Did you have the green light with the original PSU ? If yes, then the power supply is not the problem. Probably it is the systemboard.
----
In either case, calling Dell for advice would be the best option.
My husband took the power supply from an older (working but unused) Dell Desktop computer and tried to replace his power supply with it, but nothing would work with that power supply in his system (non-Dell). He purchased a new PSU and had no problem.
You may need a specific PSU for your computer.
But considering that you get the green light on the systemboard, you probably have a systemboard problem (ie. it's seeing some power).
The 4550 is a newer model; I'd recommend seeking Dell's assistance before doing anything more. Especially if the unit is still under warranty.