Paper Certifications?
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by tim_holcomb
If someone wants to know the level of expertise that I can give them, they need to know what *I've* done to earn someone's respect, not MS's respect.
If the customer wants a "Certified" professional, then more power the them, but if you want the job done right, then go with the *experience*.
by shanghai sam
Why do people with years of experience think someone learning a new area of expertise through classes or self-study in order to increase their skill set in this rapidly changing industry is a threat to them because they have passed the required tests?
A person who is a good study and has cranked out his or her MCSE in six months knows full well what a limited skill set they really have and how far they have to go before considering themselves on par with someone who's been in the trenches for years.
If I had ten years experience in one area of the industry, say networked accounting applications, and then decided to expand my horizons and protect my earning potential by learning an entirely new area, say Cisco, or SQL or Oracle, or Exchange, should I need to learn everything hands on before being qualified to take a test showing I now have these new skills?
No. I study and learn the technology, and take a test to prove that I have attained the minimum knowledge requirements to be considered for at least an entry level and possibly higher position, depending on other factors such as people skills and a willingness to be a team player and the ability to learn.
A certification isn't a license to perform brain surgery, and the ones attaining them realize it more than you do Greg, get over it. Or better yet, go add a few easy line items to your resume by knocking off some certification tests.
Joe Buchberger
AS-Accounting, A+(highly qualified), MCSE, MCP+I, CCNA(paper)
by tim_holcomb
While in the Army, I *learned* to troubleshoot according to a manual. But, I inherently knew more than the manual could tell.... Not that someone had taught me the troubleshooting skills, but my inner creativity allowed me to *try* this and *try* that, more often than not, I found the problems faster than someone using the manual. And with the same results!
So, no, certs and degrees will get yer foot in the door, but will they hold the sweat and tears of long hours and average pay?
Don't think so, experience and knowledge can do that for you.
by dixiedi
Like you I agree there are too many individuals out there with certs and no idea what they are doing.
I am self taught, using online classes and free tutorials whenever I can find them.
I know more than a few individuals who had the money to go to school, just about memorize possible test questions, then get very well paying jobs.
In the meantime, because I only have free Brainbench certs, I am still a struggling self employed person. While my friends are now earning $75,000 + a year. Asking ME how to do this and that via ICQ, email, etc.
Needless to say, I have gotten tired of working for them for free and got a new ICQ number and don't use those email addresses anymore.
I have one "friend" who put my struggling self employment business on his resume as my employee. This guy now makes $50,000, free automobile, great benefits, etc. With a Microsoft Work Station Certification! It is all beyond comprehension to me!
by spazzy814
I can see the point about the diminished value of certs when you have people who pass them from rote memory only, with no working hands on experience or understanding in the "real world". True, its an embarassement for the rest of the IT community when these newbies constantly flub the job after boasting their paper successes, but in some cases, certification is what gets many "a foot in the door" into their IT fields in the first place. Most of whom I've met have proven their expertise time and again and many credit their success to taking the first step which was studying hard and bringing their goal to fruition through certifications.
I do agree however, that when a newly certified employee comes on to the platform with no proven experience, that there should be a time of apprenticeship served. Many employers are beginning to see the financial benefits as well as the gain in productivity from this type of arrangement. Why in productivity? Because the apprentice wants deeply to prove him or herself and there is less boasting and covering up for lack of knowledge. It promotes an atmoshere with the liberty to ask questions when an uncertainty arises, instead of making a critical mistake and covering it up...and we all know what can occur when that happens!
What do all of you who read this think? Am I way off base with this?
LD
Network Technician
by jeffz
I also believe the value of "certs" have diminished. In the glory days of the past if an individual held a computer cert of some type it held more "weight" than it does now because you had to gain the experience in the field and hits the books to pass the exam. (Work or reference books, not the ones made to help one pass the tests) Presently, with all the cramming, boot camps, and brain dumps anyone with the time and mental capacity to retain it can become a cert holder without any real worldexperience.
I also believe that it can be a way to get your foot in the door and that all depends on the needs of the company your applying for. And there is no comparison between a college degree and a ?cert?. A cert gives you the knowledge ofone subject per se, where a degree gives you knowledge in many different areas. Neither will make you a professional once you have that paper in your hand. It takes time in your chosen field to be seen as a professional. I don?t care how good youthink you are, you?re not a professional until you have proven yourself to your employers, peers, or clients and have their respect in my mind.
I?m a senior LAN administrator for several LANs. Versed in heavily in MS server application with 8 administrators under me. I?ve seen MSCE?s come and go. Given the cert-crazed environment today, when a person tells me they are a MSCE or others cert ? I take it with a grain of salt. There?s far more to running networks/LANs than books can teach, but the book is a technical start. No, I don?t have a cert and wasn?t really interested in getting one until this thread but out of curiosity I want to test my knowledge against an exam to see the results without studying for it.
JZ
Senior LAN administrator
by arg cio
by arg cio
I think you're wrong on a few points.
First you say that you would hire a person either for his/her degree or experience equivalent.
Well, I know I'm not breaking any news to you by telling you that a degree does not in any way equate to hands-on years of expereince. If you hire for a degree only, say in Computer Science, you have just hired a greenhorn with mostly programming education. While if you were to hire an expereinced IT professional, well that speaks for itself. It is obvious that the experienced pro is the better candidate.
Secondly, no IT manager in his right mind hires based on certifications or degrees, he would hire based upon the knowledge and experienced needed to get the job done, and neither certs. nor degreessay anything to that effect. What does matter is a combination of all three.
by seanr
I would also have to agree to a certain extent. However, it is a little like getting your driver's license. You need to have a little experience before you can go and take the drivers test, otherwise there is no way that you would be able to pass the parallel parking portion of the test without practice.
On the other hand, employers aren't so blind to the whole situation. Just because you have a license to be a driver doesn't make you qulified to drive a bus or 18-wheeler. I think the same can be said of the certs because of the fact that experience comes into play just because of the fact that we all know that many of the things that you learn for certifications are not specific to the needs of the company and the integration of other systems. There are many things that one must learn under fire, and I think that this makes many better at their job than those who are just paper certs.
And who are we kidding, you can't really get the big jobs without experience anyhow. That would be like hiring an engineer right out of college to head a massive project with no help, and without learning all of the tricks of the trade.
Sean
MIS/Network Admin
by dano1971
I have been reading these postings for quite some time now. I believe that many of the people here are very angry with their own industry right now and find some form of relief slamming the "paper people", which happens to be myself right now. I have just recently become "paper certified" with A+ and MCSE. I am so green that I havent even begun looking for that new shiny IT job yet.
Well, here is my situation. I have been working for 7 years in the security alarm industry (YIPEE right?)And I have always been facinated with computers and have owned at least 1 or 2 pc's at any given time. So to make this short story long, I wanted out of the old alarm crap and into the IT industry. So, I asked many many IT pros out there like yourself, what is the best way to get into this IT industry? 95% said get experience however you can!!! And if that is not immediately available then go to school to learn the theories so that you can "GET YOUR FOOT IN THE DOOR" somewhere and begin to get that experience!!! So my question to all you angry IT guys and gals out there is "why are you upset with people like me the PAPER MCSE?" "I am just trying to make a career change to get out of a dead end job and by the way "yes" I truly enjoy working withcomputers and Yes I do want to "EARN" a better living by doing this. Is that so hard to swallow? You have "EARNED" your way up.....let me EARN my way up please!!!
by auman
I agree that protecting the value of our certifications is important. I have often wondered if Microsoft and Cisco have considered a sponsorship program where two or three people with a specified amount of real world experience have to sign off on you before you recieve your certification.
This may not be the ultimate answer, but it at least grants some accountability because someone with some experience has to hang their name on you before you get the piece of paper. I think it would also encouraged mentoring - something we don't do alot of in IT.
-Chris
MCSE, CCNA
by scraggz
by theshaftman
by kma11
by kmm19h
by pkust
Your post contradicts your opening statement. By your own admission, you are self-taught, and it would appear you have been successful in building on that initial experience. Yet you say it is of no value. This is not a logical argument.
As for your closing statement, it is simply absurd. "Never" hire an engineer without considerable field experience? If your staff consists of nothing but experienced professionals, it is in big trouble. Proper balance requires that experienced engineers be augmented by less knowledgeable juniors; the experience of mentoring and passing of knowledge develops both mentor and mentored alike. Without "new blood" within its ranks, any team is going to stagnate and deteriorate.
There are tasks whichrequire the experienced hand, and there are tasks best done by the inexperienced hand. Best Practice in any field is match tasks and skill levels appropriately; anything less is poor personnel management.
Cordially,
Peter Nayland Kust
TEKMedia Communications
pkust@tekmedia.com
http://www.tekmedia.com
by pkust
While I will concur that creativity is innate and not learned, everything else in your statement is learned. That which is learned can be taught--must be taught.
Can you teach a postive attitude? Yes. Parents and pastors do that every day.
Can you teach troubleshooting? Yes. The core of sound troublshooting is not creativity but highly structured and disciplined logic.
Can you teach someone how to be good, or how to excel? Emphatically yes--the Marines have been doing that for two hundred years.
If you believe that a person cannot be taught, then it is certain that the person will not be taught. I choose to believe that all people can be taught, and have been well rewarded by more than a few individuals who have learned those things I am able to teach.
Cordially,
Peter Nayland Kust
TEKMedia Communications
pkust@tekmedia.com
http://www.tekmedia.com
by tjryan123
I appreciate your comments Tom and I certainly meant no disrespect for them.
It looks like you had the same hard decision to make for yourself, that being to start over and follow a more satisfying path. When I quit my management job and people found out that I was going to be taking such a cut they thought I was NUTS. But the job satisfaction I get now is worth more that the dollars. In my support postion people ask me to help them setup their PC's, use applications, upgrade RAM, install CD drives, get their machines on the network by setting up the TCP/IP. Part of what I like is that when your able to help someone and solve their problem most really appreciate it and in figuring out how to solve a problem I am always learning somethingnew.
I have told my employer that I'll string Cat5 and make up RJ45 connections or help them assemble racks if they want me to so I can move more into direct network support which is what I really want to do.
Like I said, the MCSE help get me in the door. I can sit in on dept meetings and if someone mentions TCP/IP, or IP address or SMTP I at least have some idea of what is being discussed. Now that I'm in the door however, I am seeing how much I really don't know about real world IT. ButI am going to continue learning.
Good luck to you also.
Terry Ryan
Houston, Texas
by wizardwayne
by jbuchberger
That nonsense salary survey published by MCP Magazine showing all those rediculously inflated salary ranges are the main reason you see people with no experience in computers rushing to get certified.
$45,000/year for someone with a simple MCP after only one year? Get real!
by rustpicker
by kmk0500
Certifications indicate a CURRENT willingness, interest and achievement whether one is employed or trying to get into the field. There are way too many people on the job who become comfortable and do not want to do the rigorous studying and training to keep up-to-date. I have seen these people keep a whole organization in the dark ages because all their time is used pasting together old hardware and technologies and they don't really want to learn new stuff.
No matter what you think, certifications are not a "paper thing." I took the MCSE courses on weekends for a year and estimate 100 hours of additional home study for each exam. I made a $10,000 investment and now my MSCE is delayed and there are more courses to study. I've worked hard to make myself a desirable IT candidate and wish I had the opportunity to utilize my knowledge on the job, but I continue to bump into the "2-year experience" wall while looking for for a "trainee" position so I can prove myself. This is also while corporations are crying that they cannot find qualified help.
No, I do not believe the certifications should be only for experienced professionals.
In my work experience I have met many, many new grads with great, fabulous degrees, who don't have the most basic knowledge of the business world or life in general. It is assumed that somewhere their collective educational knowledge will gel and through experience they will become valuable. As they apply the knowledge of their degrees, they learn, make better decisions and become self-reliant and instinctive. I see no difference with those of us not yet lucky enough to break into our chosen field, but still working on our certifications to get a foot in the door.
Give us a chance.
by fshco14
I agree with maitaining a level of professional credentialing , paper certification alone cannot do that.I have been a Medical Technologist (MT)for over 20 yrs..I am currently in a CCNA program and have passed the CompTIA a+ cert. test; one of a number I hope to attain if needed.
To be a M.T. one must aquire a BS/BA,get through a 1year internship and then pass a certification and or license test. None of this helped us since the Gov. and insurance cuts have forced Hospitals and Labs to tighten on positions and wages . This tightening has created an increased demand for lesser trained (and payed )workers to be in greater demand. I see many similarities in the IT field. What hurt the M.T. field was multiple accrediting agencies,Gov. intrusion and lack of unified professionals . The IT field may also be affected (wages not stds.) by the gov. allowing increased immigration quotas for techs. Thanks Dan
by pedro sousa
I have 7 years in IT, mainly teatching other technicians. Last year, and after a lot of years of study and experimenting, I had my exams for the MCSE. Done it all in 3 months, mainly because of some experience I had and HARD study. But reading and taking an exam doesn't make me an expert.
I agree certs give people a "door" to begin in IT professions, but the experience and hard work makes you good in your job.
Something that is stuck in my trouth is that now I've got my cert, Microsoft forcesme to update to Win2K until the end of this year.
So why have I spent my money and time studying for the exams, just to have to do them again.... Because my line of work makes me be certified (Have the damn paper) I have to do it.....
Dispite this, experience and study makes you good, and IF YOU DON'T KNOW SOMETHING ASK. Nobody borns with knoledge, evebody has to learn from someone (If with a book, remember someone wrote it). So ASK, LEARN and DO IT.
I've been in the IT field for nearly 15 years. Through the years I've watched the trends and learned a thing or two. So, here's my 2 cents worth.
(1) Certifications are a good thing. It gives a business a way to measure knowledge when hiring new employees. Unfortunately, both the vendors offering certifications and the general business community have lost site of the main point. Corporate america is mistaken to believe that any training will replace experience. That was part of the complaint they made to Microsoft which caused them to reconfigure their certification process. That's why Microsoft now suggests you have 1-2 years experience before you approach their certification tests.
(2) Vendors are on the verge of abusing thecertification process. It's been predicted that Microsoft's revamping of their process will cut the number of MCSEs by 1/2 this year. While you may think that helps boost your salary you're wrong. There's already talk of Corporate America lookingelsewhere to bring in qualified technical staff.
Microsoft has already stated in their materials that 2000 is the beginning of their efforts to Lower The Cost Of Ownership. They plan to do that by getting rid of many of YOU. Those who want tostay in the industry need to shoot for the highest rungs of the ladder. The lower and middle tech positions will begin disapearing over the next 5 years. Operating systems will become smart enough to do your jobs for you.
My suggestion is to get certified as quickly as you can and get the experience where you can. To that end I've created an on-line educational site that provides IT courses.
http://www.creativelearninglabs.com. You'll also find FREE Study Guides and other userful links and information.
by dbertsche
I don't think certification programs are a bad idea but regarding vendors abusing the program, what did Microsoft expect! The old adage "follow the money" comes into play here. A lot of companies have made tons of money off of the certification process and in the process have mislead people at times.
I was going to try to gain certification on NT4 but when I heard this would not last long I'm having second thoughts. My company has not adopted 2000 yet so I can not gain any experience on it. I would bet there are a lot of people in the same boat.
I believe it's good to get certified but only in an environment where you can learn the practical aspects. For this reason I will probably put getting certified on hold.
I know this runs counter to what you're suggesting but I don't see what you're predicting happening any time soon. In fact some of the environments I've worked in and clients I've worked with are still at very elementary levels when it comes to technology and itlooks like lower and middle level techs will still have jobs for some time to come.
by matt
I agree with you, I see no way that lower level techs will be left out. I think lower level techs will always be needed, who else is going to install cards, set up new comps, replace bad hardware, it certainly would not be an upper level tech. I think if anything the upper level techs will be the ones in trouble. Who needs a network manager onsite, when half a world away someone can remote control the network. If there are problems that can't be fixed remote, then a call is placed to the low level techs to fix them on site. This is where many companies that I have worked with are heading.
As for certifications, I think they are a good way to gain knowledge and show you have some knowledge in a particular area and are great for entry level. But I think that without experience, there should be no way for a tech to get to those upper levels.
by beblin
No cert/degree, am working my way towards both, in the "Industry" 18+ years.
Been pretty lucky to work for big companies (options,etc), because I was able to get in the door via experience. Company I just quit, I would of swept floors at just to get the proverbial footinthedoor. I will admit I have interviewed people with certs/degrees including DR's in CS that either knew it all or didn't know squat. Again, I have interviewed the ones who just blew you away with only experience.
I will tell you this - DO WHAT IT TAKES TO GET YOUR FOOT IN THE DOOR ! Screw those who say you need a cert/degree/exp, whatever and just go for it! What can they say but NO? I've said NO many a times, but have said yes to the ones whom I had faith in becomming a "STAR" and have not been let down. Keep in mind with over 350K open positions, your bound to strike gold somewhere. There are hungry individuals out there who want to "Like their job", and those who have no Life, but live to work. There arethose who have every piece of paper under file 13 who want the easy way in and out and who won't do you or your company a bit of good. Those are the ones you wonder "how in the heck did they get hired"?
Last company I worked for had a 12 person/all day interview. 3/4's of the interview was being bombarded by tech questions from people who know their s#!^.
I feel lucky, I only passed the interview 75% of the way, but they saw potential.
Company I'm at now, didn't have a tech interview,they were just impressed with whom I worked for and the vast HW and SW experience. Now learning Oracle, Cisco, SAP & stuff couldn't get in schools, only hands on.It will help in future jobs. No stock, but great $.
Do what it takes. If that means late nights to study the companies systems, classes at night, RTM's, etc., then do it. It can only help you in the long term. As my dad used to say,I know, I been there!!!
by blitzer
I find that when it comes to doing the actual work, nothing holds up but experience. When I was looking at a career move, I looked at certification, but while I was getting that certification, experience were getting me the jobs (contracts). What I usually ask people that joing an argument like this, without saying you're experienced, or certified, do you qualify for the job? My angle on this is unusual, some people would say that qualification is having the bare minimal to do the job, I disagree, I see it as qualifying for every single task that you will be required to perform!
I'm still working through my NT4 MCSE certs, not because I'm going to flash it around and say "Look at me, certified pro!" no! because I'm learning from the exercise. I would say that my knowledge, only 20% comes from the certification studies I've done, the rest, is asking, seeing, playing. And I do make sure that everytime I took a contract, I was qualified to do every single task that would be asked ofme.
Do you qualify to do the work you're doing?
Daniel.
by mmcisaac
Experience is certainly the best qualification.
Many employers aren't qualified enough to ask the right questions in an interview to accurately determine a candidate's suitability for the position. So a certification can be said to do the work for a lazy or unqualified manager.
With almost ten years experience I find it very frustrating that some employers will not consider people who do not have an MSCE or an A+ certification. Even though my college education far exceeds anything that an A+ cert. can possibly hope to offer. I consider MSCE courses simply introductory material. I enjoy them for the other IT people I get to meet with and discuss various network issues. I have found that the some of the course materials don't make very good reference material however.
In short a good manager or interviewer should be able to tell if the right skills are there. Certification can be a good kick-start, but this certification craze is a little out of control. I find it really boring to study for MSCE exams. I've already worked with the stuff so I want to move on to areas beyond the course material. (Having said that, I have used the course materials for review from time to time)
There's more than one way to skin a cat!
Mike
by matt
by rdwarf2000
I currently work for a new boss who hires people based on certifications first- those are, for the most part, fairly clueless individuals. I don't have certifications, as I am "test impaired," but I was fortunate enough to work my way up and be hired by someone (my current supervisor's predecessor)who found in an interview I was qualified. I am now a team lead. Nowadays, most companies won't even let you interview without a piece of paper, which leaves out many techs like me who have over 15 years experience and can fix damn near anything but freeze when a test is placed in front of them.
Comapnies need to interview all candidates, not just the papered ones.
by kima
I strongly agree w/ you rdward2000, I don't have a "piece of paper" but I have experience and lots of knowledge that I have gotten at home studying and by setting up my own home network, but it seems like nowadays a "piece of paper" is necessary.
I can't believe that employers will based knowledge on a piece of paper, I believe that they should give a fair change to everybody and test them if they want. I went to a few interview myself where the interviewer don't even bother to test or ask technical questions to find out if you know, they just look at your resume and if you don't have "piece of paper" or education then you are nothing to them.
That's to bad, nowadays they keep saying that they are short in technical people and bringpeople from other countries w/o even looking hard here in the states just so they can save some money and pay them less than us. Shame on them!!!! That's my personal opinion on what's going on, so please don't be disturbed by it....
by baz
Very good point I have interviewed people
with certification but little if any experience. Trust me you would not let them near your network.
by toksymore
It's a fair baseline for assessing proficiency/expertise in the IT world, however still not a substitute for experience and on-the-job intuition.
I would prefer a professional with both qualifications though.
by jmissild
First of all you have all of these training companies advertising big money if you can pass (x) number of tests. Half of these people have no real world experience and will blow it when real skills are needed. Anyone can study for a test and pass. These paper certified people make people that actually have the knowledge along with the certification be paid less. I agree with the time limit in the industry.
Jason
Network Administrator
by gary.evans
Until the testing methodology is changed, paper certifications will continue.
The Microsoft tests are a joke!!
Cisco has the idea of doing hands-on. Until all certifications are hands-on, this will continue.
by __23skidoo
You assume that someone with a certification simply memorized the material and regurgitated it on to a test. I believe it is an unfair characterization.
I was in the electronics field for several years and unsatisfied with my field. I took the knowlege I gained at home and from handed down MCSE books and applied it. I got an entry level help desk job with NO experience OR certs. Now I'm full time IT support, working on my degree (which I think is more important). My point is that I made my own way in and am very happy with my progression so far. If I had no way of getting in the door, I'd still be hating life. Just because someone gets a position w/o experience doesn't mean he/she doesn't deserve the opportunity to apply their skills.
by adminsparky
I applaud your efforts to improve the perception of the entire IT field. However, ultimately, it is the perception of your employer/customer that is of greater importance. In support of your view, I would propose that using generalizations to catagorize a group of people (those with certs), has led to the dilema that you describe. However, generalizations, such as yours, are just a different swing of the same pendulum.
It is management's responsibility to hire competent individuals, and to release those that are not. There are a myriad of tools and criteria available to make these decisions. Certification is only one such criteria. Until a business identifies an economic impact related to a person's poor performance, that company will continue to support its decisions based on the investment already put forth.
The truth of the matter is, that in the event of an economic downturn, only those persons capable of performing the job will be retained, regardles of how they entered the field.
by emsiesekrap
If what you mean is for those people that certified thru reading books and pass the exam definitely I agree. What about those people that went to an eight month course with hands-on labs training then I'' say otherwise. I went through that route andI tell you we had our share of hands-on training that I'll bet you I could do some
administration on my very first day, if given
the chance. Even better than those that are working, but no training experience like we had. Besides degrees also goesthrough on the job training once they are hired.
by emsiesekrap
by emsiesekrap
For those people that are career changers like me, being certified would be my only way in. Although certified as MCSE, I do not expect to be hired as head of an IS department, and I probably would not accept
the responsibility for I do not have full skills and knowledge to administer a network. For only through work experience would I have the knowledge and confidence to run a network. But don't down the certification process all together, get yours, together with your years of experience
and see your reward ........ financially.
by an2370
by jbuchberger
Why not try college as a foot in the door for a technical position??? You have got to be kidding! Why would someone want to go to college for four years to learn what according to everyone else on this discussion says is only possible through hands-on, real world experience.
If you really do have 15 years of actual experience and not just installing hard disks and reseating ram, and really have performed all those LAN Admin and Domain Admin functions, then why not quit complaining and go in and take the tests that these book smart people have taken so you will get called back after the interviews. If you have the college degree that you think is so important in a technical environment then you must also have the 'book smarts' required to pass the tests.
by arg cio
by shanghai sam
hello everybody,
I have been following this discussion from
quite a long time , still my question is unresloved. can all these threds realy help solve my problem or will end up tieng me is a question itself.
I am now opening my case for discussion
here is my Case
I am a Chemical Engineering graduate (fresh) interested in making my career in this wonderful field. now i have three options in front of me
go for a PG course in IT or
go for certifications or
simply learn more my self & getsome Experince in a small company based on my present tiny skillset?
Tell me what shall I do for this ? ,I thought
this discussion will help me resolve this
ambiguity but I am unable to arrive at any conclussion, please help me I am in a grate confussion.
Chandrashekhar HN
by matt
by jadair57
I also have been following this discussion for some time and it seems the degree advocates, for the most part, are semi-illiterate. High amount of misspellings and poor grammar. "Paper" degrees? And of course the guy with the paper (degree) gets the entry level job instead of someone without the paper.
I have some college, but no degree. I also have almost 2 years experience in help desk positions (some of you purists might call it customer service, as I support end users). This is a career change for me; I used to be a Steam Engineer in a utility power plant (people could die, not a server crash, if I made a mistake at that job).
I want to know the names of some of these companies that are hiring MCSE's with just the cert and no experience, as I have obviously taken the wrong career route! I felt that just the cert would not be enough to do the job so I am working my way up with experience and certs. I have my A+, will have I Net+ and Network+ within 2 or 3 months and amup for promotion to internal help desk. And computers have been my hobby for more than 20 years. While this would be a nice raise, my salary is quite a bit less than a MCSE makes. And I would enjoy the job a lot more.
My point is: a MCSE with no prior background, even as a hobbyist, would truly be a paper cert, but don't forget there are a lot of us out there starting in the trenches and using the certs to build on our experience and work our way up!
by chanveda
But my basic degree is chemical, will it not
affect in the long run?
by rossmon
by webmaster
Want the truth do you? Well, speaking as an IT manager, I can tell you this. The MCSE cert. has become such a bloat and scam, that most REAL technical companies don't take much stock in it. As a point, most are migrating towards Linux. Why you may ask? Quite simply. Linux is a Unix clone. Unlike NT you can't rely on a GUI to be able to navigate and administer a network. You have to really know how the system functions and performs. You can't bs your way into a *nix network. You eitherknow it or you don't. Plus, all of the certs available require hands on problem solving and trouble shooting to pass the test. It is not just a question and answer test.
So, having said that, I would recomend anyone wanting to be a REAL administrator to learn *nix. Not only will you gain a full understanding of true network architecture, but *nix administrators are in more demand than NT AND the salaries are higher.
I can train anyone to point and click to administer a small to medium NT network. But it takes years of experience to master the *nix environment.
I have seen alot of postings from people who say computers are their life. If so, invest a few bucks in RedHat or Caldera or Slackware or any other Linux OS. Tear it down, rebuild, do it again and again. And just when you think you understand it, build a Linux system from the original code. Once you can master that, you have the knowledge to be a *nix administrator and will command respect from the rest of the IT community.
Tom Johnson
IT Manager
by jbuchberger
But if I learn all that on my home network, will I still be considered a paper cert Linux guy because I haven't worked on one in a live environment for two years?
Damn! It seems like the more I learn the less I know, in this business, and yet I still love it. :)
by webmaster
If you take a cert for Linux, particularly RedHat, you will not be considered a paper cert. Being RedHat certified carries some weight. To get that cert you really need to know your stuff. At my company we had a guy take the course and test. Even though he had worked with *nix for years, he said it was tough.
I would recomend this track for anyone serious about being a network or sys admin.
Tom Johnson
IT Manager
by shanghai sam
That NT or anything other than *nix does not need to be managed? I'd just like to make a couple of points.
I'm no fan of NT, Unix etc. I've given up on that years ago. Nowadays, when proposing a solution I look at what makes the most sense from acost / benefit viewpoint.
If someone wishes to be a Unix admin and follows that career path then great. If it's NT, well that's good also. 'Real' administration is getting an honest days pay for an honest days work - NT, Unix, mainframe, midrange whatever (I think it's also called being a professional).
I agree that understanding what makes something tick is important and as you pointed out it can only come with working with whatever product.
With regards to MCSE etc. I think these exams should be mixed with professional experience and I know that the exams strive to do so but sometimes don't accomplish the goal. I've been a database administrator for many years and sometimes it irks me that a piece of paper could mean so much - but it only does to those that do not know better. Most times experience is really the differentiator and if a prospective client does not understand this then working with said client can become difficult at best. Gratefully, most do and the others I don't work with. And I say this from my own experiences. Nevertheless, I think certifications are valuable as a personal milestone.
If computers are someone's life then that person should make a living at it - otherwise it's a hobby. Would you say that computers are not Bill Gates' life because he is not a Unix admin? What about Steve Jobs? I don't think so.
Maybe in a perfect world we'd all have Unix workstations and be Unix admins. But then there'd be no money to be made because of lack of competition.
by cscript
by diplomat1
by diplomat1
by christyt
by cscript
What ever happened to the Apprenticeship programs?
In my day you could pass the test 100 times over, but still need 2 to 10 yrs experience working the real deal until you made journeyman then another 20yrs to master journeyman.
Now THERE is an idea!!
by ozrunner
Well, Greg, didn't you get them going?
As an IT manager, I have to agree with you.
Certainly when recruiting graduates (I wouldn't employ soemone who has neither a degree nor experience), I expect to have to spend 3 months "retraining" them, as there's a whole lot of stuff to learn about the real world.
Having said that, though, I also don't believe that "on the job" training is sufficient for IT. So you really need to have the formal education, but until you have some experience in applying that knowledge to real life, it's value is minimal.
As for the debate about degrees vs certificates, I would make the comparison with cakes vs icing. The degree is the cake; the certificate is more like icing. You can certainly have a very satisfactory cake without icing, but you can't have icing without cake.
by ajm38
by chuck l
I recently took a course in network switching and routing at the local community college. The course was being offered by Nortel, so I figured that it would be up-to-date and pertinent. Instead, what I sat through for an entire term was a class (oneof four, I believe) designed to get you to pass the Nortel networking certification (I forget what it is called). Instead of delving into the concepts of network administration, switching and routing, we instead concentrated on those questions that would be on the test. The course midterm was a collection of "review" questions, copied verbatim from the course documentation. The final exam included half of the questions -- again verbatim -- from the midterm. When the instructor reworded a question on the final about bandwidth requirements to make it more pertinent (by replacing "a video feed of a Michael Jackson concert" with "a video feed of the presidential debates"), he was called to task for it by several of the students. Worse still, the Nortel course documentation was full of errors and inconsistencies, many of which made it to the review questions. These questions were "taught" with the wrong answers -- and graded that way as well -- because that's what the book said.
Obviously I didn't get what I wanted out of the class. And it served to solidify even more my long-standing distrust of "paper s." Ten years ago it was the "paper CNE" -- now there are dozens of different paper certifications.
( -- continued --)
by chuck l
( -- continued -- )
Five years ago I purchased an NT Server for my company, which was running on Unix and Novell servers. The consulting company that got the job touted its MCSE staff as the most appropriate to integrate an NT Server into a network where the Unix servers dominated the scene. (Back then, Microsoft was still on its "we'll bury Unix" kick. Their thrust was for NT to displace Unix servers, not coexist with them.) They totally screwed up the installation. One of the things that blew my mind was that they didn't understand TCP/IP, even though several of these MCSEs had the Internet and TCP/IP "option" on their certificates. Even with my staff doing all the work on the Unix side, we couldn't get the information we needed for the integration because these MCSEs were completely lost when it came to the task at hand.
As an IT employer, I have been wary of manufacturer certifications for a long time, and do not hire technical personnel based on manufacturer certifications they have or do not have. If a candidate shows me that (s)he has an MCSE, I will make that candidate prove that the certification was properly earned. I currently have several people on staff who have not bothered to acquire manufacturer certifications, who know far more about the systems that they're maintaining than other "certified" consultants.
Certifications should be industry-wide and industry-standard, and should be made available only when educational and experience requirements are met. I currently hold three ICCP certifications (the closest thing to an industry standard so far), and had to prove education and experience before I was allowed to take the first test.
CL
by devrich12
by shanghai sam
Say you had changed from electronics to law or medicine. Would you have been able to pop into your local Barnes and Noble, buy the "J.D. in Six Months" or "M.D. in Six Months" review manual, take the Bar or Board exam, and practice two months later?
It is insane to think that someone who has studied for a few months to take a test can pass him/herself off as an "expert" in the IT field. All an MCSE certificate shows is that the certificate holder can work with Microsoft products, not that the person has the broader knowledge to handle complex IT issues (including those underlying issues that the Microsoft products themselves are built to handle). I deal with Microsoft-employed MCSEs all the time who painfully show that they can't handle"the larger picture." As an example, I recently spent almost a month of constant back-and-forth communications with several MCSEs at Microsoft trying to get the information necessary to set up an in-house LDAP server for Outlook to query. Everybody could tell me what to point and click to search an established LDAP server (like Bigfoot, which is included as an Outlook default). Nobody I dealt with even knew how to set up an LDAP server (which was not my question; we already had the server running), and nobody could find out what it was that Outlook was querying of a "public" LDAP server so that I could appropriately set up our LDAP database. In other words, the MCSEs knew how to click your way onto a public server already provided by Outlook, but nobody knew enough about LDAP to get me the information I needed.
(-- continued -- )
by chuck l
( -- continued --)
If someone wants to pursue something like an MCSE certification, fine -- but it should be done in concert with real-world experience (an apprenticeship, if you will). I have several present and past employees who work in apprenticeship positions while pursuing their educational goals (right now one is in the middle of his B.S.C.S. degree). When he graduates, he'll have a degree plus several years of real-world experience -- and much broader and deeper knowledge than any "paper whatever" can offer.
Actually, I shouldn't complain that much -- we make good money cleaning up the messes that other consultants make. Many of my clients were especially lured by MCSEs touting their expertise, only to have to hire us to pickup the pieces ...
CL
by chuck l
It is my experience that many if not most MCSEs are not theory-smart. Theory is not necessary to pass MCSE exams. Just know what to click on, and when. That's why an MCSE certified in IIS may be able to click his way into setting up the FTP server, but given everything he needs to perform the same task on a non-MS server (and I mean EVERYTHING -- settings, what commands to run, full docs, and total access to the network), that person may wind up lost. It's not a matter of "I don't know Unix" or"I don't know MAC" or "I don't know AS/400." It's a matter of not having enough theory and base knowledge to transfer what you're doing on one machine to another -- even when you have all the "how-to" you need for the "other" machine.
It used to be that GUIs, Wizards and all these other "intelligent" systems allowed computer USERS to better use computers without having to spend thousands of hours learning the systems ... Now we have computer PROFESSIONALS pointing and clicking their way around computers without ever really knowing what they're doing ...
CL
by gblaze
I agree with you 100 percent, Presently I've been looking for another contract, since it will be up in a few months, and every agency I've talked too has asked, "Do you have X certification", My reply is always "I do have experience in setting up and maintaining X" But it's never good enough they want the Certification even if you don't have the experience.
Greg
LAN Engineer
by hyatt
Granted, a certification might get you in the door for an interview. Experience usually will get you the job. If a company bases there IT hiring process on certifications, then I don't think I would bother to apply.
Phillip
by dane_warren
That is all I can say.
:)
by gblaze
1) It's about giving the customer satisfaction.
2) It's about the troubelshooting skills!
It takes many years develop troubleshooting skills. Knowing what questions to ask.
3) and yes no one will know everything,It changes to much.
Greg
LAN Engineer
by ksreb
I have been in the IT field now for 5 years (plus) and received my A+ at 3 years and my MCP at 4 years. My first employer wouldn't pay for any certs, however my second employer had standards of at least obtaining your A+ within the first 4 weeks of hire. And they paid for them.
My fixed sentiments are that I feel there are too many "paper certified" professionals, or users, that have that nice piece of paper on the wall and no experience. I also know several individuals that are quite skilled in the IT industry and have no certifications. A company should hire a person on the basis of experience, not just of a certification.
My new position is an example of this. Even though I am now in a Novell environment, I was hired because of both my experience and certifications. I am on the track to becoming CNA, CNE, MCSE and CCNA by the year's end. This isn't just to increase my income, as I am a state employee now and can only do so at my yearly review, but to allow me to study, learn,and prove that I know something of those subjects.
Certs shouldn't become meaningless, but I think there should be some proof that a person has working knowledge of the cert testing for to help eliminate or cut down on those with only paper or book knowledge.
by topesblues
I myself worked in the automotive bussiness for 10 years.(parts dept.)That was two years ago. Im now A+ certified and working in a mortgage companys IT dept. Ill be starting my ccna classes on the 29th of Jan.
The hardest part of all of it is actually making the change between carreers.Get your A+ first then start looking.Unlike MCSE, I consider A+ to be nessasary to get a decent entery level position. I had to work so god awfull "IT" jobs before I got certified. A+ will make it a lot easier to find entry level work.
As far as starting pay in the midwest,Id have to say somewhere around 30k depending on what your doing and who your doing it for.
Good luck, (I have no regrets about leaving the auto bussiness)
by achaddy
I had no prior experience in the IT field but wanted to make the move as I was watching my current engineering job being squeezed by the IT revolution. I took the MCSE track to prove to any possible employers that I was commited to moving into IT and rapidly gaining knowledge in the process.
I am now about to start a new job as an IT support assistant next week. My very first IT job and I made it perfectly clear to the company, that this would be my first IT possition, in the interview.
If Ihad not been able to follow these certifications then I would be looking forward to a future of unemployment and not going forward in a dynamic industry.
Andy Chadwick
by dane_warren
Why should it be an industry cert that gets you the job. I gained all my computer/networking knowledge in my own time, I convinced employers that I knew what I was talking about, and I showed ambition. Now I am fast tracked for CCIE, but only to improve the work that I do.
Sounds like any excuse will do at times.
That is not how the industry works. Maybe you should show a genuine interest, and not let a piece of paper indicate that.
by houstonz
by dane_warren
I totally agree with the Gregs comment. I know of University students who wouldn't know a subnet from a vlan, and they are studying for their CCNA. Once accredited they finish off their last 2 years, and forget nearly everything they have learned (doing the CCNA), they use the qualifaction to get the position, and by doing so bring the whole certification into disrepute.
We need to get real here people, people should really be doing these certifications to improve understanding (in the workplace), not just to boost entry level paypackets.
Dane Warren
(Network Engineer - UOW)
by dane_warren
The ability to learn is one thing, and then lateral thinking is another!!!!!!
Lateral thinking comes with experience.
by pedro sousa
First I ask you, are you Certified? And if so, which exams have you passed?
I am MCP+I and MCSE, and one of my exams was IIS 4.0.
Theory and practice are both important, not also for the exams, but for your work. I would like to see you pass an TCP/IP exam without any theory about the protocol suite, and equipments, and OSI Layers, and IEEE.... Nice to say it, hard to do it....
I've done it.
Then you also say, that given the "how-to" an MCSE wouldn't know nothing but Windows. By the term "how-to", I think you mean Unix or Linux.... Well, maybe the person(s) your are talking about are PAPER CERTIFIED (Braindump Guys). I've installed lots of Linux, with Apache server (by the way, for a Web or FTP Server I always go for APACHE rathe than IIS) and the first time it was confusing but reading the "How-To" and it's simple. The kind of guys you speak are MOUSE and GUI dependants.... Admin with WIzards are simple.... Try it on Command Prompt and/or with Admin scripts.....
By the way, IIS exam is nothing to do with Admin of an IIS Server and the Manual/Course are worst.... Complete garbage. So, a bad example you gave....
by shanghai sam
by davecdillon
by ravenii
That is why the various certifications have multiple tiers. Cisco has the CCNA, CCNP, and CCIE. Novell has the CNA, CNE, and Master CNE, and so on. True, most of the answers can be found on the internet or in crash courses for lower tier certifications, and the person achieving his certification through such a method will pay the penalty later on.
You can never say an individual with CCIE doesn't know his stuff.
Also, did you know that you can report persons with alleged paper certifications to Microsoft? It happened at my company. Microsoft showed up and administered quick exams to the people and revoked the certification from those that didn't pass.
by greg hauser
Hi I am a professor for a community college and I teach Microsoft NT as well as Cisco, Novell, and A+. I think that may of us are not looking at the whole package when we state that the paper certification should not be the where-with-all. This istrue. But just as Greg from Micro Computer points out-
"How would you like to go to a "certified" nurse practitioner who has NEVER touched a patient? or a "certified" Public Accountant who has never ran the books of a company?"
It normally does take a certified nurse to get into the door of a hospital, doctor's office, or what ever else so that this certified person can begin thier residency. And this truly is how we should look at this. A person with no experience can obtain their residency because they have earned that right by virtue of the time spent to get certified. Also a person has many years of experience in the IT industry should not rest on this alone but strive for the next level.
This concept is precisely what I share with my students. Just my opinion.
Greg J. Hauser
by kima
Unfortunately, after reading some of the conversations I myself don't have any certifications/paper, but I have two years experience and this days it seems very hard to get a job w/o a piece of paper saying that you went to school and study. On the other hand I have build my home school and read probably more books and articles in the computer field than anybody trying to get in the IT field w/o experience and have hands on experience.
I strongly agree that you must have some type of computer knowledge and a level of skills in order to get in the field and be good at it. The IT field is not for everybody, there is a lot of branches to learn in the field if you want to be somebody......
Employers who are looking for good employees shouln't look to much into the certification but the experience IT young people out there like myself. In the mean time I quess I'll be attending GW to get the "piece of paper" require to get a job, since experience doesn't seem to be enough this days......
by jeekaette
Hello,
I agree 100% to paper cert' for IT profs', but the criteria for this certification should include a B.Sc. degree in Computer Science, to give IT more meaning, and professionalism. You can't tell me that someone that just woke up and learnt how to type with the computer should be certified, besause he's been working in an IT Firm for a year or two. No, please get real people, we are talking about a body, and a professional one. And, as such should be treated with that.
Thanks!
J.
by linda b.
Because I agree for the most part, I have never sought one. Didn't want to be counted amoung that throng.
However, there is a piece of paper that I do have respect for, it allows one to add letters like C.D.P (Certified Data Processor) behind one's name. It is a battery of tests over three days, several industry references and minimum of 5 years experience IN the DP FIELD to even apply! (It's been awhile, things may have changed a bit).
Certified professionals, engineers and project managers ... it's just not for me. I'm of the old school, a professional data processor.
Still Data Processors can be Men and Women of letters, also (not just M.D.'s, esq., CPA's, etc.).
Have I dated myself much, here?!
Linda B.
by lwood
I hired an assistant with an under graduate degree in computer sciences, and an MCP from Microsoft several years ago.
He didn't even know how to do a diskcopy from a command prompt. Which only points out the obvious, teachers are teachers and they do not know alot about the day to day activities that keep IT managers up at night.
So much for degrees, and so much for certifications.
Cummulative on the job experience with certifications or degrees is what really matters. Two years after I put this person to work he left us for a better position at a larger corporation.
If you had five years of on the job experiences I would hire you in a heartbeat compared to a college degree graduate or a industry certified individual.
It takes talent and critical thinking to be good at IT. And don't forget about people skills. Matter of fact, I hire for people skills first and IT expertise second, which is why I hired this particular assistant in the first place.
by nonsuch
I was always taught that qualifications may get you the job but in order to keep it you would have to prove that you could actually do the job.
I have come across many people who have all the certificates and qualifications but could not do the job.
The value of certification qualifications is that they frequently impart knowledge that cannot be obtained from any other source. On the other hand a person who has had years of experience could learn that way.
by reef2
And where would they get experience without somebody letting them work for them?
I tried to get into a few computer stores where I live but they won't hire people without school behind them.I can fix a computer and load anything and put anything init.But no school no job.
Jeff
by hayabusa
This argument is similar to chicken vs the egg, in the respect that both sides have right and wrong, and we could debate this until the cows come home.
Personally, I blame the media. All the time I keep here how many x million tech pros are needed to fill x million job openings. Or whatever.
Personally, i'm not into paper certifications. I have good experience in the industry, some college, but not much else. My name is free from acronyms. I will get to certificates soon enough, but only when I feel that I understand the material 100%, not just enough to answer the questions so I can be Jonnie B MCSE+I, MCP, CNE, CCIE, A+, PhD whatever.
I tend to ignore arguments like this whenever I can, because i believe it is down to the ATTITUDE of the individual. I recently left a training position with a national ISP here, where I met a mechanic who had just achieved a helpdesk position there. This man was keen, and had no certs or experience, but his attitude was correct.
But looking at computer science students who believe as soon as they walk out of colleg they will be making $120 per hour in a contract for a Fortune 500 company..(just because there are x million no. of job vacancies). That's a big no no. They end up getting frustrated, and when they finally land the $20,000 p/year job they build a foundation of frustration and don't develop as they should. But if you've got a low-level cert like a+ and are willing to learn, in my opinion you're on the right track.
I think it all boils down to people with hands on like myself don't see it as socially just for someone to waltz out of college, not knowing what it's like to work 70 hours a week, or called on a sunday @ 9am to come into the office, to work over along weekend, thinking they can (and sometimes they will) land a cool job making big bucks.
Hey, I admitted it. Will anybody else?
by fuzzymp
It really doesn't matter what kind of cert you have as long as you know your job and can think on the fly. I only got a cert when they told me I had to get it to work the job.
No one ever thinks about getting calls in the middle of the night or on the weekend or just on your day off, because nobody else can get it to work when they are going to school or studying to take that cert test. You can only put as much into a cert as the ABILITY, not experience of the individual carrying it.
Hope that made sense and didn't ramble too much.
by matt
by gpricetr
by jpgohan
This is just my two cents worth. Certification are good but only to those individuals that are really interested in an IT career. I began life in an apprentice program it did not pay much but it got me started in the IT career. I found that it was amatch for me and I enjoyed it immensely after a year and a half of training I got a job in the IT department. After that I went out and enrolled in an A+ training course and found that I had a good percentage of the training under my belt. I also found that the class was more focused on passing the test instead of teaching the material that was really useful in the day to day world of real IT. I have found that to be true with both the Microsoft certs and the Cisco certs. I would say that the best training certification would be a training and test that is not biased towards a particular manufacturer. Knowledge of hardware and software interaction is more important in my book than complete knowledge of one company?s way of doing business. I have found that most of my solutions come in different forms. In my opinion when you are hiring a prospective employee you need to look at the person as a whole not just at the certification or the experience. The attitude of that person and how that person interacts and communicates with other people the better the employee can get to the heart of the problem. Also the better the employee can understand the concepts behind software and hardware interactions the better prepared that employee will be at solving problems.
Sorry for the ranting??.Just had to put my two cents worth.
by win_inf
How is that WAN of yours that you have at home? Tell me how many exchange servers you have, and how are those domain trusts working out for your multiple domains? Who's router did you choose to place between your kitchen and bedroom? You running RIP, OSPF, Static routes?
Home learning is good for basics, but no subsititute for real IT experience.
by win_inf
Sort by Trending