Discussion Locked

Assault on US Military Info via Email

0 helpful
22 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

CNET's story on accused terrorist webmaster Syed Talha Ahsan shows that the military needs to always be a step ahead of the terrorists http://news.com.com/U.K.+Webmaster+accused+of+aiding+terrorists/2100-1028_3-6096818.html?tag=cd.lede

Most interesting in the story is that Ahsan was able to e-mail with U.S. Naval personnel and obtained then-classified plans of a naval battle group operating in the Straits of Hormuz. Their correspondence even included the group's vulnerabilities.

The ability to email such sensitive military documents shows the organization's shortcomings - http://www.essentialsecurity.com/Documents/article15.htm

What else has been emailed out from the military to terrorists?

22 replies

by nathank9

It just warms my heart to hear that our military has gotten so close with terrorists. Maybe after this war has ended we can invite Ahsan and his buddies over for a nice White House brunch.

How is it possible that someone so against us and our beliefs receive military secrets and other classified information. I don't think that it is their hacking ability that causes data leaks in the military, maybe its our own stupidity.

by marileev9

The story actually says an "enlistee" provided the information to Ahsan, not any upper level officer, but the average sailor. How can a suborniate have this data at their dispose to email? This is just as aggregious as the military computers coming up for sale in Afghanistan.

by tig2

Incidentally, how's Washington? I miss the place.

Every sailor attached to a ship is routinely in possession of the information described. Sailor knows ship movement, ship movement is confidential information. If the sailor goes home and tells his family that he will be deploying on a certain date, he has just breached security.

It is up to the individual sailor to have both integrity and discretion. Without it, situations like the email to a known terrorist can happen.

It is n't an option to simply quit telling a sailor when the ship will deploy. Those men and women have families. Require that the military be single? OK, but what about paying the bills while gone? Even single sailors have to communicate their timelines and needs to SOMEONE.

The information that was passed was (a) known information regarding ship movement (confidential) and (b) the sailor's opinion of strength and weakness (UCMJ violation). That sailor should be identified and charged accordingly.

by mroonie

Is email not an obvious everyday tool for communcation? Shouldn't it have been one of the first places the gov should've looked when attempting to place regulations on the leaking of private information after 9/11? How come they're not seeing the bigger picture here?

by jmgarvin

I mean there has to be some kind of proposal to go along with this? What should we do with email?

by jdclyde

traitor.

Sure, that word has been thrown around a lot over the last few years, but anyone that gives out national secrets, regardless of if it is to a scumbag terrorist or the NY times, should be treated accordingly.

by marileev9

TiggerTwo, thanks for the good info, but the CNET article hinted that it was more than deployement dates. It stated that the Navy personnel also passed along information on the ship's weaknesses/vulnerabilities.

Washington is warm right now the weather people are saying it'll be 90+ for the next 10 days, no rain. Time to welcome the boats, Seafair is next week too.

by tig2

When I said "ship movement" I know what that means- probably should have told you. My apologies.

Ship movement is information regarding a carrier group- the carrier itself and all ships attached to that carrier. It can include the movement of frigates, destroyers, tenders, etc. It can also include the movement of the air wings. This is all classified information that is communicated outside of the Navy on a routine basis. Has to be so that the sailor can plan appropriately.

As regards weakness/vulnerability- the sailor may have some actual data, but rarely enough to be of interest. "Need to know" insures this to an extent, advanced engineering and other things may also apply. I will make a money bet though that the sailor took information that he KNEW and added his own opinions and potentially rumours. That is a violation of the UCMJ.

To my direct knowledge, it would take a strategic nuclear device to take out a carrier. Those things are pretty tough. And tough to get to.

What worries me more is that this sailor made a decision to violate a code he swore to uphold. That is sickening- even more so because he certainly wasn't communicating his sea time to a family member, he was communicating to an unknown individual.

Would love to be in Seattle right now. I have a buddy in Bremerton that is probably hating the forecast- he does NOT like the heat! I miss Seafair- always a good time!

by marileev9

Wow, I never knew that "ship movement" was so detailed. But you make an excellent point that this sailor passing information to Ahsan was in violation of naval codes he swore to uphold.

I wonder how Admiral Mullen in charge of Naval Ops is handling other potential security breaches.

Even the hearsay the sailor passed along to Ahsan could have given the enemy the edge.

Yeah, Seafair is great. The Bite of Seattle is this weekend - gastronomy galore & our company's sponsorinig a bunch of us to run in the annual Torchlight Run before the big parade.

by longwayoff

What makes everyone think this poor Navy soul did this out of malice? Do you all think Naval types are immune to phishing? The bad guy could easily have used an official-looking email address to ask his questions - it's not hard to sound like a pompous government type. Agreed, the Navy guy should NOT have spilled the beans, but sailors are human, and not all of them are computer techies who recognize scams right off the bat. As for "vulnerabilities to terrorist attack" - read Jane's Fighting Ships, or Combat Fleets of the World - tells you right there. About as classified as the price of eggs. IF the Navy guy actually passed along classified info, sure, hang him - but find out if that's the case first. News reports are not always the most reliable of sources. Ship movements are normally not classified more than 30 or 60 days anyway, because at that point it's fairly moot anyway - especially in the Gulf, an aircraft carrier battle group is a fairly visible object on all those nice free unclassified satellite photos you can get from the Internet.

by tig2

This guy did more than send an email- he was having a dialouge with the terroist.

Navy personnel are told very specifically what they may and may not discuss and with whom. My direct knowledge only goes to 2002 but at that time, the Navy did not communicate with sailors via email and said as much.

This is not to say that I have any feelings about whether or not this guy is hung. Frankly, I think that the Navy should do the right thing, investigate carefully, and proceed.

If it does turn out that this situation was the result of phishing, the Navy will need to re-educate sailors about phishing, what they mustn't respond to, what the content of the response may or may not be.

While I know that Jane's puts the detail in black and white, the reason that a sailor is prohibited from divulging the detail of a ship is that each ship has HUMAN strengths and weaknesses. I have also heard sailors talk about a department that is scoring lower than they should on certain readiness tests. This information MUST remain in the military community. Speaking to it does indeed communicate unknown information.

During conflict, ship's movement is considered to be confidential for the entire period of movement.

Things may occur during deployment that are given press space. Due to the nature of Navy movement, generally what the press knows is what the Navy told them. The Navy would like to keep it this way.

When I was a Navy wife, it took from 6 weeks to 2 months to exchange letters. We numbered our letters for this reason. With Internet availability, the Navy has been able to speed this communication. If a breach like this occurs again, I fully anticipate that the Navy will no longer make electronic communication available to it's force.

by hal 9000

Couldn't this have all been a ruse to drag someone wanted out of hiding?

Personally I'm not overly interested in Media Reports as they generally never get things like this correct.

The Military is very good at providing [b]Disinformation[/b] when they want to and it's entirely possible that by using something like this they could have caught or killed a very real threat to Security at little or no expense to themselves personally. The best form of Disinformation is based on truth tell someone where you are what the size of your escort ships are and then through in the Disinformation about venerabilities or weaknesses that would allow a perceived successful attack on the Air Craft Carrier. Naturally if the bait was taken the perpetrators would have been rounded up and questioned very quickly.

The only real way to take out a Carrier Group is with a Sub Orbital Fission Weapon that comes straight down very close to the centre of the carrier group with little to no warning and no defence against. It it where to detonate at about 4,000 feet the entire fleet would just disappear.

At this point in time I don't know of any possibly method available to Non state Sponsored Terrorists to achieve this. At the worst case it would have been a suicide mission for those involved in the attack and the worst thing possible from the Navies prospective is that they would have had a chance to kill themselves before bing caught so the Navy would have missed out on gathering some information but no matter what it would have been no threat the the Ships involved.

Col

by mjwx

Whist the only effective way to take out a carrier with a missile weapon is to, 1. Hit the magazine with an armour penetrating round on a ballistic trajectory (would be a 1 in 1 million chance of making the shot) and successfully detonate the round in the magazine 2. Use a fission device delivered on a ballistic trajectory (and I only have three left, I'm not going to waste one trying to prove my point).

A carrier?s real weakness lies below the waterline. To exploit this weakness you need to start flooding that can either, 1. Not be stopped 2. Flood a key area of the ship.

Three methods I can think of to do this.
1. A suitably powerful concussive force (explosive) that dislodges one of the propeller shafts enough to start flooding in the engine room and prevent watertight doors from closing within the shaft itself. This can be done with a good knowledge of the effects of explosives under water. If this is successful in flooding the engine room in enemy territory or under significant fire you may as well write off the carrier. High degree of difficulty though.

2. A remote detonated sea-minefield. If you know the course of a carrier group you can set one up in advance and lie in wait. This is of course dependent on first, the minefield not being detected and the carrier running over it.

3. A weapon developed for the Collins class submarine. a torpedo that creates a large bubble of air underwater delivered underneath a large ship creates enormous pressure on the underside of the ship as one part of the ship is lifted is from the water rapidly. This is capable of breaking the spine (the vital support on the very bottom of a ship connecting it from bow stern) of a ship. This weapon was designed to take out large ships such as super freighters and tankers and is less effective on small ships such as frigates and corvettes. Of course it would need to be aimed accurately. This weapon about the only success in the Collins class submarine program.

by tig2

You both have very valid points. The Navy is very good at disinformation and the press is rarely correct. I haven't followed this story closely but recall a few incidents from the 90s during Gulf One.

While I am reasonably certain that it is possible to take out a carrier, you have to do so while being assaulted by the airwing and with smaller ships running interference. It can be done but the question about strategic value comes into play. Intersting brain food, however.

I think the question the original poster was asking is more on the line of "is this a security flaw?". The answer, at least in my opinion, is that the flaw would exist unless all active duty personnel were forbidden to use electronic communication outside of their military job requirements. That won't happen. My response is that if someone is going to violate security, they're going to do so by any means available. To me, it is a question of honour, plain and simple.

by jamesrl

Well I will make an admission. I have played thousands of hours in the 90s on Harpoon. Harpoon is a software "game" which allows you to command a carrier group or the opposing navy/land group. Before you start poo-pooing, it was used at the naval academy. Tom Clancy used it to test scenarios for some of his noevls as well. Its not a graphics intensive shootem up, it more of a strategy game, think naval chess.

The reason its used at the naval academy is that it is very realistic at modelling things like weapons capabilities, radars etc.

On the open ocean with a full task force properly set up, it is very difficult to take on a carrier. The only hope is to either sneak a sub in, or to overwhelm the air defences. Between the radar on the Hawkeye, the ships radars and the fact that the carrier is screened by other ships, its a tough nut to crack.

One of the only scenarios, one that Dale Brown used in a novel, is to have the air wing occupied striking another target, and co-oridinating an attack by something like a Backfire. It can carry a kh22 Kitchen which runs at Mach 4 for 270 miles. The task force can realistically shoot these down, but if they get a flood of them, it might be possible to overwhelm the missles defences of the task force. In other words, if all of Russia's Backfires attacked one task force at once, managed suprise and managed to catch most of the fighters in the air wing off on another task, it might be possible. Lining up the logistics of this is an entire manner that makes this theoretical than practical.

The closer you are to land, the more vulnerable the carrier is. Both from subs and aircraft. Shallow water is not the US navy's domain, and a diesel sub, running on battery only, in shallow water, is quieter than a nuclear sub, which has to run coolant pumps all the time. The diesel though, has to be at the right place at the right time. Again, a fighter carrying a nuke flying below radar, would still have to get through the screen to get to the carrier, and it would take more than a little skill and a lot of luck. A plane is a bigger slower target than Kitchen.

One of the biggest aspects of the security of the carrier task group is its speed. If naval personell leak the location and the route, its suddenly more vulnerable. If you are planning a strike on a carrier, where it is going to be is crucial.

James

by marileev9

TiggerTwo, Thanks for bring it back. You've brought a lot of first hand experience to the topic. Email is a convenience and way for our enlisted men & women to stay in touch.

I hope that your prediction that "the Navy will no longer make electronic communication available to it's force," doesn't come true. After more details to this Ahsan case are revealed, I think it will show that this case was more than just phishing.

by jamesrl

At my former employer, the one with nuclear secrets, the rules were simple. If you were sending anything that might be "secret", it had to be encrypted, and the government agency we dealt with also had encryption and was cross certified. If you failed to encrypt something when you should have, you are gone. No appeals. Part of the job was to be security conscious and they had annual events to promote information security awareness.

Anything Top Secret was very well locked down.

There were intrusion detection systems to deter hackers, and any emails with attachments were logged and tracked.

We did once have our extermal website, which was outsourced, hacked and vandalized. After that it was moved to a DMZ and had firewalls and Intrusion detection turned on.

James

by mjwx

It would be quiet easy to take out a fleet carrier but getting to the carrier is another story all together.

Stealth would be by far easier than assaulting a carrier group with any kind of weapon conventional or otherwise, but this requires that you know where a group is and when which relates to the original topic of discussion as the passing of route information and schedules allows an attacker to plan such an assault.

Never played "harpoon", but I did have a copy of Jane's fleet command back in the late 90's. I can?t find it now to save my life.

by hal 9000

But the only realistic and sure way to take out a carrier group is with a Ballistic Missile and since non of these are of the conventional type it would have to be a fission Warhead and that would simply make the entire Carrier Group disappear.

When it comes to shallow waters different escort ships are used so a few mine sweepers are thrown into the mix as well for operations in these areas and then the escort ships carry a vast array of surveillance measures so any battery powered Sub would have to be absolutely quite to avoid detection. This is possible in a Trained Navy but unlikely with a rabble of terrorists and even then it's debatable if the sub could slip through or be sailed over as there are Displacement Detectors on the Escort Ships which would pick it up as something that shouldn't be there.

Either a Sub or a minefield are possible but highly unlikely to be successful particularly if the ships are sailing in a State of War at full defence ability deployed. Currently other than a ballistic Missile coming in from a Suborbital trajectory everything is deflatable but one ICBM with just one warhead would do the job quite nicely and this wouldn't even rely on leaked information as these groups are traceable by the enemy.

Just how many carriers have been lost at sea while on duty? I would guess none but I could be mistaken. I don't think that even one was hit when Pear happened as they where all at sea at the time if I remember correctly weren't they?

Col

by jamesrl

Its tough for subs.....

The fast subs are nuclear, and since carriers are quite speedy, you need a nuke sub if you are going to stalk a carrier. But as I suggested, nucs are not quiet since they have to have coolant pumps working all the time.

The diesel subs are super quiet when the diesels aren't running. But they aren't fast.

The only hope is for a diesel to sit and wait, and hope to ambush a carrier. This has happened in exercises. Rumours are that even the old Canadian subs got a lucky shot in, but again - shallow waters(harder to detect) and a fairly easy to guess route kinda gave them an edge. In open ocean, it would be like winning the lottery.

Yes an ICBM would do it, or even a nuclear Kitchen. You might have to expend 50 Kitchens which would be 50 Backfires to get a hit, but with nukes, one would be enough. Of course, one would expect that satellites would pick up a formation that big. From Harpoon math, a Tomcat or F18, carrying 4 AMRAAMs, is likely going to have a 50% kill ratio on a kitchen (the kitchen is very fast but not manouverable). So 24 planes could take out 48 missles - and a carrier group with enough notice could get 24 in the air if they were dealing with one threat. The Aegis cruiser can handle any leakers.

The Aegis is being worked up to intercept ICBMs by the way - note one was sent to Japan recently to help bolster their confidence after the Korean missle tests. But its a little early to be confident.

edited to add - to the original point - the relevance to the larger discussion is this - with the knowledge of exactly where the carrier is going to be and when, it becomes much more vulnerable than if you have to find it by plane, ship or sub, all of which give away the fact that you are looking.

James

by mjwx

Most lost to German and Japanese submarines.

Only 2 fleet carriers have been damaged since then that I know of and none sunk. The first was the USS forestall which had it's flight deck damaged by a malfunctioning missile whist on tour in Vietnam and the HMAS Melbourne which ploughed into the HMAS Voyager. Ironically both friendly fire incidents.

Then again we haven?t had a total war like WWII since the fleet carriers (Nimitz class) inception.

James, my point was only to demonstrate how it could be done and like you said it is quiet unlikely that a rabble of terrorists could pull this off on a carrier group at sea. But it does make me think about a trained regular force like North Korea? But I think it is far more likely that they will launch a large mass of missiles at it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.