Discussion Locked

New PC, Win98/ME/XP dilemma

0 helpful
22 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I'm planning to purchase a new gaming PC, but many of the games I will be playing on it are for Win95/98 and are DOS-based games (i.e. older Master of Orion and X-Com games). I know that Win98 can be a bit twitchy with the newer 2+GHz CPU's and 512+Mb RAM. I also know that XP is NOT DOS-based and can prove difficult with DOS-based games. Should I be able to run older DOS-based games in WinME? Or should I set up for dual-OS with Win98 and XP? And if I do use dual-OS, should I look for a PC with less than a 2.1GHz processor and less than 512Mb RAM? I don't want to spend a lot of money just to find out I can't use my new computer the way I planned. Can someone please help?

22 replies

by cg it

I'd go with Windows 95 and a 1.2ghz AMD Athlon with 384 MB of memory. Since their older games I'll assume they are DirecX 8 or lower compatible or OpenGL 1.2 and I would opt for a Voodoo 5 5500 graphics card. Windows ME is to flakey, Windows 98 SE though a good O/S tends to have registry bloat. W95, though very old and unsupported is a pretty good O/S. That's my 2 cents.

by cg it

follow up Oz on Voodoo. yep they are out of business. Sold their core patented technologies to NVidia. You can still get Voodoo cards on Ebay and in their day were the best cards on the market [I use mine for running Descent, DescentII Descent III] and have DirectX 8 drivers. I also use an OLD MSI KT Turbo mainboard to run em on and 384 MB PC 133 with Windows 95. including running the original Descent [which is strickly a DOS game. Have to boot up to DOS and set my config.sys so I've got 593k of conventional available]

Chas is the hardware man but I still recommend Windows 95 over ME or W98SE.

by thechas

Aside from the CPU speed and RAM amount issues you are aware of, there are problems with new hardware and DOS based games.

Windows Me is NOT a solution to these issues.
Me is considered to be the least stable version of Windows.
Further, Me suffers from all of the same problems with RAM and large hard drives that W98 does.

(Side note: even with the new version of fdisk, Windows 98 and Me are limited to drives no larger than 137GB.)

XP does support many DOS programs. You may want to get a book that covers setting up compatibility mode. XP's compatibility mode allows XP to emulate older operating systems.

A friend of mine just bought a new PC and has similar issues to the ones you have.
Even with Windows 98 installed, he could not get the sound to function on his older DOS games.

After 3 weeks and numerous hours on the phone with Creative, it was finally concluded that the newer motherboard chip-sets do not support the DOS extensions for the sound card drivers.

He ended up setting up a second system with older hardware and a clean installation of DOS for his DOS based games.

One good way to accomplish this is to use a KVM switch, and install both PCs to use one set of keyboard, mouse and monitor.
Some KVMs even switch the audio to allow you to share 1 set of speakers.

Chas

by oz_media

To follow up on DR's coments.

Voodoo (3DFX) are not in business anymore.

I have a Voddoo 5 5500 PCI card if you are interested, it's in a box I am swapping out pretty soon, if you are interested email
ozmedia@excite.com

(That's if you can't find a used one locally)

by ð

over all what you looking to do is very complex as technology is constant changing these days. If you want to be able to play these games, keep the PC you have now for these games you want to play on and get a new PC you for your current needs or look maybe do some reseach to see if there is a later version of these games for windows XP. You do not want to spend $$ on a new PC and load 95/98 or ME just for the DOS games. by the way windows ME is problem manic since it first release. other words it suck as shit, nothing but problems since day one. windows 95/98 how ever does not utilize anything more than 128MB of RAM according to Microsoft back in 1999(wasted a contract call for nothing). In the end is your call and your money. this is my advise.

by otherworldone

Poster rated this answer.
There are no later versions of these games made to play on Windows XP. So, I'm pretty much stuck with the suggestions made by "D.R." and "TheChas". Thanks for trying to help, though.

by otherworldone

The reason I'm buying a new computer to run these games on: my current computer is my husband's. Sharing it isn't working. His computer has issues I'd rather not fix myself (he has WinME, by the way). And we differ on hardware/accessory preferences (I like my old Kensington Orbit trackball). So really, this will be MY only computer and I'll be using it MOSTLY for these older games. But I still need it to be practical for other everyday uses. I guess I didn't realize just how complex my question was before. :)

by herrlizard

Alot of DOS-based programs (games) will run fine on WinXP, but there's only one way to find out if the one's you play do....test them out on your current PC (if it's running XP) or any other XP machine. If they run fine, then you're problem is solved. Of course, try to run them normally, in compatibility mode, etc. to find what works best for each game.

Also, one of the major problems with running DOS-based games on XP and even Win98 is sound compatibility. But there is a solution to this problem........VDMSound! It is a software program that emulates older hardware such as SB16, SBPro, MPU-401, etc. I have used this program for several old games and it has worked phenomenally, especially for MIDI music. Check it out at the following link. It could be the answer to your prayers.

http://www.ece.mcgill.ca/~vromas/vdmsound/

by otherworldone

Poster rated this answer.
I don't currently have a computer available with XP on it to try. But according to the company that made the games, at least one of them is known NOT to run on XP, even in compatibility mode. I do appreciate that you tried to help, though. Thanks.

by thevirtualone

I'd suggest that you buy your PC and then buy VMware, http://vmware.com

$189 electronic distribution
$199 packaged distribution

Available for Windows XP, Windows 2000 and Windows NT and for Linux systems.

...then load a virtual machine so you can install a second, third or as many Operating Systems as you want.

by otherworldone

Poster rated this answer.
I HAD actally considered this, but it wouldn't solve the problems with older operating systems and newer hardware. But thanks.

by grump

Be nice and buy your husband the new PC and take his as you already run the games on it.

Seems to me, you are going to a lot expense on a new PC for old games. Maybe if you shopped around an bought a good used PC that will do the JOB?

www.secondwindpcs.com

good luck

by otherworldone

Poster rated this answer.
Already pretty much put this in the comment I added today, but....THIS computer is a LAPTOP that needs repair. My husband's desktop is currently nonfunctional, but I will be rebuilding it for him (when he comes back from his deployment). We DID just order him a new laptop to use while he's overseas, so he will have another working computer all to himself and this one will be mine. ...but it is STILL a laptop and not much good for prolonged use.
So, regardless...I will still need a new desktop for ME, and I just can't be happy with a bland-looking older PC, when I know it's going to be the one I use most.
Anyway, I appreciate the input. Unfortunately, it really doesn't give my any NEW insight. Sorry.

by otherworldone

Okay...just to clear up as much as possible about the situation here...

The computer I am currently using (my husband's) is an older Dell LAPTOP with a worn-out cable/connector for the screen. Right now, it can only be used if connected to a monitor. And since it is a laptop, it is prone to overheating and has various software-related issues that make it difficult to use for prolonged periods (which IS a problem for me).

My husband DOES also have a full-tower, however...it was a "project" of his and his buddies' that somehow went wrong, and now I am trying to salvage what I can of it to rebuild it for him. BUT it is currently nonfunctional.

We HAVE just ordered a new laptop for him, so I will inherit the old one and send it in for repair...but it is still a laptop...same problems.

And since I just can't be happy with any old PC :> whatever I get will my own custom job with a mod case...you know...all the pretty stuff. :D

SOO...whichever way I go, I will still be putting out money to BUILD my desktop the way I want (and need) it.

I know I've probably already got the best suggestions I'm going to get here. But I'll leave the question open for a few more days just in case somebody out there has one more brilliant idea for me. Then the points will go out to the ones who were the most helpful (and original) with their answers. Thanks everybody. :)

by grbeckmeyer

Wow, I can't believe nobody has suggested probably the simplest solution...WinXP as the operating system, and use a DOS boot disk with all the drivers/config for your old DOS games. Probably not all that simple from the hardware/drivers end, but definitely no need to dual boot or shell out big $ for VMware. Also, you could check out 'Bochs' and other programs at www.sourceforge.net similar to VMware. Some might be able to emulate older sound hardware.

by otherworldone

Poster rated this answer.
While a simple possible solution, it wouldn't combat possible problems associated with newer hardware incompatibility. But thanks for the idea.

by appus

I too suggest to boot with a simple DOS boot disk to run DOS based games.. So easy.. So that it wont mix up with ur winXP or anything.. If i was in your place.. i would have done with a boot Floppy or CD :)

This discussion is closed to new replies.