Question Locked

Workgroups on our network, is it a good idea

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We will be implementing a point of sale system in the near future. The Vendor suggest creating a workgroup called Retail, and these workstations would then communicate over the WAN with the Master pc.

These workstations would not be joined to our domain but this traffic is still riding on the same network. I don't know how or if its possible to hack the domain workstations from a pc joined to a workgroup or from the otherway hacking a workgroup from the domain. Am I being paranoid or are there risks here.

I think we need to create VLANs for this traffic but it will be a huge undertaking as we are spread out all over the county.

I've considered just joing these workstations to the domain but this is frowned upon from our operations staff as it would then require logins.

Any advice would be appreciated.

4 replies

by david.wallis

i would join them to the domain :) and make a seperate OU for them in active directory

by erichards

This is the direction we are looking at which will require logins for each of the POS operators. As of right now they don't have logins they just turn on the pc and the POS program runs automatically. We are a seasonal agency so we would be adding probably about 100 more users for the summer months, all of which are teenagers which creates huge problems from a password point of view, most commonly calls on the weekend, oops, I forgot my password. I've also considered the VLan idea but it appears that AT&T would have difficulty routing the VLAN addresses on the MPLS network.

by jiminpa

You have no choice but to put things on a workgroup. I work in medical and some vendors insist their equipment be on a workgroup. There are many reasons for this, first there is the fear of group policy causing problems with the application. Another issue is some programs need admin rights to run (there are workarounds to that to). You have every right to be paranoid. As an IT guy its your job to be. A VLAN is a good idea. Password management is going to be a challenge for sure. Set up a firewall, make sure you have good AV software and if possible resrtict internet access.
You could consider asking the vendor why they are insistant about the workgroup. If it is simply a matter of admin rights you can always give local admin rights to the user group that will be using the system... or it could be more complex than that.

This discussion is closed to new replies.