Discussion Locked

Your money or your life...

0 helpful
27 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I started thinking about this when I read the story of the guy shot while standing in line for a Playstation 3. He refused to hand over his money and caught a bullet.

More recently in Toronto, a young athlete left a bar on Saturday night to go to an ATM. He was sucker punched after he left the ATM and robbed. He went back to the bar to get some friends, went down an alley to find the guy, only to get hit by a brick to the head. He died in hospital.

Personally, when I was young, I worked at a 7-11 convenience store and was robbed. Employees were plainly told that resistance to a robbery was a firing offense and that the money was not worth fighting over. That stuck with me.

If you were robbed, and you thought that there was a chance you could fight it, would you? Would you risk injury or death to save a couple of bucks? A hundred bucks? A thousand?

Personally, I wouldn't. But clearly others would.

Now that I support a wife and kids, its even more clear to me. I would risk my life to protect my families safety, or even a stranger's safety.

I once dragged a guy out of a building that was on fire because he insisted on fighting it with every fire extinguisher there. He and I were the last ones there, there wasn't much visible flame, but we knew the fire was in a wall/crawlspace and not easiily accessable and the smoke was building up. I was ready to throw in the towel as I expected the fire trucks to roll up any minute. I was happy to try and preserve his life, but I wouldn't risk my life or even injury to save bricks and mortar. Firefighters have equipment and training and a team to back them up.

I'm not risk averse, but I do consider life's risks and decide which risks to take and which to avoid.

What do you think?

James

27 replies

by maecuff

risk my life over money or any other material possessions. I would risk my life to save another human, but other than that, I'm a chicken and I will run as fast as I can.

by tony hopkinson

pinning someone who tried to rob me at a cashpoint to the wall. I didn't think about it, he went for a snatch and I stuck my elbow in his throat.

If he'd have stood out of range saying things like I've got a knife, I would have given him the money.

If he'd just pulled it and come for me, I would have had a go at taking him out. Some of the buggers will stab you anyway.

by jamesrl

Some will stab you anyway, but I'd have to think the odds are less.

And trust me, when I was working at the 7-11 I was also in Karate classes and I had a bit of a temper. I was sorely tempted when I saw an opportunity. It was an emotional reaction. I actually wonder if I had hit him once whether I would have been able to stop (my anger management issues are behind me now, but at 18...). This guy said he had a knife, but it was his fist in the pocket of his hoodie. I could have called his bluff. In the end he got $35. I think the business lost more than that by being closed for a few hours, and I know they paid me more than that to go to his trial and testify. He got 2 years total for that and two other robberies that night.

Its a chancy thing. My kung fu instructor was in a convenience store when it was being robbed, and was sucker punched just before the robbery. Of course, instinct kicked in and he pulled some guys arm out of his socket. But afterwards he was somewhat repentant.

James

by shellbot

money and possessions are nothing if your not alive to enjoy it/them.

i'd hand it over like it was a nuclear weapon about to go off and then run like hell..oh i'd be angry and i'd probably even turn into a girl (oh wait, i am a girl) and start crying.

by tig2

An elderly man who lived alone shot and killed a 17 year old who had broken into his house and entered his bedroom. The man (in his 70's) had a loaded .22 rifle in his bedroom. He heard his door kicked in and grabbed his rifle. When the would-be burgler entered the bedroom, the man shot once, catching the kid in the chest. The 17 year old died. The man crawled out his bathroom window onto a deck and made his way to a neighbour's and called the police- the man does not have phone service in his home.

The debate has been whether the man took the correct action. As much as I regret the loss of life, the kid was clearly where he should not be- in someone elses house where he was not invited and damaged to gain access. The family of the kid is busily saying that he did nothing wrong. The destruction to the man's door as well as the kid's body in the man's house, to me, suggests otherwise.

Would I give up money for my life? Absolutely. But I would also take the action that our local guy did if someone breaks into my house? Count on it.

While I realise that I have stepped away from the gist of your question, I think there is a relationship. I will always do everything in my power to avoid such a situation, but I will also defend myself if I believe that my life or my partner's is at stake.

by jamesrl

Under the "reasonable use of force" doctrine, if the elderly man had "reasonable" cause to believe he might be injured he is entitled to defend himself. Is kicking in the door reasonable cause? It certainly speaks to a lack of fear and agressive action. If the kid had quietly snuck into the house and had been shot in the back on the way out, thats a different story. But if you kick the door in, and then enter the bedroom...

You have to have a "reasonable" expectation that you might suffer injury. If you are 6' 5 300 lbs weight lifter, and a 85 lbs Grandma comes to your door and threatens to beat you, thats not considered reasonable cause. If she pulls a weapon....

Back in my anger management issue days (teen years) I was home one Saturday night when some drunken people in a pickup decided that my parents fron lawn was a good place to do donuts in their pickup. I grabbed my shotgun and ran out to meet them. They drove off. I wouldn't do that today. The grass will grow back, but my kids could miss a dead father (or one in jail) for years.

I was confronted on the street one night (bad neighbourhood, wife picked the apartment cause it was near the subway)by a drunk/stoned guy who was bleeding from a number of small cuts. He mainly confronted me, but since my wife was with me, I stood my ground, lowered my voice and got into a relaxed but alert stance. I instructed my wife to walk the block to our apartment while I stood him off. He was definately wired, as he was hurt but feeling no pain. If he had made one step towards my wife, I would have had no hesitation whatsoever in doing whatever I had to do - reasonable cause to think he was altered and dangerous. I managed however to convince him that he needed to pay attention to me, and my wife got home safely. Once that was done, I walked away. I called the police and they knew about the guy - he had been thrown through a plate glass window at a notorius bar near by.

In the PS3 thing, clearly the robber had taken money from other people in the line without incident. So a "reasonable" person might conclude that if they handed over the money, they might be treated the same way.

In the Toronto incident, the athlete had been punched, robbed, but had gotten back to the bar to his friends. If he had stayed there, he would be alive today. I'm not suggesting he was a bad kid, just made a bad choice.

James

by tig2

Your question made me think of it because it has dominated the news here since it happened. Today the kid's family has been going on and on about what a great kid he was. I don't know that he wasn't a great kid in some circumstances. However, he and the other two people he was with are wanted for another burglary earlier that night as well.

I think that material anything is not worth the price that could be exacted in that situation. I also think that people sometimes don't think- that they, like Mayven mentioned, want to hit back. To them, it speaks as a reflection of the powerlessness that many people feel any more. The athlete and the PS3 robbery are, to me, examples of people who let the anger at the situation get the better of them.

In a side note, it surprises me somewhat that you have ever had anger issues. You are one of the calmest people around here.

by maevinn

I'd WANT to hit them. Hard. But, I wouldn't. Money and possessions aren't worth it. I had my house broken into not too long ago, and some of the things that were taken were irreplaceable--items my father gave me when I was a child, before he passed away. The losers who did it lived down the road, and were busted because a week later, they unloaded some of the stolen goods from their car into their house, right in front of my husband. The DESIRE to go down there and beat the ignorance out of them was very strong, but ultimately, I believe in playing by the rules until the rules are proven not to work. We called the cops, they came and 'interviewed' the kids, recovered some of our stuff, and the kids went to jail. End of story.

by jdmercha

I too suspect that I would not do what I should do. As others have stated, money and posessions are replaceable, but life is not.

However, I'm afraid that I will react before I think. Even with 15 years of martial arts training, it's just not worth the chance.

by tony hopkinson

Give me time to think about the consequences, I'll probably do the latter, it's not my first reaction to being threatened though.

by old guy

Absolutely I would hand it to them. One, I don't carry enough money on me at any time that it would adversely affect me financially so it would never be worth taking that kind of chance. Two, stuff just ain't worth it.

The safety of my family (not trying to brag but) that would unleash a beast.

by maecuff

bragging. It's what we do. I've had the 'Mama Bear' spring right out of me on a few occasions. I actually had a man run from me and lock himself in his car in a Walmart parking lot because his behavior scared my son who was 6 years old at the time. I absolutely went off on the guy and he ran off like a little girl. :)

by old guy

than the beast that lives inside me is a mama protecting their children. Actually, I had to describe myself one time as an animal and I chose a mama Grizzly bear because I don't think there is a more fierce animal when protecting their cubs. My babies, even though 18 and 22 now are still my cubs.

by onbliss

It will be hard and awful to lose money to thieves, but under most circumstances money is not worth the life. I am not sure how I would react if someone was going to steal all my life savings and material possession, hopefully I keep cool.

by w2ktechman

I am not sure how I would react, but I guess it would depend on the circumstances.
I have had a gun to my head before and survived. Also, I was in a 7-11 once and some guy was trying to mess with me, but for some reason I backed down a few times. Usually I wouldnt in those days, but this time I did. A few minutes later, just after I got back home (a friend had a police scanner on), a guy fitting this guys description popped off 5 rounds in the next parking lot over from the 7-11 store. Whew. If I hadnt been working on my motorcycle all day, and a bit tired, I would probably have been shot. But these are totally different, none were to rob me or related to money.

P.S. If you know someone with a gun, dont ever sneak up on them, especially if they are tired, stoned, drunk, etc.. I thought all of his were locked up, but he had been shooting that day, and was cleaning them. I snuck up and wow, a gun to my head, cocked and loaded. If I didnt freeze at that moment, I would again, probably have been shot that day.

by john.a.wills

I was walking to church from home when a young man suddenly said "gimme your wallet" while holding a big knife at my abdomen. I explained that there was no money in my wallet. "Well, gimme your money". I refused. He threatened "I'll spill your guts". Eventually I said "This is ridiculous: I've got places to go and things to do". He hesitated then ran away.

by jamesrl

That worked out well for you and I am glad. But its a gamble, and you have to think of whether its worth taking.

In the Toronto scenario, where the star college athlete took on the homeless guy who robbed him, I would have bet the odds favoured the star athlete. The homeless guy had a break. The athlete was bigger, stronger and should have been faster (he had been drinking).

In high school I was tormented by a young punk. I was a yearbook photographer, and had a soft leather camera bag, that one might mistake for a purse. He knew it was a camera bag, but gave me a hard time anyway. I stood my ground, and he wanted to fight. I told him the place and time. He never showed. I called him on it the next day. We actually became friends, though I wouldn't say we were close.

But a knife changes the equation. I would have handed over my wallet.

James

by tony hopkinson

to sub-conscious clues, I've got to say you were very lucky. In fact if I were religious, I'd have gone back to the big man's house and said thank you.

by tonythetiger

would risk their life to save another before they would risk it to save money. After all... money is replaceable... lives aren't!

by jmgarvin

Of course the only time I've been in that situation, I lucked out.

I was in high school working at Jack in the Box when a guy tried to crawl through the drive through window. I beat the guy senseless with the window (he was about 1/2 way through, so I just slammed it repeatedly, and I really didn't want him in the store).

About 10 seconds later a cop pulls up (to get some food) and arrests the guy. It turns out the dude had a gun.

Had he asked for the money, he could have had it. If he pulled the gun...There is no doubt in my mind he would have shot us.

The best part (this was the late 80's, so it was pretty "new" to do this) was that he tried to sue us (and Jack in the Box) for injuries that he sustaned trying to rob the store.

Anyway, he got 15 years for armed robbery and apparently he had a ton of warrents and past issues as well, so he got some time for that...I'd bet he's either still in jail or back in jail.

by onbliss

My son is taking Karate lessons (I just started it too). The teacher keeps reiterating to the kids that if you can get out of danger then do that first. If you have to scream and run, then just do that. Defence is a necessity only if there are no other means of getting out of the danger and one is absolutely cornered.

by tony hopkinson

defence in this context is being forced in to battle on your opponent's ground, at a time of their choosing. That's bad odds, unless they've screwed up big time.

by mjd420nova

I worked at a pinball parlor/shooting gallery in the mid sixties, and because of the presence of weapons and live ammo, we were required to pass a weapons proficiency course as part of employment. The gallery had four 22 cal rifles on a 25 yard shooting range. We used gallery special ammo, what they call frangible today, was made from pressed iron that powdered up when it hit resistance. It wouldn't kill you if it hit you, but would make a real mess none the less. One of the owners used a shotgun, myself I prefered a 44 mag. We were instructed to never ever let anyone get away. The rifles were chained down, but could still present a hazard if someone was intent on doing harm. We also ran a large gallery at the state fair where we had 10 weapons on the counter and a large target range. There was no age limit, so the kids really had fun and some had never fired a weapon before. You sure won't see that today. Things have changed now, and unless you have a trigger lock on your weapon you can be prosecuted. Having a weapon in the house is one thing when you have small children, but nothing is worse than one that's not loaded. Might as well have a baseball bat. My children are now gone from the home so I have no worries there, and I bought and showed my wife how to handle a weapon. I still prefer the 44, but it is a bit much for a woman. She prefers a 380, nice, powerful and not much recoil. Good stopping power and small enough for her hands. We go to the shooting range every other month, and really enjoy it. Yes, I will defend my family and property with my life and I hope that those who wish to rob me or do me or my family harm understands this. When the crooks understand that the person they confront might have a weapon, they will think twice.

by jamesrl

I've learned over years to work them out.

Getting enough exercise helps.

A few years of martial arts helped.

Experience helps.

Age helps - maybe I am slowing down.

I am pretty calm, but I do have my moments. I show lots of patience with my staff and with my family. I sometimes do not suffer fools gladly.

James

by blackswan

It?s about your sense of safety and freedom and someone taking that away from you. That is what I would fight for and risk getting hurt or even killed. But you do have a point about weighing the risks. As a man without any kids to worry about, I am willing to put myself at greater risk. If you have kids, your first obligation is to them and not your own idealistic views of freedom and its worth at the moment.

On the other side, if it was easy to point a gun at someone and walk away with their money without the risk of them fighting back, I think it would happen much more often.

by gary.atamian

People that rob you are nothing but bullies. I hate bullies. I will never be a victim. Some a-hole sticks a gun in my face and says, 'Hand it over,' I'd say, 'Come and get it.'

Don't think I'm one of those people that thinks I'm brave behind a keyboard... I can back up what I type.

I've put myself in harm's way to help others. I don't even think about it, it's just reflex.

I'm not a hero, but I hate injustice. I don't see enough justice in our court system with liberal judges meting out slaps on the wrists to thugs who deserve to be behind bars.

I'm not a vigilante, either, but I don't have a problem with vigilante actions, provided they're just. Say what you want about anger issues, I don't care. God help the scumbag who tries to make me a victim.

This discussion is closed to new replies.