Question Locked

Workgroup/Domain

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a small business with 16 users and 1 Win2K server and a new 2003 server that is not yet installed. We are currently set up as a workgroup and am considering switching to a domain. Is this worth the effort? We have 1 IT person(me) and a small budget. What is the best way to get started? Internal security is not that big of concern but centralized backups and not having to go around to 16 desktops would be huge. Just looking for help in how to get started.

Thanks.

11 replies

by oh smeg

You may not have a choice here. All new versions of 2003 since the R2 release have to be run as a Domain not a Workgroup.

Have you even looked at this new server yet?

by trbleshooter

Actually no i had not even looked at it. It is a 2003 R2 SP2.

by cmiller5400

and by limiting how many user accounts are needed (just one vs one per station) that alone could be worth the switch. Totally up to you. I would run a domain even with just 5 users. But that's just me. :)

by dhanushkapg

Domain is use for Authorization and Authentication. It will helps you to maintain high IT security Level.So if u consider of org. Security u can use Domain Concept. Otherwise Domain is no need for small scale organizations.
It depends on security Level

by cmiller5400

You can have a domain with little security so your point is invalid.

A domain makes things easier to manage and provides a central place for that management. You can configure it to be like Fort Knox or as loose as you want.

by trbleshooter

IF you set up the 2003 server as the DHCP server and also use it as a fileserver will the performance be a factor? How hard does acting as the dhcp affect performance?

by dhanushkapg

Domain Concept is for Centralized Authendication and Authorization or centralized Control...As i told you if you want to implement high level of effective IT security you can use Domain. Org. size is not concern that occasion...

by cmiller5400

My point is you can also implement a high level of "IT Security" as you call it, in a workgroup. You don't necessarily need a domain to accomplish "effective IT Security".

I was just trying to point out that using a domain from the start will make things easier as they expand. You may only have 15 users now but what about a year from now? 50?

by sgt_shultz

it'll be so much easier to administer and have lots of extra benefits. plus you'll get experience. if you get small business server it'll pretty much set itself up out of the box

This discussion is closed to new replies.