it and guess what, up popped whatever version of Messenger comes standard with the OS at the time the master copy was compiled. You have to go so far as to not only remove the program but also the associated services.

You know what, I think there's not enough time in the world to learn computers, but yet there is so much to learn. If I don't know anything about a particular subject I find someone who does.

Anyway, this is slightly of topic here but enjoyable none the less. :)

by jmgarvin

1) Because they present their product as something it is not: The end all be all solution to all corporate IT problems AND all home IT problems...

2) Because they don't scale well in a server environment. How many Exchange servers do you need? Now how many qmail/sendmail/postfix servers do you need?

3) Patching, patching, patching, and more patching. While I'm not saying *nix servers don't need to be patched, I am saying that Windows servers have to be patched VERY often...and usually there are patches for patches.

4) Security in the MS world is non-existant. Too many issues with security and too little to actually address the issues.

5) The upgrade cycle is getting out of hand.

by netforce

For a different perspective:

Windows is capitalism
Linux is socialism (for the people/free)
Apple/Mac.......theocracy?

spyware = extortionism
Virus = .....well, there virus

Hey this is fun, add your own

by hal 9000

Windows is a Virus that you pay for knowing full well what it is likely to "Not work the way it is claimed!"

If that is capitalism there is a Hell of a lot to be said for socialism. :p

Col ]:)

by lastchip

I've always considered myself a Capitalist, but perhaps I'm really a Socialist at heart!

by bizzo

I think people bash Windows just because they do.

I've been working with MS OSs for years now, all the way from DOS 3 and have never had a problem. I grew up with Sun OS and then to AIX, wrote systems for OS/2, and have now been working with almost every flavour of Windows. I think each OS has its pros and cons. There are a lot of MS bashers out there because there are a lot of MS machines out there, and in general, people need something to moan about.

I've never had a machine "blue screen", and I've never had a problem with a properly installed, patched and managed machine, other than hardware failures.

Most people seem to be complaining about the amount of time they spend on patching and security updates. Manage your patching properly and it will all fall into place quite nicely.

In one of the posts, someone said it took them 48 hours to build and configure a Windows Server. What??? Did that include delivery of the CDs?

by hal 9000

Granted now M$ aren't quite so bad but at one stage fairly recently before they moved to the "Once a Month" Patches they used to release patches that didn't mealy break computers but totally trashed the OS and a few weeks latter they would remove that patch and eventually replace it with one that didn't do the same amount of damage.

I still have a very vivid memory of installing a Java packet from M$ that hosed the OS to such an extent that the SCSI devices disappeared along with all the external Drives and network connection and that was on a XP Pro installation but admittedly prior to the "Trusted Computing!"

Granted they are much better now but it still is not a massive improvement just enough to lull you into a false sense of security so that when the next bad one comes out you don't just trash your test rig but the entire network. As you have pushed it out before having the proper test done just to make sure that nothing bad happens. That MS Java thing I installed while speaking to the head of MS Technical Department and it was not fixable in any form except wipe the drive and reload as it was on my main workstation it's not something that I'll forget in a hurry and I didn't even think that it would be a dangerous thing to install after all MS had been using Java for years prior to that and it wasn't anything new.

Col ]:)

by jbaker

You forget that M$ was ordered to remove Java from the OS, so if the patch was Java, it was probably from Sun, NOT M$.

by jbaker

About 97% of the times I have seen a blue screen, it has either been a hardware driver acting up, hardware in the process of dying, or software that was poorly written (application, not OS). This includes working with Whistler (prior to release). The only time that I have seen the OS kill itself was Win 3.1, Win 2K SP6, and once or twice (out of hundreds of machines) XP SP2.

Don't get me wrong. M$ has LOTS of room for improvement, but the bashing is unwarranted. Is UNIX/Linux more stable? Probably, but it does not have anywahere near the hardware and software support that Windows does.

by hal 9000

Patches that M$ was pushing out a few years ago that trashed the OS when installed?

Actually I do think that the bashing is warranted as when a M$ product mucks up on a CEO's computer who do you think gets the blame M$ or the local IT guy who has no control over what is happening? It's happened to me on tooooo many occasions now to even want to think about, it's a real nightmare as these people think that once they have a working unit nothing more ever needs doing to it so it is almost impossible to prize the Note Books out of their hands to patch them install Service Packs or whatever as these people see it as unnecessary but still blame their Tech when it breaks.

What is bad enough is that most of them use their NB's to trawl Porn Sites and get them chokers with spy-ware don't keep the AV products up to date and then it's our fault when they break as they have been sold on M$ as being the answer to everything which it clearly isn't but we do have to live with it. :D

Col ]:)

by rapt0r

Linux does have very broad hardware and software support from mainstream vendors (IBM, Sun, Novell, Dell, HP, CA, McAfee, ADIC, Veritas, Oracle, nVidia, ATI, AMD, Intel, Palm, etc.). And then there is all that excellent software over at Sourceforge. And lets not forget that Linux vendors also offer support. About the only people not doing something with Linux is Microsoft.

by husp1

Never had a "Blue screen"? Ever? Your gonna miss out on the best part of M$'s new nightmare I lovingly refer to as "Leghorn" the "Red screen of death". As to Mr. 48 hrs I'd have to think that he's typing in the entire OS by candle light.

by arleenw

You can't possibly have worked with Windows 95, 98, ME and NT and not ever seen a blue screen. I custom install every machine. 98 gives a blue screen because the wind changes direction. Apps lock up all the time and using ctrl-alt-del is a crap shoot. Will it recover? Will it bring the os down?

I agree though, you have to be diligent about your patching, run anti-everything and your Windows install should be ok.

by sepius

yeah I agree, however of all the OS's I use, windows has the worst swap file management program ever along with the print spool program. I use windows and I use linux and BSD and OS7, at home. Value for money is where windows fails. I dont hate windows, I just feel that it is way over priced for what you get, compared to other OS's for around AUS$130 it is easily beat.
Now, I work in the fuel industry, your comparisin is off. Leaded fuel was discontinued becouse of 1. environment and 2. Market influence from vendors. If we keep LRP, then new car sales dwindle, move to the new fuel and people will buy new cars. The big money makers wanted to make even more money, thats what did it, not the consumer, not technology, ....M$ is the same, they tell us what we want, not let the market choose. XP is a good OS, M$ are rogues. It's not the dog but the master. Think, Dad, Mum, and Junior have PC's. 3 OS's and office suite, around $5000 for the license's, is that right?? for mediocre products. I dont think peolple BASH windows, its M$, I expect more from my AUS$300 and dont get any help at all, thats why they get bashed.

by hal 9000

I've had a look at the wholesale price lists from the MS Agents admittedly only one of the major 3 but XP Pro comes in at $202.20 AU Wholesale and Office SBE costs me $316.00 AU again Wholesale both are OEM versions and the retail ones are more expensive. That is a Wholesale cost of $518.20 AU for just those two for one unit and a recommended retail of $627.00 AU if you can actually get it a potential profit of $108.80 AU which most cut into to make the price of the finished units cheaper and that is only suitable for a very small business or home user without any AV or anything else involved.

It makes it very hard to sell against the Sub 1K units that are currently being advertised which although they don't come with Office or even XP Pro only the Home version still makes it a hard fight to get across.

Col ]:)

by jbaker

Simply because they are the big dog. If you look around, that is the way our society works. A company busts its a** to get to the top of hte market (whether by completely legitimate means is not at issue here), and people feel obligated to bash that company. It is not just M$, it is any company that is the large and prominent in the marketplace.

by dc guy

1. I have a problem with the entire PC software development community. They don't believe that we old mainframe jockeys have anything worthwhile to share. They ignore everything we learned the hard way and by golly they go right out and make the same mistakes we did 30 years ago--only now they affect thousands of users, maybe millions, instead of dozens or hundreds.

Deadlocks? Application-layer programs with the power to crash the operating system? And my personal deal-breaker: PCs that actually allow strangers to upload instructions disguised as data, and then they blithely go ahead and execute them without any human intervention.

We did away with those fundamental design flaws on the old Univac 1100 mainframe. Instructions reside in one part of memory. NOBODY can store anything there without the knowledge and approval of the person in charge--which on your PC would of course be YOU. Data resides in the other part. NOBODY can execute anything out of the data bank. Period, no exceptions. It simply can't be done.

Sure, PCs have a more complicated architecture and have to perform tasks some of us never dreamed of in 1975. But that is no excuse. Your first requirements when building software are integrity, reliabiilty, and security. Once you've designed your platform around that, THEN AND ONLY THEN do you start providing the end-user functionality requested.

The PC community is driven by the lust for quick money and an astounding ability to not give a darn about their users, so they rush software to market quickly and cheaply by ignoring the basic principles of QA that we took for granted.

2. Windows takes this to an extreme. People are still finding wormholes in Windows XP that are left over from Windows 98! Fatal defects that have gone unidentified and unrepaired for seven years! Yet they keep patching the same barely-functional OS and remarketing it as if nobody knows that "fixing" software almost always makes it worse.

Windows junkies bash Apple because every major new release is really a new release, so there's no promise of downward compatibility. This way every new release is developed with state-of-the-art project management practices. This means that when there finally are enough Macintoshes in the world for the hacker community to take an interest in the challenge, they will find it to be a daunting challenge indeed. No seven-year old sloppy-coding defects to exploit.

3. I may be an IT person. But I used to enjoy working under the hood of my own car--now I drive a Mercedes because I have more important things to do. Similarly, I used to enjoy troubleshooting software--but now I expect my computer to behave like an appliance and only need professional attention a few times a year. I want to use my experience and skill to help my company use IT to improve its business. I don't want to play shade-tree mechanic and spend my time just making software do what it was supposedly built to do in the first place.

4. Windows was obviously written by programmers for programmers. Nothing about it is the least bit intuitive to people outside our profession, people who don't think like we do.

I only have to mention the fact that you hit the START button to turn your computer OFF, in order to illustrate my point. That defect has never been repaired, it's like a rite of passage for every new PC owner. OK, you're an official software mechanic now, you found the OFF switch. Welcome to the guild and don't tell anybody.

There are six billion people on this planet who don't have the time, aptitude, or interest to be software mechanics. We will NEVER be able to sell this kind of programmer-friendly, user-hostile garbage to them! It's time to poke our heads up out of our little sandbox and understand that the rest of the world is NOT AT ALL LIKE US. They need their computers to be appliances, not toys.

by djameson

If you didn't hide the off button on the start button how many people do you think would "Accidentally" shut off their computer? users are DUMB!

by dc guy

People aren't "dumb" just because they're not as adept with computers as we are. But they'll come up with some choice epithets for us if we don't stop talking about them that way.

PCs are daunting! I have a university degree, an IQ of 140, and I've been in IT since 1967. Yet PCs continue to exasperate me simply because I don't find them INTERESTING and FUN enough to put in the time and effort required to coddle them and clean up after them and fix their messes. I'd much rather play with my dog, practice my music, or read a good book, than figure out why Windows screwed me up THIS time.

And I'm one of you. Can you begin to imagine how normal people feel about PCs?

by knudson

Mainframe protected memory, let's see CICS came out in the late 60s (I was there), protected memory in the 80's. The mainframes crashed, if you worked on them in the 70s and 80s. It wasn't until the late 80s they got more solid.

Let anyone upload code, none of these MainFrames were connected to anything but dumb terminals. Unplug your PC from the net, it'll never get infected.

Don't get me wrong, I loved the 30 years on MFs and I love Windows. Only have some experience with Unix (Unix, Linux ... they are all the same, but different, thats my complaint with them. They SHOULD and COULD have ruled the world if they hadn't been so religious about my version versus your version ....)

I still think Windows gets a bad rap because anyone that can speel(sic) PC thinks they can build, configure and operate a PC.

I have a collection of machines here, servers, workstations and laptops. All running 24x7, several get abused adding and removing software.
Crashes, haven't seen one in ages. Ok the one server kept crashing a while (long while) back. Switched two of the mem cards, not a problem since. Oh that wasn't a Windows problem, it was hardware (Ok some of these are cobbled together on the cheap and from spare junk).

Put a GM engine in your Mustang, then go to Ford and complain because it doesn't run right.

by roger99a

I'm not understanding your arguments. The great strength of Windows is that it is so much easier to use than most other operating systems. Note: not easier to fix, just easier to use. Software installation is almost automatic, which in some cases is now a liability, but still, no tarball to unzip and no wondering where the heck it put all those files. And the large installed base of users means less training for an employer. And then there's the huge selection of software, most of which will run on most versions of Windows.

Now, I'm not a big fan of MS either. Personnally it's just a gaming platform, much too insecure for even email and web. In this regard MS is failing. I often think that MS writes code with the belief that there are no evil people in the world.

by wordworker

Gosh, after all these years they've been making cars and releasing "upgrades" and those upgrades still require constant maintenance and hand-holding. Mine won't refuel itself, won't put air in its tires, won't change its own oil. And geez it was obviously engineered by engineers for engineers. You need tools and special skills just to keep the things running! Damn money-grubbing car companies churn out products that pollute the air and are fuel-inefficient to boot. I need my car to be an appliance I can just hop in and drive. I don't need a toy that requires 10% of my time to keep it running. One day everyone will drive an open-source vehicle, and we'll get all our oil changes and tune-ups and repairs for free. One day...

by jrod86

I don't recall anyone bashing Sony for putting out crappy products. You pay a premium for those as well as MS products. OK, so they operate more like appliances, but they are a major manufacturer. Just thought I'd throw that in there, I know we could find more examples, but that was an easy one.

by djameson

I have a high school diploma and a IQ of 180 (so were even) and I fail to see how a person who can't use common sense or at least try... to figure it out wouldn't be considered "dumb", my children have a better grasp of using a computer then some of my coworkers and they are 4 and 6. PC's aren't daunting, you just need the patience and self control and a little motivation and everything falls into place. I have built 40-50 systems of virtually every common configuration, and have dealt with people from janitors to high level executives there are two types of users those that are dumb and know it and those that think they are smart but are really dumb.

by Member 30789355

Just thought I'd join in the fun and state my IQ as well. Unfortunately I don't know it :(. Come on guys, why don't we just list our weiner sizes as well?

And djameson, you are wrong. There are 10 types of people in this world: those that understand binary and those that don't!

by jaqui

10 types there are 11
those thatt do,
those that don't,
and those that don't even understand enough to know they should be either catching something or missing it.

by alarena

Get your point? Is your point that techs have to make sure everything fits, drivers and hardware wise? No brainer, patch control management. No problem!

But if the Engine in the car has so many problems that the producer has to issue rubber bands, duct tape and yet More and More fixes year after year then maybe the OS is the problem. Let's just say that Linux is Premium octane and Windows OS is still Very leaded. Get the point? I drive an Acura Sport, and it works better than an my restored '56 Chevy.

Here's my other point Angus, and please take it as a lunchroom "back and forth". I gave a careful look at your note and concluded either that you are not a very old tech, though Maybe a modern day network "guru", or you may be in an "easy bake" environment. With layers of techs in front of you. My guess is someone has the time to actually keep the engine purring.

Thank you for the lecture or opinion or whatever you're talking about... but the same theme still continues with Windows. An OS that is full of holes because of whatever "business" game plan they follow causes Microsoft to rake in the money and control us while grabbing our wallets andproducing monstrosities instead of real operating systems. Ever check out the history of Linux, who wrote it, what it can do... I'm sure you know. I'm talking Microsoft, not Linux or any other OS's. We need to go back to the scholars, not the merchants.

by Former member

Hey, I grew up in the golden age of the home PC market. No fair. ;)

I'm old, just not old enough to have grown up in the hey days of computing when uni students got play with main frames and the like. Wish I could have though.

And you are talking to a guy who has an Amiga 500 and Mac Performa 580CD sitting on his workbench in perfect working order and still being used for the sake of it. Would've still had the Amstrad 6128 if the damned floppy drive didn't pack it in completely. Couldn't find a replacement for it.

You know what, I love the old stuff better than the new. What is it with that and technicians? Why do we just keep reliving the old days? :D

by hal 9000

We have a small semblance of a chance to have an idea of where they will go.

Unlike a lot of people who ignore the past and just accept the future we can't have the easy option as we have to be on top of the problems before they arise. :)

Col ]:)

by Former member

In a situation like yours, why don't you have a ghost server with an image of the OS and all Apps. Anything that takes 48 hours to, you should be looking at ways to cut that down.

But that's another topic. :)

by hal 9000

Across the range and consistent software as well. A lot of the places that I do work for are one off installs where it just isn't feasible or possible to clone Drives or push out installs from a Server mainly because they don't run a server of any kind and spend all their IT budget on Hardware/Software and just expect it to work. Granted these are now all Small Business which I now only work in and while I did like some of the play toys that I had available to me when I worked in Big Business the sense of accomplishment that I now get far outweighs the constant moaning and complaining that I was subject to while working Big Business.

Only on the small servers can I use any redundancy and that is only in places where they are willing to accept money being tied up in something that they don't appear to be using to produce profits which is only a very small number of places that I do work for. But when one of these goes down it is back up and running within 3 minutes by just plugging in another Hot Swappable HDD and away you go. I come around latter and fix what went wrong latter.

Col ]:)

by jaqui

when it's an occasional job, for a few preffered clients, I'm not to worried about it.
these clients are the one's with the knowledge and skills to do it themselves, but wish to pay for me to do it so that they know it hasn't been hosed.

some of the machines are dual cpu workstations, some are dual cpu home systems, some are single cpu systems.
an image of the os configured for each is a pain.
then you get the user data loss also.
( I'm getting called really only when something went wrong and they are afraid they are going to lose thier data if they do it )

by jrod86

If you deal with different hardware, that's fine and I agree you don't need a ghost server, but you could map a drive after Windows setup and either get a program to package and push the applications in a certain order with standard configurations, or just launch the install through the network. That should cut the install time down considerably.

Sorry, 48 hours just seems like WAY to much time to spend setting something up (even with 20 apps, I do this regularly as well).

by hal 9000

They dump Windows all together and go Unix with a Windows like GUI front end.

Then they can have the look and feel of a Windows Workstation but the stability and security of a Unix installation, I think we'll be seeing a setup like this on their next server range and it will be a massive improvement.

Eventually when they move it to the desktop and relegate Windows to the Home it will be even better.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

This happened when M$ was illegally using Java and it was a MS patch or program that they where pushing out. It was KB 320 something.

It didn't happen yesterday but a few years ago and was a total mes to clean up. Just how Windows could claim that there where no drives present when it was running on one is still way beyond my level of understanding. :D

Col ]:)

by jaqui

unix like os, it's the person that installed is the culpret, but you also find the problems almost instantly.
( solving them may take longer...much much longer)

:)

by peter_es_uk

There are many reasons to hate windows. Top of my list is the number of things that just stopped working when XP sp2 was installed ....

by peter_es_uk

I remember the mayhem when they introduced office 2000 and loads of access 97 users pressed 'yes' when asked if they should upgrade - what a mistake that was !!!

by philip.grogan

I have been involved with support and admin on Microsoft, Linux, Solaris, HP-ux, AIX, BSD etc etc.

In my opinion, one of the reasons why people bash Microsoft, may be because the Charging mechanism used for the Microsoft suite of products could be considderred unfair. For example with the OS pricing, Linux is free and support can be as little as ?25 a year. There are literally thousands of good source pointes for help which are free. (The same applies for Microsoft, but generally these are set up by people who refuse to accept that you need to pay ?2000 a pop for a Microsoft course). Microsoft on the other hand is a minimum of ?70 for an upgrade and ?250 for the full product. Non transferrable these days, with tricks to break the system if you upgrade the hardware etc.

From the software side, again many free processing and spreadsheet options for Linux etc, but Microsft charge upwards of ?250 a pop for their suites. Its not cheap and these days its a necessity.

dont get me wrong, I understand the value in creating software and publishing and we all nead to earn a crust, but you would have thought by now that the R&D had been returned on Microsoft products and they could lower the prices.

Because of this, I believe it is the main gripe for users, IT professionals. I would challenge that if the source was free like Linux with the option for a paid for version with additional features, it would become more popular.

But, alas it is inevitable that we will continue to use the products and have a little moan every now and then. In this day and age, we really cant do without it.

by verd1

Well I have read through most of the post here and I have to say that I personally use and service all OS's. I personally use all of them on my own network in my office. Each one has their special problems and headaches. How I see it is this, Windows is the one that most people use. Most Linux users are geeks. I do not have the time or my clients do not want to spend the money teaching people a how to use a new OS. Even though it may be better and Window$ cost more money. I am the network admin for 3 corperate networks in my area. I am running Windows Servers, and Red Hat and at one FreeBSD as a mail server. I USE them all and all have problems, SO what if one has more than another one. It is all keeping me in business and putting money and food in my pocket. So what is the fuss. It is kinda the same "HATE" that people have for the president. It does not make sense.
Well that is my $.02 worth.
Keep rocking Microsoft, OS10, Linux etc. I like them all and ALL show and have a purpose. Sorry, you will not change my mind.
Doug MCSE

by peltyc

Follow the link and find out more about what the physicists are saying on chaos theory governing the processor. Maybe we techies are trying to fight the natural laws of chaos in regulating and predicting systems as complex as weather?

http://arxiv.org/abs/nlin.AO/0506030

by silvioandpauly

My Windows servers are just as reliable as our legacy mainframes! Our XP machines are MUCH MORE reliable than the NT 3.5/4.0 days.

People just generally like to whine about stuff.

by ken g.

Look at the natural process of humanity here for a moment:

If you're the biggest kid on the block, sooner or later someone is going to want to knock you down.

So is the legacy of Microsoft. Lets call a spade a spade here gentlemen, Linux, Mac, and the many other well written Os's (and great competitors), STILL have their share of the spaghetti code. No code written is perfect -- and it never will be. It would be absurd to assume otherwise.

Okay, I'm off my soap box now... :)

by coremantle

Windows is allot more stable than it was, say ten years ago. Allot of my contempt for windows comes from the mid 90's. The Windows machines always required more attention than the unix workstations. I started out in the eighties on main frames then unix. After ten years of operating an OS designed for commercial/industrial use. You insert systems that are PERSONAL COMPUTERS and expect them to work at the same level. Not going to happen.
There is allot of bashing on microsoft because it the big boy on the block. Their business practices killed allot of software that was better than their own. You know what? their business goal was never to improve the computing community it was to make money. They are a company and that is what companies do. Comparing Open Source operating systems to microsoft. Is like comparing the Record industry to your church. Both have music, but what is thier intent?

by treadmill

Got a simple solution for that. Don't support a product that's not officially supported by the company and certainly not MP3 music!

If I was in your shoes I'd refuse to fix his/her sodding laptop!

by a.c

but it doesn't quite work.

any petrol vehicle pre 1922 would have run on unleaded fuel anyway, and I don't see a 286 running XP any time soon.

Newer leaded only vehicles can have a head rework to run unleaded - which is a hardware upgrade.

On the why people bash windows - maybe you should ask the people at GM and the famous reply to the Bill Gates comdex "if the computer industry made cars" comparison.

Me, well I'm perfectly happy to have an OS that occasionally causes problems, otherwise I'd be out of a job - I'll give credit where it's due, MS now make fairly solid OSs and if we could line up every spammer, phisher, virus writer and scam artist around the world and shoot them, they would be even better

by bshane

How sad. Another ignorant newbie who grew up in the shadow of the theft of DR's OS whining about how stupid the users are. Perhaps if the OS was not intentionally crippled in the first place there wouldn't be so much of a fuss. To use the illustrated analogy of the used car - Windows is intentionally designed with built-in obsolescence for the sole prupose of making a profit and insuring a victim-market. This is not as clear now where each module is authored by an entire workgroup instead of a single guru and a staff of assistants, but it was clear from the beginning. Fortunately or unfortunately, depending upon one's point of view, Windows is 90% profit-making bloatware and only %10 market-driven innovation and security. Witness the latest MS Acquisition of the spyware Gator. MS is to OS what Income Tax is to the Consumer. To quote "The Wiz," "You can't win, you can't break even and you can't get out of the game." 'nuff said.

by parrish s. knight

I can't believe you said this. Try using Windows ME or System 7
for about three or four weeks, then see whether you still believe
this. Those OSes would crash if you looked at them cross-eyed.
Hell, I used both of them extensively and even remember
occasions where I might not have even touched the computer at
all in half an hour or so, and the OS crashed. Granted, those are
both older OSes, but if older OSes can be unstable, newer ones
can, too.

Not only that, but but but... You are attempting to claim that any
OS crash is caused by human error, not by the OS. What you're
overlooking is that the OS is also created by humans, who quite
commonly make mistakes in writing the OS (witness the patches
and service packs that we have to keep up with and keep track
of). If the human end users are capable of error, as they
certainly are, then the human OS writers are also capable of
error.

by ddissent

You haven't been around very long little boy ... have you? I feel so bad now knowing that my ignorance of what drivers and (how did you say it ... blah blah blah ... is that TECHNICAL terminology you learned in college?)hardware to use is what caused the problem ... Not that Microsoft seems hell bent on releasing OS versions that are far from clean (hence Service Pack 90 release 800)
Great Googlie Moogly I've read some STUPID posts on this site but this has to be a hands down winner ..... I don't know who to be more annoyed with right now ... You ... or Tech Republic for infecting the rest of us with you............
and NO ..... I DON'T get your point about the stupid petrol analogy ......... WOW!

by paul.vacquier

I'd say it's a combination of things with a major cause being WinXP being advertised as the best at x where x can be any thing you care to mention.
What does not help MS is the wide variance of hardware/software combinations that it's expected to run on (systems from stand alone to corp level networks, simple word processors to the latest shoot-em-up)
plus its an easy target
If the hardware was set at a certain level (say X-box level) then it's an easier proposition to develope software for it in terms of stability, but users want the latest graphics card/gismo - just look at the numbers of PDA's available to connect up by usb/wireless/cable connections for example and all expect it to work first time no problem - still, keeps me employed :)
I can still remember the joys of CP/M (sysgen anyone? for 32K northstar with hard sectored 5.25" floppys :)

regards
ppv

by mollenhourb9

Your statement that a person is not a true techie (which, by the way is a compliment) because their OS crashed is funny. You state that it is "your fault for not loading the right drivers". Therein lies the rub. With the Mac OS, I don't have to mess around with drivers. It just runs.

by mill3502

You get what you get out of an operatings system. I don't see hundreds of thousands of applicaitons available for Linux or other operating systems and if they had hundreds of thousands of applicaitons Linux would crash just as often as M$ because programmers are human and until you folks wise up to human error you never get over your prejudice shortcomings. Wiresless access is the worst thing that ever hit the PC market but I don't see people jumping off the band wagon to fast for "something better" You live with human error and make the best with what you have.

Get over it, you don't like Microsoft because the person who owns it is the most successful person alive and your jealous.

by philip.grogan

No question that there are few people who would argue that Microsoft provides a good living for many people in the trade.

Hey, I like the Wintel operating systems (all of them), they have provided me with the opertunity to become successful at something.

My argument is that you would expect the natural cost shift to a lower price given the return on investment. Microsoft should reduce the cost of its previous versions to reflect the R&D recovery. They do have a right as a company to charge what they see fit, the only trouble is that over the years they have removed the competition or destroyed them as they had the funds. Again, this is not a criticism in business as it is a shrewd move.

Microsoft would earn more if they dropped the price of the sofware bundles, thus getting more for less illegal copying etc and may even clean up on the support and training etc.

by mike.morris

Got a simple solution for that. Don't support a product that's not officially supported by the company and certainly not MP3 music!

If I was in your shoes I'd refuse to fix his/her sodding laptop!

Posted by: kevin@... Date: 07/21/05

That's a brilliant statement... "No CEO, I will not help you"... "Col, You're FIRED"...

Nice advise...

by unixdude

I started in networking doing Netware servers... most of them would go 200-300 days without needing rebooted if you let them. We switched to Windows and there were some servers that needed rebooted twice a week (still are). Now I do IBM AIX Unix, and again most of my servers could go 200-300 days without needing a reboot. IBM has had a lot of "buffer oveflow" security issues but they are fairly quick about patches. Microsoft has a habit of breaking other things with their fix patches.. IBM doesn't. These facts speak for themselves.

by philip.grogan

Having had experience with IBM AIX the Kernel core is stable, however when the system has issues it is usally the app that breaks. Having the system up longer does not necessarily mean that your service available.

I have installed Microsoft Small Business Servers which only require downtime when I want to patch for performance gains. They run for up to two 400 days.

Obviously if they are external facing you will need to bounce them more regularly for security patching, but the same applies to Solaris and AIX.

by goble

Let's start with the obvious. A seemingly infinite number of security holes. Or maybe the number of bone head flaws i.e. having to remove a font to install Office 97 on a Windows XP machine, leaving the messenger service wide open to exploit. The list is very long. I think Angus must be a Microsoft mole.

by mtsx1us

It's the "de jur" complaint that's easy to pile on, that's all. I've worked on OS code from Commodore and Timex-Sinclair through VAX VMS to MAC OS X. The more popular an app or OS is, the more it gets hacked; it's that simple. Hackers and script kiddies go for maximum "exposure", and for some time now that has been through M'soft products. It's changing, but how come the Adobe vulnerability didn't get the attention, press, or snide remarks that any obscure buffer overflow from M'soft seems to get?

Get over it guys; Linux is now firmly in many hackers' sites, so expect it to start taking hits too. Life doean't revolve around any OS, vendor, app or component. Life revolves around what the tool does for you.

by mike.morris

Actually they are. Billy boy is scared of Linux and has an entire team devoted to Linux. As a matter of fact, according to some sources I know inside M$, they have several Linux servers in production... They have been, for quite some time now, comtemplating a M$ version of Linux...

by gothicscott

This is why:

- XP for example, is code bloat run amuck. It is slow and full of fluff like butterflys and goofy feel good Fisher-Price animations and graphics. Who needs this crap? If one needs it, watch Nickelodian.

- Quit pushing software down our throats that turns the consumer population into a gigantic beta test group. Oh, and while you're at it, tighten your code. It will run better.

- There's an arrogance @ Microsoft from the top down. They have a take it or leave it attitude that permeates down to the user. Read their licensing agreements to see what I mean.

- They're greedy. I'm not a liberal capitalism basher,...far from it. However, why must I buy expensive copies of their software to run on more than one machine that I own? Isn't this company rich enough? Apple allows one to install its OS on multiple machines owned by the same person without gouging the consumer for more $$$$

- Microsoft screwed over people in its certified professional programs. The certs have become an industry joke that have limited shelf life requiring an IT professional to spend way too much time and money to get qualified on the latest overpriced, excessively complicated bloatware from Redmond that will be obsolete a few years time.

- Microsft Certified Trainers got shafted 5 years ago. They're now paying extortion fees to MS to retain their cert.

Enough?

_scott

by pbiss

Fine as far as it goes but some OS structures can be more prone to instability than others and it may well be that not all the packaged drivers are as compatible with the intended hardware or applications software as they should be.
I have made the following practical observations.
Win40, now dead, was nowhere near as stable as WinNT and it defintely had something against MS Office.
WinNT benefits from increased RAM, which reduces the load on the virtual memory paging. Now crashes virtually never instead of every six weeks.

One thing does irritate slightly.
PC history has dictated that practically everything that BIOS knows or discovers about the system is thrown away and Windows has to start again from scratch. Is this really necessary?
One of my machines runs a RAID stack of HDs.
This had to be laboriously configured in BIOS and then again in Windows. The same applies, though less evident to the user, to HDs larger that 7.8 GByte (the famous visibility horizon).