Question Locked

DVD

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I recently bought DVDs in South East Asia, and find that while I could play the discs on a living room DVD player but not on my computers.
The Discs are not even recognized in the drives by Windows Explorer.
I would like to know whether this is normal, if not I would return the Discs for a refund, because I bought them mainly for watching on my laptop when away from home.
Also is there a way to solve the issue.
Thanks for any suggestions.

15 replies

by seanferd

Windows is more restrictive with DRM than DVD players, sometimes. Note that when you can change your region, frequently this is limited to a certain number of changes.

by nhiep_nguyen

I know about the region issue. My computers have DVDIdlePro that makes them read DVD without the region restriction.
As said I can read the first two discs without problems.

by ameack

I had similar issue and I ran out by changing Region settings on my XP Machine
Then I installed thid DVD region free and it runs fine.
I dont have to worry about changing Region everytime i get another ZONE DVD.

by oh smeg

Have what are called Region Codes to prevent their use in other parts of the world.

This is supposed to prevent cheap copies bought in Asia from working in other regions where the cost of the Disc is greater.

You can change the Region Code on the DVD Player a limited number of times before the Drive gets locked to 1 region or use something like one of the many Region Free like Utilities the one here

http://www.slysoft.com/en/anydvd.html

Or you can just copy the Disc and remove the Region Codes so that you can play the copy on most DVD Players.

Col

by oh smeg

I have young Nephews who destroy Disc's so I always make a copy and let them wreck the copy. :p

Of course it doesn't do the Player any good at all when they coat the DVD with Peanut Butter and then insert it into the drive. They are not quite that bad but they also never clean their hands before handling DVDs so it's just easier to let them wreck the copies. Not to mention lots cheaper. :D

OH BTW this is my exercise Bike

http://i271.photobucket.com/albums/jj121/HAL9000_photo/DSC00445.jpg

One or two modifications but the one I really like is what they call a Poo-Poo Pipe. Supposed to give another 10% increase in Power. So with all that extra Power I fitted a smaller rear sprocket down to 36 Tooth from 44 so I can go faster. :p

Col

by nhiep_nguyen

I have region free apps on my computers.
The whole question is how to copy the discs since they are not recognized on the computers' drives.

by oh smeg

If they are Gold or a Silver Color the Drive should read them. However some Blue Faces can not be read by some DVD Drives.

But other than Dye Lots not being suitable the most obvious is that the Region Code has been overused and locked the Drive from reading those Region Disc's.

If other Disc's work in that drive and Generally Speaking if a DVD Reader can read a Disc then a Computer should be able to read it unless Disc's are left in the Computers Drive for long periods of time in which case the LED that Generates the Laser Beams to read the Disc loose intensity and you then need to replace the computer drive. Just remember here that CD's and DVD's use a different Color LED to generate the Light so it's perfectly possible that one type of Disc can be read while the other type can not.

But if it's related the the Region Codes that have been locked the only real answer is to reload/Rebuild the system. ;)

Col

by nhiep_nguyen

Thank you for your input.
I just want to say that I have not changed the region code of any of my drives (4 in three computers). My DVDIdle Pro app takes care of that and I have consistently read lot of DVDs from various regions.
The Dye is silver color.
Of the same story that spans on 19 discs, I can read the first two on any of my computers or on the living room DVD Player while from the 3rd on none is recognized on any of the drives while play fine on the DVD Player? Could it be a DVD protection scheme that aims solely the drives and not the players? If yes how this can be done? I mean on which parameters they achieve the feat?
Also the LEDs of the drives are working with all other DVDs.
Thanks.

by oh smeg

It sounds like the Windows DMV is the issue here.

Windows has lots of easy ways to kill off things and one of the things is that they stop some DVDs from being read that work perfectly well on Drives not connected to computers.

It's M$ way of keeping onside with the Copyright Owners. ;)

Col

by nhiep_nguyen

Hello,

My problem is solved by using an external USB Drive.
Good or bad discs are read all the same.
I've double checked it with a friend's computer, its internal drive cannot read the incriminate DVD either.
The reasons why the external drive is better at reading the DVD is unknown to me.
May be the power supply is stronger? the Laser is more powerful? or the reading process is better?

by oh smeg

Many different Models of DVD Drive have limits on what they can read. ;)

Col

by oh smeg

that different Makes & Models of DVD Drives work in different ways.

Quite often the technology is changed between different models in the same Product Line or even different makers can chose how well that they stick tot he DVD Standard. Where a DVD Drive that has more Power in the Laser Beams may read a Disc it is quite possible that a Drive with just the Minimum Power Laser Beams may not read the same DVD Disc.

Then when it comes to recorded Disc's there are lots of differences in the Dye Lots used by different makers of the Blanks. So it's possible that one color Dye may not be readable by a DVD Drive with it's own Color Laser but it is perfectly readable by a different Make or Model DVD Drive with a different color Laser.

Back in the early days of Recordable Cd's many makers would make CD Recorders that could only read the Disc's that they made and not read or record disc's from a different maker. Kodak used to be very well known for that back when we where paying $25.00 per Disc for each & every Blank CD.

Computer Optical Drives tend to be closer to the Standard as laid out by Phillips where as DVD Readers for things like TV's tend to be open to a lot more formats and just be able to read all Disc types. This stops them getting returned as not working for the customers needs, where as Computer Drives are not expected to be as flexible particularly if they are Burners. Also Computer Optical Drives can tend to only read Specific Type/Format Disc's like some can read DVD +R but not DVD -R or maybe even DVD RW Formats.

You can find out what Type Formats the Computer Drives work with by removing the Drives from the computers and reading their Specifications on the Label on the Drive. This will tell you what Formats the Drive is capable of reading. ;)

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.