Discussion Locked

hmm, IE has the super majority?

0 helpful
46 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Not according to the visitors in these stats.
[pre]
Browsers Grabber Hits Percent
MS Internet Explorer No 177 44 %
Firefox No 135 33.5 %
Mozilla No 33 8.2 %
Unknown ? 28 6.9 %
Safari No 13 3.2 %
Netscape No 8 1.9 %
Opera No 4 0.9 %
iCab
[/pre]

46 replies

by jdclyde

never allow facts and reason to stand in the way of a good myth...... After all, EVERYBODY uses IE for all of their web needs, right? Aren't they the "standard"?

by jdclyde

according to the last link that shows the breakdown by country, it shows IE usage at 93.37% compared to 80.73% US and 78.52% in Canada. loooosers! :D

The FIRST link really shoot themselve in the foot by adding the disclaimer [i]"W3Schools is a website for people with an interest for web technologies. These people are more interested in using alternative browsers than the average user. The average user tends to use Internet Explorer, since it comes preinstalled with Windows."[/i]

More interested in web technologies, yet 5.8% are using IE5 last month? THAT is comedy! Yeah, really up on their tech, huh?

by m_a_r_k

Data without a reference isn't very useful. Who compiled the stats? What web address? With only 400 hits, the data can be skewed by a few people accessing the address many times or doing a bunch of refreshes. Number of web hits does not necessarily translate into number of users. A five-person company may generate more web hits in one day than a group of 50 casual users in one day. If the company uses Firefox and the casual users all use IE, the stats would make it look like there are as many or more FF users than IE. We need to see stats for an ubiquitous web site like Yahoo or CNN. You'll probably see over 80% IE. I've used both. Personally, I see no difference and have no preference between the two. FF does have a few quirky things that take a while to get used to if you've become accustomed to IE (or even Netscape in the olden days (does anyone still use Netscape?)).

by jaqui

use netscape.
firefox / mozilla suite /seamonkey/ camino/ safari are all the open source version of netscape.

[pre]
Month Unique visitors Number of visits Pages Hits Bandwidth
Jan 2006 0 0 0 0 0
Feb 2006 23 29 42 84 151.33 KB
Mar 2006 104 120 148 402 124.96 MB
[/pre]

by stargazerr

is that it decides to close down all the windows I have open at the precise moment I am doing something [b]really[/b] important.

My fellow support person uses IE. He says IE only does this once a month. Firefox does this all the damn time.

]:)

P.S This does not mean I am going to start using IE

by m_a_r_k

The Open New Window (Control-N, I think) or Open New Tab (Control-T) opens a [b]blank[/b] browser window. I like the way IE does it. It opens the new window and loads the same page as the previous "parent" window and also carries along that window's history for the Back and Forward buttons.

by vaspersthegrate

When my Firefox browser "closes down all the windows I have open..." this I interpret as *crashing*.

It means, in my case, that Firefox has to close down completely, and they want me to send an error report, which I no longer do.

This is why I navigate the web with 3 or 4 browsers open, so when Firefox crashes, every 5 to 20 minutes, I have Opera, IE, and Avant ready to go.

by amberhaze

Well as a heavy Linux user, I must say my browser of choice doesn't even register on the scale. I tend to use Konqueror for about 90% of my browsing, with very few issues. (and none of the vulnerability problems...)

I can't remembember the last time I had it crash for any reason. And the only down side is the lack of flash and other toys I don't care about in the first place.

It has all the toys that make firefox popular. (since it is also Mosila based)

by stargazerr

I absolutely hate it when IE opens the same window in a new window i open up. I usually open a new window to go to another page.

]:)

by m_a_r_k

seems like it would be better to give the user the option to stay on the same page so it may as well open with the same page. Why NOT give the user the choice? You can always easily go to another page if you want. It's kinda like the "Open in New Window" (or "Open in New Tab") option you have when you click on a link.

by sleepin'dawg

It's a free download that overlays on IE and gives you pop up, script, flash, blocking on demand. It gives you tabs that are configurable, opening blank or with the same page and tabs can be opened or closed independently. It provides, cascading windows and split windows; either hoizontal or vertical. It's as fast or faster than stand-alone IE and offers almost as much security as FF. Usage is very intuitive but it comes with help, a tutorial and an uninstaller. It's what IE could have been if Micromush had really tried.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by inertman9

ctl-o opens a dialog asking for the url before opening a window. ctl-t starts a blank tab, no page. otherwise just click the mini tab at the right of the rest or your browser shortcut and start w/ your homepage. why is this an issue?

by m_a_r_k

You don't HAVE to use the tabs. And why don't you like the tabs? The alternative is to have separate browser windows.

by m_a_r_k

You being the open source afficionado that you are, Jaqui, I'd sorta expect that you'd get a higher number of non-IE browser hits. I'd kinda expect that to be the case for any personal tech-oriented website. You're not gonna get many hits from Uncle Buck and his IE browser on your website. :D

by m_a_r_k

I'll give it a try. Er.. the avantbrowser.com web site is down at the moment. I hope this isn't indicative of the Avant browser. ?:|

by sleepin'dawg

to a couple of years, especially since the EU started jerking MS around. The Japanese lead the world in graphics, a position they took away from the frogs but for overall computer inovation and technology North America still leads the way despite having brain damaged cellular technology because Congress keeps playing games and won't adopt one single technology like the rest of the world has. Canada is tied to the US because our phone systems are interlocked. The US still hasn't settled on CDMA or TDMA and until they do the North American cellular system resembles the hard wired systems of Europe and The UK of the early sixties, in terms of user friendliness and functionality. Even third world nations are forging ahead of North America because the US hasn't pulled the thumb out and settled on a single standard and the reason they haven't lies on the doorstep of Congress.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

like download.com; majorgeeks.com or tucows.com. Use whichever is the least busy. Majorgeeks has a download site right next door to you practically. I think Avantbrowse.com is running on an overloaded server. You never have trouble from inside the browser but contacts from outside can be problematic.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by ni70

then maybe the website is trying to inject your IE with something! LMAO!

by jaqui

but konqeror has the same functionality, to identify itself as one of three: IE, netscape/mozilla or konqeror.

Ipersonally don't really worry about it. since I only code a site to be W3C standards compliant, if it doesn't look / work right, it's a fault in the browser's rendering engine.
[ usually it's only infernal exploiter users that get a bad looking site ]

by jellimonsta

I am just trying Opera out this week. I got sick of FF freezing up and bombing out all 16 active pages.
For those pages that really need IE like browsers I use Deepnet though.

by stargazerr

If it werent for the tabs, half of my screen would be covered with open windows. I have at east 15 windows open at one time with 3-4 tabs each.

]:)

by stargazerr

Its just very frustrating to have firefox crash at exactly the wrong moment.

Using 2 or 3 browsers is a good idea. But I will still loose all the work I was doing when FF crashes.

]:)

by stargazerr

more along the lines of downloading Avant ...

Its bad enough that we are forced to use Windows ... I am steering clear of any M$ produt I can ... :p

]:)

by jaqui

Gecko Rendering Engine has 46.8% of the users.
M.S.' Rendering Engine has 44%
unkown has 6.9%
Opera's Rendering engine is 0.9%

Firefox, Mozilla, Safari and Netscape all use the Gecko engine.

by justin james

Funny, if you look at the logs for my business, it shows 100% IE usage. It also gets more hits than yours does.

Here are the critical problems with your numbers here:

1) "Hits" != "Users" as any webmaster should know. "Hits" == HTTP requests. 1 person on Firefox looking through 10 pages with 5 images each creates 60 "hits", but is only 1 "user".

2) 400 "hits" total? You think that is representative of the Internet? Hardly. It's hardly even representative of the people you personally know, since a "hit" is not a "user".

Try looking at some real statistics, drawn from an assortment of real-world websites, with a large sample size, variety of interests, global reach, etc:

2006 IE6 IE5 Ffox Moz N7/8 O8/9 O7
March 58.8% 5.3% 24.4% 2.4% 0.5% 1.4% 0.1%
February 59.5% 5.7% 25.1% 2.9% 0.4% 1.4% 0.1%
January 60.3% 5.5% 25.0% 3.1% 0.5% 1.4% 0.2%

2005 IE6 IE5 Ffox Moz N7 O8 O7
December 61.5% 6.5% 24.0% 2.7% 0.4% 1.3% 0.2%
November 62.7% 6.2% 23.6% 2.8% 0.4% 1.3% 0.2%
October 67.5% 6.0% 19.6% 2.6% 0.4% 1.2% 0.2%
September 69.8% 5.7% 18.0% 2.5% 0.4% 1.0% 0.2%
August 68.4% 6.3% 18.9% 2.4% 0.4% 0.8% 0.3%
July 67.9% 5.9% 19.8% 2.6% 0.5% 0.8% 0.4%
June 65.0% 6.8% 20.7% 2.9% 0.6% 0.7% 0.5%
May 64.8% 6.8% 21.0% 3.1% 0.7% 0.7% 0.6%
April 63.5% 7.9% 20.9% 3.1% 0.9% 0.4% 1.0%
March 63.6% 8.9% 18.9% 3.3% 1.0% 0.3% 1.6%
February 63.9% 9.5% 17.9% 3.3% 1.0% 1.7%
January 64.8% 9.7% 16.6% 3.4% 1.1% 1.9%

That's from http://www.w3schools.com/browsers/browsers_stats.asp

I really don't know why your blog sounds you like beleive their is a global conspiracy to pump up IE's usage numbers. I could just be misreading it, but it is rather odd to think that your 400 "hits" (even if they were actually "users") proves anything other than your website receives almost as much traffic via FF as it does IE. That is all it proves. If you want to make a statement about the Internet as a whole, go get some numbers samples from around the Internet.

I would also like to note that FF (and most Gecko browsers) have utilities to let you pretend to be IE, so your numbers are quite possibly wrong anyways, you could very well have more FF users than it appears, because they could be spoofing IE.

Your numbers here are like if the only place I visited in New York City was a subway station, and I concluded that the entire city was underground.

J.Ja

by jaqui

the post you replied to is from unique users, not hits.
each number there is from distinct ip addresses reported.

I never said that it's a perfect representation of the entire internet usage, heck the site barely works in ie so I don't ever expect to have a majority of ppeople using ie to view it.

when ie renders sites that are compliant correctly the usage numbers might increase. I really don't care. IE is not something that matters.
making the site 100% standards compliant is all I worry about.

by stargazerr

Even if it is a tad bit better, it is an extra click to confirm the url. and if you have to type it in ... well, thats plain old stupid.

]:)

by m_a_r_k

I'm going to check out Avant also. I hadn't heard of that until the Sleeping Dog told me about it. Every now and then he has something useful to add to these discussions. (j/k) :D

by inertman9

couldn't reply to the reply, "max message limit" but the "that's just stupid" reply is odd to me. if you want to open a new window to go somewhere else, not the page you were on and not your home page, is there another browser out there somewhere that magically reads your mind and goes to the page? additionally, you don't have to type it in, there's a drop domw list of your visited sites, you might have to type in something you've never been to before or a broken link, but that's the same w/ all browsers. and there's no extra click to verify, not in mine anyway, you just hit enter as if you were in the addy bar. try not to be so angry, huh.

by inertman9

who's forcing you to use windows, or even use a computer for that matter? you could buy a mac and join a minority of users even smaller than homosexuals. or as many people here seem to preach the use of linux. it's just the narrow minded who say things like "i'm staying away from any (insert item here) i can". take responsibility for your life and your choices.

by stargazerr

I have never checked out IE7. Lets go back to what I was saying ..... which was that if you do a ctrl o, and try to open a new window ..... and if the browser asks you where you want to go .... It is fine if the URL (the page you were already on) is already entered and all you have to do is press enter or click Go .....

If you have to enter the url again ..... Thats stupid.

]:)

by stargazerr

We are not allowed to use anything other than windows because the higher ups have some sort of a contract for buying windows xp as bulk.

I have never used a mac but I would certainly like to try. I have worked a lot on linux though and do happen to think that it is brilliant.

]:)

by stargazerr

I can try it sometime. Flash and anything similar is the last thing I will ever think about, so I can be happy with konqueror.

In fact, my dad thinks I should have flash, because he tries to send me winks over MSN and I cannot play them because I dont have flash installed .... :D

]:)

by jaqui

konqeror says it uses khtml as rendering engine, not gecko.

My only issue with konqeror is that it is not much more capable than ie for rendering standards compliant sites.
[ look at Stu Nicholls' css play website, there are some oddities in konqeror that don't show up in gecko based browsers.

by justin james

... because you contradict yourself pretty badly.

"J.Ja, the post you replied to is from unique users, not hits. each number there is from distinct ip addresses reported."

And how was I to know those stats were "visitors" when your chart is quite clearly labeled "hits"?

Browsers Grabber Hits PercentMS Internet Explorer No 177 44 %Firefox No 135 33.5 %Mozilla No 33 8.2 %Unknown ? 28 6.9 %Safari No 13 3.2 %Netscape No 8 1.9 %Opera No 4 0.9 %

Furthermore, "distinct IP" does NOT equal "unique visitors". A significant portion of the people on this planet are behind a gateway device of one type or another that will make all visitors at that location have the same IP as reported to your log. You could have had 5,000 unique visitors behind 1 NAT gateway and you would see 1 "visitor".

"I never said that it's a perfect representation of the entire internet usage... so I don't ever expect to have a majority of ppeople using ie to view it."

Funny, the title of this whole thing, "hmm, IE has the super majority?" sure sounded like you were claiming to debunk the idea that IE comprises a majority of users. If you knew your stats didn't prove anything, why claim they did?

"when ie renders sites that are compliant correctly the usage numbers might increase. I really don't care. IE is not something that matters. making the site 100% standards compliant is all I worry about."

I have found that the sites I have done, when I "stick to the basics" and don't try the "latest and greatest" render just dandy in both IE and Gecko-based browsers, as well as other browsers.

The attitude of "I don't care if 70% of the users on the Internet can't view my website" is just crazy. Even if all of your readers are all Firefox users, you mean to tell me they shouldn't view your website if they are at work in an IE-mandated environment? Call me silly, call me crazy, but it is a LOT easier to get a website to work well for 95% - 99% of Internet users (maybe not 100% perfect, but not noticably different at a quick glance) than it is to increase traffic (or sales, if you're selling something). If I had a website selling something, if 5% of the people out there couldn't use it, that's 5% in lost sales. Would you turn away 5% of your potential customers out of some pride/ego kick? Would you take a 5% paycut without a tangible benefit?

IE's particular brand of rendering is certainly not W3C compliant (what browser's is?), but 70% market share is certainly a "standard" in and of itself. Just as I can send someone a Microsoft Word document and reasonably expect them to be able to view it, even though Word is not installed as a "standard" on every computer, or I can separate email addresses with commas even though that isn't a standard either.

HTML/HTTP compliance is an admirable goal. I hit it the vast majority of the time, and never less than 95% or so. But it is a false idol. The customer does not give two figs about your code. What they care about is getting the information/product/entertainment/whatever that you are offering them with a reasonable amount of resources spent on their end. To enforce compliance at the expense of compatability is just pigheaded.

J.Ja

This discussion is closed to new replies.