Question Locked

XP Pro 32bit 4gb memory causing Blue Screen?

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm trying to figure out if what I heard is isolated or widespread.

The doctors in the office use Toshiba laptops with Dragon dictation and I want to max out the A7s to 4gigs.

A co-worker said his home desktop machine got the BOD when he installed 4 gigs on his 32bit OS. He says that when/if the computer uses ALL of the physical memory, it will crash.

I call BS on this since it's not even recognizing the full amount and there's nothing (I think) that can or should cause his BOD that's memory related unless it's bad memory or not compatible, IE timing, speed, ECC, etc...

10 replies

by thumbsup2

I have 4GB installed on several XP Pro systems and no BSOD.

The only problem with installing 4GB on any 32bit OS is that it will only REPORT there is approximately 3.2GB installed, the rest being reserved by the system so you can't access it.

But, as for the original question, you are correct. There is no reason for the installation of 4GB to cause BSOD unless there is something wrong with the RAM they put in.

by derek-merritt

I think you are right in that it is bad memory, or the wrong type of memory. Have him test it the machine with just one stick in at a time.

by peconet tietokoneet

You will get the BSOD if you have bad drivers also. But if you have the same make,speed and size of memory then you should not have the BSOD.

by oh smeg

I regularly use 4 Gig's of RAM with 32 Bit systems to get the best performance possible out of the Dual Chanel M'Boards without a single problem.

If you use any less you do not get the best possible performance out of the M'Boards and if you use Different size RAM like 2 X 1 GIG and 2 X 512 MEG the system doesn't perform as well as it could. If you use 3 X 1 GIG the system runs in Single Chanel Mode and is considerably slower that it is with 2 X 2 GIG RAM Sticks in use.

As for what your friend is experiencing that is most likely due to incompatible RAM where there is a Major Timing Issue present between the different RAM being used. If you stick with 4 GIG Kits from the better makers there just isn't a problem with using 4 GIG on a 32 Bit Windows System.

Mater of Fact this particular computer that I am using now when running a 32 Bit OS has 16 Gig's as 4 X 4 Gig fitted and doesn't have a single problem running either XP or Vista 32 Bit Platforms.

Col

by thechas

First, just to be clear, with any 32 bit OS the maximum usable memory is 3.2GB! Any installed RAM above that is wasting the cost of the RAM and the power it takes to run the RAM.

While we cannot dismiss the possibility of incompatible RAM or bad RAM, I suspect that there is a chip-set / BIOS bug in these systems that is bumping heads with the RAM over the 3.2 GB of usable RAM.

Keep in mind that the system does not use the upper limit of the 4GB RAM, it uses the address space. The PCI bus and video communications take place in that upper address range.

So, if there were to be a bug in the BIOS that did not mask off the installed RAM in the upper address space, it would be possible for there to be a conflict between the RAM and the system communications.

One last thought. You did not say how much RAM these systems reported. If the reported RAM is 2GB or less with 4GB installed, you could have a RAM density conflict. That is the chips on the new RAM you installed have too high a density for the memory controller in the systems to work with. It is a true statement that not all memory of a given type will work in all systems that are designed for that type of memory.

Myself, I never install more than 2GB of RAM for a system that will run a 32-bit version of Windows.

Chas

by seanferd

Then you can search it up and get at least a general idea of what is causing it, and proof that it is not the RAM.

by reuben

I'm glad I found this post that is kinda really recent... I've received today a dual (2x1GB)channel pack of kingston RAM DDR400(PC3200)...

I already had 2x1GB of RAM on my machine...

I had bought the last great PC set before PCI express and dual core came in...

I have recently bought the latest AGP video card... ATI SApphire HD3850 and upgraded from 1.5GB to 2GB (Dumped the 512GB for 1GB+1GB dual channel)...

However process explorer marks the memory as bottleneck during certain Crysis scenes...

So Thought of upgrading the RAM... with two more 2GB...

I have an MSI 865 NEO 2 PLS with 4 slots supporting a max of 1GB each... I also have an Intel 3.0 HT processor.

Well... upon installation of the 2GB RAM in the remaining slots... the PC got the Blue Screen of DEATH just at it got into windows... Fact is it happens so fast before rebooting automatically that I can read what happens...

It's past midnight here so I'll check the RAM individually tomorrow...

For now I removed one of them (bye bye dual channel)... I managed to get into windows and get 30 minutes into Stargate COntinuum before the BSOD appeared again prior to immediate reboot... [I've got to film it - so I can read what in Says in slow mo]...

I've interchanged the new RAMs and It won't get in windows...

I'll replace the previous two I had with these two new tomorrow... if I have time before going to work...

I'll check it out...

Meanwhile... Anyone has any suggestions?

Thanks and Regards...

Reuben

by cdobrescu

Make sure the memory is not ECC or it'll always do that, although it should do it while posting and not while loading Windows.

I had a similar problem when I changed the timing on my memory from 5-5-5-18 to 4-4-4-12. With 2 paired sticks I can run the faster timing but with 4 stick (4gigs total) it defaults to 5-5-5-18 and it crashes while playing WoW. I changed the timing to Auto and it's not crashed since.

The BSOD with 4gb of memory actually does happen when it maxes out the physical memory but it's application specific. In your case, it's not even getting that far so I'm guess your memory timing is off or it's not compatible memory for your motherboard...

Hope this helps!

by oh smeg

But with A Bit and Gigabyte M'Boards if you install the wrong RAM in all 4 Slots the Boards will perform very strangely from not starting at all to failing the POST Test or getting a BSOD when Windows starts to load. With the above brands you need to replace all the RAM at the same time with Identical Chips and ideally from the Same manufacturing Batch as Timing is Critical.

The other thing is that with 2 sticks the M'Board can accept and work with slower RAM but when all RAM Slots are populated you need to use the fastest RAM that the M'Board supports.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.