112 replies
by ontheropes
by maecuff
you should mention it. I'm COMPLETELY broke right now. :)
Okay, even though I am cash poor right now, we are far from poverty stricken.
And yes, I grew up in poverty. We had a house to live in because my mother's aunt let us live there for free. But as bad off as we were, there were people in my neighborhood that were in worse shape. I had a friend who lived in a house without a front door. They just tacked up a blanket when it got cold out.
All in all? I'm not sorry. I definitely learned how to take care of myself. And I appreciate what I have.
BTW, my mother in law tongue plant is growing like a weed. :)
by ontheropes
It's real nice to hear that you took my advice and that it's been good for you. That just made my day.
by boxfiddler
good until Mom and Dad divorced.
Broke city thereafter.
Ate one whole hell of a lot of eggs and rice.
by maecuff
I am so enjoying my new green thumb. I've never been able to keep houseplants alive. Now, I have a bay window filled with them and I haven't lost one in over a year.
I am constantly battling this white powdery mold, though. Any suggestions?
by boxfiddler
As I recall, ABC didn't even notice our poverty...
I'm glad that I came up broke. Came into this life with nothing; can't take anything with me when I leave it.
by ontheropes
I still appreciate simple things. I'm not really very complicated.
Friends. I appreciate my friends. I still have TR's Christmas card propped up sitting here where I can look at it everyday. Weird, huh? Would you believe that except for one cup of coffee I've drank every coffee I've had at home from one of my TR mugs? I have all of my swag close at hand too. They're gifts, nothing asked for in return. I like gifts.
As you are so fond of saying, now that you know it bugs me, whatever. :^0
by boxfiddler
I didn't realize it bugs you.
I'll stop.
Er...
It might take a few minutes.
by michael jay
never been really in poverty, but close.
You mean this card, it means a lot to me.
http://i424.photobucket.com/albums/pp321/michaeljay2009/christmascard.jpg
by jdclyde
Want less.
Appreciate more.
It took a long time for me to get past wanting things I was never able to have. What helped was once I was able to start getting them, I found many were not as satisfying or fulfilling to have as I had thought they would be.
Now, one of the best experiences I can have is camping (no electricity/running water) cooking a simple meal over the open fire, and enjoying time with people I care deeply for. More meaningful and more lasting of a memory than going to see a movie or going to the bar.
Of course, at 17, it is a constant battle to get around the natural blinders people have at that age, to get them to see the world around them, and the impact their actions or inactions have on their surroundings.
So far, so good.
by ontheropes
The world revolves around me.
Not you.
by ontheropes
by ontheropes
by michael jay
by ontheropes
You show promise.
Millions...join me in what we may have to do.
by maecuff
by ganyssa
by hal 9000
Bring her back immediately this is completely unacceptable that you a Male has Kidnapped and are currently Impersonation Boxy. :_|
Only a male would say something like that and we all know that Boxy is a Female. :p
So who are you and what have you done with Boxy? Much more importantly did you actually expect to get away with such a Heinous Crime as what you have perpetrated here? :0
Really Boxy would never make an admission like this
[i]I didn't realize it bugs you.
[b]I'll stop.[/i][/b]
Now you have blown an otherwise almost perfect crime by being stupid. Don't you realize that [b]No[/b] Female Alive on this Plant [b]Ever[/b] would admit to not knowing something? And then compound the admission that they are not the Know Alls that they tell everyone that they are by claiming [i]I'll stop.[/i]
A poor excuse of a Criminal who didn't think out or research their crime and attempt to get away with it. :-q
Females are always correct and know everything worth knowing. They will tell you so themselves and the sensible males let them continue to believe that we believe them when they say things like that by not rolling around the floor laughing our heads off.
Yes Dear I know it's a Lovely Day outside I'll just go and let Hurricane Katerina in to pay you a visit. ]:)
See my point here? Say are you insane there is a Hurricane outside and they will tear into you with a vengeance unriveled in the History of our Species. But offer to let the Hurricane in to join them and they will stop you immediately and say that they must have been looking out the wrong window or something equally ridiculous. ;)
Col 0:-)
by jdclyde
At these poor times in the past, was it still a good life?
I grew up in a very poor house, but we were happy and appreciated everything we had.
So much of todays "poor" still have multiple cars, cable tv with multiple tv's, and everyone has a cell phone.
Put that in perspective of 30 years ago and more how "poor" people lived, and you see a lot of people have created their own problems because of poor spending habits.
I anticipate making about 22k this year thanks to the layoffs, but hardly consider myself poor and still do not live paycheck to paycheck. (not bad for not working for 5 months) Not going for fast food and not using a credit card helps a lot.
The only real lifestyle change going on right now is drinking Canadian whisky instead of scotch more and more.... $13 a bottle is much more my speed right now.
by jamesrl
I'm pretty sure my Grandparents would have defined it differently than today's generation, or ABC for that matter.
Growing up, financially we were poor, we had a lot of kids (5), didn't have a lot of money, didn't travel etc. But we had a roof over our heads, cloths and food.
We didn't get an allowance, but we did get money for things if we needed (as opposed to wanted). I inherited most of my clothes from older brothers. Same with bikes and skates. I earned a little working for neighbouring farmers. We also planted our own garden, raised chickens, occasionally pigs, ducks, whatever.
I managed to go to university on student loans - my parents were supposed to contribute some big amount according to the formula, but in fact, I got a few hundred dollars a year. I managed by working weekends, and living frugally.
Things were tight when I was laid off in 2002. After the severence ran out and I had to pay the mortgage and other bills on $400 a week (wife can't work), but we survived the months until I got some contract work. When your housing costs are over half of your income, thats scary.
I'm pretty good at the moment, wracked up a little debt, but my house is getting paid down. I can pay and do continue to pay down my debt.
James
by tonythetiger
by nicknielsen
by jck
Have I ever lived in it? Yeah. Mom was in and out of the hospital for months, Dad was the only income. I was an 18 year old fielding phonecalls for debt collectors and banks and all.
Plus, I lived on $20 for a month. How do you do that?
12 for $1 ramen noodles
4 for $1 packs of hot dogs and hot dog buns
lots of water
staying with friends who lived near the college so i didn't waste gas.
i went home a few times a week to check the mail and stuff, and make sure no one broke in or to call dad.
Did I live that way all of my life? No. I was lucky.
Now compare that to my father, who grew up living in a tiny house in urban Iowa with his mother and 7 siblings while his father worked away in Chicago for the railroad.
My father was delivering newspapers in the 1940s before he learned how to do multiplication.
And then, there was my mother who before she even went to school, she was washing other peoples' clothes and helping feather and butcher chickens because her mother was a single parent in the 1940s.
Neither of my parents or their families took a hand-out. They always worked for what they got.
Something that's been lost amongst many in society today.
by ontheropes
by notsochiguy
Without going into too many details (I'll share if asked...not embarrassed....just don't like to sound like a whiner is all), I lived in poverty for much of my youth.
Bear in mind, when the media talks about 'poverty', they are talking about an arbitrary income number assigned to a given family situation. Here is a chart I found:
http://aspe.hhs.gov/poverty/09poverty.shtml
I'd say that people that are living even up to $10K above these amounts are probably still struggling mightily.
by jamesrl
I think a large factor is where you live.
Big cities equal higher cost of housing, higher municipal taxes, less access to cheap fresh produce, etc.
Ontario did an experiment to pay for welfare families to move from big cities to small towns. They found they could have a much better standard of living with the same welfare cheque.
James
by notsochiguy
Different areas have higher costs of living, different access to public transportation (we never had a car growing up), better access to jobs of all levels, etc, etc. One of the reasons I'm not keen on the government 'guesstimate' of the poverty line is that the amount listed means far different things to someone in the greater NYC area than to someone in rural Iowa. If they broke it down by at least region, it would be more sensible, imho.
From my personal experience, I think it was better I was in the city. I was homeless for a span of a few months at one point, and suffice to say, it was rough. I think, though, it would have been exponentially worse had I been out in the burbs.
That's just my hunch. I don't plan on ever knowing for certain! ;)
by dmambo
But next year my oldest starts college. Despite having decent joint income, there's no way we will be able to pay what's expected. And our savings for it, which weren't nearly enough to begin with, got killed a year ago. Then there are 2 more, each a couple of years behind her.
I didn't come a well-to-do family, but we weren't poor. When I look at what's ahead, I think poverty is right around the corner.
But isn't that what all parents work for anyway? To spend money on our kids' futures? Hell, my grandparents crossed half a continent and an ocean to better their kids' lives. I just wish they invested in IBM in the 50's!
by jdclyde
apply for every grant and scholarship under the sun. There is a lot of money out there, you just have to look for it and be willing to fill out paperwork.
And no, it isn't all based on grades or income.
Having the twins go off to college at the same time (in two years) has me terrified. I don't expect the ex to step up and help at all, so it will fall right into my lap.
by tonythetiger
It's a category which presumes that every person has exactly the same needs.
While I have lived with less money than the government thinks I need. I have never been impoverished.
I'm just low maintenance :)
by boxfiddler
Wash the foliage with a mild concoction of dish soap and water. It won't hurt if a little bit of the concoction gets into the soil.
If that doesn't work, it's not mildew. A pic would help, in that case.
by jdclyde
and they will not only tell you what it is, but how to get rid of it.
Aren't a lot of the molds like that from over watering? (VERY limited exposure to all this, but my sis worked in a nursery for a few years, so was accidentally learning some of it.
by boxfiddler
by jdclyde
by boxfiddler
by nicknielsen
Our income when I was growing up was VA and Social Security survivors' benefits. I believe even back then that such income put a family of five below the poverty line.
Did we always have what we needed? Yes. Did we ever go hungry? No. Did we always eat what we wanted? No. Leftovers from Friday, Saturday and Sunday dinners were usually casserole for Monday through Thursday.
There's abject poverty, and then there's relative poverty.
Abject poverty - the lacking of basic human needs, such as food, water, and shelter - is practically nonexistent in the United States. Anyone in such a dire state of existence in the United States has any number of options available from which those basic human needs can and will be met; thus, abject poverty in the United States is nonexistent.
Poverty, as often (or always) cited in such stories, is based soley on personal income as reported to the IRS and/or by the Census Bureau statistics. This is relative poverty. I've often wondered if it included people who might have little or no income, live in a home that's paid for, and live comfortably off of savings or tax-free investments. I admit, I don't know; I haven't bothered to look that far into it, but my guess is yes. Or does it include those who actually choose to live the simplest lifestyle possible? Again, probably yes.
Moreover, those relative poverty percentages as often cited don't include any aid provided (federal, state, or local aid, or aid provided by private charity or personal help.) A family of 4 might have an income of only X (X = whatever the poverty number of the day happens to be - $14,000 per year, for example), but they live in subsidized housing, receive food stamps, etc. Their actual living conditions are head and shoulders above the [i]image of poverty[/i] most people conjure up when hearing the stories such as you cited.
Conclusion: Any [i]poverty[/i] statistics cited should be taken with the proverbial grain of salt - or seen in relative terms.
Have I ever lived in abject poverty? No, because there is no reason for anyone in the USA today to suffer under such conditions.
Have I ever lived in relative poverty? Sure I have. I've been so broke that I couldn't pay attention. I've had annual income in my life that fell well under the poverty threshold of the day.
Is living in relative poverty always a bad thing? I suppose it depends on the state of one's own mind. If [i]other people[/i] are [i]expected[/i] to improve one's own standard of living, then a such a person is probably forever destined to live under any defined poverty threshold (since it's a monetary number always on the rise). On the other hand, it's facing such personal circumstances that should be the impetus for a person to reach deep within one's self to improve one's own standard of living. Necessity is not only the mother of invention, but also an extremely strong motivator.
by jck
[i]Anyone in such a dire state of existence in the United States has any number of options available from which those basic human needs can and will be met; thus, abject poverty in the United States is nonexistent.[/i]
You haven't been to some parts of rural America.
Go to the old coal mining towns in WV or the steel towns in PA.
Some people don't have cars, can't afford a bus, it's too far to ride a bike, etc.
Getting to care/help isn't possible in some cases.
And, the local pastor isn't always willing to drive the welfare mom and her kids into the city 40 miles away to help them.
You overlooked it intentionally; for me, it was an oversight (not using it again when I repeated myself).
The full comment:
[i]Abject poverty - the lacking of basic human needs, such as food, water, and shelter - is practically nonexistent in the United States. Anyone in such a dire state of existence in the United States has any number of options available from which those basic human needs can and will be met; thus, abject poverty in the United States is nonexistent.[/i]
The word you conveniently (and intentionally?) overlooked: [i]practically[/i]
by purpleskys
by maecuff
Thanks!
My mother will be so proud. She still can't believe that I haven't killed them yet.
by nicknielsen
She first got a clipping when I was in first or second grade and left the plant there on a table in the center of the bay. Other than occasional re-potting, that's where it stayed for the rest of my Mom's life.
When I left home at 20, that cactus was four feet across. :0 And Mom was giving clippings off it until the day before she died. :_|
Still there, as far as I know. My stepfather's been taking care of it.
by purpleskys
by ontheropes
by jamesrl
When I was unemployed, I couldn't ask anyone for money. Not my parents or brothers, or inlaws.
But I had no problems asking my social and career network for job leads and ideas. In the end I found the jobs myself, but I was grateful for the slimmest lead.
I also didn't turn down the food charity from my wife's church, and I made sure we gave back what we got and then some when I got a job.
At my new job, I worked with the social committee and helped package and deliver food at Christmas. I saw my share of tears of joy, and proud people who were smart enough to accept, if only because the family was in need, not just the proud head of household.
James
by ontheropes
I slept in a mobile home without any utilities on a mattress on the floor. Nothing like waking up to rats running over you. I can't really recommend it.
I was at different shop doors the first thing every morning trying to get to talk to the foreman and talk myself into a job. I had one guy ask me to give him a bid to clean all of his shop windows and lights. I bid a ridiculously low price but I knew it would let me eat. He accepted and after I was done he said he liked the way that I worked and offered me a full time job. It was onward and upward from there, mostly.
I think that we all have a long story to tell.
One thing though, I don't feel that I owe anyone anything. Maybe that's not 'right' but that's how it is.
by jdclyde
the harder you work to better yourself, the less assistance is available from government sources.
Rather counter productive effects on a society. Intentionally?
by ontheropes
How do you do that?
by ontheropes
by av .
When I grew up, our family didn't have much, but we had a house and food. I came from a big family, so we lived very frugally and at times were just scraping buy. We had only 1 car and my father needed that for work, so mom and the kids walked everywhere.
It wasn't poverty, but it was a very simple, no-frills life. I'm thankful for that today because it taught me the value of things and to appreciate what I have.
I'm not surprised that the poverty rate is more than they thought. There are a lot of people out of work. Just in my family, there are 4 people out of work, living on severance or unemployment.
AV
by ontheropes
A woman contacted me via Facebook. She used to be my girlfriend in Kindegarten. :) She filled me in on what's happened to some of the old East Side Gang. Simpler times way back when I was in Elementary school. She said that Kindegarten was a very good year. :^0
Hearing from her brought back a flood of memories. A veritable deluge. Oh well. My Dad didn't mean to die. It just happened. Fifty eight and overweight, back in the days when they didn't do bypass operations.
Survived it. I believe that the important thing is that I'm pretty much at peace now.
by ontheropes
by ontheropes
Forgot. You know what my real name is too. Duh.
by ontheropes
Given the background that only I and some few others know about you, deputy, you say nothing to them.
Confronted, you are already behind the curve. When they start pulling your fingernails, which is before they start chopping off segments of your fingers, beginning with your littlest, don't bother looking for the door.
You ain't never leaving the room.
That's what I call impoverished.
You got nothing.
Over the course of years - and thousands of words and dozens (or perhaps hundreds) of messages, I've formed an opinion and image of jck - just like you've (and he's) formed an opinion and image of me.
Have you (or has he) done a study of me?
Your answer to my question could probably be my answer to yours.
Have a nice day.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=319455&messageID=3186129
Otherwise, your question is moot.
You come on way too strong.
Anyone familiar with offense knows, or should, that a strike invariably opens the striker to underhanded counterstrike.
Worse when the counterstrike is knowingly lethal.
Tone it down, please.
You are largely too good to kill.
If Ropes doesn't, I will.
by ontheropes
by ontheropes
True, fifty bucks means more to a single person than it does to an octo-mom but that's my uneducated, non-governmental definition. BTW-I said chit-chat not deep analysis of the poverty problems as defined by the US Governement or whoever determines poverty.
Right now I believe that there are people living in McMansions with 80K+ worth of cars in the driveway that have lost their jobs and are having to tap into their savings deeply every month just to keep up the facade. I may have more free money to spend each week/month/year than they do. People without savings and without jobs may not even qualify for SSY because they have too many assets. They may count themselves fortunate just to HAVE fifty bucks.
As you can clearly see, I'm not poverty expert. All I know is that when you don't/can't find something to eat, legally, for 4-5 days at a stretch it's likely that you're living at a poverty level. Having an extra fifty bucks per week will, of course, allow you to put money back so that one can buy an Internet connection and a computer. >tongue planted firmly in cheek<
by tonythetiger
[i]Having an extra fifty bucks per week will, of course, allow you to put money back so that one can buy an Internet connection and a computer. >tongue planted firmly in cheek<[/i]
Government has determined that high-speed internet is essential to life, and that everyone should have access :)
by tig2
I'm over 40. Of course I have been there, done that. I expect I will again at some point- possibly soon- in my life.
As long as I can still divide a can of cat food between me and the girls and we all come away feeling fed, who am I to complain?
Poverty in America will continue to be a problem until we figure out that insisting on living by arbitrary and often idiotic standards should define who needs what is stupid in the extreme. I had my greatest sense of peace when I had the least.
Personally, I wonder how ABC is defining poverty.
I should read the thread now, shouldn't I?
by tig2
I guess my point was that my definition of poverty has changed quite a lot recently. Living without money? That is actually pretty easy as long as you don't insist on having "things". I'm lucky. I don't insist and have few "possessions" that I give a rip about. My biggest worry is that I live with cats that like a standard of living that I may not always be able to provide.
The greater poverty? Losing those things that mere money can't buy. I may have a different perspective than some.
by ontheropes
Having been there, done that myself, I've had fears of it happening again. We now owe nothing on credit. Nada. That was my biggest concern, get the s**t paid off. Finally did. I'm less likely to be homeless in the forseeable future.
Worried about you ma'am.
by tig2
Even when I couldn't afford to feed me, I always found a way to feed them. I have a theory about that- my cats are my constant comfort. I have lived without cats and hated it. My Minou is an incessant cuddle kitty and Callie is a gentle sweetheart who is quite content as long as she can be where I am. They are an expression of unconditional love.
Poverty of spirit- of the essence of life- concerns me significantly more than a lack of money. Certainly, money makes many things easier. But money alone simply manages the physical needs. Being bereft of spirit is a greater concern to me. Losing the few people in my life that I count on is a greater loss than losing the roof over my head.
I'm doing okay. Some days are better than others but I guess I expected that to some extent.
by ontheropes
by ontheropes
by locolobo
At least that's how Mom explained it us kids back in the 60s. We did have a car, TV, radio, & washing machine. The washing machine was one of those older ones that had a "ringer", two counter rolling bars that pressed the liquid out. Caught my arm in that when I was young.
We ate meat a couple of times a week. Lived on beans, potatos, and veggies the rest of the week. We lived near the railroad tracks and were never so poor that Mom couldn't give some beans & potatos to the occasional hobo (they weren't homeless then).
I don't remember the times as being that bad, but do remember Mom crying herself to sleep sometimes. Some of that was because Dad was only home two or three nights a week. He was a truck driver.
by ontheropes
My wife and I lived 24/7 damn near 365 on the truck together. We spent more time together than many couples who've been married for years. She was my naviguesser and used a laptop and GPS to tell me where I missed my last turn. Kidding, mostly. She was very good and took her job very seriously. She never slept while the wheels were rolling but there were times when she was in the bunk and out before I even had my seatbelt off. Driving is a rough life.
by locolobo
by jamesrl
We had one till the mid 70s. We used to hang the laundry on the line. The dryer indoors was an amazing luxury when we got it. Hanging clothes in the winter meant wating for the right day to do laundry.
We didn't suffer for meat though. Dad had an arrangement with a local butcher, and we bought whatever was left over after market day, at a fixed price per pound. We wrapped it ourselves, most for the freezer. We also got chickens from our own shed, or from the neighbours. They were so much nicer than the chickens I can buy in the store these days. We ate well.
James
by locolobo
by nicknielsen
When I was in high school, I helped one of the local farmers during hayings. He had about 80 acres of alfalfa and could cut it usually twice a year, three times in a good year. I helped him with five hayings over two years. His son had a slaughterhouse. My pay each year was half a heifer–a couple hundred pounds of meat–cut and wrapped: roasts, steaks, chops, ground meat and sausages.
Got awful crowded in the freezer when the beans, peas and corn came in and my mom did the canning. We'd transfer most of it to my grandfather's freezer and still eat beef a couple times a week until there was enough room.
by notsochiguy
It's my way of putting the proverbial size 12 boot into my own @ss when I need a little motivation.
I am with you, though, on not owing anyone anything; except my wife and kids, of course. I owe them everything I have to make sure they never know what any of that was like.
by dmambo
by ontheropes
I found out that I don't need stuff, very little anyway. I used to think differently but I've grown up.
by dmambo
The worst thing that I have done for lack of money (as a starving college student, so not really in poverty at the time):
In order to cut my meal bill, I was kitchen manager at a fraternity house. After the traditional grilled cheese lunch on Friday, the cook dumped the leftover sandwiches in the trash. Later when I came in to clean up, and knowing that I had no money for food over the weekend, I pulled 6 of those sandwiches out of the garbage and ate them all weekend.
I was caught between a rock and a hard place. I did have about $5.00, but I needed that for beer for the weekend.
I don't want to make light of peoples' real suffering, but this memory is actually kind of funny to me now. Do others have any "happy" memories of when they were broke?
by jamesrl
After univeristy, the job market sucked, and I had a job doing telemarketing. It happened there were a number of us working together who were friends. My room (not apartment) was on the third floor of a house and had a decent balcony. We had a Risk boardgame, a radio and we would chip in for the cheapest wine we could find and play Risk and drink. It was fun.
I've not pulled food out of the garbage but I would if I had to. One of my university jobs was working at a theatre that showed midnight movies on weekends. We searched people to ensure they had no glass bottles, and if they had, they could abandon them with us, or not come in. We collected a fair amount of beer some nights. We didn't trust any bottles that were opened - so not much liquor. We would meet at someone's hosue after the show and consume the unopened beer.
James
by jck
your absolute statement at the end:
[i]Anyone in such a dire state of existence in the United States has any number of options available from which those basic human needs can and will be met; thus, abject poverty in the United States is nonexistent.[/i]
That's why I said what I said..."anyone" can't always get to those "options" you say make abject poverty non-existent.
Sorry, but I can find you some damn impoverished people who can't walk or bike or skateboard or steal a horse to go to the local food stamp office, can't call, and don't have a neighbor who can help.
..... which is the state of living without the basic necessities of life: clean drinking water, adequate food, basic shelter, people dying of disease and contamination, widespread malaria and malnutrition, orphaned children roaming the streets, and so on - that's the [i]image[/i] most likely to be conjured up when people hear about poverty statistics.
That state of [i]abject poverty[/i] IS practically nonexistent in the United States - as well as in many developed nations around the world. We almost need a two different words to describe the two different states of living; abject poverty and relative poverty don't seem to be adequate, especially since the adjective (abject or relative) is often (or always) omitted.
The World Bank (whose goals include reducing world-wide poverty) actually list 124 nations in which some percentage of the population lives in abject poverty. The United States is not on the list; nor is your adopted home-nation of Ireland; nor are many others.
Poverty in the Congo:
Poverty in Cambodia:
http://www.pillowsforpeace.org/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/04/village-shot.jpg
Poverty in the United States:
Poverty in any one of the World Bank's 124 listed nations: A person survives on less than $1 per day.
Poverty in the United States: A person who earns less than $10,000 per year, or a family of eight with household income under $41,000.
http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/poverty/povdef.html
http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/poverty/threshld/thresh08.html
Thus, I stand by my comment: That state of [i]abject poverty[/i] is nonexistent in the United States - practically or otherwise.
And I think I adequately proved my point. If you want to try to prove otherwise, knock yourself out, but do it in a rebuttal with substance and proof, not just your usual rhetoric.
by jck
You go from stating:
That anyone living in "abject poverty" as you defined it within the borders of the United States can get help, and that therefore makes it non-existent.
to:
The United States itself is not a state in abject poverty as a whole.
Two different points, Max.
I go back to your [b]original[/b] statement, and say it's bull$hit.
As for your follow-up, of course the USA is not like Cambodia, Zaire, Sierra Leone, or Cote d'Ivore.
We are a civilised, industrial nation with a fully formed and operational infrastructure.
Those are third-world countries, some of whom are in the middle of long term civil war.
Nonetheless, you went from making a point about anyone in abject poverty in the USA...to pointing out we are not a nation where abject poverty is the state of our nation.
Two wholly different points.
Again, I call BS on your first point and ignore your second point because it had nothing to do with your original statement that I was pointing out the inaccuracies of.
Thanks though.
by jck
If a person wants to quit smoking, he would do better by avoiding those who smoke.
If a person wants to quit drinking, he would do better by avoiding the bars.
If a person wants to maintain a positive mental outlook on life, he would do better by avoiding those who drip with negativity.
If a person wants to overcome personal obstacles and hardships, he would be better to avoid those who say it can't be done.
If a person wants to be a victim, he would do better by avoiding me - because I will maintain there's absolutely no good reason for it.
What's that old saying about birds of a feather?
by ontheropes
when you're perfect in every way.
I can't wait to look in the mirror
'cuz I get better looking each day.
To know me is to love me.
I must be a hell of a man.
Oh Lord it's hard to be humble
but I'm doing the best that I can.
by tonythetiger
by jck
You can't see the difference in two statements you made.
Typical.
A person in a state of abject poverty, and the state of a country being abjectly impoverished are two wholly distinct, seperate things.
A person can be in "abject poverty" in a wealthy country, such as impoverished families in rural America who live in sheds with no doors, no power, no water, etc.
A country can have total abject poverty for its population and still have wealth. Look at some of the countries in Africa, where the dictator/leader is a millionaire yet the people are all starving.
But, your first topic statement was absolutely off.
Your follow-up was of delineating the state of the whole nation being in abject poverty (which we obviously are not), rather than what you asserted in your prior post which was that "anyone" within the USA being able to get away from their abject poverty (which is not always the case) and that makes it non-existent (which it isn't).
I never said our whole country was, or even compared in its state to 3rd world countries.
I just said it's BS that anyone can get out of abject poverty here.
That's just not the case.
Trending Desktop posts
Sort by Trending