Discussion Locked

Consulting Firm Questions Validity of Outsourcing

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A recent document released last week, Deloitte Consulting has come out harshly about Outsourcing and has stated specifically that ?In the real world, outsourcing frequently fails to deliver on its promise.? Furthermore, Deloitte Consulting stated that ?Rising negative sentiment in the media, analysis of a sample of 50 problem deals, and other surveys prove that the tide is turning in the outsourcing market.?

One of the points that are made in the whitepaper is that companies used outsourcing as a cost-saving strategy during the recession, and are still using this now as a way to continually cut costs, however, the study is calling into question the benefits of outsourcing today. ?In today?s economy and labor market, organizations looking for differentiated growth solutions should avoid outsourcing when based solely on cost savings.? Adding to the report; ?An unfavorable mix of rising costs and increased demand will drive up the cost of outsourcing for organizations and vendors.?

The survey shows that 20 percent of outsourcing relationships fail within the first two years and fifty percent within 5 years, according to Dun and Bradstreet.

The report ?Calling a Change in the Outsourcing Market: The realities for the World?s Largest Organizations? Dates April 2005 is available at http://www.deloitte.com/dtt/cda/doc/content/us_outsourcing_callingachange.pdf.

11 replies

by jamesrl

Lets face it. With very few exceptions, unless you are going offshore, outsourcing doesn't stack up as a big money saver. Never did in my analysis, wrong reason to do it. If you want to leverage someone else's expertise in a non-core area of your business because you do it inefficiently, it might make some sense. But you have to balance efficiency and the outsourcers need to make a profit. Between the two, there isn't a large room for savings.

In a lot of the contracts I am aware of, they throw in a sweetner - they will hire your staff at current salary for 2 years. How can they make money if they do that? By hitting you up for extras. You find that if things stay status quo, you can do ok, but if your business is growing, outsourcers will charge exhorbitant fees for upgrade projects you would have done in house with existing staff.

James

by the admiral

I will take it one step further. If you don't plan on growing, then a single contract fits the need perfectly, but if you are growing and you signed the contract, your not going to be able to adjust the contract once it is signed. It is a double edge sword.

One of the complaints that I fished out was that companies grew in areas and were choked off by the outsourcers because they were sticking to the contract and not giving an inch. So if you could have it in house, would you? You would have more flexability than a stamped out contract.

by jamesrl

Because the outsourcer will do whatever is in the contract and not one iota more.

I recall a co-worker who did some teaching ont he side. His college was looking at an outsourcing contract. It looked pretty attractive from a labour rate standpoint. But the devil is in the details. Common practise, based on grow rates, was to update the mail servers every three years. The original contract had the school selling the outsourcer all the hardware. The costs of upgrading servers 2 years down the road, was at least from a labour standpoint, outrageous, and the outsourcer would not be able to committ to a specific cost increase for the hardware.

If I worked in a stable, low growth company, I might look at outsourcing. But if I was in a company that was growing, and I knew that the manner of that growth was unpredictable, I would stay in house. A great deal of project type work gets done in house by operational staff that is not counted in the outsourcers equations.

James

by jessie

In the companies that I've worked for who have outsourced ANYTHING, they've always ended up having to hire on more people after the Vendors have hired away their employees, so that they could get things done in-house that were not covered in the contract.

I've worked for a few companies that outsourced support for "home-grown" applications and ended up BUYING back their employees after the contract term ran out. It's really just NOT cost effective!

by jbaker

I actually worked for an outsourcing company prior to taking this position. Depending upon the management of the company, and what type of relationship the client has with them will really determine what they get out of the contract. IE-if they have a good relationship, they could be getting services that would normally cost them an hourly fee and a service call for free.

There are some situations, though, that a company prefers to not have to take on a permanent employee, or even a conract. We had one law firm that insisted on paying hourly rates for a minimum of two hours per day, five days per week. And when they had issues, it usually ended up being much more than that. Their costs were ridiculous, but they felt compfortable with it, and did not feel comfortable with an employee or contract.

by the admiral

That is one of those cases that they were doing income leveling. They were doing maintenance, then when something catastrophic happened, it was ok to pay the extra.

by the admiral

It has been my experience that they bring it back in house because the code that comes back is crap in the first place.

by jck

when I look for a large price item (car, computer system, etc.), I do take notice of internet articles as to whether or not their support calls are taken overseas.

The call number for Kia America is in California.

The call number for support for my television is in Ohio.

The call number for support for my guitar is in California.

I would have no problem with call support being overseas if it provided me *better* support, but quite often the times I did have call support overseas, I could not understand the tech. It wasn't that I didn't try. It was that the person sounded like they had learned enough English to read a "100 top questions of troubleshooting" list to me. They were always polite, but communication made it to the point where I would often say thank you and hang up and figure it out myself.

The one exception was 3dfx video cards years ago. The guy I got in the Phillipines was totally understandable and knew his stuff. Had me working in about 3 minutes.

I don't care about how much a company makes on support centers...until it affects the level of quality I receive after I've paid them for support on the product.

Like with my Toshiba laptop. I have a 3 year support deal on it. My call support is out of California. If I ever call up and find it's moved to Bangledesh, I won't care unless I can't communicate with the technician. At which time, I will proceed to call their corporate number to discuss the fact that I could not resolve the problem due to a linguistic problem and would like to speak with someone who can communicate effectively enough to help me with my issue.

Otherwise the only thing that bothers me about it...is that the American tax base is being eroded bit by bit with every job they ship overseas.

by jamesrl

Outsourcing can be in the same country - in Canada we have lots of examples of specialised companies taking over IT services. Offshoring is outsourcing to another country.

Companies don't make money on call centres. They make money selling you stuff and a calle centre for support is a cost of doing business. Their reputation may suffer if they do a bad job, and that may cost them future sales, but there are no direct revenues from call centres.

I'm most familiar with outsourcing to firms in the same country.

James

by the admiral

In America, offshoring and outsourcing has become synonymous. It has gotten to the point where Chinese are writing the technical manuals for servers, desktops & laptops, and the information may not be close to actual by any means.

The same for software and applications. We have someone who is a H1B visa who writes code like a spreader spreads dung in a dung heap, and we wind up spending our time un-dunging it.

So it all depends really how much pain you want to go through.

by the admiral

I will take it one step further. The American Tax Base, Skill Base, and Manufacturing Base is eroded piece by piece by outsourcing.

Many of the people who support tech as it is today are moving on to other career fields and not taking a second look at tech. So when the jobs come back, there are no bodies to fill the spots. Same with manufacturing.

So it is a widespread problem that no one wants to take action on, just make money from it before pillaging the next company, manner of speaking.

This discussion is closed to new replies.