Paper Certifications?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by rljones
I agree that Certifications should only be available to people who have been in the industry long enough to earn the respect that used to be associated with them. However, there's more to it than that.
First, there are those who hear, or read about how much money IT people earn, and suddenly feel that they should jump on the IT bandwagon themselves. Money should never be the reason for a career choice. I have found that these people are the ones that don't want to earn their income, they justwant it handed to them.
Second, there are the digital kids coming up with computers that probably know more about them than most IT professionals. However, they lack the discipline, and maturity to know how to deal with their knowledge. Getting certified for them probably isn't as difficult as it should be.
Then of course, there are the IT pros that have been working in the field for a few years. To them certifications are used as a measuring device to decide if Joe Blow will make a good fitwithin the given organization.
I believe that certifications should be limited only to those that possess a B.A. in Computer Science. Like most other fields; this will ensure that everyone working within the IT field is a competant, mature adult. I believe that this policy should, and will become even more important, now that our ecomony has become so greatly dependant on those of us that support it.....
by peter_au
I think your being a bit elitist here, having a degree before allowing any certification is just silly.
As to people going into IT for the money, well why else so you come to work. If your not in it for the cash, then offer your services for free.
I see certification as a indicator that the person has a fundemental knowledge of a product. And just as importantly, an indication that the person has the drive to learn. Anyone who disregards the level of experience(whatever that may be)will do it at their own risk.
by gnx
by rhale
by banner
by crandall
Greg,
I agree to one point in your statement, that certifications are losing their worth for working certified professionals, however, I would like to know-when you were first certified, how much did you really know? Thats part of being a "newly certified professional". If someone says their certified and wants a job, great test them. If you have a person with certification and 2 years of experience, wont you still want to test them? And as for a paper thingy, that paper thingy still means that they have met industry standards and done the work, which I might add can be quite challenging.
And, Greg, we all must start at the bottom, and if you dont, youll probably end up there.....
Coral Randall
Damn good IT Coordinator - Certifiedwith some "paper thingy's"
by drobinson
I thought that the purpose of certification was to learn a given skill set. If thats the case, what does "two years" have to do with anything.
Most certification programs require that an individual be MORE THAN familiar with their product, so your comparisons are skewed.
Certification is meaningless, only if you did not learn anything during the certification process. Now snatch the pebble from my hand, Grasshopper!
by peter_au
by acelogan
I've been in the buisness for 10 years now. I got my current job because of that amount of experience. I do not have a single piece of paper to back that up other then the list of refrences I have.
On the same token a friend of mine did 2nd leveltech support for a large on-site firm that would only hire A++ certified people. She told me such tails as the guy who was on his first onsite, and had never turned on a computer before and was looking for the power button! Or another guy who got into Windows Safe mode by just turning the computer off.
In my current evironment certs are a dime a dozen, yet the un-certified people out perform them....
Rick
by ptswolfman
Both degrees and certs show a certain level of experience. I've been an A+ certified PC tech for about nine years gaining knowledge on networks and various IT issues over that time.
What it sounds like you are saying is that just becuase I cannot afford to go to school right now and get a degree in an IT field means that I must not be fit to work in the IT field?
I myself would very much like to go back to school and get my degree. But you know what? Look at that degree. What is it? It's a peice of paper right? Granted it's one of the hardest certifications to get...but when you break it down, it's just another cert on the wall. I agree with one of the other guys, higher levels of troubleshooting cannot be taught. It's something that you were born with, the ability to think in a troubleshooting manner. That is what makes a good Net/System/Infrastructure Admin.
by angel garcia
by jackieb
by jpmcse2b
What about making it only available to four year degree'ers? That'll keep "us" from making our lives better.
--By "paper" do you mean those who just study at home, or those who attend school for two years to prepare for the exams? Attending schooldoes give some experience. Employers recognize that as a start. I am assuming you're lumping us all in the same category.
--I am thankful for the opportunity to change careers, study hard, and hopefully pass the certification tests. Yes, I'll bea "paper", (with A+ and Network+) but I'll give credit to the employer who hires me because I'm willing to do studying before I'm employed. I may not have all of the seven+ exams passed when I do join a company, but it's a start. I am not naive enough to think I can make as much money as you who are "experienced with at least two years or more," but the money is not the important thing to me. It's being satisfied with my accomplishments and achievement of my goals.
--Perhaps there should belevels of certification for MCSE - Master level with those who do have two+ years of experience - to distinguish the "real" MCSEs from the "papers." If so, the tests should be different. As it is now, the tests are geared for those with experience.
--I am 42 years old, a female, a starting over. ---
Jen
by northwind
by ljmaniatis
by mjohnson
by 98321
I've been working in IT for the last four years, started in data entry...
Now build web site's and can bung a network together in a day, dont have any certs, but am never out of work, I refuse to get one because they mean nothing to me now, but employers want them, i was working for one company, when i first started in 1st line support, they brought in this firm to sort out some network issue, they all had MCSE's and blew up the network took us three days to get in back, thats when I thought wants the point, I looked into it and found that College degress and the like are far better, because employers will want you so you get experience and quals at the same time
Andy Leaves
by lchavez
Let's be totally honest, "certification" is an industry in itself and a very profitable one at that. This was driven in part by the explosion of IT and the lack of practical technically based college level programs.
As a Supervisor of Network Services responsible for the hiring of desktop and network support technicians and engineers I find a balance between both experience and certifications when selecting candidates for hiring but, nothing weighs more heavily on the scale of an acceptable candidate than personality and someone with good customer service skills. Anyone with technical aptitude can be taught the "technicalities" and become certified but, if you don't care about the people you service then I don't care how many certs youhave under your belt.
by webmaster
I agree with the principals you have stated. I am self taught with 6 years experience. However seeing a resume from someone who was a painter for 15 years, and 2 months ago got his MCSE and now wants to be an administrator just doen't cut it. I have worked with too many MCSE's who wouldn't know how to configure Perl on an NT system if it talked to him!
I have gone through other certification programs outside of the IT field, and many of those REQUIRE a minimum of experience just to apply to take the certification. I don't think the IT field should be opening itself up to any person who can memorize content and pass a test to be certified. We don't trust the local mechanic with an ASE certification and years of experience to change the oil in our car, yet we are willing to trust our electronic security and IT stability to a piece of paper.
There are plenty of oportinuties for beginners to enter into the field without certifications. Although many are being told that piece of paper will get them 65K a year, that in fact is not the case. They should earn the right to take the test through experience from the ground up. How can one possibly be an effective administrator without understanding the reprocussions of their actions on the end user?
As for giving them a chance, that is what entry level is for. Let's find out if you have what it takes before we give you power.
Just my two cents....
Tom Johnson
System Administrator
by shanghai sam
1. Certifications should be performed by an Independent Certifying Agency which can be litigated in the event certified personnel don't measure up...once that happens, the certification will have "real" meaning. Until then, having certs "sponsored"by the same folks who sell the products raises questions of integrity, creates a potential for abuse, and financially rips the lips off of people who need all of their lips. The companies won't even stand behind their certs with performance warranties! Requiring two years of experience won't resolve those problems.
2. We employ lots of IT personnel. We have some old ones (64) and some young ones (18). Some are certified, some not. Some are even second-starts (and, yes, for a tough pay cut - don't apply for a GOOD team unless you're dedicated enough to EARN your spurs the way everyone else did). They're also of different colors, life-styles, religions and sexes. Our IT team is highly successful, but it doesn't come from certs, experience, or magic. It's because they all try their hardest, they are all dedicated to their IT customers, and they are all committed to the success of their team as a unit. In return, they all know that if they perform well they will go upward - with our blessing.
3. To be brutally honest, I don't see any evidence that most of the whiny crybabies, young braggarts, Grandpa-hating trash-mouths, egotistical know-it-alls, or who-cares-if-YOUR-company-goes-broke-make-ME-rich folks on this thread could be successful on a really good IT support team. The problem is not with their age, their certs, OR their experience, but rather with their attitude...
WOW,
Did you hit the nail on the head. Almost all other professions have resident, journeyman, and master or apprentice programs. These programs require a certain amount of verifiable time in their field of licensure. I guess that I liken it to the Dilbert cartoon where the tech support person comes up and boasts:
"Step away from that network server! I'm certified!"
Then confidently says:
"I summon the vast power of CERTIFICATION!"
and wilts when he says:
"Well, this is embarrassing: That's all I remember from the classes."
Learning and memorizing are different than experience.
Those of us in the field know that the classroom and books are 180 degrees opposite of the real world.
by unal
You sound really pissed off! What, just lose your job to a paper certified person or something? You should relax a little and take a deep breath before posting next time.
As far as paper certification is concerned, it is just like a Uni degree ifnot better in some areas. With a degree tightly in your hand, as you commenced employment for the first time, did you know everything there is to know about IT? Did you not ask any questions, did you not learn 1000% more in the field? I think so!Compard to some degrees I think probably a certification is good especially for those changing careers at a later date. Dont forget they also take with them years of managing and customer relations. (Like myself who changed careers from IT, Working on CRAY X/Y-MP mainframes (hardware and software) to the hospitality industry, only to return to IT 11 years later!) I took with me a wealth of customer service and the qualifications of managing upto 400 people at a time!!!
I think a degree means that you have the stamina to finish what you start, (even if the technology is out of date by the time you complete the degree) - Even then you need experience, I dont think that this is a shortfall of the education system but rather a feature of IT at the moment, IT is travelling so fast that you just cant fill the gaps unless you promote IT certifications.
So relax and dont worry there is plenty of work out there for all of us!!!
And dont forget any person with a certification or degree,it doesnt matter, if they have not aquired the necessary understandings, it will show up in the first month(s)...
...Give them enough rope and they will hang themselves :-)
by xdcbjx
Lets get realistic the IT comunity does not want people to be certifyed unless there allready working in the field. You can not get a job unless you have a certification. so you tell me how do people get a start in the industry.
davy
mcse
by ahevans
Hi Greg,
(Look what you started! :-)
First, I think your position is valid and sincere, but not really practical.
Someone could work for many years in an IT position and NEVER be exposed to much of what is required to get a certification. Vertical specialization is the reason.
Current certifications are only a guage that a prospective employer can use to determine if a job cantidate has the potential to fill a position. It is also a valuable indicator to prospective clients that theengineers working on their project have had SOME formal training relating to their project.
Rarely does a cantidate enter a job having all of the 'hands on skills' needed to fill that employers opening. The certification only indicates that the cantidate has been exposed to a broad array of technology so that he will be able to understand the larger picture relative to the job he will actually be doing.
The true measure of the IT Pro's value (and subesquently his continued employment) isthe sucessfull execution of the clients project. The 'paper' got him the job, and it's then up the the IT Pro to demonstrate competence.
I guess my point is that someone that works in the industry for, say, 5 years may still only have a 'paper cert' since his current job may only require him to know and use a fraction of the information he had to absorb to get the cert in the first place.
Tom
Programming Analyst
by server queen
I've been in IT for 23 years, starting out as data entry. I took what classes were offered, worked hard, and when we got network PCs, started assisting with admin. I was lucky to start out in a large company, where I could move around, learn new things, and steadily accumulate knowledge, experience, and responsibility.
Now, I'm network systems manager for a large school district. Quite a few of the high school kids have MCSEs. I've never gotten around to taking the certification exams myself, but supervise and train MSCEs, some of whom have NO experience working in IT. Most hiring managers are looking for a proven track record; only the more inexperienced managers are looking solely at the letters after your name. You get a track record by starting out wherever they'll hire you, solving customer problems, and learning new skills. A certification is one way to get that entry level job, especially if you're changing careers.
Certs aren't a magic entree to high-level network admin jobs. A person may not deal well with customers, or not handle stress well. Everyone can be taught basic troubleshooting methods, but not everyone can necessarily think of what to do when the email server won't is dead and everyone is screaming at you.
A sensible organization has a mix of experienced people and people with book knowledge, willing to learn from each other. I don't hesitate to ask an 18-year-old student with an MSCE for an opinion; the student may have learned something in class that I've never run across. By the same token, if the student realizes that an MSCE does not mean they've learned everything there is to learn, that student will ask me to share knowledge, too.
Those with experience should be anxious to learn from those with book knowledge, and vice versa. If you're convinced you already know it all, you won't learn anything new, which will make you obsolete.
by blkbull69
by blkbull69
by jparks1972
by kevin
by garryb
I have seen too many "paper" MCSE's and CCNA's come through the door and demand the same salary as a seasoned pro. The expectations generated by some trainers are way out of line with the real world. Granted, the theory is there but if you read the NT doc's and believe what you are taught in the courses, you will never need more that a 500mb C:\ partition on a NT server.
Try it.... 'Nuff said!
by unal
If you even thaught about looking at the date of publication for the NT Books, I beleive it was about 1994 - 1995, when yes, 500 mb was a sufficient amount of memory to alocate and 16 Meg or RAM was HUGE!!!
... Forgive them lord, you gave them eyes for they shalt not see!!!
:-)
by st_paul
by cwdunn
by peter_au
After scrolling through the discussions that have been taking place, I think it obvious the both experience and certification is required to get started, unless you lucky enough to find an employer that will take a chance and hire you without exprience or cert's.
To those who think certifications are rubbish, when employers stop putting certifications down as a prereq' to a postion then, the number of people doing cert's will probably fall. I for one will still gain cert's if it mean's advancing my career and knowledge.
I think companies that offer certication courses are endevouring to create a baseline of knowledge about their particular product.
It is not the be all and end all.
by convict
by jamiquest
I took the training to break into the IT Profesion. It wasn't easy and I can't claim to know everything. But neither can you.
If you don't trust the testing system then YOUR Certification isn't worth much is it? At least I've proven I know something. Which alot of IT Profesionals haven't done.
But I still appreciate their help.
by marcelle
I totally agree with you on the fact that people should have at least 2 years experience before doing the certifications. Fine, if you have taught yourself everything at home and think you are ready then there should be a knowledge test to see if you are ready.........hands on, not written.
Younger people out of school think that if they obtain their certification they will make a lot of money in the IT industry, but they do not realise, that a company like the one that I work for, running seven servers, would never even consider someone with no hands on working experience.
The fact that just anyone can certify is one of the reasons for so many unemployed, qualified IT people. Who in their right mind would take someone on with no hands on experience, except a firm that is looking to train someone to their needs, but how often do you find that. Companies want someone who can just come in and start working.
Experience is always the key!!!!!!
Marcelle
by parsonsac
Over the years I have watched the value of the various certificates diluted down to a level where thay are simply indicators of the theoretical knowledge vested in an individual.
Over the years I have built many IT teams for companies in all sectors and have learnt that certificates without practical experience to back them up are worthless.
I salute anyone who takes the time and effort to study enought to gain certification but caution newbies that this will not be a fast track to meaningful employment.
Companies are beginning to move away from stipulating certification as mandatory for a given position. This is because over the years the number of candidates who have taken accelerated courses to gain the likes of an MCSE or CNE do not have the experience to back up the "book learning".
My personal opinion is that organisations selling theses courses do have to shoulder a great deal of the blame as they foster the myth that by simply passing one of theses courses means that the candidate is worthy of earning huge amounts.
by rharris
How would you like to have your network administered by someone who only knows what he's learned from experience? Yes, experience is priceless, but if you don't have a foundation to start with, and I mean one that is properly tought, how would you know what that person can do? Would you hire someone with no training or experience? Then how do you get experience? It's a catch 22, the best way to evaluate someone is to at least see that they have trained and PASSED some sort of assessment test. And isn't that what the IT Cert's are for?
Please take a reality check! Or are you upset cause you had to work at your cert. while other people seemed to breeze through them?
Sincerely,
Robert Harris, Jr. MCSE, CNA
by sgross
Wow!
Having just waded through all 13* replies, here's mine:
My Story:
- I was at DEC for 6 yrs. in the 80's after getting an Associates Degree at a community college in Computer Maintenance Tech.
- I spent most of the 90's outside of IT, and when my position was axed, was back on the street.
- I spent *alot* of the money I had saved over the years to go to school full-time while my wife worked to learn NT 4.0 and Novell 4.11.
- I spent even more to get my CNE. For over a year I had no life, just a mission.
- The CNE paper, along with good manners and having a head on my shoulders, got me my first IT job in three weeks. They hired me over other prospects because they were a "Novell Gold Partner" and their CNE was taking a year off. I worked there until I get a job closer to home at a school district as Network Administrator. At this point I had been out of school less than a year. But I had my CNE, and the other prospects didn't...
My observations:
The 4.11 CNE tests were put together by Marketing folks, asking questions about features and numbers, mostly multiple choice. They are not easy. They make sure you know their product.
When I went back to the test center to update my CNE to Netware 5, I failed the first time because I mistakenly thought my 1+ year of administering a few 5.0 servers would help answer test questions. Wrong. Back to the books and self-tests and more expenses.
Now that I have over 2 years experience, I probably won't take any more tests.
I left the District and Novell a few weeks ago to take a positon as a UNIX Administrator. I'm learning UNIX on the job, because experienced UNIX people are hard to come by here in Massachusetts.
Bottom Line:
Yes, the tests are flawed. They need more real-world questions, as others have pointed out. But, they are not worthless.
Steve Gross CNA CNE
by fultron66
by systemsdude
by acombr
I disagree.
Does a person become an Accountant or Engineer by Hands on Experience of two years??? Heck no. They go to school and get a degree and then enter the ranks of those looking for a job. What is so different about this and someone going to school and getting the instruction/training so they can enter the IT field? A certifecation says that you passed the test of what it is expected that you should know.
How does someone get into the IT field? No one wants to hire someone without "experience" At least the certification says that the person has some level of understanding of what is going on. It gives the employer a way to say that this person, even though a beginner, has a certain level of competence and training. Why must this only be hands on experience of two years??? How did you get your job? By the way, most certification schools have a lab where you practice the skills.
If you have at least two years experience, you are on the inside of IT. I am workinghard to get there too and I am studying very hard to learn all the book stuff, so when I do get a chance to enter the IT industry, I will be a quick learner and become a very productive member of that company in a short time. I will not need two years to learn the ropes. I will be productive hopefully on the first day or at least quickly.
By the way, if you think that all of the certifications are easy, A+ was not bad, but have you looked at the MCSE for Windows 2000? It requires a good understanding of the subject.
Those that are certified have shown that they are willing to put forth the time, money and effort to learn on their own. This is training that the company does NOT have to provide which saves them money and time.
Your idea certainly leaves us beginners out in the cold and the company no place to look for their entry positions.
Roy Acomb
by paul.kennedy
Engineers, architects, nurses, doctors, and probably others I missed, need to do significant work experience in the 'real world' before they are awarded their degree. Most professional associations also require some period of experience before a professional is accepted as a 'full' member.
Entry level positions are a great way to learn a lot very quickly. You will be surprised how much you learn in your first 6 months. Good luck.
by webmaster
My wife happens to be an accountant, and having the degree did nothing more than prove she could take orders. Her knowledge of accounting came from experience. Books can only teach theory. Anyone with in depth knowledge knows that to fully understand and perform you MUST learn in the real world.
My experience was self taught. I spend alot of time and money developing my skills. I did as one gentleman suggested. I started my own business because I knew I would not get hired without theexperience. When I sold my business, I still had to enter the field at an entry level. I could not prove I knew what I knew from just a piece of paper.
I am by no means trying to keep anyone from entering the IT field. In fact I encourage it. However, just because you can take a test doesn't mean you get full reins and compensation. That must be earned. I think we should do as the electricians and other trades do and require a journeyman's appretice position for a period of time in order to allow the person to gain working knowledge and experience to enter into the sys admin role fully armed and qualified.
The MCSE, while it does require knowledge, has fallen by the wayside for that which it was intended by all of these so called training courses. I can buy a book and memorize the questions and pass the test. Does that mean I know the fundamental basics? I think not.
Anyone can learn how to repair a computer. It takes a special breed to be an effective admin.
Tom Johnson
by emsiesekrap
I went to a technical school to study for my
certs. It wasn't until three years later that
I completed my MCSE. We had hands-on lab then
and I continued at home until now, after all these years I think I'll be an easy learner
when a company finally hires me, although no
work experience, but had a lot at home, practicing, fdisking, installling, re-installing, that's where my experience is. To
bad though if you don't have one of the other
(experience or certs) no one seems to want to
hire you. I'm beginning to think that all of
this about IT is all "hype"
by a.kuhl
SB that wants to start a career in IT will need some sort of certification. How are you supposed to get into the IT field without certification ? Maybe your Uncle will hire you ? What really counts is the experience on the job - agreed - but there has to be a way to get in to get experience as well.
(...who would administer this anyway ?)
by ray.pasley
Okay having been in the industry for 15 years, uncertified, I and the folks I now have working for me have created award winning Web sites, before that, implemented corporate wide wans, first banyan then NT, and along the way any number of other creative and productive systems. None of these people were certified. Many had no previous IT exp before working in our group.
An example, a retired Navy nurse with stong interest, going to college, first interned, then hired.
The point is, the perception around certification by corporations is they are getting a bargain, with pre-qualified personnel, though many don't have any interest other than the cash the job brings, not the real satisfaction of doing creative work.
I have worked with cetified personnel who really could do nothing more than search the web, paste info together, and hand off to a 'real IT person' to implement.
Nother point is what can you do, not what paper are you basing you application on count for more in myexperience.
So I suggest you look for those companies that realize bargains are what they are, potential lemons. If you are truely interested in the Science and Art of Information Technologys, like cream you will float to the top.
by strikeleader
by mugen
I think certification right now is a way for new comers into the IT field to get there foot in the door.
As for the companies that think they are getting a bargain because they are hiring someone based on the fact that they are certified, that company problem isn't a company you'd want to work for anyways.
I have to admit that even though someone is newly certified it doesn't mean they are an expert. As in previous posts everyone seems to agree that it's a level of measurement. This goes for people with degrees also...
I myself have had some minor experience with PC's and networks before I received my MCSE but even after I received my MCSE, I don't consider myself an expert. However it was a way for me to get involved in IT andit gave me lots of good opportunities.
Whether you have a degree or certification or both, once you get your foot in, all that matters is that your prove that your a valuable asset to the company. After that, your paper certs & degrees don't mean as much, it's your performance that counts!
All in all, it's what you make of your certification or degree. There are always a few shining stars out there!
by robert
Maybe instead of limiting the certification to someone in the field for two years, the testing portion should be harder...
Cisco Systems does not have a documented 'paper' anything, because they change the test often enough to prevent memorization. You have to KNOW the subject matter, not just know what to look for on the test.
This is what Microsoft has tried to start this with the Win 2K testing (at least that's their claim)...we shall see...
Paper certifications are commonplace nowdue to Tech Schools and the like that will go and push a class out the door without any hands on. I know of one person who passed the NT 4 tests and got hired because of the Certification, yet she had no hands on EVER!
Perhaps we should require the SCHOOLS to be more aggressive with hands on training and less on test prep...
In actuality, I believe that the A+ certification should be a requirement for someone to get hired. Then perhaps, they can get certified in other things.
Robert Clark
MCSE, MCP+I, MCP, A+
MIS - Texas Cellular
by ray.pasley
Yeah actually small companies do hire folks who have learned at home. Small companies are a good place to start for the self taught systems or apps programmer.
Small companies that have had a contractor set them up, and find that their systems donot function well, or consistantly, are great targets for the self starter to begin their IT career, it gives em the 'larger system' to build a resume of experience, as well as have experience. The small company will be highly dependent on your skills, so you will feel the urgency, the criticalness of doing it, and doing it right, since most small companies can't afford the price most certified people expect coming out of the class room based on the hype the training company got em into the classroom with.
Of course when you go to a small company with your self taught self, you should have the actual knowledge needed to be of value to that company, you will be if not the only IT person, one of very few in the group, and your mistakes will not be noticed till they affect the small company in big ways. That of course is the risk small companies are forced to take with their smaller systems and budgets.
by denpeters
Are you for real? If you seriously think any legitimate company is going to hire a 'paperboy' to do any high level administration or engineering without any real world experience, then you really need to pull your head out of the sand (or whatever it is stuck in).
I am an intelligent fast learner with a degree in engineering (BSEE from Penn State. I bartended for ten years to support my music career as a solo acoustic musician. One year ago when I decided to change careers and pursue a technical career, I chose to acquire my MCSE through a two week boot camp. There was no other way for a 35 year newbie to break into the IT field. I had no experience and no desire to be a gopher tech monkey for years just to 'earn my right' to utilize more than .001% of my brain capacity as a blue collar techie. It worked, and after a year of help desk, I feel more qualified to move on in my career. I had no misconceptions that my paper MCSE would land me a lucrative high paying position, and believe me, neither did any company I applied to.
I could have wasted several years attempting to do anything in IT to gain experience enough to qualify for training, or anywhere from the six months to several years others have spent getting their MCSE, or the two weeks I spent taking the course work and, yes, passing all six exams for my NT MCSE. I chose wisely. I am now a valuable asset to my company. I got my MCSE to get into a field, not to gloat or conquer it. I know what it is worth, and so do companies. So don't fool yourself, Greg. There is no magical, mystical quality to certifications, and nobody, including respected companies, puts us on a pedestal without relevant experience and a track record to back it up. Think about it. This isn't the old boys club, it's high tech.
Dennis
MCSE, MCP+I, BSEE
by el guapo
by mugen
You are now separating people with degrees and those without? I've met many people with and without degrees and you get your fare share of idiots in both categories. Having a degree does not always guarantee you can do the job.
The difference between someone getting there certification with no experience and someone who has experience is their starting point in the IT Field...Joe Blow taxi driver is not going to get his MCSE and then become Senior Network Administrator of AT&T....While someone like yourself with more experience will most likely start at a higher position and pay.
I don't think people currently in IT have to worry about MCSE's without experience taking over the job market. There's a spot in IT for the experienced and the inexperienced.
by tony
I agree that to keep the MCSE standards high there should be a requirement of 2 years hands on experience before being considered. I get p....d off with so called I.T pros constantly bitching about the paper MCSE. I am an IT pro of 8 years standing who completed my MCSE last year. Believe me , it wasn't easy. I dont believe that anyone without corporate hands on experience could pass an MCSE.
I have a theory that most of the people who disparage the MCSE have either failed to get one or dont have the drive and ambition to get one.
The MCSE was one of the most difficult and therefore most satisfying achievements in my professional career. Oddly enough you dont often hear MCSE's disparaging none MCSE's do you?
So come on, we all have a free choice about whether or not to become certified so dont ram your particular belief down other peoples throats.
PS: You will still have a lot to learn even after certification.
Tony
by wabernat
So, you can get a MCSE without ever having built a server? If you study enough and have a good memory, you can be a Cisco Certified Network Professional with out ever having logged into a router. Is there a physical you build it, we break it, you fix it kind of thing for the MicroSoft Certifications?
Hummm... It sounds like some employeers have gotten burned with "paper" certifications. It also sounds like some empolyees have worked along side someone who knows less, but gets paid more justbecause he has that "paper" certification. However, if employeers are willing to base hiring decisions on "paper" only, and not have a good technical interview process; and, if they are willing to cough up the money for my "paper" certification, I am takin the money.
by kbnet
Finally someone out there who has figured out what it means to be certified. If an employer was going to pay me more for having a piece of paper saying that I had the basic Knowledge to perform the job of course I am going to get my certification. Ifind it really weird that all the IT people out there who refuse to get their certification or think the little piece of paper does not mean anything have not figured this out.
I guess these, what I like to call Idiot Technologist's (IT) people like to work for less money then going and taking the so called worthless certification exams and placing themselves in the position to where they could make more money and provide for a better living for what is really important (I don't mean your little precious network that you won't let anyone touch who has a certification) your FAMILY. So EVERYBODY OUT THERE, STOP YOUR WHINING ABOUT CERTIFICATION AND EXPERIENCE AND DO WHAT MY DAD ALWAYS SAYS:
PLAY THE GAME MY SON!!!!
by e00011rob21
by arg cio
by ninewands
Troubleshooting involves very little in the way of "creativity" ... what is involved is either analytical thinking or it is blind luck.
Analytical thinking, with regard to troubleshooting, is the ability to apply the scientific principle of causeand effect to backtrack from the effect to the cause, and that skill can be, and is, taught everyday in all of the scientific disciplines.
Experience allows one to be selective in the paths one follows while backtracking, thus avoiding the process of chasing rabbits down blind trails.
You can't excel in ANY technical field without both.
Regards,
ninewands
by kbolling
I can't completely agree with this. While it is true that there are some "paper tigers" out there, certification is also a great way for new people in the field to get at least a grasp of the overall picture. Now if a company hires someone with noexperience, but who is an MCSE or CNE, then that company needs to review its hiring practices. But, we shouldn't penalize newbies who are changing careers and want a chance. Are you going to hire a newbie with no experience AND no certs?
Kevin Bollinger
MCP (4x), CNA
by mattbrowna1
Certifications are already a prerequisite for getting an entry level job in this industry. If experience is made a prerequisite for certification, no one will be able to get a job or a certificate. Pay in the IT field, and respect for it professionals are decreasing because of big business' greed, and desk jockeys thinking we are just bonehead mechanics, and only they make business profitable.
I am an A+ certified technician, and have used computers since early childhood. I had to get this cert first to get a job. I was laughed out of interviews before I had it, but hired, albeit by a temp agency, only two weeks after getting it. Don't want paper certs? Design examinations that test problem solving intelligence, not memorization. Comptia is already working on that.
by mattbrowna1
going to scholl doesn't give you experience, and with the cost of tuition today, It's a privelage of the rich to go. Also many schools are just diploma printers for anyone who pays their tuition.
The sad truth is that IT pay is just going down.No matter what we do, we are not going to get rich like in the "good old days" we've all heard tell of. A lot of people with college degrees are doing jobs that involve wearing a name tag and saying, "fries with that?" college recruiters won't tell you this.
by my4deuces
It took me over twenty years to figure out
that I needed more than just the work
experience to get me where I wanted to be
salary wise. You are right that the cost of
tuition is high, but you have to make the
necessary sacrifices to get the education if
you want the higher salary. I have a BS
degree in Management Information
Systems/Computer Information System, yet I
still can must continue on the complete the
certification process because 15 year of work
experience still isn't enough. I have to
agree with the person who earlier stated that
there needs to be contols in place making the
certifications a part of the job, and
experience a requisite for ceritication.
by jmccull418
Good Idea, NOT!
I'm sure Greg was born with a keyboard in his
hand.
Since I am embarking on what I hope to be a new career,I hope that someone will be willing to work with me,not try to insult my
effort to better myself.
I love what I am doing!
Everyone starts somewhere.
by brasslet
by gnx
by heybobk
Gee, then I guess we shouldn't allow "certifications" for attorneys, doctors, dentists, CPA's, and other professions unless they have practiced for at least 2 years. The problem is, nobody will let them practice UNTIL they have their certifications!
And I guess we shouldn't allow college professors to teach MCSE-related classes unless they have "practiced" in industry for at least 2 years before they obtain their MCSE.
In the absence of industry experience,taking classes and passing the tests to obtain an MCSE certification certainly does not diminish or invalidate the person's knowledge of the subject. Certainly, there is no substitute for relevant experience, but lack thereof doesn't mean the person doesn't know anything, or isn't worthy of an MCSE cert.
On the other hand, I know people who have, say, 5 years of experience, but it's really just one year's experience five times, if you catch my drift.
Greg, your message sounds like you believe some of the elitist garbage being floated these days. Being certified is not, in and of itself, an indication of competence. It is simply an indication that certain tests have been passed, and that the person "should" posess certain basic knowledge.
Kind of like a college degree, huh? The degree itself doesn't mean you can do a particular job, it just means that certain tests have been passed -- kinda like an MCSE.
Bob Keller
by marence
I worked as a trainer in a computer learning center, and suffered through trying to teach basic Windows skills to students who were told "Network engineers make the BIG BUCKS" by account reps who wanted to sell these career changers expensive training courses, and hey, you could put in on your credit card! My colleagues & I had the bonus of teaching the same students over & over & over, as there was a "take it til you pass" guarantee on the classes.
The classes had the bare minimum of hands-ondemos, and were often taught by paper MCSEs and CNEs who got the certifications, then the training cert, and never touched a server in their lives - not exactly conducive to learning real-world skills along with the theory.
You really need both hands-on practical experience as well as a thourough understanding of networking to be successful as an engineer.
by bj9
To begin with, the context of the complaint is indicative of someone with a personal gripe against the system. If anyone can take and pass any of the certification tests, without using the software or technology, should amaze us.
I do believe that the Certification demonstrates completion, not competency. I personally have been exposed to NT for the past 6 months and have passed 5 of the 6 tests. I will have my MCSE in 1 week but could I administer and maintain an NT network? Maybe, or maybe not.
In this industry, the certification should indicate that you understand the concepts and the intent of an OS or App and are able to apply that knowledge in support of clients, customers, or users. Employers need a baseline to evaluate potential employees. First we needed a High School diploma, then a two year or trade school diploma, then an undergraduate or Graduate degree. All of that is too generalized. Technology is becoming too specialized.
In a nutshell, the Cert is just another hoop to jump through.
by ssg0487
by jbuchberger
I didn't spend thousands of dollars on cram courses to attain the knowledge needed to pass my certifications. What I invested is long hard study time using several sources of information for each test, including expensive text books, free websites, hands on fooling with it as much as I could on my home system and at work where possible.
The people who think you can pass the CCNA test or any of the MCP tests by simply memorizing questions and answers from a braindump site are misinformed, plain and simple. Does this mean I think I could take over management of a complex network? No. I know I'm still what I consider a 'paper cert' holder, and without real world experience that's all I'll ever be. But before I started working for my certifications (A+, MCSE, MCP+I, CCNA) I was just a hobbyist with no clue about networks and routing principles.
I began the certification track as a way to focus my studies into what is needed in the marketplace. For example, I see a lot of jobs requiring knowledge and experience in Exchange so if I decided I even wanted a chance at those jobs what I would do is learn the technology well enough to at least pass the Microsoft test. This might get me in the door at least to where I could get some real life exposure to it and become a 'guru' eventually if I found liked it.
The other point I want to make is that many companies are required to have X amount of MCSE's or CCNA's or A+'s on staff in order to maintain their dealer authorizations. That's why I have a CCNA and have never worked on a router other than simulators and logging into website labs. I don't claim to be an expert at Cisco technology yet but if I ever get the chance with entry level exposure, I know I'll at least have the basics with which to build on.
Joe Buchberger
by cotty
I was a degree qualified, registered engineer who spent many years using and working on electronic equipment (including computers).
I have just completed the A+ certification, and am working as a help desk technician with a large company. My previous experience in engineering meant nothing to my employer, but the A+ did. How did I get it? By buying the book/s and studying. Plus my hands on previous knowledge.
If I had needed the two years of experience I would be out of work! Surely it should be up to the employer to evaluate the persons qualifications and experience, and make/or not the work offer based on those findings.
Cotty
Ex Engineer/now techie
by ravensperch
Cotty,
Your real-world experience means far more to me than your A+ cert. Had you knocked on my door when I was running a Nat'l DSL installation company, I'd have hired ya. Given you a week or two training, and then sent you out solo.
Guys with MCSEs BOUGHT (not earned through hands-on experience) from tech schools came knocking on my door everyday. 99% of them failed the simple test I gave them - constructed of questions like "How do you add an email account in Microsoft Outlook Express? What does TCP/IP stand for?".
It's the guys who EARNED their wings through hands-on and hardcore studying/practicing at home that aced my test everytime. No certs. And they were my best workers - the MCSEs acted like they owned the world.
I'm starting up my own company now and I tell ya, if an MCSE walks through my door with no experience, he'll be kindly thanked and never called again.
I don't want people who slept through lectures and crammed to pass an exam. This ain't college. This is real world, real computers, real customers who need solutions.
And for that, I only want REAL techs. The guys who have been-there, done-that.
Two thumbs up to the 2yrs prior before certification idea! There are plenty of entry-level positions or even internship to build up that first 2 years. Then we'll know that Paper Techs can actually hold their own with Real Techs.
by janetf
I don't have much IT experience but I have a paper certification and I help students to achieve their paper certifications, mostly as Oracle DBAs.
I advise students who do not have the recommended year or two of experience that they will need tocreate it for themselves through intense practice.
I train experienced DBAs, programmers and career changers with little to no computer experience.
The students that practice at home regulary are getting a kind of experience. It's also no surprise to me that the same students who practice a LOT are able to pass the exams and I suspect they did well in their previous careers too. They work HARD!
Most paper certifications are not earned by listening to lectures and memorizing textbooks. Sometimes they are just like some doctors go through medical school and never learn to relate to patients patients.
I think a good technical interviewer can tell one paper certificate(memorization) from another(synthesized experience)by askingtechnical questions just not too soon after the certification date!
by jbuchberger
It takes most people more than just plunking down their $100 and taking a test to earn their CCNA or MCP certification, but it doesn't take any expensive classroom training either. $13,000, or even $5-6,000 to pass 6 MCP exams and get your MCSE is too much if you ask me. All you really need is some self discipline and maybe a hundred dollars or so worth of study guides per test, and the willingness to invest the hours you need to pass each one in order to achieve your goal. A home lab is greatand only takes a few low-cost and maybe outdated pc's and parts to get started.
Also, after reading many of these postings today I'm beginning to wonder how any amount of certification can do someone any good if they can't write at even a 6th grade level in order to create a professional looking resume.
by ravensperch
Roger,
There is a difference though, in what you can do. You'll be working during the day and taking classes at night sometimes. Okay, so on the nights that you're not taking classes, go down to your nearest ISP and do some intern work there.
Yes, this will make it tough at home with the family. BUT you could be able to trade that time for credits, AND you'll be using what you learn, AND when you finally get that coveted CCNA you'll have more than just paper under your belt. You'll have the experience.
Besides, if you start working for an ISP for free and prove that you learn quick and are eager to learn more and take on more responsibility, it's far more likely they'll give you a paying job after a few months to supplement the sacrifice you're making spending time away from your family. (They wouldn't put it like that, but I would.)
Then once you have your cert and the more important hands-on real-world experience, you thank your local ISP for letting you learn and go demand the salary your combined qualifications (cert + exp) out in the IT world.
Good Luck!
(I'm not in the midwest so can't tell ya. Texas, Florida, and Northern VA near D.C. are real hot spots though for CCNA's.)
by webmaster
Is Bill gates MCSE or MCSD?? NOOO!!! What if he had been required to have a certification before he made windows? Did he make windows?
The point is we as IT professionals are allowing some scam artist book worms dictate how our profession isperceived. It is up to those of us in a management role to look at the experience and then and only then should we account for the paper cert. When I review resumes, I look for the experience, not the paper. It doesn't hold value to me anymore.
I would rather hire someone who has sweated and spent every ounce of energy perfecting their skills. And not because someone told them they could start out making 65K a year, but because they enjoy it! I am fortunate in that my job is also my hobby. Most admins that excel are the same.
To us it's a passion not a job.
Tom Johnson
by tjryan123
Well, at age 53 I decided to make a career change after 26 years in eng/const management. My salary was over 100K/yr but for the past 10 years I hated my job.
I have had a computer since the Pong game came out. I loved messing with my home computer screwing it up and figuring out how to fix it.
In 1998, I quit my E&I job tapped my own savings and went back to school. Took 346 hours of classroom/labs. Got A+ certified first and the MCSE next. Took me 8 months. Worked partime in helpdesk slotfor $8.00/hr while going to classes. Out of our class of 24 there were those who snoozed or generally goofed off. Some even passed.
BUT there were also those of us who after class went to the CBT lab to study more, studied everyday 7 days a week. Met in study groups. When didn't understand something we bought other materials or used the internet to get other explantions. It was very hard for me but I loved the learing experience.
After looking for 3 mo for a full time slot I wound up workingwith another E&C company but in their IT dept providing desktop support adding PC's to the network, troubleshooting. I took over a $50K/yr cut and was glad to just get a chance in IT. I knew I would take a big hit but was ready and willing to make the jump to IT. My employer recognised that I had little experience but also recognised the value of my determination. I just received a quality excellence award after 6 months on the job. He did say that without my "paper MCSE" I would not have been considered. My MCSE schooling gave me the basics and helped me make the transition. Now it's up to me to expand my skills. But without the schooling and the paper and an understanding IT manager I never would have got the chance.
Us "paper MCSE's"aren't all the same. Some of us did it the hard way. You could be overlooking a valuable asset to your company when you just look at "yrs of experience".
by webmaster
If you read my post correctly, I said I look at experience before the paper. That means I prefer a hard working, determined person over a test taker. Your case is a rare one. 9 out of 10 applicants just got certified and now want to be an admin.Doesn't work that way. You actually did it the right way. Start at the bottom and prove yourself. If you are the dedicated person you claim, the proving part will payoff in a big way in a short amount of time.
When I sold my business, I alsotook a big hit. I went from grossing 1/2 mil a year to 40K a year. But my determination to be in this industry was worth it. As I said, I would rather hire a person whose life IS computers than some snot nosed punk who thinks because they can pass a test they have earned the right to be an admin.
I admire your determination. These snot nosed punks could learn alot from you.
best of luck.
Tom Johnson
by haffly
by jbenson
by georgeb
My view of certification is multi-layered. If you consider certificates as works of art they are worthless, but what they *represent* can mean a lot.
Some are awarded for passing a Q&A test, where a good score is sufficient to prove that you understand *Something* fairly well. The more tests, the better the understanding. This type of certification - by pure Q&A - implies no practical experience or adaptive skill, but it can be helpful when preparing for an entry-level job, or learning something new, to 'broaden your skill set'.
Other certificates, such as those held by commercial pilots or heart surgeons, cannot be gained, or even maintained, without considerable, ongoing "field experience". In these occupations, errors are measured in human life, and entry-level positions are simply not available (except in emergencies).
Somewhere between 'printer setups' and 'code blue' there is room for debate on IT certification, both in principle and in practice. Should they be pure Q&A? Should there be a "master" or "doctorate" level, where field tests are included? Should certificates have an expiry date, or a mandatory periodic re-test date? How much of any test should be standards-based, and how much should be vendor-specific? Of the dozens of IT tests available today, how much or how many will still be relevant in another 5 years?
As a proof of learning, I believe there is room for all manner of degrees of certification in IT, just as in every important field since the word 'test' was first used. All tests are crude measuring tools of knowledge and skill, and most require hands-on experience as a final supplement, but they serve a useful purpose, as benchmarks of understanding and as evidence of competency and a desire to learn.
by ninewands
You amaze me with your attitude. I, personally, have about 25 years of "home" and "additional duty" experience in IT areas, and couldn't get a recruiter to talk to me until I started accumulating certifications. On the last contract gig I had, I was advising the Back Office expert for the prime contractor on how to resolve issues related to cross-platform networking (mixed environment of NT, Novell and Linux servers). And, while I can't do it knee0jerk automatically, I can do a fair job of configuring a Cisco router. Be that as it may, no certs, no response to the resume. Not even a polite "No thanks."
BTW, I also have three degrees, including a doctorate, but they are not IT-relevant, so they don't open any doors either.
I wonder how many people like me your attitude has cost you?
Regards,
ninewands
by jbuchberger
I want to learn as much about the industry as possible, and while it isn't feasible to be an expert in every area, I can sure get a grasp of a new subject by learning it well enough to pass an industry certification test. I'm also up front with recruiters who ask about my actual skill set; while I studied my butt off in order to pass each test, I don't pass myself off as an expert in say, MS Internet Information Server 4, which I book studied and have never used in real life.
Professional interviewers don't seem to expect it either as long as I'm straight with them up front about what I know I can and can't do for them.
I've run into a few arrogant bustards though who's first words to me in interviews were that they've been in this business for X amount of years and don't have any damn certifications while they look accusingly at me like I shouldn't either unless I'm as experienced as they are. Do these jerks feel threatened by an entry-level applicant who's happened to spend the time and effort in learning the material well enough to pass a simple standardized test?
I've been working with computers since 1980, in PC sales and support initially and in accounting software application support more recently. I knew next tonothing about NT networks, or networks in general until I discovered the certification tracks and that's when my 'formal' computer education really took off.
You old hands in your field, crusty with your hard earned experience, ought to check your prejudices against those who have worked for their certifications yet haven?t gotten the experience YET. And while you?re at it, if the tests are so damn easy why not waltz into a testing center and plunk down your $100 and crank out a passing score so you don?t feel so intimidated by the newbies who?ve only had the tests as their measure of progress so far.
by ninewands
You know, I'm beginning to get REALLY bored with this thread.
No one will ever agree on the relative value of degrees and certifications because they are fundamentally different.
A degree is broadly based and focused on the broad underlying principles of the technology because people with degrees are being trained to produce the technology of tomorrow.
Certifications are SUPPOSED to indicate an in-depth knowledge of the details of a technology because certified people are expected to be able to maintain the current technology.
Like it or not, that's the fact. Engineers in R&D labs MUST have degrees. Technicians and admins NEED to have RESPECTED certs. A vendor who allows the value of its certs to be devalued to the point that they are not respected does itself a disservice. They also do a disservice to the applicants who pay money to take their tests.
Regards,
ninewands
Congradulations on your degree. I also have a degree. A two-year degree from a technical college TSTC, Waco. I also have MS and Cisco certs. I wanted to focus my learning on my career, not on frat parties and a bunch of worthless and sometimes too liberal classes. Most people, they go to college, get a BS degree in nutrition, and then work as a receptionist. You wasted a LOT of time and MONEY on your degree, and now you're a little annoyed that you're made to look the fool who wasted these resources just to get into a field that didn't require a degree, and that there are degree-less people doing better than you at it.
I like the fact that in this field, you are recognized and rewarded for your IT-ability, while the level of your degree(AAS, BS, MS) is not relevent.
by jdow
A MCSE or CNE, or whichever cert your looking for shows you know how "MICROSOFT or NOVELL" says things should work. Your experience in the field shows you how things ACTUALLY work. The problem today, is for professionals, a cert doesnt mean anything compared to an ex-psychologist turned computer man. But, I do say this, regardless of certification or past experience, there are ways of making it out there, your intelligence and will to succeed will show, and employers respect that.
Just mytwo cents.
by jdow
by jdow
by jdow
It is not all that diffcult to obtain a MCSE,CNE, etc certification. In the past I have worked with individuals that have had a CNE certification but didn't even know how to shutdown the Netware server properly.
I believe a graduated certifcation process is the right approach. This would allow for those folks who have learned at home etc to get the higer level of certification and at the same time allow those people that have little or no experience to show that they have some theoretical knowledge etc.
by rromo
Bravo for having the nads to say so. Certifications only teach what the Certifier wants you to know, making you a drone. The best example I can offer is when I took a few NT classes a few years ago at a nationally-known training center. Wanting to know how to optimize a server's performance for the OS, I asked an obvious question. I gave all the parameters (number of users, CPU, disk capacity, etc.) and asked how much RAM would be optimal. "I don't know. That's a good question." This from a certified teacher of teachers. A little more probing revealed that this instructor had never configured a network in a real enterprise. As a matter of fact, she had to call in tech support to troubleshoot a desktop that wasn't hitting the server.
"I don't know" seems to be acceptable in today's world of ninety-day wonders. Having been an EDP, MIS, IT - whatever - professional for almost 20 years, and having two undergraduate degrees, I never tell my boss or those that I support that I don't know. Worst case, I tell them I'm resolving the problem. And I do. At the risk of sounding immodest, aggregate downtime of my systems (five production servers, two web servers, two proxy servers and almost 200 clients) while at my current employer of six years has been less than eight hours. That's right. Total is less than one work day over a six year span. Now that's knowing your systems inside and out. And I'm not certified.
A degree is more than just paper. It's years of class time, analysis, theory, and hands-on in labs. Add a few years of installing, maintaining and administering networks - that makes a bonafied professional. Certifications are worthless without the years of experience and/or formal education.
Asa manager, I don't hire certified professionals without the degree or as many years in experience.
by lou1
by tim_holcomb
I myself am not certified, more reasons than I'd care to explain is why I am not, but, I myself have atleast 8 years in the IT field.
Does that make me a professional? No, because I don't have a *certification*!
So, no, I can't agree with thetwo year *Professional Certificate*. That's total BS, most of these people have spend hard hours studying over manuals and texts to take the proper tests to get *certified*. And some breeze through like it was nothing.
So, uh-unh, No way, the two year thingy is BS. I do like the add-ins about the nurse and accountant though, but IT is *totally* different from those fields.
Let's face facts, if you have enough expendable cash you CAN get your MCSE (at least in NT4) by going to a boot camp type setting, where they grill you for 10 hrs and you take tests the whole time. It DOES happen, otherwise why would there be such an outcry of employers and experienced MCSE concerning "paper" MCSE's. Bottom line is this, experience has been, and always will be, king. An experienced IT professional (certs, degrees, or just plain experience) worth their salt will be able to demonstrate via their resume of past projects or during the interview process of their capability to perform the job.
-B-
by michelle d
Have faith, JBane.
I hired two developers last year who had finished University and had just over 1 years experience...at home and hired them because they knew what they were talking about. Not all employers are concerned with qualifications andyour job history some are interested in the individual and their aptitude and interest in their CHOSEN profefession.
Sort by Trending