Discussion Locked

boot from external HD

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Is it possible to use an external HD as primary boot drive and move it back and forth between two computers? If so How would I do this.

5 replies

by thechas

That depends on a few things:

Do both PCs have the option to boot from USB or external devices?

What operating system are you planning to use?

How similar are the 2 PCs?

For Windows NT, 2000, and XP, the hardware on the PCs needs to be nearly identical or you won't be able to boot up one or the other PC.

Even for Windows 95, 98, and Me, if the hardware is significantly different, the second PC may not boot into Windows.

For any hardware that is different between the 2 PCs, Windows will want to install drivers every time you switch between the 2 PCs.
This can lead to registry bloat and other system file issues that will quickly degrade performance.

For XP in particular, you have the problem of activation. Even if the hardware is identical, the components used to determine the system hardware ID will report different serial numbers and trigger an activation event.

Another issue you would need to address is licensing.
If you read your end user license agreement for Windows (and most other software) you are allowed to install the software on only 1 PC at a time.
You are allowed to remove the retail version of Windows from 1 PC and install it on another PC.

You would find it easier, and fully legal to purchase another copy of Windows and use the external drive as a data storage drive so you can easily share files between the 2 PCs.

Chas

by byteside

Thanks for the info. I thought it would be difficult to acomplish but I have an individule who wanted to carry his external HD from one state to another and gain access to all his stuff without having to update each pc every time he went back and forth.

by poettone

You stated "external hard drive" this would assume a usb drive..

This is not possible as any bios alive today will only boot from
A. HDD
b. CD-Rom
c. Lan/PXE

SCSI drives that are on cards are loaded and specified to load up the os..

You can't do this with a usb drive...

One thing you might consider is a 5 1/2 inch drive sled. This would allow you to remove a ide HDD from the system and take it to the other machine.

You should be able to load the system on one machine then create a hardware profile for your second system.. Although Ihave never done it this way..

Or you could dual boot the drive, having one os for one machine and boot the other os on the second machine..

Again as stated you will need a licensed copy of ecah os on the drive..

good luck.

This discussion is closed to new replies.