Discussion Locked

HOW MANY NETWORK CARDS ON NT???

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a question. I run a LAN with one server (NT 4.0) and it is a file/print server. All other computers run WIN 98 and have an assigned IP address. Would putting more than one network card in the server affect the speed of data retrieval??? Are there any special configurations I need to know about?

Thank you,
David Dotterer
Computer Guy
270-384-6408

23 replies

by Member 29244100

David.

I'd say that the answer depends on how busy the box is doing what it is currently, and how much extra load you'd put put on it in addition.

I would think that if it's a reasonably well specified server, and just doing File & Print work it would be ok.

To give you some idea, I work with NT 4.0 boxes with three Four-port 100Mb NIC's together with the manufacturers embedded one (Total 13 ports) in as a Firewall; without having any problems, but the box WAS dedicated to do this.
Are you expecting to use DHCP Server on this interface? Bearing in mind that Scope issues or DHCP Relay will be involved in assigning addresses on different subnets out of different NIC's.

The only other potential problem is the WINS issue; if the server registers with WINS, which address(es) will it register? Will other WINS Clients be able to see "both" of the addresses for your multi-homed server.

Jason.

by hi-temp

We do not use DHCP or WINS and do not plan to. The box will have no extra load put on it as of yet, but if needed, I can solve that issue.
If all is well, do I just need to install the new NIC(s) and be done with it. Or are there other configurations to be dealt with???

Thank you,
David D.

by mckaytech

In reading the original question and the other postings, it sounds like you want to add an additional NIC to speed up access to the server. Whether this would do any good depends on where the bottleneck(s) is/are and also depends on what the rest of your network infrastructure looks like.

For example, if you currently have a 10meg half-duplex connection to your server, going to a 100meg full-duplex connection would provide 20 times the throughput but would require that you have a FastEthernet switch on the other end of the server's network connection.

Also, adding a second NIC to the same subnet is not going to accomplish load balancing unless you have software on both ends to support that. If you have Compaq servers talking to Cisco switches, for example, you can use "teaming" where both NIC cards are run in parallel, effectively doubling throughput. Without that sort of capability, the only way to load-balance is to divide up the workstations into two segments and have eachsegment correspond to a subnet and a NIC on the server.

But before doing anything, you may want to open Performance Monitor and see if your network is, indeed, the bottleneck. If it's not, the time you spend trying to get a second NIC to behave properly won't be time well spent.

regards!

paul

by sadipara

hi,
we have around 80 machines. our database file size is approx. 180mb. all the users are finding network very slow. server has 1 enet card. we are thinking of putting 2 more ethernet cards in the server. each card will be connected to a switch (so total we will have 3 switches)each card will have diff network addr. in such case how do you configure dhcp? suppose if addr are 192.168.0.1, 192.168.1.1, 192.168.2.1. i"ll have to create 3 scopes. now how dhcp will know which ip addr to be given to the card? do i have to do any settings?
pls reply?

sanjay

by chrisms

David,
I don't believe what you intend to do would be a problem. If all computers have dedicated IP addresses, I'm not sure how you would configure each individual NIC on the server, as I believe that assigning different IP's to each card might cause a problem. If it is just to install more printers, I think that should be OK.

by ahevans

I have run similar setups and with no problems..I assume you want multiple nics for internet sharing ...if it really bugs you using multiple nics..just go buy a router for 200 bucks....that way you won't need a proxy server,,,also the router has a built in firewall for added security since you will have more vulnerabilities open....but more then one nic has never caused me any latency before...so go with it .....

by Member 29244100

Another useful feature to watch out for is with Fast Etherchannel compatible Switches and NIC's.

You can add multiple Intel Pro-100 (or Pro-1000 for that matter), Compaq NC3120, or Adaptec Quad-Port cards, and have multiple links establishing one"virtual" trunk if you're just looking to beef up the bandwidth between the server and the LAN.

In this situation, four 100Mb Full-Duplex links literally equals 400Mb Full-Duplex between Server and LAN.

However - Switches that support Fast Etherchannel (Such as Cisco Catalyst).

Obviously, this will just shift the bottleneck elsewhere.

by hi-temp

So basically it's one NIC w/ FOUR PORTS

but then they are connected to a HUB. But will 4 ports on the HUB entail more data being able to go through?

by Member 29244100

David.

Etherchannel aggregated pipes only work with Switches;

If you connected four independant channels to a hub, you'd probably find that the OS would force you to specify a different IP address for each link, and then you'll be in to the multi-homing problem.

You'll definitely find that installing a Switch will improve performance significantly, as the Switch will carry on multiple independant conversations down each port simultaneously; A busy "Port 1" will not affect "Port 3" or "Port 4" unless the traffic is targetted at a device down that channel. The print requests will then not be passed down EVERY port on the hub, only the relevant ones, as supervised by the switch.

Hope this helps...

Regards,

Jason.

by hi-temp

So i need a switch that connects the 4 NICS that are installed into the server and then where do I go from there. I have approx 10 client pc's.

Thanks for all support,
David.

by Member 29244100

David.

I'd suggest that you go for "Intel Pro-100" Nic's or the Adaptec Quattro 4-port card, A small switch like a Cisco Catalyst 2924-XL or 2912-XL will do the job nicely for the teaming.

You set the NIC's up in one "Virtual Trunk" which needs one IP Address, and on the switch, under each interface, you specify a "Channel Group N", where N is the same for all the four ports in the trunk.

The exact syntax of this varies depending on what switch you've got. On a Catalyst 4000, 5000,or 6000 series you'd use a "set port channel 3/1-4" command to turn ports 3/1, 3/2, 3/3, and 3/4 in to a single EtherChannel.

Be careful what switch you buy; I KNOW this is possible with most Cisco Catalyst switches, don't know about other vendors.

The other Hub(s) you've got can then also be connected to the Switch, possibly with a crossover cable (if the hubs don't have an MDI/MDI-X port) to 'contain' each hub in it's own segment. These will all still be in the same TCP/IP subnet, etc.as you're not routing them. The Switch then becomes the high capacity "BackBone" of the network. Any other high utilisation Servers (and even PC's or printers) can be connected to the switch (as though it were a hub) to get the benefits of reducednetwork traffic generally.

Have fun!

Jason.

by dukebytes

I just want to say that everything JasonC said is very true and not trying to dispute him at all. But why do you need a 4 port NIC and a 12 port 3.2 Gig back plane switch for 10 clients...

I can't really imagine that you server is working that hard via the NIC for 10 clients. If you went with a cheaper switch and ran full duplex to each client/server at 100 Mbps your network should be fine. Unless you are transferring really LARGE files ? all the time, it sounds like over kill.

Don't get me wrong - I LOVE Cisco stuff - but you could easily get a 1912 with a 1 Gig back plane and connect all 11 machines to it running 100/full and it would probable work a lot better than it is now. The big advantage a switch will give you is that you no longer have collisions - and that is the big deal with Ethernet. I just don't really think that 400 Mbps at the server (4 port NIC) will do anything at all for you.

If your server is really that slow with only 10 clients it sounds more likeyour hard disk subsystem is not standing up to the load. Are you doing software RAID or hardware RAID - or any RAID at all. It might be more benefit to you to buy a $500 RAID adapter and 2 more drives and put them in your server and set them up asa RAID1 array than put a 4 port NIC in the server.

Just my thoughts.

Good luck,
David

by Member 29244100

DukeBytes,

Can you still get a 1912 switch!

I think the problem is more likely to be that the available bandwidth is being used up with lots of Collisions or Broadcasts, rather than real "relevant" traffic. Since the network doesn't have any Switches in at the moment, all this junk traffic is going everywhere, and is giving a general performance hit. Even a faulty NIC somewhere on the LAN could cause drastic performance problems elsewhere if there are no switches to contain it.

David D ~ Have you tried a Packet Sniffer on the network to look at the traffic profile?

I appreciate what you're saying re the 1912 switch would do just as fine; and they support Etherchannel, (just not Fast Etherchannel ~ if memory serves correctly the 1912 is a 12-port 10Mb Switch??).

I'm not sure how many clients are on this network. For a smaller number then simply increasing the bandwidth is a good first step, but that doesn't solve the root problem.

Of course DukeBytes is correct in pointing out that it might not be the network at all that's causing the problem; hence my earlier post "it depends what else the box is doing".

Might well be worth playing with the NT Performance Monitor for a while!

There are other switches out there too, that aren't as expensive as Cisco ones. I don't know what other vendors produce Etherchannel (FastEtherchannel, or GigaEtherChannel) compatible devices.

JasonC

by hi-temp

I am going to try the packet sniffer soon. But I know the problem is collision after collision. It's a bunch of jukn traffic as you stated. I really appreciate all of your posts and I welcome many more to come. I am looking at the aspect of the switch at this time. But need all of your input.

by dukebytes

Ummmm - I think that you can still get one :) - not sure for how long.

And it is only a 10Base-T switch. You should really go to a 100Mbps switch if you can afford it. The 2912 XL is a 12 port 10/100 - so it would do both if you have any eq that won't connect at 100. It does have the 3.2 Gbps backplane which I think is more than you need for 10 clients - but it would be nice to have :)

The only reason that I said about looking at the drives and such is because I have run a 40 + node network on 10/half hubs (cascaded) before and it wasn't that bad. Yes traffic was a lot worse than it is these days because of collisions - but that was all that we had then :)

(hope no one from Cisco is watching :) 3Com switches are OK - I have had fairly good performance from them in the past - BUT - you might want to make sure that your running 3Com NICs in your machines before you go that route.

If your using Intel or generic NICs - I would go with a generic (Asante, Allied Telesyn, Netgear, Linksys) switch if you can't buy a Cisco - they seem to work pretty well with those.

A quick way to test for a bad NIC in the system is to shut down machines when things are going really slow. This very well could be a bad NIC.

Good luck,
Duke

by hi-temp

I am looking in a catalog @ a LinkSys Switch. Are those worth looking @? We run mostly NetgearNICS on our workstations (2 LinkSys NICS) and our server has a 3COM NIC.

What about a NETGEAR???

Thank you all again

by dukebytes

David,

Buy a netgear - it's pretty good stuff and if your NICS are already netgear it should work fine. I would look into the FS524S. That one should do all you want it to and gives a little room to grow.

Good luck,
Duke

by Member 29244100

David.

Any Switch is going to be better than a hub; As Dukebytes suggests, a Netgear will do the job just fine, although I do remember a problem with one of the early Netgear switches and a Duplex Negotiation problem with some NIC's. I'm sure that's fixed now though.

You need to make a decision on Value for Money now versus the future. If your network is growing rapidly, and you can justify the money, it might be better going for a slightly more mid-range switch like a 3Com Superstack II, a Cisco Catalyst 2900 series. It sounds as though a big Chassis based job will be way OTT for what you want.

Intel and Bay (Nortel) Switches are very good too, and reasonably priced.

If money is a constraint, I'd suggest looking at a Cisco 1548-DS-U Micro-Switch; These cost approx ?200.00 ($300??) and are simple little 8-port devices.

Dukebytes - I wouldn't touch a High End 3Com switch any more; not after the way they treated their customers!

With Switches in general, I thinkyou get what you pay for; Cheaper switches do tend to be quite limiting (1024 MAC Address limits for example) and when they reach those limits, they drop back to being a dumb hub again. Other limitations are the expandability, and manageability. In a small network though, you're not likely to want much RMON ability!

Still, if you're buying something cheap, you can afford to "recycle" it when you want to go further up-market!

Have Fun!

Jason.

by dukebytes

Sorry, I hope that Jason and I are not running you around in circles. BUT :)

Go out to www.usedrouters.com and click on the Cisco products and click on the 2924-XL-EN its a 24 port 10/100 auto sensing switch that they are selling for $1,100.00. It's referb - but if its OK - you can't beat that price.

Sorry again :)
Duke

by hi-temp

Yeah, $1,100 is a good price, but that's a little of our range at this time. I am thinking on the Netgear switch (going to look into the limits) also
What is a good packet sniffer to use???

Thanks for all of your input on this query! Keep 'emcomin because I appreciate it very much.

by Member 29244100

David,

One of the best Packet Sniffers for an NT environment is "Microsoft Netmonitor", but you have to buy a copy of SMS Server to get the full blown product. There is a crippled version that can be installed with NT, but it only allows you to examine traffic that is sent to or received by your host.

There is a v. good free one called Ethereal, that has been ported to Windows from Linux. Check out www.ethereal.com

Rgds,

Jason.

by Member 29244100

David,

I don't know much about the DMB on NT, but I do know there are some tools in the NT Resource Kit that help with troubleshooting...

Hope this helps.

Jason.

This discussion is closed to new replies.