Discussion Locked

Failing Hdd's

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In the past 3 weeks I have had 4 hdd's do the click of death on me. 4 weeks ago my system was stable running dual wd 250's when one started doing the click spin thing. I let it go for about a week when it started to get worse. I bought a new seagate 200gb hdd installed it and during the windows install I got the click of death as well. Considering that I might just have the worst luck ever I went out and bought a wd 200gb hdd. That installed fine and workd for a few days and now it has the click of death. After reading other peoples problems the conclusion was maybe a failing powersupply???? With only 2 optical drives and 1 hdd running now it seems to work but trying to run games causes the hdd to click and spin again. I have a radeon 9800pro which requires extra power and was wondering if this is a full sign of a failing power supply. Btw the power supply is an antec 550 "true power" only 6 months or so old :(:(

Thank you

9 replies

by m.a.s. matrix

This can also be caused by bad J connectors. The white power connectors. Loose wires or wires that are not pushed in to connectors all the way. Sometimes when connecting power to devices the wires will push out of the connectors. If you are using Y adaptors or adaptors that came with case fans this will happen. Check to be sure that all wires are properly seated in the J connectors.

by m.a.s. matrix

I have neon lights in my pc and they came with extra adaptors that I had to use in order to use the lights. The wires were not seated correctly in the J connectors and it cause the read head on my drives to skip. By the way sgt, if you are indeed in the service, where are you staitioned if you don't mind me asking?

by sgt_shultz

wow, that is a weird one. i do not personally see how pwr supply could cause this kind of failure so i would be trying to get wd and seagate tech support maybe 2nd level to tell me what would cause repeated failure like this.

by hughiemcginley

I cant see power supply being the culprit in this case . Return the drives under warranty and get replacements. Try another brand of drive ( see are the serial of the drives close in number) I met with several qauntum drives 8 infact a few years ago, that had similar problems 1 and 1/2 years old or there abouts.
Be sure you are not moving your system and that it is not rocking not even a little when it is inoperation.

by loodachris

To further my problems with this computer now when I start up a game call of duty or eve for example the game locks up for a second and I get stripes on my screen in multi colors. I can still use the mouse to close out the game and restart windows but cant really see anyting behind all the stripes. All of my friends do not have a spare psu that I can use to test this thing so I guess I will just have to purchase another one and try it out. I would also like to mention that surfing the web and watching some movies do not cause lockups or the clicking. Also when I plug in my other hdd then power up the system they both start giving me the click of death and I cant boot up. Maybe this info helps others to help me? Just a few days ago I was still able to play games and use both hdd's but not power down my system or it would take forever to get it to boot up. Now i'm down to 1 optical, video card and hdd.

by ozi eagle

Hi,
Check the tension on your power supply connector sockets. I have found that they can become loose and cause all sorts of HDD problems. Simple cure is to stick a small screwdriver between the casing and the metal socket to close it up slightly.

by mikex

Question:

"WD 200GB

Has anyone had any trouble with these drives? I bought one about a year ago from a local retailer. It lasted 4 months and then started clicking... (it was dead!)
I RMAd it to Western Digital and received another 200gb drive.

Well this one lasted me about 8months. It is not clicking, but last my computer shut down while surfin the net. Tried to reboot and got some errors. Still drive wont format. Tried everything and finally called for yet another RMA.
Is this normal? The model is WD2000
WD says they are experiencing no problems with htis drive. Am I that unlucky to get 2 bad drive in 1 years time?"

Answer:

"Every time I see a post like this I think "power". Without going into a long-winded story about the damage systems I've managed have experienced due to ratty power, suffice it to say that bad power can and does damage components all the time. Plus, it seems to happen even with otherwise reputable power supplies in the PC. So, if you haven't already done it, get yourself a *quality* (by this I mean avoid the $40 specials at Staples, and third-rate manufacturers like Belkin) UPS. One that has over 100dB of filtering, line isolation (preferably), and both under and over voltage protection.

Just a datapoint: I've used so many WD drives that I can't count them. In my systems, their reliability has been excellent -- in fact, I can't remember the last time one failed, it's been several years. I have virtually no hardware issues to deal with."

And just another detail :)!!! :
"As far as power, as you will see in my sig, I am using an Antec True Blue 480W.

As far as cooling, The drive is barely luke warm when running, and I have 2 fans blowing right over the top of it.

I guess i'm just darn unlucky!"

Here's the link for the whole discusion:

http://www.broadbandreports.com/forum/remark,11760128~mode=flat

by txtopgun

Are the wires to the hard drives stationary (i.e., do you have the hard drives screwed in place and the sides on the case, etc.). I actually have three drives in this particular system and all of them will periodically do the same thing you describe...you can move the wires and they start working again. The drives are one each, Seagate, Western Digital, and Maxtor. For the record, this a Koolance case with no side panels and the drives are not fastened in. Though there is no reason for the wires to be moved (there is another CPU sitting right beside it) for some reason apparently they do. One other item of note, if I take all but one of the drives off (it doesn't matter which one I leave) it works fine.

Though I am running 450W PSU, I am also running a total of seven IDE drives.

by wlbowers

I run multiple drives in a tower system. Western Digital is my drive of choice. Second is IBM. Third is Seagate.

I experienced what i thought was drive failure. It turned out to be a bad supply.

The supply I replaced was less than three months old.

Good Luck Lee

This discussion is closed to new replies.