Discussion Locked

ATI All-In-Wonder video card locking up

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have a ATI All-in-Wonder X600 Pro video card. Am using ATI's Multimedia Center 9.08. Windows XP, Service Pack 2. Multimedia Center (MMC) locks up in TV Mode after several hours of operation. Not sure how long. To test it, I let it run over night. In the morning, MMC is locked up. Unable to kill the task via Task Manager. Have to reboot PC. Motherboard is Asus A8V-E Deluxe. It is a new PC. I installed newest software and drivers from ATI website. Did not fix problem.

24 replies

by willcomp

AIW have good cooling flow? Any PCI cards in adjoining slots? Good intake and exhaust in case?

If you haven't guessed by now, trying to eliminate overheating of GPU or video memory as cause.

In many cases, a slot cooler next to video card can work wonders (pun intended).

Dalton

by m_a_r_k

Darn it, I attached my comment to my original message instead of your answer, Dalton. Let's try again. It's a PCI-Express card. Only have one option for which slot to install it in (which means I have no options). There are no other cards installed on motherboard. All peripherals (network, USB, audio, etc) are resident on MB. Since the card only experiences problems when in TV mode, I am going to guess that there is no cooling problem. I'll check the card's CPU fan this evening when I get home.

by m_a_r_k

It's a PCI-Express card. Only have one option for which slot to install it in (which means I have no options). There are no other cards installed on motherboard. All peripherals (network, USB, audio, etc) are resident on MB. Since the card only experiences problems when in TV mode, I am going to guess that there is no cooling problem. I'll check the card's CPU fan this evening when I get home.

by willcomp

You were correct to start with. Add comments to your question until you know whether or not answer is correct or you need more info.

Do not assume cooling is OK. Remember that problem uccurs after several hours. Could be heat buildup in case causing problem. As stated previously, a slot cooler next to high end video cards (especially ATI cards) is a good idea. They are cheap and easy to install.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.asp?Submit=Go&DEPA=0&type=&description=slot+cooler&Category=11&minPrice=&maxPrice=&Go.x=12&Go.y=31

Dalton

by m_a_r_k

Only have one slot for the PCI Express card. Ther are no other cards in box. PC is running 24x7. If coolingwere an issue, it would lock up even when not using tv tuner software for card.

by hal 9000

If you uninstall the rest of the ATI Software and only leave the drivers that should cure your problem. The ATI software has been know to cause quite a lot of problems with SP2.

Col

by m_a_r_k

Drivers seeem to be working fine. This card has a TV tuner. I need the rest of the software (Multimedia Center) in order to use the TV tuner. The MMC is what is not working right.

by willcomp

If you know so much, why did you ask for help.

You still can't grasp the fact that video card is working, not idling, when in tuner mode. To have a good comparison, load a good game demo and let it run continulously and see if TV mode is your only problem then.

At least remove side panel from case. That won't cost a cent and may help.

by m_a_r_k

Removed side panel a few days ago. Problem still occurred. Returned card to mfr for exchange. If it's an overheating problem, maybe a new card will not have same problem. If it does, then it's a defective design.

I only have 2 choices for rating answers: unacceptable and acceptable. My rating should be "TBD".

by stultir

Another thing to check is hardware acceleration on your soundcard (I know it's a built in one on the mb) - try repeating your test with a lower degree of hardware acceleration or none at all. Would agree with the previous poster that running a game demo or benchmarking test might help to ascertain better where the problem lies.

by stultir

BTW - That's not a typo above, I've had problems before with h/w accellerated soundcards seemingly conflicting with graphics cards before - the error looks like a graphics problem but is actually caused by the soundcard, never really got to the root of the problem (possible IRQ conflicts) but was able to work around by lowering the degree of hardware acceleration.

by rickrbyrne

This one sounds like a heat issue. Get your self a video cooler. Also what kind of cooling are you using on your system (# Intake # outake Fans ) cause you could lower the temps in your tower which in turn would lower Temps on your Video Card.

Hope I could Help

by m_a_r_k

I don't want to jump through hoops to fix ATI's design problem if it is a heat problem. If it is a design prob, I will get a different card. Using 2 fans. One on top of CPU. And the standard case fan in back of case.

by m_a_r_k

I don't think it's a heat-related problem. If it is, it is a design problem and specific to my card. I exchanged my original for another X600. Same problem. After about 90 mins of TV display, it locked up. Maybe there is some incompatiblity between ATI's hardware or software and the hardware or other software on my PC. If it's incompatible with my PCV h/w, it would only be the ASUS motherbaord b/c the video card is the only card installed in any slots. I disabled all software except ATI's from loading at startup (anti-virus, firewall, etc) and that did not solve problem. I'm giving up on ATI. Am gonna exchange it for one from a different mfr.

by m_a_r_k

Typo error in my previous comment:
I meant to say if it is a heat problem, it is NOT specific to my card.

by willcomp

I still believe your problem is inadequate ventilation. If that's the case, changing brands probably won't help. nVidia cards are just as susceptible.

Best approach is to address root cause, which you have not been willing to do.

I'll reiterate, slot coolers are very effective and cheap.

Dalton

by m_a_r_k

I suppose inadequate ventilation would mean I have a poorly designed case and/or poorly designed motherboard which places the cards in locations that won't allow for air circulation. If the slot cooler is as cheap as you say, maybe I'll give that a shot. I hadn't heard of these things and I was enivisioning all kinds of freon tubes and fans. Slight exaggeration but you get the point.

Does anyone know of a way to rate these answers with something other than "Unacceptable--Didn't help" or "Acceptable"? If I rate as acceptable, then I think it closes the discussion. All of these answers have been helpful, but not enough to fix the poroblem, so therefore they should be rated as total rejects.
:/

by thechas

While I agree with Dalton that heat is the likely suspect, I do have another idea.

As a side note, removing the side panel can actually reduce the effectiveness of your case ventilation.

The slot cooler that Dalton is referring to is a fan that you install in place of a slot cover.
Remove the slot cover nearest the video card and install the slot fan so that it blows fresh air onto the video card.

Anyhow, on to my alternate suggestion.

Perhaps you have a memory leak.
Open and run Performance from Administrative tools.

Watch memory usage with the TV tuner operating.

If memory (or any other resource) usage creeps up as you watch, you have a memory leak.

The source of the memory leak could be an incompatible process, a corrupt file, or just bad code for an application.

You can try shutting down your background processes and see if that helps.

Unfortunately, the only real fix I have found for memory leaks is a clean installation of Windows.

Chas

by m_a_r_k

Hmm I hadn't thought of that. I've had a few memory leaks in software I developed. Nasty problems. I would hope that an established company like ATI would ring out their product well enough to find all memory leaks. But this is the first-to-the-market cutthroat world of the PC business so you can expect anything. Maybe it could be caused by interference from other processes running. This is a good suggestion. But Windows continues to run fine. Only the ATI MultiMedia software that runs the TV display locks up. So the Performance Admin tools probably won't detect a leak on a peripheral device.

by willcomp

As I said before, add comments to your question instead of rating answers. Once an answer is rejected, we cannot add comments to that answer and have to keep adding new ones to answer all your comments.

Poor system, but that's the way it is, at laest for now.

Chas and I are good at following up on our responses, so just keep adding comments to your question and we'll see them. Otherwise we may tire of this.

I gave you a link to a slot cooler early on. Why didn't you at least look?

Dalton

by willcomp

Memory leak Chas was referring to is within Windows itself and likely would not have anything to do with video card.

ATI AIW cards are excellent, but they do require adequate cooling as do all high performance video cards. ATI cannot control installation by home PC builders. Case cooling is both a science and trial and error. Chas believes in positive pressue (more intake than exhaust) while I advocate the opposite. We're both right depending on which air flow test results you reference.

by m_a_r_k

I give up. I tried a slot cooler. Didn't work. Maybe it needs a bucket of ice. If it has a heat problem now when brand new, the problem may get worse with age. Maybe there is some innocuous incompatibilty with some other software that I have installed. I'm ditching this card and replacing with another brand. Thanks for everyone's help.

This discussion is closed to new replies.