Question Locked

GPO folder redirect - confining to laptop, not user

0 helpful
14 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am currently testing the use of redirecting the my documents folders of our laptop user. The trouble is that several users may move from one of our offices to another and not take their laptops, for various reasons. In these circumstances, they will be logging into a shared computer at one of our offices. We do NOT want the shared computers to be syncing their documents to those computers.

I have tried to add the machine name to the security group that is running the GPO, but thus far, I am unable to get this to work. Anyone have any ideas on how to accomplish this?

14 replies

by cg it

well you don't apply a GPO to a security group. It's applied to the local machine, a site, domain or OU. In your case, probably an OU. Group membership can effect GPO application though.

why not use roaming profiles? If the office is a site, they will always get their profile. If the office is a child domain, then you have to allow the domain GPO to flow to the child domain or creaate a new one for the child domain and link it to an OU.

by macinslaw

While a GPO is attached to an OU and such, the folder redirect is attached to a security group. A security group is supposed to be able to have any kind of object in them, however it seems only users can be there for this purpose.

As for roaming profiles, I've never been a fan of them. First they are not, or at least were not, supported by microsoft as this was never an truly intended item, it only came about as a "side effect" of other things that were implemented. Second, we're talking about storing even more data on our network, and making remote offices even more dependent upon our servers. Aside from the sheer lack of storage, this simply won't work. While we have a T-1, we are still seeing between 70 and 300 ms latency between here and LA. Yes we are investigating.

But thanks for the suggestion, though.

by cbernhardt

unfortunately, that GPO your using is only for user settings and not PC/device...have you considered using a shared folder on some type of NAS storage? this way you can taylor the permissions only to that user...

by macinslaw

Just kidding! Actually, we do have shared resources and folders. The permissions, as needed by the Folder Redirection portion of the GPO must have modify rights to everyone set in order for it to work. The issue is that we have sales teams that are in and out of offices, and we have other team members that travel between offices.

The sales team are not computer savvy and are unable to use or understand sync programs, and they are not disciplined enough to be trusted to perform their own backups or to even make sure that the latest versions of any files are on the server. We have had OSes crash recently and each salesman lost everything because they did not do this.

So, the idea is to have a foolproof method of allowing them to have their Offline files, via GPO (Aministrative Template/Network/Offline Files) while forcing a sync anytime they are in the office, but keeping any other computer they may sign on to from syncing their my documents.

If you look in any GPO under: Windows Settings\Folder Redirection\My Documents - go into the properties, you will see when you click on "Browse" that it asks you to choose a security group. (I only mention this because 2 of you have stated that GPO's only govern users, and I understand, but the setting within the GPO utilizes security groups, so why can't I use a machine?)

Anyway, thanks to both of you for your thoughts. I hope you guys can help me figure another way of doing this.

Also, I thought that perhaps I was n't as detailed as I should have been in my original post, so I thought I would go the extra mile and explain our needs in greater detail here. I hope it helps.

by macinslaw

Thanks - That is the article that I used to do this in the first place. The issue is that we do want the Laptop "my documents" folder to be replicated, but not any other computer that they may be signing on with. We don't want any other machine to sync except for their laptops.

Currently, on my test user...me, if I log on with a laptop, great, my files sync. However, if I log on from my workstation, it also syncs. I want to figure a way to limit the sync to a particular machine, and not a user. Everything that I have read still only mentions users, and no way to restrict the action based on machines which is my issue.

Now, after re-reading the article again, I understand why you recommended using roaming profiles. We don't like them, it will be a pain to change everyone over and we do not want to have the extra garbage on our servers. The laptop my documents will be quite enough. (For example - one of our laptop users had 5 Gb of files, mostly .doc's and .xls's, in that folder.) We just want to limit this function by machine. **he types as he bangs his head violently into the desk as he is beginning to understand that what he wants to do is next to impossible**

by cg it

there is no way to limit a user profile configuration to a particular computer unless you limit that particular user to a particular computer. Even roaming profiles dont really solve the problem because what you want to do, my documents redirect only on a particular computer, is user specific which follows the user around.

I don't think a logon script would work either. How does the script know it doesn't run on a laptop but run on a desktop?

by macinslaw

I was wondering if a script could be written to fire a GPO if a particular computer was connecting. And the raoming profile would solve our issue, because the real issue lies in the "offline files" rather than the folder redirect. The nature of the "Offline files" is such that is will sync whenever the user logs on...hmm.....although I gues I could turn off the automatic sync, but then that takes me back to trusting the end user to do it.

by kjell_andorsen

I'm not sure, but it strikes me that it might be possible to add a WMI filter to the GPO that restricts it to only running on laptops. I'm not a WMI guru though, anyone else have any thoughts on this?

by cg it

humm offline files sync turned off with a particular computer regardless of user profile used. Have to look at that. If it was a hardware setting .... could use hardware profiles on the laptop. A script might work for sync... dunno never had the issue so never thought about it.

by macinslaw

That is a very good thought. You can bet I will be checking into this.

Thanks for the lead!

-Mac

by Former member

http://support.microsoft.com/kb/231287
might help.
In policy editor you will find it under computer config > administrative templates > system/group policy.

we use it to apply a unique set of user profile settings to users, only when connecting to a set of terminal servers. I would think it would work for you, if I am understanding your question correctly...

by macinslaw

I just about gave up on this! I am looking to apply a set of policies to a group of users connecting only from laptops, so the qualifier would be a Laptop group in the Computers OU, unless there is a better way.

Thanks again, I'll let you know how it turns out!

-Mac

This discussion is closed to new replies.