Question Locked

IBM XIV versus Traditional SAN solutions

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Speaking of FUD on a revolutionary Linux based solution...

Does anyone have any actual experience with the IBM XIV storage array solution?

I've looked high and low, and I can't find impartial, non-biased information anywhere on the blogsphere or really in trade magazines that gives a lot of helpful information that I feel I can trust. Whitepapers are few and far between. I get the feeling that a lot of the info written out there by impartial 3rd parties, and a lot of the comments that follow, are actually IBM and EMC having what amounts to a bloody corporate war via the Internet.

I'm looking for examples of real world application in traditional SAN storage solution scenarios, in particular running mid to relatively large MS-SQL DBs.

I'd really like to hear any DISAPPOINTED purchasers, if they actually exist. I hear they MUST - but I can't seem to find any talking about it in public. If you're too embarassed to speak in public, by all means leave me a note here and we'll figure out somewhere else to talk about it in detail.

5 replies

by oh smeg

As if IBM sold this correctly they would not be placing this into a position that it isn't compatible with.

So while there may be shortcomings if IBM supplied and fitted this option correctly they will not be supplying it into a position which it's unsuited to solve the customers needs.They also have very good backup for these devices and very fast turn around times. ;)

Col

by Member 19291532

I've got a Clariion (why must EMC(2) make all their trademarks so difficult?) 300 and we're between a Clariion 4xx and the XIV.

The XIV being marketed toward the wrong market/tier of storage is one of my concerns, but the blogs are really a flamewar between EMC and ex-EMC-now-at-IBM storage experts.

I'm interested in optimized performance for MS-SQL DBs ranging in size up to larger than 1TB of data. Arguing back and forth regarding if granual configuration of spindles and RAID on SaS drives is superior to nearly unlimited spindles across a giant pool of SATA disks has smoke coming out of my ears at this point. Both sides have REAL compelling points.

I think I'm going to end up trail-blazing on this. If it doesn't work out, I'll be posting my resume in 6 months to a year. :)

by oh smeg

Advantages and Disadvantages over each other but the reality is that both will work and it all depends on what your individual circumstances are as to which is the better of the 2 listed options for your needs.

It would be a extremely Hard to deal with Management though who fired you for buying IBM and the services not working satisfactorily for their needs. Provided that the storage worked, long term reliability is in the Lap of the Gods and is not something that you can guarantee. ;)

Col

by obrieng

We are currently evaluating EMC CX4 with Unified Storage front end, Hitachi AMS2300, and IBM XIV. 3Par was in the race but poor salesmanship and high price lost it for them. I find the same problems with XIV,it seems to good to be true and there are alot of negative posts out there but I cant find anything concrete on the positive side. It would be nice to see some real time XIV users put something up but if it works well, who is going to take the time to post?
We are coming close to a decision but I need to keep that secret for now.

This discussion is closed to new replies.