Discussion Locked

Windows 2000 or XP

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi,
Believe it or not I still have many clients running windows 98 computer on windows nt network.
I'm going to be pruchasing new computers. I'm not sure as to go with windows 2000 or XP for my clients computers. Any advice would be aprreciated

5 replies

by oz_media

This question has been raised so many times and yet no solid answer is available as there are so many reasons to look at either OS.

I have removed XP from more clients PC's and installed 2KPro on many occasions, yet this is often just the extreme change they don't like. People don't want to relearn navigation.

On the other hand, if you use XP Professional (Home will not work on your domain)you will not need to upgrade for some time, 2000 will lose it's support (date is always changing but I think they say end of '04 now).

XPPro and 2K are VERY similar and now the bugs are being ironed out.

The other reason I'd choose XP is that you say you're already budgeted to buy NEW computers so meeting the XP hardware requirements will be easy. ot to mention, prefessional desktops will usually ship with XPPro (retail boxes usually ship with XPH).

Long story short;
If new PC's, go XPPro
If older machines, 2K may save a lot in hardware upgrades due to compatibility.

Don't forget lots or RAM, XP LOVES RAM.

by oz_media

When I say VERY similar I mean they run on the same kernel, so they perform the same.

Now that I think about it and due to your budget, I would definitely recommend XPPro (With LOTS of RAM!!).

by thechas

If you are on a network and have a corporate licensing agreement with Microsoft, I would go with W2K for the tighter security.

With most PC sellers, you may be forced to get XP on a new PC.

While you can lock down XP to be nearly as secure as W2K, it is a bit of work.

If you go with XP, make sure to get XP Pro for ANY networked computer.

Chas

by chris910

You did not mention the main purpose of your computers.
If you have special/nonstandard applications Verify compatability. I have run into several applications in my enviroment where the vendor says that their software will work with XP but when I did the actual installs I found out that yes the software works under XP Pro but only if the user is logged in as Administratorwhich is not an option in the location where the software was to be installed.

by mueed2

Hello
Win XP in very good but it is a new technology and has loop holes and week points that can invite viruses or other malicious codes.on the other hand Win 2000 is old mature and having tight collaboration with Win2000 server. i would recommend to choose Win 2000.foder level securities are very easy to manage in Win 2000
best of luck
Mueed A Mirza

This discussion is closed to new replies.