Question Locked

Power supply/motherboard issues---need help!!

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

OK, I have been building my own computers for many years now, but have never had an issue like the one I have been having. I had my newly built computer running perfectly fine for about 6 months. One night we started having thunderstorms late at night, so before I went to bed, I turned off the computer, and unplugged it from the power supply to ensure it wouldn't have any problems. The next morning, I come back downstairs, plug it back in, and nothing happens. I opened the case, played around with it for a little while, and it finally came back on. One of my harddrives became disconnected while doing that, so I had to turn it back off, reconnect and turn it back on, and nothing again. This time it took a good 15 minutes of playing around to get it to come back on. Again, something wasn't in right, so I had to turn it back off and restart it. This time, it went dead and wouldn't come back on. I thought it was a bad power switch, so I attempted to jump it with a screwdriver to the power plug in on the MB...no luck. I then tested a few other power supplies with the board and no luck either. I took my power supply that I had out of the non-working computer and tested it in my working computer---no luck. It appeared the Power supply and the motherboard had malfunctioned. No big deal---both were under warranty. I got RMA numbers, sent them in for repair. Get the MB back, test it, and nothing. Call the company and they claim nothing was wrong with it when they tested it. Told me to just connect the fan to the MB and see if it starts working when you turn it on. Tried it, and nothing again. The guy told me to send it back, which I did. Power Supply came back, and apparently something was wrong with it because they sent me a brand new one in a box. MB came back, and again it appeared to be the same board. Hooked the power supply up to my MB, and again, nothing. I take the power supply and hook it up to my working computer, and the MB light comes on, but when I hit the power button, nothing happens. When I plug the original power supply in, it works fine again.

I need some help here---I cannot for the life of me figure out what is going on here---I guess they could have sent me a new power supply that was DOA, or partially DOA. The MB has got me very frustrated and the tech keeps telling me it tested fine, which I have serious doubts on---I am not some newbie that doesn't know what he is doing---I have built, tested and fixed computers for many many years now. I bought quality retail parts, not cheap generic ones, so that should not be an issue. Is there anything else that could be at play here?? I have tested with just the MB, the power supply and the CPU fan, and have gotten nothing from the MB(the new one has no light, so I can't see if it has power or not). I am confused as to why the power supply would give my other MB power(the light comes on), but will not power up the system, even tho my other PSU works just fine. No it is not a watt issue, as the one not working is a 500W PSU and the working one is a 350W one...

Please help, this is driving me nuts!!!

5 replies

by usit

removed all items so that you only have the motherboard,ram installed? I have seen this issue when I had a bad video card installed...

by matter2003

Yes, I am booting only with the CPU Fan connected, MB and the power supply...I was told by Gigabyte Tech support to do this, and still nothing....

by tintoman

and went off to bed during the thunderstorm, did you perhaps leave an ethernet cable plugged into the computer and a modem/router or a usb cable connected to a peripheral device that was plugged either to the power supply or a telephone socket?
Do you see where I'm going with this?
I am convinced that somehow a power surge did hit your computer, and I dont believe that the techie person has tested it properly, although a power surge could just as easily have damaged the RAM and processor so unless you sent the originals back with the MB I cant see how they would know.
Anyway the reality is that if this machine was spanked with a power spike there could be endless damage to it

by matter2003

OK, I have to chalk this up to something I have never had happen before. I just got off the phone with Gigabyte support. They claimed again that the unit was working fine. They had all the tests that were done and the resulting software analysis, etc. He claimed that stuff cannot be faked because it is hooked up to each board, etc. Regardless, he was going to issue me a replacement board, but told me to take it out of the case and test it first. He said that when they test it they have it sitting on benches(I guess this must be where the term benchmark comes from??). He said it is possible that something in the case is causing a short. Lo and behold, I take it out of the case, sit it on the cardboard box it came with, and voila! Power supply comes on with no problems, and the CPU fan spins....

It appears something in my case is shorting out the board, although I am not sure what I can do about it...very strange set of circumstances, and a very strange solution, although it does me no good if it only works outside the case...

Now I have to go test out some stuff in the case I guess...

EDIT: The problem I found was that the screws holding the motherboard were tightened too hard and it apparently was shorting out the board. I loosened the screws and it powered up with no problems...that was really crazy...

This discussion is closed to new replies.