Discussion Locked

Failing drive in PC with non-working fan

0 helpful
20 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm actually trying to see if others concur with my diagnosis.

I've got a client who came to me today with her computer - 1 year old Gateway running XP Home, it's been locking up more and more (don't know exactly how long) and then she kind off-handedly mentioned that when she shuts it down by pulling out the plug, it seemed hot.

I checked and sure enough the power supply fan was not working. So I replaced the power supply. However, after a reboot I decided to run Norton Anti-Virus. It gets about 2/3 through and the computer locks up completely. The last time it did this, after it had been on for a few hours, it wouldn't even reboot. I just rebooted after it had been off for 1-1/2 hours and it's fine.

I'm thinking that the fan hadn't been working for some time and that now the hard drive is heat damaged, such that when it works hard (like in Norton), it fails. I'm thinking that if this is correct I'm going to tell her to get a new drive and I'll Ghost it over.
But before we go to that expense - any other ideas of what could be causing it?

20 replies

by gar2n

HI! it sounds like it could be a virus, I had the same thing happen to me back in oct. every time I would try to run norton the system froze.When I could finally get the system to work again I went to norton update page and downloaded a utility to flop and cured my problem.
It may be worth a shot, good luck!

by forvirg

No virus. After keeping the case open, I was able to run Norton several times. All clear.

by sofestibeest

Hi,

Perhaps it is a virus, however, i don't get the imresiion that it could be a virus.

Try to boot up. then start another util like MS Defrag! en then defragment the drive. IF the harddrive stops respondig, it will surely be damaged. If not try connecting the drive to another IDE channel.

Goodluck

by forvirg

Well, defrag worked once I got it to stay up long enough to run it (which was when I had the case side open)

by donmars

ARE ALL OTHER FANS WORKING? CAN YOU TELL WHAT THE PROCESSOR TEMPERATURE IS BEFORE IT LOCKS UP? YOU SAID SHE SHUT IT DOWN BY PULLING THE PLUG, IS THAT AFTER SHE SHUTS DOWN WINDOWS PROPERLY OR DOES SHE JUST UNPLUGS IT WITHOUT PROPER SHUTDOWN? DOES THEHARD DRIVE MAKE ANY FUNNY NOISES SUCH AS CLICKING? IS THE HARD DRIVE PAINFULLY HOT TO THE TOUCH? IN BIOS MANY NEWER COMPUTERS WILL GIVE YOU THE CPU TEMP, THE CHASSIS TEMP, THE CPU FAN RPM AND THE CHASSIS FAN RPM. THE CPU FAN MAY APPEAR TO BE WORKINGBUT DUE TO HEAT DAMAGE OR DUST OR AGE MAY BE TURNING NOT AT OPTIMUM SPEED TO REMOVE HEAT FROM THE CPU, SO LOCK-UPS OCCUR. USUALLY WHEN THE HARD DRIVE FAILS AFTER OVER HEATING IT PRETTY MUCH STAYS FAILED. IT ALSO USUALLY WILL MAKE NOISES, THERE IS ALWAYS AN EXCEPTION. THERE IS ALSO THE OS TO CONSIDER. HAVE YOU TRIED AN OS REPAIR OR REINSTALL? DID YOU CHECK ALL THE BIOS SETUP PARAMETERS? REPLACING ANY PART WITHOUT GOING THROUGH ALL THE EASIER AND CHEAPER STEPS DOES NOT LOOK GOOD. I AM HAVING A HARD TIME THINKING THIS IS A HARD DRIVE FAILURE USING WHAT INFO YOU PROVIDE.

by donmars

I had much information for you and when I went to post it lost everything. I am now emotionally spent and cannot bring myself to recreate it. Anyway here is a manual for the PC. Copy and paste in address bar:

http://support.gateway.com/s/manuals/servers/eseries/8506984.pdf

Your temp sounds good now maybe because you replaced the thermal compound. It is on the cool side but better than hot side. Check out your BIOS settings. Fiddle with them see what happens. Pay attention to things like cpu multiplier (clock ratio), settings to match up memory frequency etc.

by m.j.

Turn off the system restore function. Reboot into safe mode and try running norton again. If it will work in safe mode then you need to look at the operating system. let me know.

by thechas

Personally, I would suspect the CPU or RAM before the HDD.

Install a run a mother board monitor or a similar utility that allows you to monitor system temperatures and voltages.

If the CPU runs hot, then it is likely the damaged component.

Do not rule out damage to the motherboard itself.

I would only suspect the drive if it stops spinning when the system locks up.

Chas

by forvirg

Well, I tried to comment on DonMars and TheChas answers, but don't see them so I'll post this.

I've now run MemDoc to test the RAM - including a burn-in test - and it passed all. Today was trying to install WinXP Home SP1 when it locked up again. FYI, ALL power management features are set to never turn off anything. The screen saver had come up and been running OK when I left the room, when I came back - all locked up.

Then I cleaned out CPU fan (which did have some dust in it) and added clean thermal compound. So far it won't complete a reboot. The HDD spins - but nothing comes on screen. So, since the HDD is making normal sounds (nothing unusual) I'm now leaning toward CPU (Pentium 4 - 1.8Ghz) or Motherboard. I was runningMotherboard Monitor when this last lockup occurred, but haven't yet been able to get back in to check logs. However, it was showing 32F as CPU temp last time I looked. ?? Sounds inaccurate to me, but I'm no expert on that.

Anyone ever heard of motherboard problems in Gateway E4600?

by sroberts

I agree with chas Iwoud check out the cpu and the ram before hdd as these will heat up quicker than the hdd
good luck
steve

by wlbowers

Any component is subject to fry if the primary cooling takes a powder.

Boot to floppy without the hard drive and perform a burn in test for a couple of hours. I use The Troubleshooter but there are a lot of free ones on the web.

If it startsthrowing errors during this test you know it is the motherboard or cpu.

A lot of the new drives get real hot in normal operation. Have you tried it in a different computer and run diagnostic on it.

Good Luck Lee

by dragononedon

Check your computer management/system tools/event viewer/applications. Look down the list for error and warning messages and see what they have to say.

If you have a reliable power supply that you have had no problems with, try using that and seeif that doesn't work. I know you said you just replaced it. I have had new ones that I had to replace causing the same problem.

Good Luck

by rmorain

I am having a similar problem with a Gateway Performance 1400. The client upgraded from ME to XP Home after Gateway accidentally wiped her HD. Since recovery of HD to ME, she tried install of upgrade to XP Home, got locking while working & while idle. Brought it to us, wiped HD clean install of XP Home, still getting random locks, only had 128 MB of RAM told to upgrade, upgraded to 640 RAM, processor is 1.4 Ghz PIV. No longer locks during activities, but now locks when idle. All power settings are set to never & hibernate is off.

Was wondering what you found out about your problem?

This discussion is closed to new replies.