Question Locked

Win 2003 Fileserver on a budget..

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We have a setup of around 30 desktop and laptop PCs in a peer to peer network (workgroup). The PCs are running a mix of Windows 2000, XP Home and XP Pro. As the number of PCs in the LAN has grown from around 10 a couple of years ago to around 30 now, the network has become slow. Network functionality is shared internet broadband access, shared folders on the PCs and also 4 shared printers.

One Win 2000 PC (Workstation OS) is used as a file server for some of the PCs. Now more of the PCs in the network needs to access data on this file server, and we get into problems with no more than 10 concurrent clients connecting to that PC. So we consider upgrade to Windows 2003 Server on this PC.

Our concern is: as there are (many) XP Home PCs in the LAN, these can not make proper use of Active Directory. I understand that XP Home PCs can connect to shares on the domain, but still am not sure if it would be a good idea to use a domain considering the XP Home PCs..?

Can we install and configure a Windows 2003 on the fileserver without a domain, and still achieve to speed up network traffic compared to now? What could be beneficial to do re. this?

This is for a non-profit organization with limited budgets, no indept knowledge re. Windows Server OS & Domain etc, and we need to keep things as simple and affordable as possible..

4 replies

by m61

then perhaps linux using a samba share as it is free, and windows can see samba just fine

as for speed ups of the network, you may have to look at setting up workgroups or something, maybe even the hardware is old [10mbps line instead of a 100mbps line?]

by churdoo

Any IT term, like "Fileserver" followed by "on a budget" is an oxymoron if I ever heard one. I'm not saying that any IT venture has to break the bank; what I am saying is that you want speed, reliability, simplicity, without spending the proper amount of money to get such? OK that's my preaching for the day, now let's get down to business.

Just as your PC's are made up of various grades of inexpensive and/or donated equipment, I suspect so is your network infrastructure, i.e. switches, router, etc. Having evolved from 10 peer-peer nodes to 30, you've definitely grown beyond the scope of a peer-peer setup, and the problems that you're having are directly related to an overgrown budget peer setup.

I do think that your answer, especially for 30 nodes, is to switch to a client-server setup and overhaul that network. Peer-peer is only meant to be a solution for up to 10 nodes and even that is arguable -- I have a non-profit client of 4 that I'm pushing to have them move to a client-server (SBS) setup. The more you move over to a properly configured client-server network, the less administrative traffic there is, i.e. netbios broadcast traffic for name resolution.

The Windows 2000 workstation that you're using as your fileserver -- W2K Pro, i.e. the non-server O/S, only allows 10 concurrent connections for file sharing; to go beyond 10, you need to move to a Server O/S like W2K3 Server, period.

While you can use W2K3 Server peer-peer, it's little-to-no more work to run it in AD mode and still accomodate your Home O/S'. In other words, for any of your workstations that already have Pro O/S, supporting these becomes easier, and supporting your home O/S' on an AD network, while not ideal, as long as you create a username/password in AD that matches the username/password of the local user of that PC (and don't use the local administrator account for users), and a small batch file in the startup group of the PC, supporting these is no more than in your peer-peer environment, and probably still a little easier. And over time, you can upgrade or replace PC's with Pro O/S, and gain all the benefits of the client-server environment, mainly the centralized management tools via AD and GP, and better network performance as a result of the centralized name resolution services and server optimization.

Here in the States, non-profit organizations can get donated software from MS and other vendors through an organization called Tech Soup (www.techsoup.org). This or some similar organization may be available in the UK. With this, you could potentially apply for enough XP PRO upgrades to cover your network as well as the Server O/S' and CALs, all for only a minute administrative fee. Don't forget your MS Office licenses at the same time.

Next, take a look at your physical network. I would suggest in a network of 30, that you get rid of SOHO grade devices (if you bought it or can buy it from the same place that you get your pencils and post-it notes, then get rid of it!) and replace them with business grade switches. You can get business grade switches pretty reasonably these days, and also make sure you're not hopping from switch to switch to switch throughout your facility. If you have multiple switches, you want one good business grade switch at the top of your rack, uplinking from this one switch to each of the rest of your switches. Some rewiring may be necessary to cable everything back to your main distribution area, or if you have switches located elsewhere in the building, i.e. sub distribution areas, you want a good clean gigabit run coming from each of the sub-distro's to your main distribution/switch.

Hope this helps.

by jehove

Your reply to my questions made us invest in Windows 2003 Server (and we got this at academic licensing costs). Thank you very much for your comments.

Our network, including over a dozen XP Home PCs, half a dozen Windows 2000 and the rest XP Pro and Vista is now up and running, at much better speed - everything is working perfect. The network performance has increased significantly. Amazing what a good conductor can do for a small assembly.

Actually (and I deliberately did not want to mention this initially) the network consist for the most part of Wireless client PCs, connected through a 24 port D-Link corp. level switch and 3 WAPs, with 2 range extenders. About 10 PCs and the 3 WAPs are connected with CAT5 cabling to the Switch, the rest of the crowd have no strings attached and seems happy with that.

The old Dell Dimension Desktop PC with the former 2000 W.S. OS has been promoted to a Windows 2003 Server job position (with a dedicated Synology Diskstation backup harddrive), seems happy and proud with the new job positon and everything is basically functioning perfect.

We decided that when we were at it to try push this to the limits and the Dimension has been promoted to a CD Server (Virtual CD Server http://www.virtualcd-online.com/) and to function as print server for a Samsung laser printer as well, and is handling both jobs to full satisfaction.

All different issues and concerns with Microsoft and good and bad decisions, some engineers must have been awake and alert during the development of Windows Server OS.

Thanks for your comments, got us finally in to the upgrade and no regrets.

This discussion is closed to new replies.