TurboTax vs H&R Block: Best Pick

I recommend TurboTax if you want a guided experience with access to on-demand expert help. It’s ideal if you’re a freelancer, crypto trader, or small business owner with complex returns. Its base fees are $0 for simple returns and $119 for self-employed filers, with additional costs for state filing and upgrades. It also offers live expert filing from $129 for individuals and $219 for business owners.

H&R Block, by contrast, is best if you seek flexibility in the prep process. It offers a solid online experience, plus in-person support at over 9,000 locations. It works well if you’re an investor, homeowner, or small business owner who prefers more hands-on help without giving up the self-prep option, which tends to be more affordable. Online filing starts at $0 for returns with only W-2 tax input. H&R Block also offers virtual and in-office Tax Pro Review starting at $60 if you seek extra peace of mind.

Quick comparison of TurboTax vs H&R Block

Pricing: TurboTax wins

If you seek strong features at a lower cost, TurboTax offers better value across comparable tiers. Its Premier plan costs $89, while H&R Block’s equivalent Premium Online plan is $100. The same trend continues with self-employed options in that TurboTax charges $119, whereas H&R Block costs $125. These savings add up, especially if you have complex returns.

Although H&R Block includes perks like in-person audit support and free state filing in select plans, TurboTax delivers a more affordable option without sacrificing features. With its lower pricing and intuitive interface, TurboTax stands out as the more budget-friendly and efficient choice.

TurboTax

H&R Block

Features: H&R Block Wins

Tax return storage and access: TurboTax wins

Both allow you to access past returns, but TurboTax provides more flexible storage options. While H&R Block stores your returns for up to six years (even on free accounts), TurboTax has a 7-year retention period . On both platforms, paid users can archive copies securely in an online account.

In-person support options: H&R Block wins

H&R Block is the only one that offers physical locations for tax help. It has thousands of offices nationwide, giving you the choice between online filing and face-to-face help. You can start online and finish in person, or book a full-service appointment with a tax pro. In contrast, TurboTax operates entirely online. However, it offers live video help through TurboTax Live.

Donation tracking and valuation tool: H&R Block wins

H&R Block includes a unique tool for valuing donated goods, which helps maximize charitable deductions.
Its DeductionPro lets you calculate fair market value for clothing, appliances, and other donated items, which adds accuracy and confidence when itemizing deductions. Meanwhile, TurboTax’s ItsDeductible tool supports charitable deduction analysis, but users find H&R Block’s DeductionPro to be easier to use.

Multiple refund disbursement options: Tie

Both offer secure refund options and a wide range of refund delivery choices, making this H&R Block vs TurboTax comparison for refund disbursement options a tie. Each supports direct deposit, mailed check, and refund loaded onto a prepaid debit card. You can also apply your refund to next year’s taxes or use it to pay prep fees.

Amendment support and ease: H&R Block wins

Correcting a return is easier and cheaper with H&R Block. In paid plans, it allows free online amendments for three years through the user dashboard. Additionally, the process is clearly guided and does not require purchasing a separate product. While TurboTax also supports amendments, the process can be more complex. For desktop versions, you may need to download the original software and manually install updates.

Guided tax law updates: TurboTax wins

TurboTax does a better job of walking you through changes to tax law. It provides real-time updates and context-sensitive guidance, especially during periods of legislative change. These updates are built into the platform’s Q&A style flow. H&R Block offers updated content, too, but the guidance feels more static. You may need to refer to its help center instead of seeing changes integrated into the workflow.

Use cases

Choose TurboTax if you

• Receive income from multiple states and want help managing multi-state filings
• Sold cryptocurrency or other digital assets and need guided support for accurate reporting
• Experienced major life changes (like marriage, a new home, or having a child) and want personalized prompts for tax-saving opportunities
• Freelance or own a side business and need clear organization for self-employment income and expenses
• Seek the smooth import of previous years’ returns and of tax documents from financial institutions

Choose H&R Block if you

• Prefer the option of in-person support at a local office in addition to online filing tools
• Want a robust free version covering more tax situations than competitors, including student loan interest and retirement income.
• Seek one-on-one expert review without mandatory upgrades to higher-priced plans like TurboTax Live
• Prefer to store and access past returns for free, with less pressure to pay for add-ons or subscriptions
• Are switching from another provider and wanting seamless import of prior-year data from TurboTax or other platforms

More about Accounting

• What Is Accounting? Definition, Types, Importance and Examples
• Best Accounting Software and Services
• Verito vs. Rightworks: Which IT Provider Is Best for Your Firm?
• Top Free Accounting Software
• Accounting Glossary

My methodology

When comparing TurboTax vs H&R Block, I evaluated not only the technical performance of each platform but also the alignment of each with the needs of today’s tax filers — from simple W-2 employees to gig workers and investors. The ultimate objective was to determine which software offers the best overall experience.

My assessment was based on the following factors:

• Pricing transparency: I assessed how clearly each platform presents pricing, upgrade prompts, and data usage policies. This included examining whether users are pressured to upgrade or given clear explanations for recommendations.
• Initial setup experience: I compared how they handle the initial setup, including importing prior year returns, linking to employer or financial institutions, and verifying identity.
• Personalization and adaptability: I evaluated how well each tool tailors the experience to different user profiles. This included the ability to adjust questions and guidance based on whether the user is a student, homeowner, freelancer, retiree, etc.
• Time-saving automation: I reviewed the platforms’ features that help reduce manual input, such as auto-import of W-2s, 1099s, and previous return data. I looked into whether or not these features are widely accessible or restricted to higher-priced plans.
• Data accuracy and error prevention: I measured how they ensure accurate data entry and filing. This included the effectiveness of real-time error checking, flagging missing information, and offering explanations to avoid common mistakes.
• Audit preparedness: I compared how each solution prepares users for the possibility of an IRS audit. This included the availability of year-round support, audit representation, document storage, and step-by-step guidance in case of inquiries.
• Post-filing tools and updates: Finally, I assessed how the platforms support users after submission by tracking refunds, amending returns, responding to IRS notices, or planning for the next tax year.

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)

How do the platforms handle late or amended returns?

Both allow you to file late tax returns for up to three prior years using their software. Any late returns must typically be printed and mailed, and TurboTax will guide you through that process.

For amended returns, TurboTax provides step-by-step support to correct mistakes from previously filed returns, usually after the IRS has accepted the original. It even helps estimate any penalties or interest owed due to late filing or payment. H&R Block also offers guided help to correct errors on previously filed returns, including changes to income, deductions, or credits. It even helps you understand any penalties or interest you may owe.

Which platform is better for tracking changes in tax law?

TurboTax tends to be faster at integrating new federal tax laws into its interview and guidance flows, thanks to Intuit’s real-time update infrastructure. However, H&R Block shines when it comes to state-specific incentives, especially if you’re filing in a state with complex local benefits. Its in-person network also helps ensure up-to-date knowledge through local tax pros familiar with regional rules.

Which platform is better for reporting nontraditional income like gambling winnings or hobby income?

Both platforms support reporting these types of income, but H&R Block’s guided interview tends to make it easier for non-experts to distinguish between hobby income, side gigs, and gambling winnings. TurboTax supports these, too, but you may need to dig a bit deeper into form selection or pay for a higher-tier plan to get full support.