Question Locked

Why say Vista is crap?

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We're setting up a mail server on a network that runs various Mac OS, Server OS and XP with Vista.

Some stations see the server and can access all areas from the C drive, blah, blah.

We need to set up our mail server for us to begin with our e-commerce.

Dell, who supplied the workstation, were referred to us by Windows after discussing how to configure Vista for the email server. Unfortunately the Dell help desk are not sufficently trained to walk our IT technician through the set-up and troubleshooting.

Does anyone have an easy answer, or will we get the same reply from Dell?

Vista is crap, get XP....!

12 replies

by 1bn0

I would be suspicious of any mail system set up on a desktop OS for "e-commerce" use.

What mail package are you trying to implement? That would be the most important piece of informatin here.

by toretto84

She doesn't say that she's trying to make a vista desktop into a mail server... there's a problem with vista and the mail server. Now it's up to us to guess what that is, and try and solve it at the same time.

by oh smeg

And connect to the computer so we can see what is happening here.

Unfortunately the SCSI Interface of mine broke 3 weeks ago and I can not find any place that still sells these so I'm stuffed here. :(

Col

by oh smeg

To correctly Interpret the Future?

That is just like using registry cleaners nice when they work but fraught with lots of danger.

While the Internet & Computers are great you should never expect them to find the required solutions for you. When you do you suffer the same fate as all though that have trusted [b]Machine Logic[/b] it bites you on the Butt and tels you [b]LIES.[/b] :D

Col

by 1bn0

But you sound like you really miss the old crystal ball.

by jdclyde

bad call.

Your best bet is to find a consultant in the area before you go any further.

You will want a server and a server OS.

by thechas

What version of Vista is on your systems that have Vista?

If you have either Home Basic, or Home Premium, I would be willing to bet that that is your problem. Just like with XP you should be using XP Pro for any networked business environment, you should be using Vista Business or Ultimate on your networked business computers.

Chas

by staceyo

Based on poor advice from Dell with what OS we should
be running, we have Vista Basic! Notably, when we run
our connection through Windows 2007 Server NO PROB's.
The reason why we're not using Server to run our mail
server has a few scenarios. 1, We're running our Print
production from this server and this cost us a few pennies
to install. 2, The Inspiron Dell is ONLY going run our
internet portion. We're not even running Word from here.

Speaking to Dell support, all the IP addresses, subnet
masks, allocations and directories have been set-up, yet
no machine on the network can receive mail through the
'server'. Dell have then suggested that we go back to XP,
because of its ease to configure the internet with.

This may seem naive, but if we could run the 'server'
through an 8 year old dell running the original XP
Professional, what's changed?

by thechas

What has changed is that you actually took a step down when you went with Vista Home. From a networked computer standpoint, Vista Home has no better functionality than XP Home did. Neither should be used on a business network.

Your options are:
Go back to XP Pro.
Install Vista Ultimate.
Install Vista Business.
You might also be able to use Windows Essential Server on this system.

From a business network standpoint, Vista Business edition should function as well as XP Pro did. With tighter security settings.

Vista Ultimate is really for the computer geek who needs to have the top of the line in everything. Think of Vista Ultimate as the Gamer or Graphic Artist version of Vista.

If Dell support will help you roll back the system to XP Pro, that would be your lowest cost option. Just keep in mind that in 4 years or so, Microsoft will stop producing security patches for XP and you will need to switch to Vista, Windows 7, or a server version of Windows.

Chas

by oh smeg

The Old Gigabyte GA6_BXDU M'Board those old Slot 1 Dual Processor M'Boards flew along with only 1 GIG of RAM.

Something about those old BX440 Chip Sets just hasn't been improved on since their demise. Seems to have gone back wards since them in performance terms. :(

I still insist that it ran XP faster then my new Quad Core CPU on a Gigabyte Board with 4 GIG of RAM. It was far more reliable if nothing else anyway.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.