Question Locked

Windows Boot Issue

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'll start by saying I've just performed a fresh install of Windows XP Pro(SP2). Everything with the install went fine, and the computer booted up as one would expect it to. However, when I performed the first of the Windows updates:
Windows Installer 3.1 (KB893803)
Update for Windows (KB898461)

the computer would not boot properly. It would loop to the boot options screen:
Safe Mode
Last Known Configuration
Start Windows Normally

I was only able to boot into Safe Mode. Once booted into Safe Mode, I uninstalled the "Update for Windows (KB898461)" update. I then restarted the computer and the computer booted fine. I then randomly restarted the computer and experienced the same issue of being looped to the boot options screen. My only successful option was again to boot into Safe Mode. Once in Safe Mode I simply restarted the computer. The computer booted into Windows just fine. So once again I restarted the computer and again I get looped to the boot options screen. I wound up removing all of the Windows updates. I then restarted the computer and have had no boot problems since.

Some side notes: I do see the Windows Splash screen each time, "Start Windows Normally" option does not do anything but loop me back to the boot options screen, as does the "Last Known Good Configuration" option. I also have not "Activated" Windows yet. However, I've been able to successfully download and install Windows updates before "Activating" on other machines.

If anyone would know why this is, and provide some suggestions for a solution it would be much appreciated.

9 replies

by oh smeg

And this should stop you downloading any patches till you have Activated the product. This is how M$ is cracking down on Pirate Software and Windows Genuine Advantage is something nasty which can kill off the OS any time that it takes it into it's mind to do so. Granted this is worse with Vista but I can not see that M$ has not been able to introduce the bulk of WGA so called benefits into XP as it gives M$ total control over the computers and which ones it will accept for activation.

Whenever I'm not working with Volume License Copies of XP and this isn't very often I always install an AV Program Update it and then activate Windows and then start to apply any available updates. This seems to work and initially there should be 3 patches that get installed then after a reboot several hundred MEG to download and install. Though to be fair here these also include the Office Patches or Service Packs.

Col

by twood20

It sounds like you're right on with your thoughts. I'll activate Windows and see what happens. I had already installed an Anti-Virus program so now it's off to speak with M$!

Well, I activated Windows and restarted the computer. I experienced the "loop" again. I booted into Safe Mode and then restarted the computer...it booted fine. I went ahead and installed the first two Windows updates and restarted the computer. I experienced the "loop" again. I booted into Safe Mode and the computer booted fine.

Any thoughts?

by twood20

This whole situation started as a fresh wipe and clean. I used an OEM Windows disk with SP2.

by oh smeg

But if all you did was use a Windows CD to install the OS you can not have wiped the HDD as Windows doesn't offer this option.

If you want to use a wiping utility Boot & Nuke is available here

http://tinyurl.com/4rfur

This will write zeros to every sector of the HDD to totally destroy any data underneath where as if you used the Format option it only writes to every third sector of the HDD and leave the other two thirds of the drive alone. If you used the Fast Format Option that only writes the Master Boot Records and doesn't actually touch the HDD at all.

Of you can try doing an In Place Install by following the directions here that will fix any altered files from new and correct any errors that may have cropped in. Though it's not 100% effective it may be worth the time & effort in this case

http://tinyurl.com/g4bv8

Personally from past experience I would perform a wipe and install as it tends to work out faster.

Col

by twood20

Ok, I'll use the Boot & Nuke utility. I also went ahead and used a brand new hard drive, performed my fresh install using the same disk, and the same procedure I would normally follow when installing Windows. Everything seems to be fine. I've restarted several times, I've downloaded and installed the first of the basic Windows updates(haven't done the 40 some updates that come next), and I have not activated Windows at this point. I've not had any trouble booting into Windows.
I was wondering if there was something wrong with the previous hard drive (i.e. inevitable failure...sooner rather than later.) I'll try the Wipe and Install and see what happens.
Thanks for the continuous feedback.

by twood20

Oh Smeg, If you're still listening I just wanted to say thanks for your contribution. If you're interested, here is how things played out since my last post on the topic.

*Ran Boot and Nuke.
*Reinstalled Windows.
*Had two or three days of normal activity after installing Anti-Virus software, and performing available Windows Updates.
*Experienced original problem with the computer booting and looping to the boot options menu.
*Decided the hard drive was somehow faulty
*Opened a brand new hard drive and followed my usual procedure for installing Windows

It's been about a week and haven't had a problem yet...cross my fingers.

Anyway, thanks again.

This discussion is closed to new replies.