Discussion Locked

Working for an ex-employer

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Tell us what you think about going back to work for an old employer, as featured in Monday's Career Advice e-newsletter. Would you consider returning to work for a company that laid you off? How would you approach the interview? Would you negotiate any special "deals"?

23 replies

by madmark

Oh, I would definitely work for an ex-employer. I am proud of my work history, and the successes that I have contributed to along the way.

I have been laid off (Am now as a matter of fact! You hiring?) in the past due to economy, restructuring,and downsizing decisions over my 20 year career. I didn't like it, but it is business, don't take it personal.

I would approach the interview with a firm handshake and a smile. After all, they are looking to fill a need, and they accepted the meeting. That would indicate that they feel I may have some value. I am much more valuable to a previous employer NOW than when they first hired me. I am also a 'known quatity' and have an edge over any stranger. Unless I was perceived as a total jerk.

I would make it clear that I enjoyed my tenure with them, remind them of my accomplishments while there, and fill them in on my latest gigs. I would listen to their needs and look for ways to fill them.

I negotiate a 'special deal' at every interview. Chances are, they are not my family members, so they are not about to give more than what is fairly negotiable. I would negotiate options based on past track record, for instance, I had an employer that didn't pay travel expenses on time. A solution to that dilemma would have to be negotiated. Another employer had no training plans or budgets in place. THAT would be negotiated and put in writing.

This industry is huge, globally. Locally, it is just a few thousand companies. If you choose to only pass this way once, your career options are limited.

by frozen one

Yea, i would consider if they invited me to join them again at a higher position and compensation than the one i had before.

Laying off is a crucial management decision, specially if the one concerned is a technical guy, whom they invested heavily on trainings. The fact that the company invited me, will secure my salary negotiation.

Working for a previous company has its advantages, you have an existing bond with senior colleagues/ decision makers, and you have the full support of your previous subordinates, critical factors if u are in the IT industry frontlines.

by frozen one

Yea, i would consider if they invited me to join them again at a higher position and compensation than the one i had before.

Laying off is a crucial management decision, specially if the one concerned is a technical guy, whom they invested heavily on trainings. The fact that the company invited me, will secure my salary negotiation.

Working for a previous company has its advantages, you have an existing bond with senior colleagues/ decision makers, and you have the full support of your previous subordinates, critical factors if u are in the IT industry frontlines.

by frozen one

Yea, i would consider if they invited me to join them again at a higher position and compensation than the one i had before.

Laying off is a crucial management decision, specially if the one concerned is a technical guy, whom they invested heavily on trainings. The fact that the company invited me, will secure my salary negotiation.

Working for a previous company has its advantages, you have an existing bond with senior colleagues/ decision makers, and you have the full support of your previous subordinates, critical factors if u are in the IT industry frontlines.

by galyon

Isn't it just so cute how employers seem to expect complete loyalty but are so willing to dump you at the first thought of problems? So, to win the game play the game their way. Use financial 'leverage' to help filter out whether it's worth going back. Negotiate a 'parachute' that guarantees you have protection if they bail on you again; for example if they dump you within a year you get severence equal to one year's salary plus benefits. Year two you get six months and so on. This should helpdetermine just how serious they are and how confident they are in their recovery. You may also want to consider negotiating a contract for services provided instead of being an employee. Up the ante by at least 50% to make it worth the hassle of handling your own business affairs.

Unfortunately, except in VERY rare cases, loyalty is a thing of the past. In the commercial world you must always remember you are a mercenary. Pay for performance...period! It will spare you a lot of grief in thelong run.

by galyon

Isn't it just so cute how employers seem to expect complete loyalty but are so willing to dump you at the first thought of problems? So, to win the game play the game their way. Use financial 'leverage' to help filter out whether it's worth going back. Negotiate a 'parachute' that guarantees you have protection if they bail on you again; for example if they dump you within a year you get severence equal to one year's salary plus benefits. Year two you get six months and so on. This should helpdetermine just how serious they are and how confident they are in their recovery. You may also want to consider negotiating a contract for services provided instead of being an employee. Up the ante by at least 50% to make it worth the hassle of handling your own business affairs.

Unfortunately, except in VERY rare cases, loyalty is a thing of the past. In the commercial world you must always remember you are a mercenary. Pay for performance...period! It will spare you a lot of grief in thelong run.

by montgomery gator

If you return to a previous employer that laid you off, they might do it again, particularly if they have financial problems. I would not go back to an employer that laid me off unless I was desperate and that was the only opportunity available. They showed a lack of respect and loyalty to their employees by laying some of them off.

by montgomery gator

Listen to what Nick says, it is a matter of who can you trust. I would not go back to a company that laid me off, unless I was desperate. They showed a lack of respect to their employers by laying them off, and might do it again.

by techmail.cmccubbin

I learned along time ago - you never go back to fromer employers or former lovers. You'll only get your heart broken again. In this case why ruin your reputation by going back. If they were to fire/lay off again would the new company take you back, not likely. You'd be labeled as an unfaithful employee and the resume would always find file 13. Moreover once you get that reputation new employers will steer clear as well. Like I said never go back, no matter what they offer.

by dlreazor

Going back to work for a previous employer is OK under the right circumstances. This is not one of those. If this was a year or more later and the company cleaned up its finances and was doing OK, then you need to review the companies position before accepting. Right now they are looking to fill positions and because of their status, are finding it difficult. If you took your current position just for a job, then look around, but not at your previous employer.

by mcberg01

i was in a situation of where i quit from the company i worked for in one city. i moved to another, where the company had another division located. i had found a job with another company. 3 months into the new job, i got a call from the divsion that was in the same city as i. they wanted me to come back to the company. after negotions, i went back. But the important thing i did was keep up the communications with the current company i was in to let them know.

by brian.kiser

I went back to a company once, and they treated me right. It all depends on the circumstances of how you left.

I'd be very cautious about going back to a company that canned me originally! And no way I would leave a great job and return to a place like that.

Job-hopping is a science. :)

by debross

Just a word of encouragement about your old employer that you liked so well -- after some years working in legal/bankruptcy field, a company that has been reorganized under Chapter 11 usually has eliminated all "dead wood" and is in a very solid financial position. Unless you've seen it in action, you wouldn't believe how many people (judges, lawyers, accountants, bankers, trustees, etc.) oversee the bankruptcy process to make sure the reorganized company is on solid feet. To me, that would almost level the playing field, and I would opt for the job I loved. Good luck.

by wlui

You should not go back to your old employer who laid you off. How important they thought you were to them when they made that decision to lay you off. If you get hit once, do not go back to get hit again. Move on with your new job and look forward. Never look back and dont let your emotion control you. No matter how much you like your old job, a job is a job. Your old job dumped you and you move on.

by paul g.

Do you truly, can you truly, trust someone who has already made it clear they DO NOT WANT YOU OR YOUR CAPABILITIES to suddenly turn around and cry "Come Back Little Sheba!! Come Back!!"?

by juggernaut1

I would have to look at this situation with the same grain of salt that I would if a company made a couter-offer to keep me on the job. The are probably doing it just to keep the position filled with "a warm body" (substitute "cannon fodder" or any other relative terminology), and you would become expendable whenever it was convenient for the company. Plus, if the old company put any stock in seniority, being the last hired would mean being the first fired, even in a far less drastic downsizingoperation than was experienced before.

One would also be wise to look at the big picture of how it reflects on your job history to quit a job after just two weeks to go back to a former employer (or any other employer). Unless you plan on stayingwith a company until you get your gold watch - which is highly unlikely these days (even more unlikely with a company that had previously fired you) - you don't want to appear as though you can't make a commitment to a company. Nothing puts your resume into the circular file faster than a history (even a short history) of bailing out before a company starts to get a ROI on the cost of hiring you.

Bottom line is that I would stick with the new company for at least a year to see what opportunities and happiness you can find there. If it doesn't look good at that point, you can still use your contacts at the old company (which should be on a more solid footing by then) to see what positions are available there.

by harilal55

Going back depends mainly under what conditions where you laid off. If employers think they deserve our consideration and we must give them a standard two weeks notice, why don't they do the same thing? As far as I know employees are never notified in advance, I think I would never go back unless is the only solution.

by tomsal

I think its ridiculous how we as employees are expected to give a notice, even up to a month in some cases, before we resign - yet the employer will just come in your office one morning and your co-workers see you packing by lunch.

Yet, employeesare judged about being all professional, courtesy and "oh my - watch how you talk to your boss, etc."....seems awfully lob-sided to me.

by j.g.camp

Certain management would have to be kicked out or leave and certainly would never return for what they were paying me before. What persecution that I endured in the last 3 months there is worth pain and suffering damages. Screw them and their internal collusions !

by andreas_tolkmitt

As the head line says I did go back to an exemployer. The company did not support me in my Career in the first place. So I went to another company providing training and supporting my career. Still kept in touch with my former Coworkers. My former employer changed mangement and business structure over time and where looking for experienced staff. So I was asked to come back. I agreed on a Senior position and made a special deal.
I would allways keep in touch with former employers or at least some friends.
Companies change and knowing the company gives you allways a headstart over any other applicant.

by discordian

really, this is more of a irrational debate, there is no absolute since it really depends on the circumstances behind the situation.

sure, as a general rule you should be cautious about returning to an ex-employer, be sure to remember why you left or why they left you out in the cold and be honest with yourself about the chances of that happening again and if you are willing to forced to take that chance or deal with problems you might of left behind. in some cases, it may work out, at leastto the extent that most of us end up staying with the same employer anyways.

so, it's a pretty senseless debate, there cannot be any significant or correct and absolute viewpoint to take here.

by lance.gillis

How can you grow as a person if you stick yourself back in the same old place? Go back to a former employer? NEVER!!!! Move on with your life. Meet new people. Do things at least a little differently. Gain new experiences. Grow! (I think thisis where "Live long and prosper" comes in) Really, move forward in life, not backward.

by discordian

it probably is more prudent to move on than move back as a general rule of thumb. yet it is situational since there are going to be circumstances under which one would be best advised to go back to an ex employer. management changes, economy, or even the realization that mistakes were made on one or more sides could prompt a favorable condition for return.

it's difficult to suggest one course of action that is right most of the time for this situation, especially in today's environment with a weak economy, poor opportunities for technology professionals, and an unprecidented and overwhelming upper hand that employers have over employees. it's rough out there, and i can completely understand why it may be very compelling to go back if the chance is there even though i may not agree that people should do so in an ethical sense. yes, the free market should work in a way that would support a fluid workforce so that poor employers would have difficulty obtaining workers, but it doesn't work that way right now. employers have all the power at this time, thus it's each person for themselves since people as a whole are not interested in overcomming that situation as a whole for whatever reason. as long as that is the way it is then you are best advised to do what is in your best short term interests at the time, even if it's swallowing your pride and going against your better judgement to go back to an ex-employer.

This discussion is closed to new replies.