Discussion Locked

Paper Certifications?

0 helpful
312 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Good day,

Certifications should only be available to IT professionals who are currently employed in the IT environment for at least two years -- maybe more.

It should be a "Professional Certification" to enhance the already established IT professional's credentials.

It should not be a paper thingy.

How would you like to go to a "certified" nurse practitioner who has NEVER touched a patient? or a "certified" Public Accountant who has never ran the books of a company?

Get real you IT people out there!

We all let the money people BS us into diluting our only professional certifications down to the point where they are now almost meaningless.

Shame on us.

Greg
Micro Computer Coordinator

312 replies

by theq

I agree with your point here. I wouldn't want a nurse practioner who has never touched a patient, practicing on me! They might inadvertantly cut out my spleen.

I however also disagree with you. Sometimes the certifications are a way into IT field. Cert first, experience later. Althought it is better to get the experience, then the cert. Take A+ for example, I recently got my A+, if there was a minimum requirement of being proffesional for 2 years, I would never have been able to get my cert. as all my experience is at home. I haven't worked for an IT company yet, so I have no credentials, other than the A+ cert now.

Most certifications are a standard piece of paper saying that you know how to perform a certain task, wether your a pro or not! A certifiation gets dilute, and loses it professionalism as the market gets more and more populated with MCSE, CNE, CCNA, etc...

It is a scary thought that there are people out there that have certs that dont know a damn thing about computers, but we have to give them a chance. How can they prove themselves and enhance the knowledge behind the cert, unless given the chance? Home knowledge doesnt cut it anymore.

-Mark Carman

by jbane

Certification for those of us who learned everything we know at home is the only way to get recognized in the IT industry. There are plenty of us home geeks that know our S*** and to say that you need 2 years experience in a professional IT envirment is BS. That is out only avenue of acceptance anymore. Home experience counts for nothing these days.

by walterzalewski

Having different levels of certification might be better, say you have one group of certifications for those without experience. Then another for those with a certain amount of experience.

Everyone has to keep in mind that certification means only one thing, that the person received training in a particular area. Only foolish employers are going to hire someone with only a certification and no working experience in a high level position. However, it is a good way of getting your foot in the door(entry level), as everyone has to start somewhere. Otherwise, how do you get that 2 yrs. experience if you can't even start.

by mesager

Home experience *shouldn't* count. There's a reason for that - it's impossible to simulate or gain the experience one obtains in a month working professionally in a year at home - no matter how many toys you have. I learned on my own, at homw, with a network, for 2 years before I got an IT job - and the only things I took with me were an intimate knowledge of a computer's internal systems (still useful in these days of cheap parts and plug & play, but not as much as it was) and superficial networking knowledge. I am now an experienced IT pro, running a department with 10 engineers, and I could care less if you have a certification - doesn't tell me anything other than that you know how to pass a test. What you're missing in your analysis are all the little, forgotten things that you can only learn by doing - how to deal with users, why this driver version is unstable in that configuration, dealing with the pressure of having to fix things by yesterday...no way you get that at home.I'll *never* hire another engineer without considerable field experience; it's just asking for trouble. Do it for free if you have to, I don't care - but get experience if you want to work in this field.

by diplomat1

Its the old argument of which came first; the chicken or the egg. People who complain about "paper certs" seem to forget that a degree in some fields is pretty much the same thing. It basically signals a level of theoretical knowledge which is thebasics a person need to enter a particular profession.

Having spent time at University doing Computer Science, I fail to see how that degree does not count as a paper cert. No amount of coding in class can prepare anyone for the realities of thereal world. What a "paper cert" does is to open the door for the possibility of bigger and better things. It does not guarantee anything more than my driving a BMW makes me a better or experienced driver.

All of us had to start somewhere. Noneof us came into this world tattoed with experience. Someone gave us a chance when we knew zilch so I have no problems with people spending their money to give themself a chance in a profession. Whether or not they will make it is another matter.
There are good and bad in every profession regardless of how much hands on experience was involved in the training. Doctor's mistakes still end up being buried - literally - so it is hypocritical for us to think that all IT pros are very good at what they do. I hardly think so.

I say that "paper cert" bashers should take a chill pill. Even with the paper, the people having them still have to walk the walk. Only those who really know what they are doing will survive. As for me, I reallywouldn't worry about it. Technical skills can be taught. It is the other intangibles - good customer service, being positive, etc. - that are often very difficult to find.

Take a deep breath everyone. We all started at Ground Zero or did youall forget that at one point we really knew nothing about IT?

Diplomat1

by arg cio

But "Technical skills can be taught"? MY A$$!!!!! okay, BASIC skills can be taught.. to trouble shoot a loss of network connectivity ping localhost, ping local IP, ping gateway, etc. if something fails, swap it with something that works, until it works again. But, the network is a little flakey, oh, well, just replace that Cisco 7206 router (with one of the 20 or so just laying around), and go! RIGHT!!! I hate it when people say, "technical skills can be taught." THAT IS BS, and everyone knows it! There is a special skill in troubleshooting issues effectively. (i.e. you can access the file server, but not the internet.hmmmm.do you really need to ping the localhost?) To do it fast, effective, and efficiently takes creativity, and THAT cannot be taught! Good customer service skills can be taught, but the positive attitude cannot. Be polite, that can be taught. Never blame the customer(but sometimes to be good, you need creativity.), or make them feel bad about it. SO, okay basic tech. skills can be taught, but you can't teach someone how to be good or how to excel at it! AND intermediate CS skills can be taught, but you can't teach someone how to be excellent at it. You can teach them a lot further in CS!

by cschauf

I agree somewhat here, but you have to agree that for some wierd reason, employers will look more closely at someone with a cert over someone with experience. At least it used to be that way. I think that is changing somewhat though. Employers are aware that there are a lot of paper CNEs out there.

Chad

by paasch

What are IT jobs all about? solving problems.
You can train a rat. but you cant train a rat to solve problems. 50% of all these paper people never go into IT. They heard they could make alot of money. They never realized you had to work for it. I dont waste my time or money going to any schools. I just sit down and fix it, do it, resolve it. whatever it takes. Sooooo I make alot of money because I solve problems. Who cares what paper crap people have? People care about who gets results!!!!!!! Quit whining. Get results get recognized. Forget certs. forget if your home trained. Show them by doing. Dont get me started on this wally whiner stuff guys. If companies dont want you. Start your own.

by trebligb

Minor point you overlooked..... If you have no education, little experience, etc how do you plan to get the opportunity to show that you are a problem solver?

Also, if you are a small business would you hire some dude with no credentials to maintain your network and computers? No.

by ssegro

You can work in you basement on computers all day long and really know you stuff but without that little piece of paper showing me that you realy DO know something, you won't be touching my computers or my network. If you want a job working on my network you better have a cert or 2 just to get me to interview you.

I'm a Network Administrator and hold the following Certs: MCSE,MCP+I,A+,Net+,CNA. I worked hard to get where I'm at and I love what i do and would expect the same from anyone Iwould hire.

by nettek

Theq has a point. Sometimes certifications are the easiest way - or perhaps the only way - to break into the field. I broke into the field by going to a technical school. Upon graduation, I received a "certificate" in Network Engineering and Data Communications. It was by attending that school and getting that "certificate" that I was able to get an entry level position. I now have a few years of experience, and I am now running a multi-server, multi-site network. I am now currently studying for a "manufacturers" certification.

What is annoying are those people who paid a significant sum of money to take a cram course and receive a CCNA, MCSE, CNE, etc., without ever touching a network.

I can only hope that the IT Managers of the world have some degree of intelligence, and would higher someone with my credentials as opposed to someone with little or no experience but who has a "paper" certification.

by cst1268

So what are you saying? That it was ok for
you to break into the field with a cert and
no experience, but not the next guy?

PS: Cert's sure don't seem to be the easiest
way to break into the field - employers want
EXPERIE

by ess pee

Certs like a bachelors degree shows that an individual has the ability to learn. A Cram MCSE cert shows that an individual has the ability to learn in an technical environment. That is what employers are looking for.

by comptech3

I made a career change almost 3 years ago from motorcycle mechanic to computer technician. I had been dabbling in it as a hobby at home, so I decided to make the change.

I'm currently attending junior college part-time to get my AAS in Network Admin. My opinion is that certs will eventually expire so that new ones can be "sold" to the public, but my degree will never expire.

I maintain a computer lab with 54 desktops and a server. I find that what I learn on the job helps me in school and vice versa. There is no better teacher than getting your hands dirty.

I can see the point where getting certified will probably let someone be at least familiar with concepts, but there are some things you just will not be able to pick up in theclassroom.

by dcal

I have read many good points from both sides of this discussion. As a "wallpaper" certification holder personally, I say this...I paid over $10k to get my MCSE. Courses were about 2 weeks long, 4 hours every night of the week. Alot of time was invested, not to mention the $. I felt it was necessary to invest this time and money to "get my foot in the door." Yes I am a convert from a former career.

I have achieved 1/2 of the exams needed for the MCSE. Will I succeed in passing the rest? They are tough exams...for those vets without certs, take them, see if you can pass...if so, then that will be the true testament to whether or not experience is the only thing needed to attain the job. If you can't pass them, then there is something to be said for us who made an effort to "self-improve"

With that said, I must admit that my certificatiosn are just that, CERTIFICATIONS. I got a start in tech support because of the certs i had at the time. After 6 months, I landed a realgood job with a start up internet company in western NY area. I have NOT used any of the knowledge I learned in preparing for any of the exams, in either of the 2 jobs I have held in the IT field. Were the certs worth it? I say yes and No...yes because I was fortunate enough to get a real good job, 6 months into my new career in IT. I say NO because I spent a TON of money for certifications I haven't used, and most likely won't use because they are expiring come 01-01-2001.

For those thinking about taking the plunge and spending that proverbial TON of money, take heed, DON'T do it, unless you have the discretionary income. Take some classes, do some self studying, get that first job and go from there. Don't believe the Hype thatcertifying will increase your salary...experience is a needed and valuable attribute.

by snowie

Thanks for the input. Personally, I am new to this field. I have been working with a vast field of very knowledgeable IT people. Many are not certified. There is no substitute for experience and schooling. Certification would mean more if it was a "hands on" situation instead of "memorize and choose" the correct answer. I have come in contact with many "certified" people--depending on the individual--for many it is just a piece of paper.

Bottom line--I don't care about becoming certified. Once you enter this field, and you are faced with situations, believe me no cares about how many "papers" you have hanging on your office wall--all they want are results and they want them yesterday.

by mike.clemmer

I hold several hardware certifications from an organization call ISCET (www.iscet.org). They have an associate level certification program for students and graduates with less than 4 years of combined field experience and training. They have journeyman exams for those with 4 or more years of experience in a specific of dicipline. They also have a continuing education program. This is one approach.

by rctv

Hello All,

I would say I have to agree with all posts here so far. I can see both points of view. The experienced IT people dont want "paper holders" to just jump into positions that are higher up the scale without paying some dues. The "paper holders" want to get those good jobs if possible.

My current position is probably not a good one. Been in the Auto Repair business as a technician for 22 yrs. Driveability and electronics my area. Also ran my own part-time electronics shop for 10 yrs. Am a computer novice and have built 10 personal systems. Want to quit the Auto end of things and get into the "computer age". At my level, employers would laugh at me if i applied for thieir jobs(justly so). I'm 40 yrs old and have a mortgage anda family. My plan is to go to the tech school and take what they call their "A+" classes. This is suppose to prepare you for the A+ exam. Its 1 semester long. After that, the college is now a Cisco Certified Training Center and have the CCNA available in a 4 semester course. I plan on taking that next.They claim its alot of hands on training and say they're setting their student goals high. Thats supposed to mean they will make it tough to pass. I dont see any other way for me to have a chance in this envioronment. Employers want certifications and experience.
In my situation,(mortgage & family) I can only give them one. Keeping my current job to pay the bills and school at night gets me the paper but not much experience. Providing you havent stopped reading this being mad, what would a projected salery be in the Midwest area (Omaha,NE.) for someone certified but not much experience? I'm sure thats tough to answer. I hope i didnt anger any of you(espically with experience) but this is my situation. Thanks for any feedback.

Roger Carnell

by jpw6466

Interesting comments, associating doctor's with IT pro's, but since that pandora's box has been opened, we'll run with it. I have had numerous discussions with graduate Doctors and if in a crowd, they are quick to brag on their obtaining their degrees and their prospective national licenses. Set aside, they are all scared s^%&less and will tell you so, confident that they can do the job but know that they could use some seasoning and some real world experience. Anyone else seeing any parallels? Microsoft, Cisco, etal all are not wrong in putting out vendor certs, realize that just obtaining them is not a complete package, but is an integral part nonetheless. The IT industry is not that different than any industry. nearly everyone that is in a position of ability is quite forgetful about the time they spent screwing up, asking questions, looking redfaced, asking again, sometimes the same question. Guess what, Microsoft, Cisco, etal have entrusted me with certification that I canpresent to a perspective employer that says, hey, I can LEARN this job, what do you need? Can I or anyone walk into a new network and know it cold, doubtful. Can anyone learn by certs the particular problems that their network has, its personality, limitations, NO.
So back off a little seasoned vets, we don't want your job, we want A JOB!!

love to hear replies
jpw6466@swbell.net

by rzan

I would have to agree 100% with mnay of the previous comments. Certifications have become more of an embarrasment than a prestige, as more and more ambitious and clueless idiots are passing exams and getting a cert. They heard somewhere that getting a cert will raise your salary by $30K or so, but what they didn't hear is that without experience, you won't get anything. The IT industry is being soiled by people who memorize answers to a specific exam and whalla...here is your cert. Put these same people in front a real server that is experiencing problems and you will see how quickly they panic and freak out because they didn't learn a thing about troubleshooting. I have seen a negative attitude towards certified professional as I have been looked upon potential new employers as another paper cert. They grilled me with such off the wall technical questions that only someone with experience could have answered them. In a way, I am glad they are doung this to weed out the real pros from the phonies. Cert exams need to be harder and nothing substitutues for real world experience, even if you have to build a network at home to play with. If you are serious about IT, you will invest a lot of your own time and $$$$ to learn asmuch as you can.

by chris

I commend you on your effort to better yourself in a new career. I too have a family I am supporting while attending school for my CCNA. I will have my CCNA and CCDA in March, the A+ certification is not very impressive, check out the CompTia Network +. This will help you with your CCNA. As far as "Paper Certificatons" just do what you feel is right, and get arrogant. Study hard, ask tons of questions, and don't listen to any negative S*** from anyone. I am still in school, and I help support a University campus. There are over 300 PC's, 3 NT servers, 1 Linux server, 1 Real Server. With my Paper Certification, I have a job, and working part time in Idaho, I am making 22,000 a year. After Graduation (Associate of Applied Science) Ianticipate making 30 to 40 G to start. In the midwest, you should make more. (Cost of living in Idaho 600 mo, for a 4 bedroom house). Get your certs, find anyone who will give you experience, (phone tech is a good place to start 20G yr.)then moveinto a good job.

When asking for a job, it only takes one yes to make a difference, keep asking untill you hear a yes.

by bullheaded

I have the same problems that you do. I am 40+ years old and want desperately to get out of my present career. So, I began investing thousands of dollars and hours of my "free" time to earn (yes, earn) my MCSE, MCP+I and A+ paper certifications. I can't afford to quit my current job to take an $8/hour job to gain experience. My family would starve. However, the potential employers that had the decency to personally respond to my applications an resumes for entry-level positions rejected me because I have no experience in the field. How about that for a "Catch 22". No experience = no job and no job = no experience. Any suggestions?

by darbizu2

Got to start somewhere and I think you are on to it. Not sure what the going rate of pay happens to be up in that part of the states but I am sure someone will give you a shot if you show desire and willingness to learn. You might try finding a small computer store that needs some extra help putting systems together and fixing them. This will give you not only some insight but that needed experience. You can work for free (God forbid) for them to gain thier knowledge and in return they will teach you the thing's you might want to learn. Only a suggestion and it might not work for you while you are going to school and working a job to pay the bills. Maybe on the weekends or on your night off spend them at the store learning the trade. It worked for me and now I am part owner of a store here in the Dallas area in Texas.Got to start somewhere and making that first step is the hardest. Good luck and hope you fair well.Ken co/Owner of CCSI Computers in Garland,Texas.

by arg cio

$25,000 - $30,000 in the NE area without any experience, but with certification. It also depends on what school you go to for this (I assume it's Metro), and what other graduates of that school have proven. If serveral IT grads from that school are slackers, and have pissed away a schools rep. it is almost useless. But, if a company got a couple of GREAT IT people, you could be a shoe in for entry level IT. Keep at it, and watch the public sector for jobs. They hire low level people to train, and do special jobs.

by kvedaa

Greg,

You are obviously confused, but that is all right most people are. Many CPA have never touched the books for a real business. Many of my friends took and passed their CPA exams coming out of school, before landing a job with a 'real company'. As for a mandatory amount of time working in IT, there is no point to it. If someone does not get it, a year, two years or ten is not going to help that person. I have worked with 'techs' that have been at it for 6 years or more that I would not let within 10 feet of one of my machines.

Are some certifications a joke, yes! But a lot of people who complain about them are people who are not willing to spend the time to really learn the subject. Certification does not equal experience, but then again experience in and of itself does not equal knowledge. And as with all else, those who have it all are in a better position than anyone else.

by zk

I agreed that certification should not be a paper thingy. But, I won?t whine about all the papers (yet PRETENDING, as experts) out there. Without them, real gurus like you won't stand out. You should thank them. Because those are the ones who'll come begging like dogs when networks crash.

To the people who just want to learn, have fun, and make some bucks, who cares what whiners say. 9 out of 10 of them don't have certs anyway.

To the people who just want an entry into the field, welcome.Don't pay attention to some old bones, they whine because they're too slow to keep up. There are more than enough jobs. Mostly, they spent half their lives installing hard drives in repair shops. Yeah, they got 20 (wow!) years of IT experience. Great! But, it is time to retire grandpa.

Some questions I just wonder.

If two years is a requirement, how come I am billing $$$ (note 3 digits) to fortune 500 clients with one year of experience, at the age of 22. Yes, I got two bachelor degrees, one minor, and yes, with honors, did them in 2.5 years. Certs? I got more than my biz card can fit.

If home learning doesn't count, how come I got more routers than some of my client companies (with over 500 employees) got?

If years of experience matter, how come the senior network admin at SPRINT is only 19? He can't be born with computers, can he? Have you seen his basement with over 2 dozen computers, half a dozen switches, and half a dozen routers?

By stating merely the years, you've left out many important factors, intelligence, talent, attitude, motivation and dedication in learning. And the most important thing is something we called brain, they?re not created equal, in case people haven?t noticed.

by zk

Here?s a joke. Right after college no company would even interview (let alone hire) me 'coz I can't seem to pass the hr bs and the experience crap. Now, I'm laughing all the way to the bank. I won?t work for these companies now even it they beg me. Yes, they have. Some of my clients don't know that, I, the system/network guru as they now called, was the same punk, who applied one year ago and got his resume trashed. Talking about ridiculous! HR? Where do you see yourself in 10 years? On the beach, rich, retired, while you ugly people are slaving your b*tts off. Hahaha. Funniest of all, my minor is human resource management. I don?t ever remember my professors training us to be the way HR people are now.

If any HR people read this, recite this every night before bedtime ?Interviewing skill is NOT the same skill necessary to do the job. While, I?m asking the candidate, strength, weakness crap, my company?s network is crashing and some consultants are coming in and ripping my companyoff.?

One more note before I depart peacefully, one more advice to HR people. Get your tech facts straight before asking your candidates embarrassing questions like ?do you know HTLM?? or posting ads like ?10 years of NT experience?. Candidates, please, please, when you?re asked if you have 10 years of Internet experience, tell them you invented the fr**king TCP/IP protocol back in the seventies. Avoid HR like a plague.

To the new people, hang in there. Take the craps with a grain of salt. Everybody starts somewhere. People will know eventually how good you are. Peace, and merry X?mas.

by rzan

I have to agree with the comments about HR. HR are nothing more than a bunch of stupid and technically ignorant morons who will aim at nothing than to get you a below market value salary. They will post salaries which they can't even come close tooffering for a particular position. They will also ask you off the wall questions which don't even apply to your position. For instance, I once went on an interview for a Novell Admin position, and they were asking me stupid crap like if I knew C++ and Java? HR, get your sh*t together and learn the techno jargon. I am not a programmer, I am a network engineer for crying out loud.
And here is what REALLY PISSES ME OFF. I go to the interview representing myself as a professional, only to have HR play bargaining games when it comes to salary. What HR must realize is that we aren't secretaries or clerks, we are technical professionals who deserve to be paid market value, and if you employers can't pay up, then shut up and stop your campaign of misrepresenting IT positions for which you can't shell out the pay.

by theq

You took alot of cracks at people here. But you do have some good points and some bad ones.

Your right when the server crashes the paper holders are the ones that will come running to the real professionals. Unfortunately the are taking up needed space for the real professionals at the moment. Unfortunately, I happen to be a paper holder, but for some specific reasons that I explained earlier in the discussion. ( you have a mouse, click and scroll to the beginning.

Old bones, Get out, let us get some experience. Or at least put in a good word with HR department and hire us as apprentices.

Two years isn't a requirement, but it would be good experience. Where did you get the money to get more routers and certs than your biz card can hold? Mommy and Daddy? Certs take money, money that most people in the US are busting their a$$ off to make, and dont see a penny of. I am 19, and neither on my own or with my parents help would I be able to go for a cert anytime soon.

Asfor the SPRINT kid, he probably knew someone up on the ladder. Parents are probably long time employees/managers for Sprint(meaning they have money to give little johnny to get his certs).

Your right everyones Brain isn't created equal. We all learn at a different pace, and in a different way? Didn't pschology teach you that? BTW, Intelligence, Talent, Atittude, Motivation, and Dedication all START from the brain.

by zk

Pardon me, if I offended anybody, I'm just sharing my view. As far as papers taking up space, I thought IT got more space than people. Don't see a penny? try 50% income tax here.

I don't mean it literally for elders to get out. What I meant was instead of bashing newbies for taking good jobs, help them. Most attitude was "hey, I've paid my dues, let the kids boil in hell (these young arrogant little bastards)." Remember the kind souls who helped you when you were green? Good, your turn.

You've achieved certs at 19, congrats, good work. I'm not the one bashing papers. I did stress, people who PRETEND to be experts, didn't I?

My parents weren't Gates. I've flipped burgers, happily, during my whole 2.5 yrs of college. I had a weekenddelivery job too, 4-3am. Now for routers, yes, my fulltime burger (nutrition prep engineer) career during college paid for 75% of my current equipment and two of my certs. See what a $100 a month of sweat saving can do. In my entire 2.5 years at college, I DID NOT have a life. Nobody said life is easy. And yes sir, when you're p*ss poor, you better be smart or try hard. Mentioning all the degrees and certs isn't about my IQ ('coz mine isn't quite there). But, how HARD I've tried. Nobody has ever called me smart a$$ before, it makes me feel smart. No sarcasm. Thanks.

As for the kid, I was making a point that age (as most people seem to equate with exp, worse yet, knowledge) isn't an issue. BTW, he has NO cert and is a high school drop out. Degree, certs, exp;yrs;age, doesn't matter. What matter is how good you're. Do whatever it takes to be good. You don't need justifications for getting your certs. It's not anyone's business.

If 2 yrs exp is required for certs, how about 60 yr old IT grandpas making the requirement, 40 yrs? All of you under 45 won't have certs anymore. Cool, we have the real pros now.

I took the road less traveled, & I'm glad. Cheers!

by hekkletekk

...an a MCNE, an a MCSE, an a CCNE, an a PhDMB* fore 9 yeer. Plus I invented Netware and the copper and fiber cable that the Al Gore Internet runs on.
No, seriously, I think I know you zk - Are you "Don't Ask Me I'm Just a Bottle Pusher" from Manhattan? (If that is nonsense to you, I've mistaken you for somebody else. Sorry.)

Have you noticed comments posted on these Paper vs Experience discussions are Xx as long as those posted to a technical forum?

*Doctor of Monkey Business

Peace/Love/Dove - Grampa CNE MCNE CDE MCP

by zk

Sorry, I don't have a slightest clue what you're talking about.

"Noticed about Paper vs Experience are Xx..." What is Xx as long as those posted to a technical forum? You mean longer comments? Man, I feel like I need two more shots.

One thing I know is, I might have the same alias as somebody else. I kind of remember seeing one.

by dpx2066

I am that guy with midrange experince. The certifications help round me out. I got the certification because I was being left behind. I am the guy who can get things done with a limited amount of help. I am also that guy who cant afford to pay for all of the training that is available. However, I do believe in self improvement by any means necessary. I purchase alot fo books and set up a lot os lost cost servers and workstation to get the job done. So to those who have the certs but no experince need to do what it takes to get it and stop being dead weight.

by ramy naguib

Dear Greg;
I agree with you but it is almost imposible to restrict access to exam certification for un experienced people.
What we can request is for the exams to be more focused on hands on experience,after all I believe it is practicaly imposible for any accountant to pass the CPA without a previuos experience.

by clarinis

I personally was going to a technical school to earn my MCSE, CCNA and MCDBA. I was aslso working 30 hours a week at an IT firm to put into practice what I was learning. If the exams were restricted based on experience, then I wouldn't have had the job as they were looking form some Certification before I was hired. Without the job, I may have beena paper MCSE, no experience, et cetera.
How can you justify limiting exams to the experienced ones? How about just changing the exams to includemore practical that would require expeience to have learned?

Comments are welcome.

by mm212

I've found that to get an entry-level position, you NEED some certs. By passing the exams, you have shown that you have some basic knowledge and can be trained to do the job. Once you've had a year or two experience, certs are less important and youmay be able to skip upgrading your certs except those in which you don't have a lot of experience.

I know of one person (know OF him, don't know him personally) who took the MS NT4 Workstation exam 5 times before passing. He got fired from his first two jobs because he could only pass the tests, couldn't actually do anything. This shows that you can get an entry-level job by passing cert exams, but to keep a job and advance, you need to really get to know it.

by wizbones

Allot of opinions running rampant. Thought I'd add my two cents. I have no certs. I took some mail in class way back when to learn some VERY basic stuff when I bought my first computer (8088) Have learned a great deal as my systems grew and personalexperience grew. Anyhow, I got into an entry level position many years later by just pure determination. I am home learned and do not have much as far as paper education goes (HS Dropout as I've been labled). They wouldn't even talk to me, because of this. Well as I said I just kept at it. Finally after two weeks of faxing my res' and calling they "let" (begged me to stop calling and faxing) me come and take a "test" for which I aced, and an Interview which I landed the job. That was several years ago, today I am still in the field and have much to learn. This industry much like all of you said is a rapid industry and requires constant learning and training. How you learn it doesn't matter. If you can't get in because of paper then there'sa problem in my opinion. I am more of a hands on person. Classrooms are very slow and well yes boring! Give me the job and I'll get it done is my attitude as are many others. I believe in Certs but they shouldn't be the factor in employment. Many bookworms out there do not have enough common sense to change a flat tire much less resolve IT issues. So my faith in the school system we have in place is not a high one, whether it be HS or College level. Ok so I added 4 cents worth. Keep it real, and always remember the effective range of an excuse is zero point zero meters. Good luck to all.

by theq

Employeers should grill prospect employees to weed out the pros from the phonies. I dont think that the exams need to be harder(from what I hear the MCSE is pretty hard all ready, correct me if I am wrong MCSE's.) Employeers should be more selective. Unfortunately with a lack of IT proffesionals, Employeers can't be pickie with who they hire. The US just increased the number of VISA's for foreign technology professionals.

Playing with a home network is alot different than playing with buisness networks. A home network you have allot more control over so you really wouldn't get the real world experience with it. Sure you will know how to put together a network, but how many home networks do you know of that suffer problems from HEAVY traffic?

-Mark

by lanman235

As an IT professional of 12 years and the manger of an IT department I look at certs this way. I was an auto mechanic for ten years. I had to work as a professional mechanic for 2 years before I could get my ASE certification. IT Pros should work for two years too. I did not have a cert to get an entry level position. I went to technical school and still continue my training. I have been to CCNA, MSCE, CNA, A+ and Checkpoint training but have never taken a test.

When I hire someone I look for a minimum of two years experiance or 1 year exper with an MCP or CCNA depending on what I am hiring. Certs ARE JUST A PEICE OF PAPER but tell me that a person has the initiative to study and take tests. I do not hold them as gospel and have a tendancy to discount them because most certified persons want more money than they are worth, have no exper and paid alot of money for training that gave them nothing.

The questions in the interview process should weed out the bad ones.

by jgasher

MS, Cisco, and Novell (are they still around?) don't want the certifications to be too hard to obtain because every MCP, CCNA, and CNA are essentially unpaid salesmen for the company that certifies them.

NT Server 4.0 is a very easy exam. MS says they don't like paper certifications, but they also benefit tremendously from the newbie that just got his certification on NT Server, because that is what they will want to use.

Paper certifications are will be with us forever. I just taught a Cisco class at an ATEC and have already received several emails from students passing the CCNA with no experience. Is this a bad thing? I don't think so. Any employer worth working for knows that experience counts more than certs. Do I get job offers because of my certifications alone? No. I get job offers because I have experience and certifications show that I've taken initiative to measure myself with my peers.

As much as it looks like it, being certified is not like being in a club. If you want to be in a club, go start one yourself. People whining about inexperienced people getting certified should realize that certification may someday be like a high school diploma or an electricians license. The more people certified the better. That means that our field is finally being taken seriously by more than just a devoted few.

Heck, maybe if enough people get certified my parents will understand what I do.

by theq

I didn't mean to offend you by posting my reply. The tone of the whole message was that of an attack. I was just looking for clarification of your views. Thanks for explaining where your coming from. BTW you remind me of my best-friend. He and Iget along like this.

by chris r

Your statement is correct, But I do not believe that there isnt problem with this system, If people want to waste time gaining Qualifications when they could be gaining experience, let them It means there is more well paying Quality jobs out there for the rest.
In reality any good employer or Client will value Experience over Certifications.

by nicks

I understand your point, and it is depressing how the certs no longer mean that you are better than the average techie. However, in my case, I needed the cert to start my career. I had been a network hobbyist for years, but with no professional experience, the only way anyone would hire me was if I had a certification. If we restrict certifications to those who have been IT pros for years, then it would be nearly impossible for anyone to start out. You wouldn't be able to get the job without a cert, but couldn't get the cert without the job. The value of certifications is lacking because of the swarm that they have caused, and there is not a whole lot anyone can do about it.

by gherkin

A degree is not the same thing as a cert. A degree shows that you can learn. A person with a degree usually has spent several years learing concepts and applying those concepts.

All a Cram cert shows is that you can memorize questions and the answers. That does not indicate learning potential or an ability to operate in a technical environment. It does not equate to understanding, only regurgitation.

by chris

If that is true, a degree shows that a student has memorized enough information to satisfy their professor, for years. So individuals with degree's are seasoned manipulators.

This makes no sense. A person with a degree can have no working experience with a network, yet why are degree's viewed as being superior? Either way, you have to have knowlege of the the product you are being certified in. While someone may not be good at terminiating wires, they may be efficent at troubleshooting aserver. Every person has their niche. In the diverse Computer Support/Networking field you cannot be everything, there is too much.
In every field the Vets do not like the fish(newbies) it takes time for the fish to gain respect.
This argument of "Paper Certifications" is another way to single out someone you fear, or do not like.

If you disagree with "Paper Certifications" so much, do something about it. Hire a "Paper MCSE CCNA CNE MCP CCDA A+ Network +" and teach them how to be a Guru like you. Then tell them to teach someone else how to be a Guru like you. Maybe they will build you a statue out of IC's in your honor.

by gherkin

And just what qualifies you as a "network engineer"? Is a CNE or MCSE behind your name or did you actually go to college and get a CS degree? See that's the problem, in other industries people go to university for years to become engineers. In IT you just have to pass a handful of exams.

How do you know HR didn't know the jargon? HR's job is to feel out prospective candidates. They most likely asked you the C++ and Java questions to see how "well rounded" you are or just how you would respond. And the thing with salary is normal. All employer want talent for as little as they can get. What you expect, for them to hand you a bag of money? You just have to play the game.

by chris

Greg,
If you are a Seasoned Vet, you should have nothing to fear. Yet I sense fear in your posting. I am working on my certifications, and gaining experience while I am attending school. Before I found this job I was a Paper Certification Professional. My experience in school, and working toward my certifications, gave me an advantage because of my specific training. My employer sees my certifications as my strength. I am arrogant, and an exellent tech. I solve all the problems that arise every day.
Greg, be scared, be very, very scared. I just might take your job.
Other vets, who are not scared. Well, If you are a better tech than me, you have nothing to fear, and I hope one day we can work together on a project.

by shulmice

I would not hire someone without atlest a COMPTIA A+ and N+ certifications. I have seen to many people destroy systems that have only a BS degree, or have been to the MCSE boot camps. You need to start with the basics, and then test, and upgrade yourself.

Yakov Butterfield
Shulmice Software

by lordinfidel

Many a night I have pondered this question.

As a MCSE who studied his a## off for his exams and who works in the field. I do find it insulting that there are paper mcse's out there who just went to boot camp, got their cert, but have no idea whatthey are doing.

For those of you who are familiar with the military and the Rangers/Spec Forces. They require the completion a pre entry course before being accepted into the actual school. Following this same model there can be 2 ways to do it.

1- B4 you are allowed to even begin taking your MCSE you will need this basic cert first plus being employed in the field. Making a minimum time requirement is not feasible because if you are a seriously in IT that means that your intellegince level is generally higher than most. In turn means you should have the ability to learn quickly on the job. But OTJ exper. is a must to learn the various networking concepts that a IT pro must learn.

2- If you go to a boot camp then you can not earn your MCSE until you can prove via check stubs time working in the field.

Also the tests need to made harder. (don't hate me) It should be based more on practicals like for IIS - make a website called blah blah with an ip of xxx.xxx.xx.xx.
And you have to create it step by step. Get rid of the scenario multiple choice based questions.

by chris

Well Army Boy,

Your solution suggests that you have a job (which requires experience) to get experience. What are you crying about with a MCSE - certification in a GUI (easiest Server OS to run) I did not study my ass of, an I work on a NT network, Microsoft is easy to pick up. Now Linux/Unix is a real OS that takes time to learn, and tons of experience is needed. MCSE 4.0 was easy because the OS is easy. Paper MCSE or not, they could learn the OS without much difficulty.

by emeraldway tech

I am a MCP. I personally worked very hard to achieve this level because I am a horrible test taker. Two years is steap. Employers should see Work Experience first then the Cert as Icing on your resume.

by shanghai sam

When an "experienced professional" who has more than 15 years of practical experience in the IT field, and writes the MCSE exams and fails them twice, would this mean anything to the people who are so convinced of the need for certification?

I amthat person which I refer to above. About a year ago, I noticed employers in Toronto, Ontario started listing the MCSE as a requirement in their job ads. Since I didn't have this certification, I began thinking that I couldn't compete in the marketplace. This led me to succumb to an instructor-led course for which I paid $11,000.00 with the goal of obtaining the MCSE.

continued...

by vision-ary

When I was deciding which exam to write first, (Workstation or Server) I took the NT Server exam first. When I took this exam, I noticed it had Workstation questions on it! What struck me was the fact that Microsoft was doing something which adverisers who say one thing and do another are usually branded with the word "misrepresentation" or "misleading" advertising. As I wrote more exams, I found this trend continued.

Then, I came across some wording prior to the IIS exam, which made reference to Microsoft not guaranteeing the results of the exam with work performance, or some words to that effect. If that is what Microsoft is saying, (which I hope they will clarify in writing to me) then why is everybody so gung-ho on getting that certification? Then it means one's work performance has to do with other factors that are outside of Microsoft's certification, doesn't it?

If that wasn't enough, I then realized that anybody who passes the 6 exams for NT4.0 MCSE, becomes party to a legal agreement (contract) with Microsoft upon the opening of the sealed Microsoft Certified Professional Certification Welcome Kit that one receives in the mail! Now, if I had known about this before I began that MCSE program, I may have decided otherwise. For those of you who haven't known about this, I urge you to carefully read that agreement and then decide if you wish to continue.

Just click on the complete link at the Microsoft site and you'll see what I mean:

http://www.microsoft.com/trainingandservices/default.asp?pageid=mcp&subsite=examinfo/policies&pagecall=legal

Now, for those people who really want to go to the heart of the matter, and think a little bit more broadly about what I'm referring to, please visit the following link:

http://www.trufax.org/
go to "What's Normal or Possible for Consciousness?"

continued...

by vision-ary

Excerpt from the book "The Paradigm Conspiracy: How our systems of government, church, school, and culture violate our human potentials" by Denise Breton and Christopher Largent.

After reading that, you might be inclined to ask the question: If Bill Gates wrote any of those exams, do you think he would pass? Does anybody know whether Bill Gates is certified?

Regards,
:Pritam:Singh (Peter)

by chirotech

When I got my BS in Engineering Science, '70, every employer knew I was a newbee. They were smart enough to know to start me off where I could learn and prove myself while getting benefit from my work.

Years later in my new career, with my paperCNE, my first 1 1/2 years on the job were tough. I left that admin job to build a new network from scratch that now has Novell 4.11, NT 4.0 with SQL server, HPUX, and workstations up from 50 to 150. Hey, all the admins who look at my network praise my work as example of what to do. I am proud of my work and love it.

I'm grateful to my first employer for hiring my paper CNE and giving me a chance to learn, to prove myself and do good work at the same time.

Does the phrase "Encourage people toward a greater future." strike you? My paper proved to me I could learn and persevere.

by lquiambao

I am currently a Certified Surgical Technologist. But before I got my first job 7 years ago, the only experience I had was the 3 month internship that I did while I was still in school. What do doctors do before they go to med school? How many patients have they touched? If every job required job experience before certification/licensure, then what would those credentials mean anyway? If they didn't need them to get into a chosen field, why would they need them to CONTINUE in that particular field?
Besides, what company in their right mind would let a "newbie" CPA "run the books" for their company? Wouldn't they just start him/her in the accounting department?
Did you start IMMEDIATELY in the position that you hold now, or didyou work your way up to that position?
I am working on obtaining my MCSE Windows 2000 certs while also working as a Surgical Technologist. I have passed the first 2 and look forward to passing the rest.
And by the way? How many Presidents of the United States had experience being President BEFORE they became President?

Leo
California

by berbar

The point is valid to a point. However, I would like to see a listing of companies that hire people with no experience (so they can gain the experience) so that they might later take their exams after having worked under a
Certified person.

Every company I have ever encountered wants to know they are hiring someone with at least the ability to learn. This is why these companies demand proof of some kind. Just having paid thousands to a "Cert Mill" that will provide a cert to all who had the funds to complete the courses needed is not the criteria intelligent companies use as a basis for their hiring decisions.

Certification after taking the courses goes a lot further to assure companies that the people who took those courses can actually answer the questions.

Until you can come up with a better solution to the predicament HR faces when trying to hire, especially with the labor market as tight as it is, the comments made are of no use to those who face the task of staffing.

So, even paper certs have their value to HR and IT departments who have to somehow (other than using black magic, nepotism, and other
failure paths) obtain at least somewhat knowledgeable personnel.

by rick_e_b

I think that the improvement of HR's interviewing and screening skills would go a long way toward weeding out the paper-boys. Perhaps setting up a screening lab to allow potential candidates to demostrate the basic skills needed for the job would be helpful.

by awebb2

Yeah Greg, I see your point, but on the other hand, Would you trust a person proporting to be "knowledgeable heart surgeon" who has no certification to practice as a doctor to perform your heart by-pass operation? It cuts both ways. Certification isthe only route for some people to make it into the IT world today. Memories are short. In the past a vast portion of the well experienced IT professionals of today were people who were trained by companies and who had no formal IT related education.Currently you cannot seem to get into a company if you don't have 2 years experience or more. The college graduate and home trained persons out there does not have that experience and thus the only loop hole they see in getting into a company is through the "high and mighty" certification route which some poor sap at some company has substituted for experience. And we all know that you can pass some of these IT certification exams without going within a hundred yards of a computer period!!! An so people...the well intentioned and the "you can make money out of computers person" will all join the IT certification fray.....The task is now to selectively discriminate between the certified person who is knowledgeable and those who don't know crap.

Ainsley

by mrtjan

Well Greg,
As an individual that had come to a point in his line of "Dead End" jobs where he didn't know what to do, I pondered what I should try next. I heard an advertisement offering MCSE Certification courses and the blah blah that goes with them($70,000+ salary). I decided to sign up.

That was 7 months ago and more than $10,000 invested in the program. I am now done with all of the courses related to Windows NT 4.0... Yes, the courses finished up just as Microsoft decided to pull the MCSE Certification Exams at the end of this year. I decided not to take any of the exams and self study for the Win2000 MCSE next year.

On to your comments...... Without the education that I received, I would still know nothing! Now I know more than I ever thought I would. This "Dead End" job has developed into a stepping stone for exerience as I am now providing LAN Support for our corp IT department. I will admit that I wouldn't be able to be a Network Administrator. This is more out of fear for what I have not yet experienced than it is out of the knowledge that I have gained. I am happy with what I am doing for once in my life and that is what is important to me more than any Certification that I have!

Greg, maybe its time for you to realize that there are people that are motivated to get into this field and this is a short-cut(over a 4 year degree). They may not have the experience that you do, but given time they will know as much if not more. These people will also look to you to teach them. Embrace these individuals as they look up to you. There might be some Certified people out there that fit into your complaints, but don't let them speak for all of us!

Happy New Year!
TJ-Milwaukee,WI

by jerry.wagner

I think the point should be that there are some people out there who have never touched a pc or maybe only changed a hard drive and now they have somehow gotten their hands on a course and studied for the test. I have seen first hand how someone canstudy for a test pass the test and still know nothing. I have no problem with entry level people going to a school gaining some hands on experience and getting certified, but let's keep things in perspective, they were taught enough to make them dangerous and should realize that as well as their employers do or should.

by ereis

I never realized how many babies there are in the IT field. You sound like kids fighting over who has the best toys. I let my work reflect my skills, not my mouth.

The people who are bashing MCSE's and all the other certs, most of them are people who never took the tests. Very interesting! If they are so easy and then why don't you pass them and prove everyone wrong. On second thought, let's stop everyone from getting a college degree. It really isn't hard work, just a bunch of testsand boring classes. I think anyone with a few thousand dollars could do it. Then we can take away high school diplomas, cause they are even easier. Trust me I have one of each.

If you don't think someone in your department has the experienceand they are out of their league then tell your boss and have them moved to something else. Or take a little time to get involved in the interviewing process. If someone had never given you your shot you wouldn't have the chance to complain on this discussion, and I know you like complaining.

If the tests bother you that much, then you are close-minded. Anyone who betters their life through education should be commended not scolded. You people are the reason society is held back instead of moving forward.

by arg cio

Your right!! There are benefits from certifications! I learned some stuff in my "boot camp". I also have an AAS in ET. I didn't have the time, or money to get BS. I decided not to finish my MCSE, I stopped with my MCP. I agree with both sides,an MXXX, or a CCXX, or a NXX should be taken at face value. If you are certified, you are NOT a god! If you have experience, then you KNOW you don't know everything! And when you get out of college, you find out, you don't know anything! I plan to take a CCNA boot-camp, to get a "start" on setting up cisco routers. I have tweaked, and programmed, and f*#ked up my little 675 at home for ADSL, but I am learning! Techies of the WORLD, remember one thing! You chose this line of work because of it's challenges, and the never-ending chance to learn. Go with the flow, teach some, be taught, and enjoy the growth in the industry that allows this discussion to take place. I am awed by the growth of the IT field, and I am trying to figure outwhich area to master next.(LOL) I am not a master of anything, but I am a hard worker, and get jobs done, on time, AND under budget. what's next? see below..

*sidenote* I am CIO for a small company, and I am charged with finding the "internet business" to generate more revenue. Currently, our business is mainly off the internet, but I have to find out how to put us on the map, any ideas?
eric@argkeno.com

by gherkin

I don't know what college you went to but when I was getting my degree it was based on the application of knowledge. There were research papers, case studies, design papers, projects building LANs and WANs from the ground up, as well as management, and business classes.

Having said that, do you expect us to believe that someone that takes a six week course, or memorizes questions and answers on the exam, has the same level of understanding as someone with a degree?

by bmccabe

Lets face it - Someone without experience IS NOT going to get a high-level certification such as an MCSE or CNE. A+ or an MCP is possible to get without experience, but certs such as MCSE is not going to be achieved without hands-on experience. I am currently (slowly) working my way to my MCSE and believe me - Experience helps! If someone feels that a person with a low-level cert (A+, MCP-Win 9x)is a threat, he/she should get a life!

by gatorman

You guys all make me laugh..the discussion on who has what qualifications is ridiculous. In my short term in the IT field I have been witness to 20 yr so called pro's who didn't know how to look up a IP address to paper CNE's not knowing what the default tree and context is. I also know there is a lot of smart "paperboy" and real smart pro's with no certs at all. Who gives a rats ass...the bottom line is that 1.) serve the customer 2.) If you don't know something ask and learn 3.) A person canknow a lot but he or she doesn't know everything.
So eat the weak......

by incent

right on gatorman, experience and certification both has its place but u cant buy knowledge, u have to get in there and get it all over yr face! the whole problem is technology is in such a dynamic frenzy that both experience and certification are kinda like 'notches on a barrel of gun' - only good till the next kill :)

by jefisher

"How would you like to go to a "certified" nurse practitioner who has NEVER touched a patient?"

A person who is in school to get their RN doesn't spend much time with patients that isn't observation only. If you are talking about Nurse Practitioner, that is pretty much just a masters degree without much clinicals.

"or a "certified" Public Accountant who has never ran the books of a company?"

Many. I would even go as far as to say "Most".

Paper Certifications do mean something. No,if you don't have any experience, I wouldn't expect you to move to the top of the ladder but it's a good way to get your foot in the door.
Jeff who has spent 5 years working in Accounting in a hospital, 2 years Accounting Development for a softwarecompany."

by mconiegs

Greg,

everyone who has a certificate is at least partly a "paper cert". Some stuff I know really well, other bits I learned for the exam but dont use daily. EG , what is the maximum length of a coaxial cable segment. Answer zero. Get rid of it and put in decent cabling. MS did not offer this answer in the exam.

There are also multiple motivations for getting the certificate. I do not want to be the "go-to guy". But I do want to know that the "go-to guy" knows what he/she is doing.

Experience is great, but I also want someone who has followed a structured and well thought out study path. Studying the MCSE showed me that some things I "knew" from 20+ years computer experience were wrong. When I hire, ideally I want both, but in times of shortage someone who has demonstrated a willingness to do something such as a certification, has a headstart over someone who hasnt.

Also have a look at the value placed on the certificate by the issuing organisation. A RN degree is forever, a MSCE is for a couple of years at best. The RN does have to keep current, but they do not take away the original achievement.

by awolf

My two cents..

I think the certs are a good thing. As it's been said many times over, "it gets a person's foot in the door."

Now, what I think is wrong are the people with the certs that are basically lying in order to get the 'better' jobs. Another words, them saying 'yeah, I know networks in and out and I have the MSCE to prove it.' They then go to the fellas that actually have the knowledge to bail them out.

Another bad thing? The 'fellas' that allow themselves to be used by thesepaper certfied 'experts'.

by shanghai sam

Anyone out there got the certifications and ended up feeling like they were robbed by the vendors? Check out my story.
With 2 yrs technical exp. in a school district, I gradually got my MCSE, A+, Network+, and Apple certs to help me find a better paying job in the private sector.
I found that job and am making more money (though not much more) but my current duties really didn't require all that preparation.
And now I have to work with this new guy who has an MCSE & A+ w/ 10 months exp. who doesn't know diddly squat!! I mean he's A+ and he didn't recognize the SYS or DIR commands (you see what I'm getting at - MCSE and A+ and he never made a boot disk!!). I glibly mentioned something about Norton Ghost and disk images and he had a look of total puzzlement on his face - with 10 months previous exp. in a large well-known investment bank! (doing what I don't know)
I feel so disillusioned. I mean I'm no NT guru but damn!! I've put a lot of time and money to get these certs and now, I'm realizing that due to lack of corporate experience, I'm going to have to stay on the cert treadmill for some years in order to keep one step ahead of all the bozos out there. Whoopee-frickin-doo!!

In conclusion: there's no doubt in my mind anymore that experience and brains is more important than a piece of paper, but if you're just starting out in this industry, you have NO CHOICE but to get the cert, otherwise bozo gets the job and not you. In other words, Microsoft wins, again. . .

by drobledo

Anyone out there got the certifications and ended up feeling like they were robbed by the vendors? Check out my story.
With 2 yrs technical exp. in a school district, I gradually got my MCSE, A+, Network+, and Apple certs to help me find a better paying job in the private sector.
I found that job and am making more money (though not much more) but my current duties really didn't require all that preparation.
And now I have to work with this new guy who has an MCSE & A+ w/ 10 months exp. who doesn't know diddly squat!! I mean he's A+ and he didn't recognize the SYS or DIR commands (you see what I'm getting at - MCSE and A+ and he never made a boot disk!!). I glibly mentioned something about Norton Ghost and disk images and he had a look of total puzzlement on his face - with 10 months previous exp. in a large well-known investment bank! (doing what I don't know)
I feel so disillusioned. I mean I'm no NT guru but damn!! I've put a lot of time and money to get these certs and now, I'm realizing that due to lack of corporate experience, I'm going to have to stay on the cert treadmill for some years in order to keep one step ahead of all the bozos out there. Whoopee-frickin-doo!!

In conclusion: there's no doubt in my mind anymore that experience and brains is more important than a piece of paper, but if you're just starting out in this industry, you have NO CHOICE but to get the cert, otherwise bozo gets the job and not you. In other words, Microsoft wins, again. . .

by bazmac

Im a freelance systems recovery consultant...
and in my daily routine I come into contact with computers that people with all of the same Paper Certificates as myself.and yet I find so so many fundemental errors that have bought networks to their knee's.
Isnt it about time the fixers of the problems created by the Certified started a governing body of our own to weed out the incompetence that giving all tech's a bad name.

by arg cio

A+ and Network+ came from CompTIA. A+ certification shows some basic computer knowledge. I didn't "study" for this, but I passed, because of experience. Yes, I missed a couple, but mostly because of wording on the test. If an independent orginization would do the certification, then the tech world would be better! If CompTIA did "Server Admin+", "Network Admin+", "HelpDesk Jockey+", "Don't hire this geek+" then the tech world would be better, but when companies come out with their own certification, to make money(, and advertise their products), then the tests are made so that anyone can study for them, and some can get lucky and pass without any real experience. But how do you measure TRUE "Customer Service Skills"? Anyone can be nicey, nice for an hour to get certified, but when the fit hits the shan, the real customer service people get bucking, and get the job done, no matter what it takes. The job market will weed out the meek, and they will have to start at the bottom like everyone else. The strong will continue to move up, and make room at the bottom, while the weak will move in, or move out!

by mark

I started working with computers over 12 years ago while in the army i have never been to school for crap about computers and for the longest time nobody would touch me without certification finally i caught a break a little over a year ago yet wheni talk to other people out there they tell me alot of companies still want you certified before they even look at your resume. I believe that is crap i would rather higher a person that knows at least half way what they are doing than someone who took a test and doesn't know crap. but that's me i work for cheap but i also get the experience which to me is much better than money at the present time " Down with the paper and up with the experience"

by arg cio

The companies are looking for someone who has experience, AND Certs. If you only have 12 years experience assemblying computers, and maybe loading an operating system, they you only have one year experience, and 11 years of repetitive motion. Thiswill not get you what you need to certify. If you've been in the "warzone" in IT for 12 years, you may be a seasoned vet. that can go get certified, I bet you don't pass without some studying! MSCE tests aren't that easy. (yeah, okay WS and Server 4.0 were a cakewalk for someone who has worked with 'em for a few years.) but someone who has never touched anything other than their single home computer WILL learn from those bootcamps! It will only be a start, and when the going gets tough, they go to a team lead, or manager, or another IT member who "should" be making more money for his knowledge. I guess to make a long story short.. experience<>knowledge.. Certification<>knowledge.. experience+certification~knowledge.. an interview SHOULD tell if the "experience"/cert. is backed with knowledge, or not. If they don't have it, don't hire them! If they fit close, THEY CAN LEARN. If not FIRE THEM, and find someone who will get the job done!

by mark

i have a total of 12 years working with all aspects of computer networking, assembly, software and hardware trouble shooting and am not cert, i never said all i did was build them. the only reason i am not cert is the fact that i am not going to pay13,000 dollars for a piece of crap paper i would rather put money down on a house and show my experience with hard work rather than a piece of paper

by mahmoodsiddiqui

Most the people who have a certification and actually know nothing about it are those who have no apptitude towards this field and they just did it because everyone is doing it.

I think the industry will filter these people itself because there could not any place for people who waste time.

Mahmood.

by e-computer

Why is a cert. a BAD thing? You act like because someone worked for weeks on end and spent hundreds of dollars for a test that they're a nimrod.

I don't think you're going to find a lot of people who go out and get a MCSE/CNA/RHCE without having some experience.

I'm working part-time for a computer firm and also completing my MCSE, A+, Solaris, CCNA and CNA cert's... don't tell me about working hard for a job. I'm not working towards these goals because they guaruntee me a job, but it WILL help more than 2 years of experience where I am now!

I totally agree that there ARE lusers who think that a piece of paper will buy them a $120K a year position, but you get that anywhere... There's crappy mechanics, crappy teachers, anything you can think of. That's the way the world works.

Stop being an elitist and think about who's going to replace you when you're obsolete. ;)

e-computer

by tary1

It is true that the certifications are becoming less meaningful because of non IT people getting the certifications without even having real experience.

I don't know that two years experience would be a good requirement for taking the exams butsomething should be done.

Not only is it going to hurt the businesses, it's going to hurt the real IT professionals who have to compete for the jobs.

Tary
TSE Marconi

by tary1

Sure entry level people need to get a start but that is why you go to school. You get the basic knowledge and some hands on experience then you apply for an entry level job to get your experience.

There are people out there that may be in a different field all together and they decide that they want to go into the IT field. That is fine but just by getting a certification without a degree doesn't mean that they should get anything but an entry level job.

Tary
TSE
Marconi

by cschauf

I agree with this 100%. I personally don't have any certifications but have been working in the industry for 15 years and a few years ago was actually teaching netware for a tech school. Experience,the desire to learn, and retention of information are the best qualities for someone in this field. Paper CNEs and MCSEs without experience and desire are worthless!

Chad

by arg cio

That is the key word! someone with a paper certification may well be worth 80K/anum! They may not know much now, but how much enthusiasm do they have to learn? How able are they to learn? Do they acknowledge that they are not gurus or gods, and accept that they have a LONG way to go? Take a chance with someone, who can prove they are worth it, and they might surprise you. Don't start them at 80K. Start them at 30K, and let them work their way up! I have friends/ex-coworkers that, given the chance, I would hire them in a second at 200K per year, because that is what they are worth to my company, but I cannot afford that! They are making 50-60K currently, and as soon as I find a way to beat that, I will! But, I also have friends that are SMART! ENTHUSIASTIC! and have little to no experience with computers, they have shown desire to learn as much as they can absorb, while working their current jobs, supporting their families, and working on a VERY tight budget. They work on their computers, and help their other friends. If they don't know, and cannot figure it out, I get a phone call. I LOVE helping others learn what I know. I LOVE mentoring others! I tutored people in my classes in college, because I understood the subject and was able to comprehend it well enough to teach it, and others needed help. It also helped me remember the little details, because I had to "regurgitate" the formulas, and theories to my "students". I learn from people, and they learn from me! That is the way it should be in IT!

by gatorman

Sounds to me like your bitter or just like to beat your chest....I hope your not like the rest of the "systems Engineers" that work in our enviroment. They do the same thing, always about "me me me" and never thinking that the customer is the one that comes first. Impress with your actions not with your words. If that is the case why waste your energy worrying about who has what.....

by gmitchell

That is soo stupid. In my 10+ years in the "IT" field I have met sooooo many CNE's, MCSE's, and now the lamest Cert. on the market C+'s, that have the foggiest clue. Now I would never hire anyone that has no experience and has a slew of Certs. A person that has the paper and no experience is totally lost on some of the most basic hands on knowledge. They would get in an environment like mine and freak. I see this guys all the time come in and have a long list of certs. and make stupid statements like "You can Quick Format a Harddrive for the first time", and "Windows ME is better than Windows 2000". Gimme a break!!!!!! These days your cert guys are a dime a dozen. How about some hands on experience. I will take a guy with 5 years in the field with lots of knowledge about NT,Unix,Novel, and workstations over a person that has 20 certs and never step foot in a real environment any day.

by pinkein

Everyone has to start somewhere. Nurse Practitioners and Accountants, for instance, go to school to gain the knowledge needed, as do people with "Paper Thingys" as you put it..and Nurse Practitioners and Accountants get their experience in school labs...as do people with "Paper Thingys"...Then Nurse Practitioners and Accountants..go out to the world and become ASSISTANTS to those MORE experienced..as do people with "Paper Thingys"..so where's the shame? We all have to start somewhere..the real point is people with "Paper Certifications" went to school as do all Professionals..got the training and do not expect to make big bucks in the beginning or expect to know it all.. they have the Certification that says "Hey, I've got the training andI want to be given the opportunity to do what I love." So lighten up..it's not as bad as you make it seem...No shame here!!

by been there done that since 75

Isn't it interesting how we all get along in reading the threads from the start. From a management perspective, Michael Silver from the Gartner Group summed it up beautifully in his article "NT Certification Benefits Employees More than Enterprises"Since Tech Republic is associated with Gartner, they should be able to reproduce the article. gartner is one of the most respected sources of information in the IT world. Perhaps a read of the article will shed appropriate light on this somewhat volatile topic.

by arg cio

How do you get that job to get into "this field"? lets see.. a degree in psychology, 15 years experience in psychology. 0 computer experience.

total score = 0

Add one MCP, MCSE, or CNE

Total score = 5/10

Add 2 years "real world" experience

Total score = 30/35

Add 5 years "real world" experience

Total score = 80/100

etc.

Certification IS worth something.. but not a lot!

by diplomat1

The statement "technical skills can be taught" was not meant to imply that everything is that simple. Sure nothing beats experience but even then one could argue that experience is gained through learning.

The guy who replace the Cisco router was not born knowing how to do it. That wsa a skill he learned and eventually mastered. So the basic skills are indeed taught and experience comes with repeated practice of what we were first taught.

Diplomat1

by arg cio

that all you did was assembly, but that is a worst case scenario where 12 years wouldn't mean squat. I don't know what piece of paper you think costs 13,000, but I'd sure like to get my hands on it.. MCSE costs around $600 ($100/test for six tests),CCNA costs around $100 ($100/test for one test), and A+ costs $256($128/test for two tests). The part that is expensive is the "boot camp" training given to "prepare" for the tests. I am A+, MCP certified. Planning on MCSE AND CCNA. I have a AASin Elec. Tech. and 4.5 years experience. I am not a know it all, but I know what I do, AND I learn what I need to. At 26, I know there is still a lot to learn, but I need to work. I have put in my hours in a sweat shop, I have done time in fast food, NOW I am a CIO, and content with my position. I've worked hard to convince people to take a chance on me, and have not dissappointed anyone yet.

by chris.e.rocek

I think it would have pissed me off if I went to college and they told me I couldn't go because I didn't have enough work experience. Education is always the begining of the road for anyone. Technology is driving the the world and will continue to do so till the end of time. This I truly believe. How would it be possible to limit the training available and still be able to meet the employment demands of the field? The market is flooded with paper certers that want jobs. The problem is that most of them would be transitioning to an entry level position that will mean a paycut. You have to start at the begining in whatever you do and for the amount of career changers in the field it is tough to get in. I have been in the field for two years now and I have no certs. I have been working on them but I knew to be successful I had to get into the field. I can only think that it is a threat to many ITer's. I don't know of many cities that don't have a good 10000 job openings in IT. We need to evolve as a workforce. If you have been doing the same thing for a few years, step up and go to the next level. This will open up the bottom of the market for new ITer's to get in. Technology will never go away and if we can't supply the field with techs growth will slow down. More people are entering this field from a college perspective every year. Since IT is cool now people aren't afraid of jumping aboard. There will always be jobs and there will always be a need. To limit what people achieve in the field, experienced or not, would truly hurt the workforce.

by tboring

Greg,

I have a question for you.

What's the difference between most college graduates with a Computer Science, MIS, or CIS degree and people with no experience and plenty of "paper thingees"?

The answer, of course, is absolutely nothing!I've seen so many college grads, toting Computer Science degrees who couldn't program their way out of a wet paper sack. Yet they get hired. Why ? It's simple, they have a "paper thingee" called a college degree.

On the other extreme, I've seen quite a few "seasoned professionals", with certifications that prove their greatness, crack after 30 minutes on a problem they then deem "unsovable", which is later solved by Jack the intern during lunch.

My point is simple. You cannot apply a blanket law to the IT industry. This industry changes so rapidly that most of your "seasoned professionals" are so out of touch it's ridiculous.

Also, on one hand I do agree with you. People should not be allowed into the IT industry that do notbelong here. It does dilute the skill pool that exists. Which is why I think all students pursuing an IT degree should have to go through, be graded on, and pass, a two-year internship with some kind of IT organization. It would be as simple as not getting your degree if you don't pass the internship. The same thing is done for Doctors and Paramedics, which are to the Healthcare industry what we are to the IT industry.

Tom
Code Poet