Discussion Locked

AMD Athlon or Intel P4?

0 helpful
50 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
If you have to choose between AMD Athlon (1.3 Ghz) and Intel Pentium 4 (1.3 Ghz), what factors do you consider to make a right choice?

50 replies

by shuja52

Justify yourself first that for what purpose you are buying... Intel IV is much widely supported by software and other hardware vendors..

by tech07

Due the test a have made of this 2 CPU's, i think Athlon still works better than intel's P. Rather than - Athlon at 1000Mhz works better than P III at 1000Mhz. I test them by 2 ways - ones at Novell server with 250 users online and than on Windows mashine used for grabbing a DV file. And the 2 times Athlon gave me better results with approximately 20% than P III. Morethan - Athlon is cheaper and gives more productivity on less price. More from that i have read - PIV uses Ram, which is 3 timens expensive than the standart SDram and even with this ram, PIV didn't works better. More - at the tests PIV art 1,7GHz works worst than athlon at 1,3 GHz. Whats the idea?
Buy an Athlon :)

regards

by chc

I am so disappoint with PIV's performance. the 1.7 G Pentium IV is slower than my 1.33 G
Athlon. I hope I read your comments before I brought them. No more Pentium IV, we are going to switch the upgrade plan to Athlon instead.

by greg abrahamsen

The AMD is a great chip. and it's alot less expensive than a p4. But dont forget to add in the cost of the RDRAM that runs at 400Mhz. That stuff is really expensive!

by shanghai sam

Like most things we buy throughout our lifetimes, you ultimate choice in which CPU is right for you depends on your application.

The fact of the matter is both CPUs have advantages and weaknesses.

The PIV for example has excellent floating point capabilities but yet its raw processing speed is lacking; particularly for its pricing structure.

Conclusion: For special application purposes that demand fast mathemathical computations like CAD (actually I wouldn't use neither Intel or AMD for a "true" cad station), or if you work for a large company that has VERY complex, math intensive spreadsheets or accounting packages - then I'd pick Intel's chip over AMD in a heartbeat.

However, let's look at the AMD:

The Athlon is cheaper and on a baseline average in raw processing speed of non specialized FPU applications - it just dogs the Intel IV at a significantly lower price/performance cost. So if you are looking for pure value for your dollar - AMD is the clear leader. The downside, as you could guess by now, is what I call the "Scurge of Intel"....AMD seemingly impossible challenge of beating the pants out of Intel's notoriously better FPU performance. This is the one thing I can't believe, when will AMD beat Intel hands down on FPU performance?

Anyway there's my 2 cents.

-Tom

by shanghai sam

For those who have been following Intel for the past few years know the quality is just not there. Intel was also arrogant enough to believe it's own lies about speed and reliability and has publically admitted it twice. AMD is cheaper to buy and more robust with a track record to back that up with. Intel cannot claim the same. This is not an opinion, but fact. Before AMD was making processors, it has been making in-spec board componants for many years and had a sterling reputation for quality.Make mine AMD!

by techwolf

I've noticed some Abit Mainboards don't handle AMD processors aswell as other brands. Personally I prefer FIC over the other brands. You may find another to fit your needs. I have had alot of success with FIC. By the way I am pro AMD.

by soponbkk

First trying AMD, I stop paying more for any Intel P series product. At lower prices but higher & faster CPU is the heaven for computer users. Don't stick to the Brand. I sold all Pentium Products in my house (3) and bought AMD instead. My son enjoys games faster and I can do all of my works much much faster & stable than any old Pentium.

by key_consulting

Although ABIT mainboards may not handle the AMD Processors very well consider the ASUS solution. Now for future considerations, since not everyone is going to jump into the DDR revolution, ASUS just came out with a AMD mainboard that will support both DDR and P133 RAM! Definitely AMD gets my vote. AMD has the advantage as they understand that the average user wants value, performance AND functionality. Too bad Intel does not understand this concept.

by daiquiria2

I've had P3 and P4 for several years and recently upgraded one of my systems to AMD. I've had more unsurpassed reliability from my AMD processor than I've EVER had with Intel! My money's definitely on AMD. By the way, ASUS fully supports AMD, allversions. Just know what you want and do your research (this is just the beginning!). Then go AMD!

by kerryrankin

I recently manufactored 1 gig and under Athlon processors. the 700meg and under draws 46 DC amps total.the 750meg and up Half as much cause L1 and L2 cache was intergrate inside cpu.drawing less total Ampere.the 250wat power supplies crowbared constintly..had to unplugged pwr cable from supply to bleed off.the 900meg and above got so hot they actually melted the plastics packaging case!!!!!using an Alumiumn heatsink on 800 an above.intel p4 don't know about pwr drainage on pwr supply.

by mayuresh

I don't like one thing about the way intel makes it's products. as they have almost near monopoly of the market, they try and control the whole market that is unacceptable. Today if you go and buy yourself a p3 500mhz, u cannot even upgrade it to another highend p3 without having to buy almost the whole of the damm cpu again. forget upgrading to anything more. i'm sure this is going to be the case with p4 as well. as far as upgraation is concerned, intel has to be the worst in the business. they make the people buy new stuff, by exploiting their monopoly, and uneducated (wrt IT) buyers as they can only see intel as a choice considering their fat advertising budget. also the kind of raw power any Intel product gives is nothing to rave about. they take out stupid ad campaings claiming the new p3 chip can enhance your internet experience. my foot it will.
Intel needs to get it's act together, if they have to survive in the long run. a company like amd which is true to the customers is bound to create more than a ripple in the intel pond.

regards
mayuersh

by shanghai sam

Accourding to my experiments and lots of benchmarks with both processors, I can tell that AMD Athlon can be your best solution if you considered the following:
1 - Don't use a power supply with an output less than 300 watts.
2 - Make sure that thecomputer is well cooled. Install additional fans.
3 - Don't use any legacy adapter that is designed specifically for Intel Chipset.

by shanghai sam

Just a cheap shot at geeks, because they show me time and time again they cannot spell! Ask any gamer which processor they would buy and the answer is always AMD. Overclock an AMD and you are sure to be safe. Overclock a Pentium and look for smoke.Why would any dumbass use anything less than a 300 watt power supply? If I remember correctly the P4 uses a 325 watt power supply! I run my system all day and all processors get hot. If my AMD runs hotter then an Intel P4, it would only mean that it is actually processing something! AMD is knocking and it's coming in Intel! Listen how quiet AMD is compared to Intel. AMD is growing not by spending 100's of millions of dollars on commercials, but by word of mouth and that scares Intel and it should.

Steve K.

by ghlbeyerlein

When I finally decided to upgrade, I chose a 750 MHz AMD Duron. Cost was one of the biggest factors in the decision - Even the AMD Athlon = ~$100 less than Intel P3 equivalent. From what I've heard/read, the P4 is nice, but save yourself the extracash and get a 1.3+ GHz Athlon.

AMD may not conquer Intel anytime soon, but they do make solid processor lines, IMO. I would, and do, recommend Duron and Athlons to anyone shopping for a new computer.

by bugzapper

Don't be too hard on us geeks. Some of us can spell extremely well. However, some of the 'geeks' on this site are trying to communicate in English, which is not their first language. Go on an Indian or Japanese web site and see how well you can do crafting a response. Maybe you will have a little sympathy for those who are struggling here.

Back on the original subject, I would choose the Athlon over the P4 in a heartbeat.

by johndumont

To complain about spelling and then improperly substitute the word "then" when you mean "than" - well, shame on you. Folks, we are finally blessed with true competition, mostly enabled by Intel's greed but also by AMD's ability to finally get it right. Enjoy it while it lasts.

by andy

On performance the Athlon wins hands down if they're both 1.3, regardless of the mainboard (as long as you buy a good brand). The comparison may be tighter once more software comes out that uses the P4's extended instruction set.
Watch out, as other factors (RAM/HDD/etc.) can make a big difference.
Remember that P4 based PCs are more expensive generally, RamBus being the main factor - although check again when Intel's SDRAM P4 chipset comes out.

by shanghai sam

After reading all the reviews on the P-4 this is what I have to say: PURE CRAP! Sure the CPU has great 3D performance. In fact, it posted record numbers on 3D crunching tests, but toss it an Office app it runs like a mid-range P-3! It seems thatthe CPU has a long 20 step internal databus. The anthology the article gave was like an auto assembly line- the more people (processing steps) there are to work on a car (an intruction) the faster it was. The Athlon has a 10 step databus and the P-3 has a 13 step bus. BUT the downside is if you change the instruction while it was working on the one it thought you wanted, it has to flush the whole bus and then reload. In the assembly line athology- it takes a long time to teach 20 people to do a new task. While with the Athlon and P-3 CPUs, they can switch to new tasks much faster.
Out of all of this, the P-4 will be good a games and poor at apps that have multiple paths to do stuff (branch prediction). The Athlon can play games justa well and allows you to write up a Word doc a lighting speed. Which would you choose?

by craig shepherd

That manufacturing line analogy is a good one.

Basically when designing a CPU the manufacturers have to consider the trade off between 'bandwidth' and 'latency'.

Bandwidth is how much data it can push through and Latency is how fast it can change tasks.

Intel has gone for huge bandwidth, which is only good for media applications where there is only 1 or 2 tasks at a time, but for everything else it works like a snail because it has to clear so much out of it's buffers.

AMD has gone for a much more practical approach and gone with very fast latency with a lower bandwidth. This means for everything else AMD will beat the living daylights out of any P4.

Anyway, besides all that AMD is so much more a consumers company. They are much better value for performance.

AMD all the way

by admin

This chip will easily run above (Some well above) 1.5

The athlon axia is THE chip right now :)

by admin

4-Connect L1 trace cuts and jumper up to 30% higher mHz.
5-Connect L4 trace cuts and jumper voltage at a higher level if you have Duron.

Enjoy the stable high speeds of tomorrow, today. (Or get todays speeds much cheaper) Power supply is VERY important here though, as are the custom cooling (Mines still air, if you are wondering.)

Not into overclocking- get this, some of my boxes at work that need to be EXTREMELY stable are underclocked. And this works too, the point being that if you can get 30% overclock out of a chip and remain stable, that's a high quality chip that will keep you running much better much longer at normal speeds too. It definately is worth considering in your critical purchase decisions.

by mayuresh

i will be upgrading my comp in the near future. At the moment i have a Celeron 366. How is the performance of say the AMD 1.3 considering, my brother will be using it to play all the 3d intensive games, and i'll be needing it for a lot of heavy pixel pushing.

regards
mayuresh

by admin

You can never, of course, have too much power for gaming, but a 1.3 with a good geforce2 or above is definately good to play on right now. Your graphics card, then memory and motherboard (and power supply and cooling etc. etc.)figure into a good gaming machine too. It's not just the processor.

by shanghai sam

Check out: http://www.tomshardware.com

While I cannot say I stand on either side of the line of AMD vs. Intel, I do research the CPU's available and keep a few things in mind while doing so.

First of all, the decision has become more and more difficult as time progresses. With the advent of the Athlon, Intel no longer has a strong hold on high performance CPU's. Intel CPU's are still more stable than AMD's however.

I've always believed that AMD is best for home computing and gamingdue to it's lower cost and high performance. The Intel is a better choice for business use with it's greater reliability; in general, users don't need 800+mhz CPU's (or even 300+mhz) to run Word and Excel anyway.

As for the Pentium 4, you might say it's before it's time. Due to it's 64bit architecture and lack of L1 cache, the Pentium 4 performs considerably slower than the PIII and Athlon (Remember the 32bit Pentium Pro that choked on 16bit code?). With expensive RDRAM, and 're-written' code that is optimized for the Pentium 4, the P4 will scream. Otherwise, at this point, you would be paying 'must have it first' prices for the performance of far less expensive PIII's and Athlons.

Don't forget about the motherboard. You also have another difficult decision that is just as or more important. CPU performance is more dependent on motherboards than ever. With the same chipset in use, performance differences between the top motherboard makers is generally negligible. But, ifyou cut corners here, you could see stability issues and performance loss. I'm certain that one reason Intel is more stable is due to their well developed chipsets.

I don't believe you can go wrong either way on the AMD vs. Intel issue. I thinkAMD is a better company, and support them in their efforts to attain a greater market share. But, again, I still believe Intel is a better choice for business use... for now.

by admin

One thing I have noticed at work. Linux seems to run faster on Intel, at least Caldera's distro -which I run as Server OS at several locations.

For the money and performance though, my personal home gaming, multimedia and music recording machinesare all AMD.

by judymartinez

AMD has superior cooling tech - they use liquid nitrogen to cool the processor?

AMD's DDR Synchronous DRAM is superior to P4's Rambus DRAM ?

by admin

To cool any processor. Condensation issues develop though- so it's mainly experimental although there are some commercial vendors.

There are many ways to cool, air is just the cheapest for the most part. AMD does not require special cooling otherthan an appropriate fan -same as pentium.
At any rate, it is not an AMD issue.

As far as DDR vs. Rambus, it's somewhat apples and oranges, IMHO. Obviously, If you go AMD go DDR.
Here's some info on the historical Rambus issue that doesn't justbash it.

http://www.anandtech.com/showdoc.html?i=1239

by dimorphic2006

AMD processors tend to run warmer then Intel processors. Processors have no way of cooling themselves, that's why people use heatsinks & fans.

by admin

Processors and cooling systems are 2 seperate things. Even if a fan is attached by a manufacturer on an oem, it is only one part of a "hopefully" integrated system that includes case design etc.
AMD and Intel don't do it all.

by shuja52

AMD Athlon is not comparable with Pentium IV.. Check out newer versions of AMD Processor..
AMD Athlon is of 1999 generation and Pentium IV is of 2000 generation

by pallan

Athlon is the official market name for AMD's current top-line processor. The current core is often refererred to as Thunderbird, which was it's code name while in development. Palomino is the next generation AMD chip and will be released shortly, most likely badged as an Athlon.

by shuja52

No the PENTIUM III, AMD K6, AMD Athlon and Coppermine were in market during 1999, and Pentium4, AMD Thunderbird and AMD Duron are the products of 2000

by dimorphic2006

The 1.3 GHz Athlon is a much better chip then the 1.3 GHz Pentium 4. AMD has done a wonderful job on the Athlon series of chips. AMD chips are usually much faster then Intel chips. In benchmark tests, the 1.3 MHz Athons have crushed 1.3 & 1.5 MHzIntels! Now you tell me, what chip would you rather have?

by mnc19

The AMD Athlon is the only processor that has the FSB of 200Mhz or 266Mhz. whereas the Intel does not support has such. So only AMD can be much better than any other Processors.
I have worked with both AMD and Intel Comparing both I personally found that AMD's performance is much higher.

by mnc19

The AMD Athlon is the only processor that has the FSB of 200Mhz or 266Mhz. whereas the Intel does not support has such. So only AMD can be much better than any other Processors.
I have worked with both AMD and Intel Comparing both I personally found that AMD's performance is much higher.

by kloran-[thrawn34

Get AMD, its cheaper, faster, and its just better overall. Think about it, if Intel had put the money the spent on PIII and PIV tv commercials on chip development, they MIGHT have made something better than AMD, but its not likely. Intel just wants to cover all of the market, and isnt really too concerened about how good their chips actually are. So, go AMD, even if you have the cash to get P4.

by dimorphic2006

You stated that Abit motherboards have a problem handling AMD processors but I care to differ on that one. Abit has some of the best boards for AMD processors. The KT7 & KT7A series are absolutly the best boards to use w/ AMD processors.

by shanghai sam

Which was "what factors to consider when deciding between CPUs".

My basic answer, reflecting l33t's, is that it's not so much the CPU, but the SYSTEM. That's everything that goes into the computer, including the Mobo, PSU, CPU, RAM, case design, cooling, and so on.

In the corporate environment do we select Intel or AMD? Actually, neither. Most of us purchase based on: can THAT system do THIS job? We develop parameters that define "THIS job", including possibly O/S and other software requirements. And, yes, we typically end up with "Intel inside" but Intel/AMD is rarely ever part of the specs.

Having said that, when I build a system for a small client, a self-employed home office, a home user, a gamer, etc., we almost always want to pack in the greatest value. So one area we can do that is certainly choosing AMD over Intel. Additionally, since we are not lookign at "systems" (as in the corporate world) but at "components", then it is my impression/experience that the AMD just performs better then the Intel of equivalent specs (MHz, L1 and L2 cache, etc.).

How mush do we save? Around 33%-50%, of the CPU cost. But for the whole PC, that maybe only works out to 10%-15%. This of course because all of the other components are not cheaper based on the CPU cost.

(and that concludes my $0.02 Canadian = $0.016 U.S.)

by dolson

Can someone please help me find info on what the market shares are for the PIV and The Athlon??
I am looking for something that will tell me if Athlon has 46% of the market and PIV has 54% or whichever.
Thank you

by tkimbrell

I think AMD will have a tremendous gamer following due to the ample performace and economic pricing, along with average end users. However, in business environments, how many "real" network, or app servers have you seen with the AMD sticker on it.

by jmstitt

I have 2 new AMD machines running Windows 2000 Server. My other 8 servers are all Intel-based machines running Windows 2000 as well. The performance from my Web server (1.2 GHz Athlon) and my application server (650 MHz Athlon) are incredible. These machines make my Intel-based servers look very weak. I will be replacing those other 8 machines with AMD-based processors when the time comes. And, at half the cost as well.

by binarypc

Use this wonderful thing called the web here and check out places like http://www.tomshardware.com for current hardware reviews and benchmarks. They will give you the raw numbers there. They even have a "dream machine" they design, (which contains an overclocked Athlon), giving you their guidelines for an awesome machine.

Personally, I am anxiously awaiting AMD's entrance into the SMP market. They have some awesome processors that I can't wait to see on my server quotes. I've even seen reviews on the development of their 64bit processor architecture vs. Intels, and it looks like they are using common sense with their 32bit compatibility, rather than trying to drive the sales of pure 64bit which is what Intel appears to be doing.

The processor race is going to be a lot of fun to watch over the next year. Keep asking the great questions.

by w. legrow

The main factor is performance. AMD definitely out performs Intel almost on a one to one basis, they're cheaper, and more stable. What else do you need to know!
One thing - watch out for dumb ass techs that don't understand how to install heat sync's. I had one that wasn't installed properly and almost toasted the chip. Luckily I found out what the problem was and was able to save the chip.

by nichomach

Thunderbird was the internal AMD codename for the first Socket A (as opposed to Slot A) Athlon. "Coppermine" is just an Intel codename for the 0.18 micron die-shrunk, copper interconnect variant of the Pentium III, although it has been applied to later variants of the Celeron. The current production AMD processors are the Duron and Athlon. The Athlon is currently in manufacture in two flavours, both Socket A, but with different FSB speeds of either 100MHz DDR (effective 200MHz) and 133MHz DDR (effective 266MHz); don't confuse the DDR bit with its application to memory. Current AMD CPUs use a double-pumped front side bus to allow operations on both the rising and falling edges of the clock cycle. It's a bit similar to the situation where Intel had 4 flavours of PIII out at once - they had FCPGA and Slot 1 flavours in both 100 and 133 MHz FSB speeds, but they were all Pentium IIIs.

This discussion is closed to new replies.