Hi everyone, an interesting thread, although a bit outdated in some areas.
Supportworks has come a long way since some of these comments, and I believe it has made some significant improvements. I'm a Consultant Service Desk manager by trade, and have worked for a number of organisations, and used a range of tools on the market - Supportworks, Marval, Remedy, Heat, etc. I will admit, Hornbill Supportworks isn't perfect. But of all the tools I've used, I found it to be the best.
Sure, it has a few short comings. I think they could do a bit to cut down on some of the mouse clicking for instance, and simplify a few aspects. Although, from what I understand, even this is in the development pipeline. That said, the advantages it offers over other tools I've used, is more than worth it!
The management of email has worked really well in both of the two organisations where I set up Supportworks. And they have moved out of pop3 a long time ago, and it now fully supports, and is easily configurable with Exchange Server. It also has a quick-log-call feature, where the essential information of common calls, such as resetting passwords, can be saved. When a reset password request comes in, all one has to do is enter the user name, click 'Log and Resolve', and job done. The call is logged, resolved, and a fully formed email is sent to the customer with the call details.
I don't know what their support was like 5 or 6 years ago, but one of the reasons I like Hornbill so much today is because they provide outstanding customer support. They also hold annual User Groups conventions to help ensure a good and open communication with their customers.
Yes, there is a large number of service management tools on the market. Many are ITIL based, just as the latest releases of Supportworks are. But for my money, I don't ever want another tool running on my desktop.