Discussion Locked

MS releases white paper on Spyware

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Microsoft has made available a 7-page white paper entitled "Windows AntiSpyware (Beta): Analysis Approach and Categories," in which it describes how it classifies various malware & the responses to such.

The paper is available at

http://www.microsoft.com/athome/security/spyware/software/analysis.mspx

13 replies

by craig herberg

The notion of false positives has gotten a lot of press lately, with certain vendors threatening legal action when their software is classified as spyware. This article has a section devoted to vendor disputes and false positives. It looks like a lot of this tracking software will end up being classified either as legitimate software or PUPs (Possibly Unwanted Programs). Goodness!

Craig Herberg

by tony hopkinson

Some pre-checked optional component you get with that AOL crap. They whinged about being classed as adware, a few phone calls now they aren't, according to Bill and his mates anyway.

by deepsand

SpyBot Search & Destroy maintains its list of sites to be blocked in the Registry.

I have observed that MS AntiSpy consistently reports 1 specific entry only as evidence of malware.

The implications:

1) MS's app knows naught of the others; or,
2) MS's app knows of the others, and considers them benign; or,
3) MS's app knows of the others, considers them malignant, but fails to report such; or,
4) Ms's app considers this specific entry benign, but mis-reports it as malignant.

Most curious.

by craig herberg

People should have severe reservations about using security software provided by vendors with many other financial interests to protect. Remember when accounting companies were auditors and consultants to the same company?

Craig Herberg

by deepsand

This relates to false positives how?

And, how is trying to make one's product more free of defects, and less prone to failure, a conflict of interest?

by craig herberg

Actually, my original post relates to the notion that certain vendors threaten legal action for classifying their products as spyware, claiming "false positive." It's all about protecting one's financial interest, as is creating security products that give preferential treatment to their own products and to those with which they have a business relationship (second post). Nothing evil implied here, just self-interest, thus the phrase "conflict of interest." I agree that trying to make one's product more free of defects, and less prone to failure, does not constitute a conflict of interest, but other things do.

by craig herberg

While we're on the topic of cease-and-desist orders, I wonder if Google knows how many people have had their browser's home page changed from Google to a software giant's search page. . .

by deepsand

I am constantly amazed at the number of people who have their browser "hijacked," and are not even aware that their home page has changed!

by craig herberg

Most people who don't know their home page changed have kids at home, and are used to everything being asunder.

This discussion is closed to new replies.