Discussion Locked

Why holodecks are "unrealistic"

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Fellow GeekRepublicist Rex had this to say about the "Girls of CGI" spread coming up in the world's most famous gentleman's magazine.

"This is why I always thought the holodeck was the most unrealistic technology in Star Trek. Because if science had created a holodeck in the 24th century then it would have meant the end of civilization--men would spend all their time in the Playboy Mansion simulation and women would spend all their time in the Husband Who Helps With The Chores simulation. Nobody would be out exploring the galaxy."
http://money.cnn.com/2004/08/25/commentary/game_over/column_gaming/index.htm

15 replies

by Former member

I said this to Rex and Jay in an e-mail and I'll say it again. Jack me into the Matrix!!! Make me famous, put me in velvet pajamas, and let me have phat parties and you can suck every bit of juice from my battery ;)

Please don't flame me yet. I actually enjoy the "real" world with all of its horror, hatred, confusion, bickering, life, death, beauty, and love (and yes, although some people will disagree, there is as much love and beauty as death and destruction). In reality, I prefer to find the balance between the good and the bad rather than complaining when there isn't enough good going on :)

Pixels, however, are simply pixels. Fun and simple!

by jkaras

You sound like it's a bad thing? Is it unrealistic? Yeah but man that's cool if it were realistic. the idea that you could create your own fantasy world that you could interact with beats a movie anyday. I remember watching Voyager where Janeway was thinking of getting freaky with a hologram. The jokes me and my friendsmade made it worth watching, just imagine anyone stumbling in there seeing her or turning it off with her just sitting there gyrating in the middle of an empty holodeck.

by rexworld

I was only half-joking when I wrote that. We already have for example Finland where some Internet users are so addicted they can't do their required military duty:

http://news.com.com/2100-1023_3-5295088.html

And there have been murders over a video game:

http://www.cnn.com/2004/LAW/08/09/bodies.found.ap/index.html

Is it possible that as games, both online and single-player, get more realistic we may see more problems with people not being able to distinguish the virtual reality from the actual reality?

by Mark W. Kaelin

As someone who has played in several online worlds over the past 5 years, I can attest to their addictive nature. Taking the level of emersion to holodeck capabilities would certainly make a virtual life even more tempting.

I found this link interesting because it indicates that online virtual worlds are more than just game play - they are socially significant.

http://mypage.iu.edu/~castro/home.html

The holodeck is where we are heading and what that means is still up for debate.

by sleepin'dawg

a way to beat the power requirements. Full color projection of live images Not graphic animation takes gobs of power and so far no one has come up with a suitable receiver. Remember EVERYTHING has to be LIFE sized. VR goggles and piezo electric sensors just do not cut it. You want to be IN the holograph not viewing it externally. Believe it or not it will happen because it is happening but currently the hold ups are the aforementioned power requirements, processing power(CPU's in parallel from DNA strands on neural nets) and storage systems with near instantaneous retrieval.
We are talking faster than anything currently commercially available. IBM is really getting into this. A 15 sec full color image of a man walking projected 18% of life size was enough to knockout a substation already set for industrial requirements. It took 30+ mins to reset all breakers and slow blow fuse links but as I said it is going to happen it is just a matter of when.
Teleport devices will arrive first say 12-15 years, they can already transport cockroaches from one room to the next and holodecks are probably coming in the 20-25 year time frame. One to beam up, Mr. Scott or maybe it could be Mr. Kaelin if your still alive then. It is not a matter of if but when and that will be dependant upon materials development. My only regret is I probably won't be around to see it all happen.

by jackofalltech

Check out the movie Existenze (not sure about that last 'e'). That is the premise of the movie and it's somewhat disturbing to watch.

Ralph

by jkaras

I liked that movie. Jude Law was great and Jennifer Jason Lee was as hot as ever. It had a really great plot/idea, too bad it wasnt a bigger budget film it would have been better.

by sleepin'dawg

A real simulation will ultmately have a risk factor such as the possibility of injury short of fatatality. Where's the fun of shooting something that doesn't or can't shoot back and if or when it does you know there is no risk because it's a hologram. Remember several characters played with safe guards deactivated so as to enhance reality. Still it was only holographic simulation unless photon technology could be incorporated to add mass and tactility to the holograms.One other consideration requires large levels of power consumption if 4 color holograms are to be produced and if the "reality" part of virtual reality is to be realized, we should expect no less. Otherwise you might as well retreat to the john with your copy of Playboy and work out your fantasies in the traditional manner. By the way I have worked on producing 4 color holographic images in reality. We could project live animated monochrome images but as soon as we tried 4 color the power demands were almost enough to knock out a substation. It was no problem with animated artwork but until we can capture and project real live subject matter, holodecks will still be science fiction. They will happen it's just a matter of when and improvements in superconductivity. The theories are almost workable but we're now waiting material developments. ]:) :D ;)

by Mark W. Kaelin

Sleepin'dawg, you are talking about a time frame much shorter than I imagined was possible. I did not expect to enjoy a realistic holographic game interface in my lifetime. But if we are talking 25 years, I now have something to look forward to when I retire. It's time to jack up the 401k contributions. :D

by sleepin'dawg

I read about a teleportation device in a scientific journal over a year ago, which one, I forget and so far Google hasn't narrowed it down. What I remember reading was that someone had actually tranported a cockroach from one room in a lab to another. Apparently the experiments had been going on for sometime but this had been the first attempt at transporting a live sample. A cockroach had been chosen for its supposed indestuctability to different forms of radiation and EMF disturbances. A theory states that in the event of a nuclear holocaust the only things sure to survive are insects more specifically cockroaches. The only things to survive Ground 0 at Hiroshima were cockroaches or at least thats the story, myth or legend. Making holograms is no mysterry its been done for years now, although 4 color images are still a little rare. Holographs are a whole different ballgame. A holograph exists outside of fixed media i.e. not something recorded on film or tape but something that would appear suspended in air. If recorded it would be as lines of code not images which would then have to be recalled and executed before any image could be seen. This is old tech and the capability has been in existence for well over ten years.The next problem to be encountered is what can you display it on and how do you display it. The first efforts were in polarized enclosed plasma fields somewhat resembling vacuum tubes but if the images were to be at all useful it was quickly recognized that an open form of display was required. That was when the initial problems of power requirements became apparent. At this point we're getting outside my area of expertise and possible clearance but suffice it to say that most of the seminal work was/is at Princeton and an offshoot of this which has now been declassifyed is the capability of plating diamond on substrates which greatly aids in combatting thermal dynamic problems in the construction of optical processors,i.e. processing at speed of light.
In the mean time IBM has been working with bubble memory and exploring CPU construction based on DNA structures - shades of biological and/or bionic processing. Research is ongoing in the medical field to use the body and its fluids as a battery,read power supply for such fundamental items as pacemakers and CCD's to bring sight to the blind. The neat thing about this is the idea evolved from a 13-14 year old Canadian highschool student conducting an experiment for a science fair back in the seventies. The idea was quickly snapped up and disappeared into DARPA but not before the kid was given a patent on it which has been classified and still is the last time I checked. My time estimates are pure conjecture based on my knowledge of what I am being asked to work on and what I KNOW others are working on and my SWAG's of what others have got in their ovens. Consider this: Television was first done in the twenties and color in the mid thirties but a commercialy viable product didn't appear until the very late forties and wasn't wide spread until the mid to late fifties. I can remember people standing in front of store windows to watch TV and it wasn't even in color. Color showed up in the fifties but wasn't widespread until well into the sixties. The first computer anybody was foolish enough to let me play with was an IBM RAMAC-507 in 1959 and it was a monster filling a room measuring 15' x 25' that was air conditioned and climate controlled. RAMAC by the way stood for Random Access Method of Accounting and Control. The computer on my desk is more powerful and the air conditioning is for me not the computer. I do know some mainframe setups are still like this but they are light years away fromthe RAMAC-507. The processing language was COBOL which in my humble 15yr old opinion at that time was crap next to Fortran. I have been proved right as C and its derivatives evolved from it while BASIC evolved from COBOL. If you are looking for guarantees to the time frame, there are none but consider this: 40 years ago LASER's required large rooms, large amounts of power and precious stones such as ruby or saphire through which to project light (We are now in my area of experimentation and to what some laughingly refer to as area of expertise). You can now buy them in the convenience stores for about $5 powered by a button battery. I agree these are not defense, industrial or medical quality lasers but one was sufficent to assist in the rescue of the pilot and passengers of a downed light air craft when all other forms of conventional signalling failed. What I stated in my earlier post is a SWAG but I like to think I'm a little closer than most to a real time frame. If your looking for investment possibilities look to companies working in super-conductivity, optical processing and switching and laser technology. Other companies to look at are ones in satellite communications and in EMF and thermal dynamic shielding tecniques. A game interface in 25 years is very possible with caveats but a commercially viable one is a horse of a different color. Add 15-20 years and prepare to leverage to the max your portfolio, mortgage your house, sell your first born and sell a kidney to get one while realizing as it comes in your front door it will already be obsolete. Wait until the price drops to the level of a game boy and games will be available unless you want to be the first on your block to enjoy the holographic equivalent of Pong which I think would get old even if the players were nude Anna Kournakovas. Imagine Holographic porn. The mind boggles. This of course will be viewable holographs but for the true holographic virtual reality experince where you join in the holographic experience a la holodeck, there are still a lot of problems caused by lack of adequate materials devopment but that is changing daily. It is happening but at what rate your guess is probably as good as mine. Some days you can't pick up a news paper or read a news letter without seeing an advance of some sort in some area other days you are left wondering will there ever be any progress. As I said, it will happen because it is happening but when it will be finished happening, therein lies the rub. You want to harness your 401K to that be my guest but I for one prefer to harness my efforts to the development of another little project of mine which is a virtual reality 3D market model. The initial version is commodities oriented and bonds will be ready early in the new year. The NASDAQ and big board should be good to go sometime in July. Oh yeah, we're close and preparing to go beta. Wait for it. We think it'll be great. Catch you later. Now if I were you right now I'd be asking myself is it real or.......(sound bite of maniacal laughter going to fade). Bummer huh????? ]:) :D :D Dawg

by sleepin'dawg

MKaelin It's putting it all together that's the hard part. A lot is dependent on your depth of scientific knowledge and how you can recognize which technology goes with which but most of this knowledge is online. An engineering background in optics, power systems and aerospace is helpful also some communications experience would be handy. Some buzz words:
Plasma fields
Plasma plating
Princeton
MIT
CalTech
Stanford
Heuristics
Neural Mapping (McGill)
Neural nets
Super-conductivity
Fusion
Fission
Cold fusion
DNA
Optical Processers
Optical switching
and that's just off the top of my head. Sometimes what you read isn't as important as to recognize what you aren't reading and then formulating the information as an indicator of the next place to look. If you have a clearance you might be able to skim the indexes of DARPA to get a snapshot of what is going on. This much I can say without reservations and caveats: It's all interesting and all fun. I have done my best to remember the source of my transporting cockroach and the best I can think of was Scientific American, The SAE Journal or God forbid Popular Mechanics or Popular Science. It might even have been in a NASA pub but not likely.(No laughter this time maniacal or otherwise) Dawg

by hal 9000

After all Star Trek was not the only show to use holodecks or something similar in the Kenny Evert Video Show they had the Orgamasitron which brought a whole new meaning to "Cyber Sex" with Calla from memory. But it didn't stop real life sexual encounters only enhanced then.

While I can see a far more useful need for the transporter technology it is only a natural off spin of any new technology that some form of R & R facility will become available to cut down on the need for holidays. Even that Arny movie something about Mars had something similar didn't it? But in that instead of placing you into a room with holo generated images they planted false memories into your brain. The Holodeck seems a better use of technology to me and far less invasive.

Although I do see a problem in the ability to convert the usable space into a realistic recreation with out the need to stop the movement around the "Holodeck."

Col

by sleepin'dawg

right now are restrictions imposed by currently available materials, power requirements, processor speed, storage, heuristic algorythms, engram heuristics and neural mapping. There are a few others but thes are the main ons. The real big one is handling the power demands and with it the necessity of shedding the massive amounts of heat being generated. We have a partial solution on the fiber optic front in that light can be generated without its UV or IR component and this greatly helps in cutting generated heat. This is light in the visible spectrum which we need but the IR has always been a big problem in the past and the UV being less of a problem but long term exposure could cause dermal problems of a carcinogenic nature. An illustration of this can be seen in people whose general exposure to fluorescent lights is their main light exposure. Fluorescent lighting is high in the blue/green spectrum and with that comes a lot of UVA and some UVB. That is why office workers can look a little tanned even though they have had little exposure to sunlight. Now throw in immense quantities of laser generated light and you can imagine the levels of heat caused by the IR component; 90% and the slight UV; 10%. We discovered a potential solution a few weeks ago when we accidently stumbled across a company in Delaware who is making fibre-optic devices with no UV or IR. We were under the impression that we were going to have to research and create the devices ourselves and hadn't gotten too far along except the consideration of photographic cold light sources and apparently these people had been producing their devices based upon work they had done in the field of dentistry. :D This discovery has eliminated our need to reinvent the wheel and has probably saved us two years of research. Previously ambient temperatures were running around 135C-175C range or 275F-350F and severely restricted unprotected human exposure but now we are expecting temperatures more in the 29C-45C range and now airconditioning and climate control becomes feasible. Seems a minor problem but what would be the point if a human couldn't work in the environment. The main goal is to one day have an individual walk into a chamber and see and feel without a need for any apparatus. After all if you pick up a glass of water in the real world and take a drink you take for granted the feel of the glass, the wetness of the contents, the temperature of the contents and the slaking of thirst. Now the last can never be truly achieved holographically but the rest can be but unfortunately only in virtual reality through the use of goggles and gloves with piezoelectic sensors inbedded in them. The more sensors, the greater the sense of the reality but the limitations of being harnessed limits its usefulness especially to the military that is the major source of funding for this reasearch. Military applications are the primary driving force behind this. You've probably seen the movie 'Top Gun'. Imagine if everything that was done in it could be accomplished without a plane ever leaving the ground. Think of the fuel savings and the reduction of real life dangers causing loss of life and yet all the physical sensations would feel and appear real. Next project your imagination to war games where squads if not platoons and battalions could receive realistic combat training without the need to expend ammunition, fuel and lives and now you can understand the interest of the military. Recreational us will develop out of this as an ancilliary benefit but in the mean time we will have to be patient. The algorythms have already been generated for the visual and auditory effects and right now work is being done with pulsed photons to make for tactility. Holographic reality is going to be to virtual reality what video games are to what was Pong if you can remeber that far back. When, not if, its brought to market the major players in the field are going to score big as investments. I'm only involved in a small part of this but based on what I've seen I've slowly begun accumulating stocks. Most of the companies involved are major companies right now but when it hits the market as a finished product the profit potentials will be huge.

by hal 9000

I think that said something about Fluro lighting causing an increase of skin & Breast cancer in night shift workers who where exposed to this type of lighting system.

With your explanation it makes a lot more sense than it did back then when I originally heard it but then again I had just dropped a car on myself to get a 2 week holiday from work. It's surprising just how much you rethink things when you are within a hairs width of death. I actually remember that time very well as on the second day in hospital instead of seeing Star Trek I was forced to watch a couple of complete suicidal fools fly commercial aircraft into buildings.

Now if only they had done it after Star Trek had been shown I just might have got some sleep that night.

Col

by sleepin'dawg

Just when you think its getting back to normal the SOB's rev it up again. I've been watching them since 1962 and there has been no change. The animals just keep on and if anything are getting worse. I've been told that my attitudes towards Islam is too extreme but after what they did to those kids in Russia I'm begining to wonder if I haven't understated the danger from these lunatics??? Don't think it can't happen down there. Bali isn't that far away. Dawg

This discussion is closed to new replies.