Discussion Locked

Printers, Scanners, Faxes vs All-in-ones

0 helpful
79 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hey everyone. I have been researching copiers/printers and all in one devices. Unfortunately, I must be brain dead because the literature and stuff assumes you know what they are talking about.

I need a copier and my printer is just about shot, so I figured I would look at all-in-ones that do copy, print, scan, fax, etc. I want something desktop or smaller, easy to use and setup and preferably wireless.

However, being as I am not understanding all the lingo being thrown around, I thought I would start a discussion here on TR about what your preferences are for printing, faxing, copying, scanning etc. I know you all have a preference and why you like it. I would love to hear your stories and opinions. I am still researching for type of printer, etc.

I would have posted in Tech Q&A, but my questions are more generic than that. Since I don't know anything about devices since the HP Laster Jet IV (the one I have still). Oh and that is another point - Laser or Ink for it?

Staples is going to have a wireless HP all-in-one on sale next Sunday for about $300-$400. It is an ink type. It seemed to have good reviews, but again I am hoping all of you can assist me out here.

Thanks in advance for your ideas, thoughts, likes, disliks, etc.

J. Lupo

79 replies

by hal 9000

The printer part tend to be more expensive per page to print as they use the Black & Colour Ink Tanks, the scanner is fairly Low resolution in comparison to even a cheap USB scanner and the Fax facility is only transmitting at 14.4 KBS which is fine for slow Fax Transmissions.

I once did a costing for a person with a Canon IP4200 Printer a LIDE 30 Scanner and a External Modem for Faxing and it worked out cheaper to buy that hardware than an all in one and Disposables where not taken into account. The only advantage that the All in Ones have is a saving on desktop space at the expense of usability as even the scanners in these things tend to be Low Quality Fax Standard Scanners about 70 DPI or slightly lower as the Fax Specs are different to the Computer Scanner Specs.

The printers are at the lower end of the scale as well but if you want something to save space it just might be worth the extra cost. It really depends on what it is you need to do any how much printing you'll be doing from this unit. Don't get me wrong anything scanned will look OK it just will not be as good as it could be with a proper scanner. The Printers like the Canon IP4200 also have a duplexer built in and will allow you to print CD/DVD Faces as well as having separate refillable ink tanks which do not have a print head on them so they really are much cheaper to replace than the all in 1 colour Ink Tanks. If you look at something like the Canon IP1200 with a RRP of $59.00 AU the replacement Ink Tanks come ion around the $85.00 for the Black & Colour tanks which is more than the printer costs and if you need to double side there is extra paper handling as well.

As an example the IP4200 Canon has the following

http://tinyurl.com/aoxlq

and the Canon LIDE25 is here at

http://tinyurl.com/zhd45

The all in 1 Canon MP500 has the following specs

http://tinyurl.com/j5c6f

and until you start looking at the Image Runner Series which are true Digital Photocopiers you don't get anywhere near the speed or reliability and cost per page of usage but I don't think that you would be interested in a 30K + AU price Tag. But they really are the only Multifunction device I would ever consider as they do it all with really professional results.

Col

by j.lupo

I am looking for something cost effective for home use. I don't really care about the fax or scan capability. It is the print and copy that I need more than anything else. These are the 2 things I do the most of. Fax rarely if ever. Scan so far never, but that is cause I am lazy and get a friend to do it for me all the time. Even my digital camera I haven't loaded the pix to the pc yet.

OH and this is a NB network at home. I haven't put in the PC that will be the server yet. I am doing everything off NB's at this point.

I get the feeling for cost and reliability/quality you are suggesting looking at Canon instead of HP, yes?

by hal 9000

So I tend to cut out the middle man and go straight for the original maker.

It also doesn't help the way that HP doesn't repair anything that breaks UG they just replace it and bin the broken thing. While it's great from the customer when it's UG it's not so good when the unit is no longer covered by any form of warranty. I got hit with this on a Conner Tape Drive many years ago when I sent [b]SHMBO[/b] to ring the suppliers to find out where to send the broken Conner Tape drive for repair. She got a less than professional answer and that's being very polite. I actually didn't believe her when she told me the response so I had to ring and got exactly the same thing so I rattled off my account number company name and asked to speak to the Manager. He just insisted that I read the book and ring the repairers listed in the book. Needless to say no one was listed on any of the accomping paperwork not even on a new one which I took in and asked [b]Where I return it to for repair?[/b] Along with an unopened new unit neither had anything about where to take it and I just rang the people who supplied them which seemed like the right idea to me at least. :D

Anyway I was eventually given a phone number to ring and when I looked it up on the On Line Phone Book the only entry was [b]Service Centre[/b] in Melbourne no company name or anything so I would have naturally thought of ringing them as they didn't have any reference at all to what it was that they did. I don't think that they got many returns for this very reason at the time but since then things have changed and I'm not overly happy with some of HP's Business practises here at least. I rang then with a faulty HP Multi Function device that one of my customers had brought where the light in the scanner never turned off they insisted that I didn't know what I was talking about and when it eventually died they replaced the entire unit 3 weeks before the Guarantee expired the owner was so grateful till I asked what she expected to happen next time? Of course the light in the replacement unit wasn't turning off either I know that HP changed the unit a couple of times in that last 3 weeks with no improvement. I'm not sure how it eventually ended up but I would imagine that they were offered some form of Extended Warranty.

Col

by wdewey

A lot of scanners have to built in option to send their output directly to a printer (basically a copy function).

Bill

by michael_orton9

1/ FAX, you already have a free one in WinXP or any major Linux distro, and if you don't like it there are plenty of free ones that you just install like a windows printer.
2/ Get a USB scanner, fits any PC, cheap, usually comes with free OCR, uner ?40, got a Goodmans from NETTO for ?16.99 when new store opened.
3/ Get any printer that will take cheap, UNAPPROVED cartridges. The printer is only a small part of the cost, don't bother with guarentee, its disposable, save money on ink.
For bulk work 50 to 100 colour runs I use a battery of free scrap Epson 440 and 600 colour stylus. Black under ?2, colour under?4 or less in bulk. Works OK win98se/Xp/SuSe Linux, and can be driver by a scrap 486 running DSL Linux on an 80 meg HD (landfill PCs!) These old epsons will run all day in a disgusting condition for years, unlike your three in one and are virtually free.
I do have latest HP Photo, but hardly ever use as ink too expensive for normal work.
Extra Parallel ports can often be got from recycers for free to ?5 as an alternative to a 486 and a ?2.50 NIC. You can get USB 2 parallel cables but just too expensive compared with free 486 or extra printer port card (but you then loose one serial port address).
A three in one will do all three jobs badly and expensively.
You could even BUY a copy of WinFax for windows.
I got a copy years ago with a Modem.
Modems, and you will need one, can now be got for around a fiver from carboot/recycling. It will do anything a three in one will do with Winfax, XPs faxing wizard or the many free programs from a google search, even works with DSL Linux on a 486.

by oz_media

Reasons to buy an Epson/Seiko (SEIKO just like the watch):
Patented magnet technology. They actually own the only land on Earth where such natural magnets are found, they use them in their watches too.

They are the only printer that still ships with FULL ink cartridges. Other printers ship with partial cartidges.

If you spend a few dollars more, you will get a 6 cartridge unit (many people groan at 6 cartidges) but they are better than those single-cartridge cheapos if you mix B&W with colour printing, plus they offer better colour tone than most single cartridge printers.

I could get into feed mechs etc. but don't need to, your testimonial of old Epsons speaks volumes alone.

by w2ktechman

While I agree that 2 devices are better, if you get a printer get a laserjet. Sure they cost more, but they are far more reliable than an ink based printer. There are some scanner/copier/printers that are laserjets, they take up a bit more space but are more hassle free.
Please dont get a cheap inkjet, the cartidges are needing replaced way too often, and the internal components are cheap. A common paper jam can render the printer useless. I have seen this many times, especially in the all in one, fax, and photo printer lines. But, it is much less common in laser printer lines.
If you need color for these as well, I found a CLJ for myself at $405 shipped to my door and have not had a problem with its occasional use.
But, if you want to print photo's, an LJ is the wrong way to go. They will look good, but they do not take glossy photo paper, the toner does not bond well and will flake off.

by llrossi

I'm a small business with the need for high quality printing for presentations and such.

Learn from my mistake. I bought the HP Officejet 9110 a couple of years ago and regretted it from the beginning. I had to send it back twice in the first six months and it has been nothing but trouble. I'll be junking it soon and replacing it with a seperate scanner and printer (unlike my LaserJets which have all been wonderful work horses).

If you do not need color and want the copy capability, I have had good luck with the Canon Imageclass D860. I use it as a copier only, but it can be hooked up as a printer as well.

by wendygoerl

I can't say much about ink vs. laser (since I have a need for high-resolution graphics, I haven't looked too hard at laser printers), but when it comes to inkjets, I'll say this: A good MFP can meet the scanner and printer needs of 90% of users, and I'll take Canon over HP any day.

When I finally got fed up with my old HP 520c DeskJet (partly because it was only 300 dpi, mostly because I throwing out a lot of ink), I finally settled on a Canon Pixma MP750. My choice of Canon over HP is the ink: HP puts all the colors in one cartridge (so if you print a lot of red documents, you'll be throwing out a lot of cyan ink); and HP builds the print heads into the cartridges, so you pay more for them (I can replace all five of my Pixma's tanks 2-3 times for what I used to pay for one HP cartridge).

As for scanning, the only thing I can really fault it for is it only has a white light (my old scanner had separate RGB lamps, which can come in handy in some situations). If I want to scan fine detail, I can crank it up to 1800 dpi; but for documents, 300 dpi is usually more than enough (I think the copier mode scans at 150 dpi, but don't quote me on that). A nice thing about all-in-ones is they can function as stand-alone copiers (fax, too, I think, though I've never used the fax function) whether the computer's on or not.

When it comes to space, MFP's can be a bit bulky. Mine lives on a filing cabinet dolly and rolls under my desk when I'm not using the scanner. This puts the document feeder and scanning bed just below seat level.

by workit9

right out of my mouth. As a former HP user, I love refilling my own individual tanks. My litle i560 Canon performs beautifully and I'm looking forward to a pixma model next. BTW, HP offers individual tanks for industry (we have 2 at work) because corporate wouldn't tolerate the waste (money).

by mjd420nova

I'm not a believer of putting all my eggs in one basket. Too often when one function quits, they all quit. As for the fax, I use Kinkos for that. I don't need it often enough to warrant my needs on an immediate basis. I had my fill of phone calls at all hours,and answering it and be met with a sreaming tone in my ear. I use seperate devices, but each is dedicated to a particular system but accessable thru the lan to every user.

by jaqui

since hp gave ms the drivers for their all in ones to be included in windows, you might find a small issue, which I have seen to many times.

windows loses the ability to use the danged thing, until you delete the printer from it, reboot then install the printer.

every month

without fail

no warning, just a failed print job once it's gone.

by j.lupo

I really want to keep this cost effective and not to big an area. I have a small area that i use for an office at home where I am building my home network center. I really only need print and copy. But it seems I can't find decent, cost effective, compatiple and space efficient devices.

I really need some education here. I am reading up on them, but as I said, it seems like a foreign language to me because all the documents are written for people who KNOW what they are doing. I think it is a way for salespeople to make you buy something you will regret later.

by jaqui

depends on the needs of the person using it.

I rarely print anything.
rarely have need of a scanner.
[ digital cameras make scanners outdated don't they? ]

fax services, not often needed.

so I actually make sure I have a dot matrix printer. old, loud, low-medium print quality, but reliable, and works no matter if it's 3 months or 18 months since last used.

You need to print papers for studies, then you need higher quality.
you need colour for charts? go ink, but go with a make / model where ink is cheap.
HP ink is 89 a tank, 3 colour, and 79 a tank black.

you might find the low end lexmark fits budget and needs well, though going with a better quality is often better long term. Canon products have been very reliable for me.

by deadly ernest

building a shelf at seated head height and placing the printer and other odities (like stapler, tape, punch, etc) on that. Once I had to set up a home office in a space 3 and a half feet wide and ten feet long. Set a desk up in the end with a shelf above it for the printer and scanner to sit on. If I had a lot of scanning to do I placed the scanner on the desk, otherwise I just stood up, or reached up to place the item in it for scanning.

The computer box sat on a shelf under the desk and one wall had two shelves along it for books and other items. The top shelve was used for sorting papers and the lower shelf had my reference books.

The old HP series 4 laser printers are good quality printers, get it serviced and stay with it, just by a basic scanner and you're OK.

by w2ktechman

As I work with HP printers and various Windows versions all day, every day. I rarely have problems with the drivers (built-in) for any of the printers and all-in-one's (except with .pdf format, then the printer is very slow).
If you are experiencing this problem regularly, something is either not configured correctly, or there is a conflict with another device.

by j.lupo

I should look at Cannon printers and copiers. I should also keep it all separate. Right?

by hal 9000

Works out cheaper than most of the current generation Multi Function Devices but once you start looking at the Photocopier Class of their line things change dramatically.

It's nice to have a 300 Page Document feed that you can scan from in Duplex Mode and they are fast with full Corporate Colour at 50 PPM and Black at 70 PPM. If you take the Service Contract which is the only way to go it will cost you 3/4 cent per page + the cost of Paper in Colour and 1/4 in Black & White. The page size doesn't matter you can pay the same for an A3 that is setup as a Booklet layout as for a double sided A4 page. But these things are anything but cheap.

Col

by j.lupo

thank you. I have some major reading up to do and then financial management to see what I can really afford.

by jdmercha

What feature will you be using mosdt often?
If you plan on using it as a printer,mostly then get one from a printer company, like HP. If you are going to do more copying, then get one from a copier company like Canon or Xerox.

By the way. Windows does come with drivers for HP printers, but they are not full featured drivers. Use that latest drivers from HP. Then you won't have the "lost printer" problem. The standard transmit rate for FAX machines is 14.4.

Then consider how much printing/copying you are going to do. How much of it will be in color? If you don't use up the toner in about 6 months it has a tendancy to dry up.

Ink jet or laser? Laser provides a higher quality output that lasts longer. Lasers are more expensive to buy but are cheaper to maintain if you have large volumes of printing/copying.

What type of scanning do you do? Are you just scanning graphics for the web? then any old scanner will do. Do you need to scan photograchs in hogh resolution, then you will need a better scanner.

Figure opu how much you want to spend, then get the best unit for your money.

by j.lupo

I appreciate that. I know my needs right now for scanning and faxing are basically nil. That doesn't mean they won't change in the future.

I am trying to plan accordingly and learn what I can. Copying and printing are pretty much at the same level. I am always printing and copying stuff. In fact I have gotten used to printing in multiples because I didn't have a copier at home. However, I am finding that I have articles and forms and such that are pre-printed that need to be copied, which is why my copying has now caught up with my printing needs.

I like HP, but Col has me thinking of Canon since Canon makes the HP devices. Hmmmm

by jdmercha

For your situation, I would go with a mid-range ($300) HP multi-function inkjet. Make sure it has a document feeder (the 7210 for $288).

I'd look closr at Canon for a departmental workhorse (over $1000) not a personal printer.

by jaqui

if MS has the drivers for the HP all in one, then HP doesn't have any drivers for it for win xp.
this has been the problem with the hp all in ones, lack of support from hp for their all in ones.

naturally, if the hp product is just out on the market, they do have drivers for it, since ms hasn't released a patch with the device drivers yet. as soon as possible though, hp gives ms the drivers then stops carrying them on their website.

by oz_media

Granted the price of an all in one is about the same as an entry level model of each, but that's usually what yu end up with, an entry level product of each put into one.

It depends on your needs, I would never try and use an all in one for business, why?

You wouldn't be able to fax while making a copy whie printing a document, it all gets queued and is processed as the device becomes available, not very productive at all.

secondly, if your fax breaks, you have to either replace your copier and scanner too or have all three down while the repair is performed, it just isn't sensible at all.

For Genereal Purpose home use, just weight it out, can you live without them while one part of the unit is repaired? Can you wait for one function to complete before the next begins?

And now think about what you just said:
"I need a copier and my printer is just about shot"

If that NEW copier dies, can you do without the printer until it the copier is fixed? Or would you rather take printer in for repair and still be able to make copies on your copier?

by j.lupo

I am beginning to see why it would be better to just have 2 separates, a printer and a copier. Maybe I can get 2 for the price of one with a little negotiating. :) I want something desktop and somewhat portable. My Laserjet at home is almost shot but it does work. On the other hand I need the ability to copy more than print at the moment. It is starting to get expensive going to Kinko's all the time.

by oz_media

I have a friend/aquaintance that buys up tons of them from (HP and Canon and Okidata)liquidators, he sells scanner for $25.0, printers for $30.00 brand new. Unfortunately by teh trime you factor in freght and brokerage, it's probably cheaper to buy there. Try Best Buy for something cheap, but if you want something diehard, look at OkiData's products.

by jdmercha

If you are the only one using it, then you don't need to worry about waiting for the fax while the machine is printing.

If you spend $300 on a multi-function printer, it is not worth taking the time to repair it, just buy another one.

by oz_media

Okay if I am the only one using it I won't have to wait.

So if I want to print a document, fax another and then photo copy another I can do all of this at the same time without waiting for one process to end? How so?

I am talking about productivity, even one person can lose productivity by not being able to multitask. I don't want to wait for my print job, .I want to get a fax off, send a print job to the printer AND scan a document to send to someone else at the same time. An all-in-one can't do this, three piece of hardware can. Send teh print job, while it's printing send a fax and then while that is sending I can scan a document and email it out. By the time my email is gone, my print job is finished and my fax has gone through, even if it redialled due to a busy number.

Doyou really not multitask at your ofice or did this just slip your mind?

As for cost, some people mind eating $300 if only 4 months after buying a new unit and don't like not having one until they buy a new unit. If we want to look at cheap alternatives, $49.00 for a cheap printer. Fax through teh PC with WinFax or a CRM program, print inbounds on your $49.00 printer.

by tink!

Sounds like you need to print and copy/fax.

Get an HP printer.
And a lower cost fax.

Remember (or take note) that you can make copies with any fax machine.

Sorry this reply is so abrupt. If I had more time I'd pull up costs for you.

I avoid all-in-ones whenever possible, as it has already been mentioned, they have a tendency to lose all functions when 1 of them goes out.

Tink

by j.lupo

Yeah I was thinking of the convenience, but as they say it ain't convenient if its broke. :)

by j.lupo

I don't want unprofessional, but I want cost effective too. It is for home use, but I am working on building my own environment and I would like this to last me a little while. I can't believe my HP LaserJet IV is still kicking.

by hal 9000

Are identical to the Canon LBP1760 I actually use a HP cartridge in my Canon LBP1760 the only difference is the drivers which can not be used with the different brands. Go figure that one, but those old HP/Canons where as reliable as Hell and just work without a second thought.

In the time that I've had my 1760 it's only cost me refilled cartridges so far and I'm kicking myself for not getting a Duplexer when I bought the unit as it just so reliable and runs without a second thought. I leave mine on all the time which is a Big No No but it just works.

For minimal Desk Space the Canon LIDE Scanners have a stand so that you can stand them on their side so as they are only about 1/2 an inch thick they take up very little room on the desktop and have the Print/Scan and E-Mail buttons on the front of the unit so you don;t even need to open any software to do the job the stand that mounts at one end takes up about 4 inches of desktop space though I'll admit that I prefer to sit them flat as I don't always want the paper mounted in correctly against the top and side edge of the scanner. The current Bottom end Canon LIDE 25 had a RRP of $119.00 AU which is about $89.50 US so it's not expensive by any means.

I've got a 4 year old LIDE 30 which besides having a dent in the top cover from dropping a Force Feedback Joystick on it looks and works like new and it's had a lot of use. To be perfectly honest I should be replacing it for Tax Reasons but I'm channelling the money into a new workstation as the new Scanners of this type don't have any advantages over the one that I currently have. They also have a floating hinge on them if you want to scan/copy from a book so they don't get that dreaded Black area around the pages.

Now I've got the new M'Board mounted in its case with the 2 Xeon's on it and the heat sinks along with the RAM and everything plugged in all I need is the time to actually mount some HDD's and power it up. I only put it this far together about 3 weeks ago and haven't as yet had a chance to get back to it but the time will come sometime. :)

Col

by sleepin'dawg

I'm still using an HP-4M and it's been going strong since 1992-3 era. The 4M was a little different from the plain 4 in that it came with a lot more memory and included Post Script which I needed at the time. A few years ago, when I knew I was going to be absent on business, I took it into HP to have it checked and serviced if necessary. When I got back they rattled off a list of things they say they did and the whole thing cost me $82. They clained they cleaned the unit, replaced the drum and the fuser. Before I took it in it had been running slower and since I had it serviced it has been running like new again.

While Col is right about going for separate units and consumable costs you have to remember he is in Australia where costs are substantially more expensive and HP may not have as good service providers or department. Here in Canada and the US they are reasonably decent and comparable to Canon or Epson in that regard.

I needed another printer a couple of years ago for a condo, I maintain near one of our other locations and while shopping around I tried a Samsung printer and was surprised at the print quality and speed, even better than my old HP. It's faster and has a higher resolution of 1200 DPI and the really nice thing was it only cost me $149 on sale and there was a $50 rebate. It doesn't have Post Script like my HP but is otherwise as good as my HP and some Canons friends of mine have. Toner costs are comparable as well. This thing has turned out to be far better than I expected it to be.

I have an HP scanner of comparable vintage as my HP printer but at my condo I bought an Epson scanner again the price jolted me as it was substantially cheaper than the Old HP unit which cost me more than $1200 dollars back in 93. I paid $149 for the scanner which has better optical specs and scan speed than my old HP. I use my scanners in both places for the few faxes I have to send. I can use WinXP to fax or I can use email and send it as an attachment. Personally I prefer the attachment route because the delivered image will be much higher res than any readily available fax machine.

If your heart is really set on a new printer do not waste money on purchasing a colour laser as they still are not capable of producing acceptable photo results. You can buy something like an Epson 300 for the number of times you require colour in a report and you can also print digital photos. The Epson 300 is a six tank printer and produces good photo results and the last time I looked it was selling in the $150-$200 range. You could spring for an extra few bucks and get an eight colour printer if you are really super critical about your results.

All these items will do well in a SOHO environment but are inadequate for use by multiple users in a regular office.

When I finally decided I needed a copier at home, Ilooked for companies that reconditioned office copiers and bought reconditioned units for both places. I actually bought my copiers from Xerox the one at home cost me $350 Canadian and included a collator and duplex printing. It other than the collator it is like any regular office copier. The one at my condo cost $265 US and is identical to the one at home. The cost per page on the copiers is about $0.02 - 0.03 per page but the speed of out put is in the area of 40ppm. Much faster than the laser printers, which print in the 8 - 12ppm range. Cost per page on the laser printers is $0.03 - 0.04 per page. The copier are real heavy duty machines and as a consequence if I require more than 3 copies of a print job, I usually do only one copy on the laser printer and copy it on the copier for the number I require.

Costs per page on an ink jet run between $0.30 - $1.10 per page depend ing on whether you are printing monochrome type or colour photos.

There are laser jet style all-in-ones but you have the same problem with them as you would with their ink all-in-one brethren although your cost per page will be cheaper. Do not even think about using an ink jet for type, the costs are prohibitive.

BTW I've been running the copiers since 99 and have absolutely had no problems. I've had the Samsung since 02 and the Epson scanner and ink jet printer since 03 and they too have been problem free.

You have to ask yourself how many pages will you require printing each month? How many pages will you require to copy? I frankly don't see the need for a fax machine anymore since you can fax from your computer a lot faster than you can from a fax machine. The only speed limitation on thei is the size of the buffer on the receiving fax machine. Sending and receiving faxes from your computer does not limit you to the 14.4 of the fax machine.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by hal 9000

Where a couple of Samsung units and their data transfer is 28.8 KBS which apparently all the new ones are running at. Of course they are backward compatible with the old 14.4 KBS Standard but much faster when they connect to a new fax machine and unbelievably fast when they hit a computer to pickup the fax.

I picked up a secondhand Canon B155 and it sends at 28.8 as well just don't ask why I had to pick up that Canon as it's a long painful story and then after I replaced it I was given the unit when the owner moved Over Seas so I just have it sitting here mostly unused but as I didn't really pay for it it's not costing me anything so I suppose I can't complain.

Col

by j.lupo

I guess servicing my HP is first, then look at copiers for the house. I don't really need all the other stuff and would just be wasting my money that could go towards a better copier.

by sleepin'dawg

The only difference between my 4M and your 4, was the 4M came standard with 16 meg of memory and Post Script built in. After running mine virtually problem free for nearly 10 years, I noticed it slowing down slightly. Taking it in for service after ten years was a great deal. They claim to have replaced the drum and fuser and thoroughly cleaned it all for $82 taxes included. It now actually runs slightly faster than when new.

Some newer printers have higher resolutions but at 600 DPI the HP4 is no slouch. If you looked at the print quality of earlier HP you might have noticed a very slight jaggedness on the obliques of letters if you really looked closely. This was because print resolution was only 300 DPI. At 600 DPI you really have to strain your eyes to see any jagged edges, although I'm not saying there aren't any, just that you need a magnifying glass to see them. Yes the newer printers do have a higher res of 1200 DPI or better and have faster output, some almost as fast as 22 - 25ppm bit the new SOHO printers don't have the same duty or life cycle capability of the older printers.

The per page costs, I quoted peviously were based on using the manufacturers toner. You can improve on those numbers by using off brand refills but I'm not sure I would advise this. Toner quality is crucial to printer function and inferior toner can result in dirty and streaky output, making a service call necessary. You can get factory toner at Best Buy or Office Depot for only a minimal amount more than reloads. You might save money on toner only to spend it on service if the printer plugs up. This by the way applys to ink jets as well. I have found the print heads plugging up when using cheap ink but I've left an ink jet idle for as long as four months with no problem using factory ink.

Think carefully before you decide what you want to do but I'll bet that HP 4 of yours still has afew years of life in it yet. when I got my HP 4M
I gave my old HP II to my nephew, which I had bought in 1986. He is still using it and it still works well.

BTW toner cartridges for the older printers are cheaper than for the newer ones.

When you are considering a new printer you can't just think of the price so much as the per page cost over the long haul. The same thing applys to copiers as well.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by deadly ernest

Generally the all-in-one options have cheap basic scanners and printers in one case or connected, commonly a bubble jet printer as they're cheaper.

I have a good laser printer, colour, that has done me well for 5 years - previously went through a new bubble jet very 18 months until the fourth died.

A good printer with a basic scanner and a modem with fax software. Then you have the exact same capability as the all-in-one in a more practical arrangment. If you want to, or need to, upgrade one part you can. Every person I know who has an all-in-one hates the damn things as a fault with any part means the whole thing is out to the shop.

I have found that bubbles jets waste a lot of money unless you do heaps of printing, the bloody ink dries up on you very quickly. While lasers can sit around for years in perfect condition.

Every scanner for some years has included software to enable you to send a scanned image straight to the printer, bingo a photocopier, it can even send it to the email program or the fax software (there's your fax machine). Most modems now come with software to answer the phone and either accept a fax or take a voice message. Faxes can be sent straight to the rpinter or saved for review first. What more do you want - sorry no electronic secretaries to chase around the desk, but they're working on them.

by j.lupo

I am considering everything that I am being told here. Maybe I can get my Uncle to put up some shelving over where I keep my printer now. Then put the copier and scanner in that area. Hmmmmm

The big need is copier and printer. I can use my digital camera for scanning purposes. Fax isn't that high on my list of necessities.

by a_chief

Get service on the LJ printer and get a flatbed scanner that suits your budget. Most of these include a "copy" button that sends the image directly to your printer. This is less expensive option than dedicated copier.

If your uncle can't put up a shelf right away, get one of those "milk crate" type plastic boxes - set it on its side where your printer is, put your printer on top of box - and your scanner inside. Arrange cables so you can slide it out of crate it you need to open scanner lid fully (e.g. to scan a large book or awkward shaped object).

by jerome.koch

They change thier models so frequently, that its hard to keep up. I got my wife an All in one (copier, printer, scanner, fax) three years ago for around 200. She uses it constantly for home schooling, and it hasn't yet failed.

You can buy addition jet direct cards to get it on your home WiFi, but they can be a bit pricey. Four hundred bucks should buy you a nice one.

by jerome.koch

14.4 baud is good enough unless you are faxing hundreds of pages. Email has replaced faxing by about 50% percent since 2000. I wouldn't get too fixated on faxing.

If your job demands a higher speed fax, buy one seperate.

by j.lupo

I am working on research for my Doctorate. I have to submit it to my committe which is scattered around the country. The document tends to be too large when put together to e-mail. Even when I zip it the file is too large. So, I have been sending in pieces for now. I can't do that when I get to final draft.

Having the benefit of a copier (3 committee members, 1 to the Dean, 1 to publication, 1 to library, etc) and e-mailing (won't work) so faxing would be next option. Also, the title page has to have original signature on it.

by marvinthemartian1

I have an HP OfficeJet G85xi which I got when they first came out. It has NEVER given me any trouble, has great resolution in scan AND fax modes as well as copy mode. It faxes as a stand alone as well as copying standalone. Ink cartridges are bit bit pricy but I can get them filled for $7 for black and $8 for color at Walgreens and the refills work as good as new ones. I don't know why everyone else seems to have so many problems with them. I love mine!

by jamierterrell

For one if you are going to use it a lot and can't be without all 3 if something goes wrong then definitely get separate machines. Plus alot depends on your volume of work. If you are going to be doing a lot of printing and scanning then again get separate machines.

If it was me I would get a laser printer and a separate portable scanner and put a fax modem into your PC. That would cut down on the devices on your desk. Any faxes you could scan and fax from PC.

I would go with a laser printer because inkjets seem to go out faster than a laser printer. As far as wireless unless you have a laptop you want to walk around and still be able to print and all what is the point of wireless?

by w2ktechman

between the print heads, ink, and malfunctions on the cheaper lines, it is better for a LJ.
But, LJ's are bulkier and more expensive (but usually very reliable).
But, if a inkjet is to be used, get one with cartridges for each color. This way you will not be wasting even more... If 1 color goes out on a multi color cartridge, the whole thing needs to be replaced. Even if you only used 1 color a lot, and the other colors are mostly full. This is a huge waste of money and product.

by j.lupo

that is why I wanted to stay wireless. I am building my home network to use the least amount of space, but provide the most power. I am doing it from the ground up, however I am also working on a Doctorate and have some immediate needs for a copier and printer. Fax/scanning is really minor to me. The scanner would be a nice, but isn't required.

copying and printing are the things I do most.

by w2ktechman

a scanner and a printer seperately, it can be used similar to a copier. Just scan to the printer. For multiple copies you may need to scan to the computer and then print multiples.

Or
in your case it might be better for an all-in-one. I see you are aware of the problems that may arise, but space is an issue and some models do work for a long time.

by jdmercha

Again I agree with what you are saying but....

What kind of work is being done. I got the impression from this thread that the unit would see relatively low use.

If you have the need to print a 30 page documnet, make 200 copies and fax 10 pages, then a multifunction unit is not for you. With this type of usage you'll want a high quality seperate units.

But with the usage describes, waiting even five minutes to finsih a print before you can send a fax, should not be a problem.

As for eating the $300, I was trying to make the point that low end machines are usually not woth repairing. And buying a new replacement is often cheaper and quicker than the repair.

by oz_media

Firstly, buying a replacement is not a viable option for someone trying to run a business or earn money, especially in a home based fashion. Who has tme to go out shopping and setting up new hardware when they have a job to do?

As for waiting 5 moinutes for print jobs and then faxing, and THEN scanning, and THEN printing again, I don't know about yohu but I sure as hell don't have the time nor patience for that crap. I want my work done NOW, I don't put up with other issues impeding my workflow or tme management.

It doesn't matter how important it is, time is valuable whether at home, working from home or at the office.

Personally I would have no problem waiting 20 minutes for print jobs on someone else's dime (employer) but when it comes to me, I don't have the time to wait for print jobs and faxes to complete. I am busy making my next dollar before the damn fax is finished sending, who's got time for that?!

As far as the useage, it was pretty clear to me that it was pretty heavy for the average home user.

by pennatomcat

Although I own an HP all-in-one (complete with bloatware), I mostly use a Lexmark Z600 series that I bought over a year ago for less than $30.00. It has stood up to fairly heavy use and still does a fine job. If it breaks, I know that I can quickly and easily replace it--2 weeks ago I saw it at Walmart selling for $22.88. I have a separate flatbed scanner in reserve, so I probably won't replace the HP. I haven't really used it much for color or graphics, but it's more than adequate for black and white printing.

by ez_1putt

I went thru this same process last month. After working on soo many MFP's (especially HP2410's and Hp5510's),, I was real reluctant to buy an all-in-one. There have been a couple times where the scanner would go bad so the whole unit would essentially be worthless. When looking into finding replacement parts, you will quickly realize that a specific part will cost roughly 3/4 of a brand new unit. It's hard to grasp when you know that a specific part will fix the problem but it doesn't make economic sense to pay for it.

I also am not very impressed with certain ink cartridges. Some HP models 'seem' to bleed more on average than other inkjet cartridges. If you do a quick Amazon search for inkjets, you can get an overall sense from the reviews which ones have a bad reputation than others for 'going thru' alot of ink.

However, it's hard to justify getting a separate fax machine when I very seldom had a need for one. To me, faxing seems to be a bit primitive when you have the capability to scan to email. I don't know any businesses that won't accept a scanned pdf thru email. Copying is a nice feature but hardly worth a separate appliance.

After realizing my needs (and my budget) it was hard for me to NOT consider a MFP. I get everything i need in one machine. After further research I went with a Canon PIXMA MP500. Read the reviews at Newegg and Amazon.http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16828102182
For the price, this MFP has the quality and reliability that other competing HP All-in-ones lack. Wireless capability, seperate cartridges for each color and a great reputation. Check yer out.

by j.lupo

I really appreciate the insights and am going to continue to watch this board for your posts. I have a lot more research to do before Sunday when the all-in-one HP I was looking at goes on sale. The sales guy (yeah I know sales) was pretty clear about its capabilities and such.

Since All I want is basic functionality, I may just put up some sturdy shelving above my office desk and put a copier and other small devices there. My Lasterjet 4 I will service and see what happens.

Thanks again. I can't thank you all enough.

by hal 9000

Let me get this right [b]You are thanking us for confusing you right?[/b] :p

Col ]:)

by j.lupo

But at least I understand the issues more than just being [i]bamboozled[\i] from a salesperson. :)

I like the HP brand, it has always done me justice, so I will also look at Cannon since they make the HP (If I got that right from the other posts). I really liked the size and functionality of the HP I saw that is going on sale, but I wasn't happy that it was Ink Jet instead of Laser and I didn't like that it looked complicated to use and setup.

If I can get the name and some literature, I will post it here. I really love my HP Laserjet 4, but I REALLY need a copier and maybe a scanner.

by hal 9000

I would recommend a refurbished Canon 6045 these are now about 6 - 8 years old and are the monochrome Analog units that just work without a second though. Currently every major print shop here has them as the Low Volume Photocopiers as they are virtually unbreakable run forever with just toner refills occasionally and nothing else. I had one of these for my mother before the Image Runner which wasn't really necessary and Canon traded it in and left it at Mums house as they where only going to destroy it and it saved them the freight in moving the thing.

You can get a 2 drawer one without a collator which will at a stretch sit on a very heavy desktop but you'll most likely see the 4 drawer ones with a 20 Sheet Collator. The one that my mother used for 7 years has only had toner supplied and paper it's still got the original Drum in it and has done 500,000 + copies according to the counter.

The Image Runner 3100 had a drum replaced at 20,000 copies and was at best a mess from the word go. I was almost at the stage of demanding a replacement unit as it caked itself after less than 200 copies and took a long time to repair.

Granted just about everything was replaced in it except the chassis and I know the senior tech so I played it straight with him but even he was talking about replacing the thing and is still thinking about it as it's less than 12 months old and if it plays up again he will have it replaced with another new one. He was even not overly happy with the results when he replaced the drum and is currently keeping an eye on it. According to the treasurer of the organisation that my mother belongs to the last batch of labels that it printed off had the toner rub off so if that's right and not just an excuse for another set of Labels I think that will be the final straw for this unit. The last time that I talked to him he was handing out $300.00 Toner refills for the 6045 which has been used whenever the 3100 hasn't worked so far he given mum about 6 of these to keep the old one running if required. She so far used one. Even he admits that they are excellent Work Horses that just work without a second thought. He actually gave it a complete service when the new one originally broke and the only thing that he could find to do was clean it up a bit. Someone who shall remain nameless had put their dirty fingers all over the image glass and that was the only thing that he could find wrong with it and he certainly tried to find any faults.

He couldn't even fault the rollers as none of them had gone hard with time or use and all the paper runners where not only intact but by his description [b]In Perfect Condition.[/b]

He actually asked me why I had got a new one when the old one was so much better for the needs of the organisation. I could only tell him that it was for Tax Reasons that it had been replaced which is the truth but he told me never to let it go as it would be running long after the new one was dead and buried.

The Canon 6045 replaced a 4 year old Natasha Tech which was the biggest pile of junk I've ever run across and the company who sells them here isn't much better either they tried to pull a Swifty when they delivered the machine by not delivering the 6,000 sheet bin feeder which was only about 2.5K. If I hadn't of been there my mother would have signed for the complete item and then they would have claimed that the sheet feeder had been supplied and we had taken it else where.

I just never felt happy in dealing with that crowd and always had to have a shower after I'd been there as I always felt dirty after trying to get the most basic service done.

They even make MS look like a totally nice company to do business with and no I'm not joking. :D

Col

by j.lupo

I will look into pricing and specs on the Canon 6045. I do have some space requirements, but I might be able to squeeze a printer/copier cabinet into the area where my printer sits now. If I can do that with the HP Laserjet 4 and a decent copier, I should be all set.

I am approaching end zone on my diss and am dreading printing 500+pages with graphics in sextuplet.

by gin590

I had a HP T45 for a number of years and it worked fine and I just upgraded to a HP OfficeJet 5600 and it workes "finer". It was easy to install and prints faster than the T45. It prints, copies, faxes and scans. I suggest you look into it.

by hodgelett

I've had an HP printer and Canon scanner combo for years. The scanner was actually more often in my dad's posession or just sitting sideways on the bottom shelf of the pc desk - the only way it could fit. It is...2000dpi I believe, pretty standard.
When I went to uni I knew I would have a tiny room and my printer was giving up the ghost anyway so decided to buy an All-in-one. Browsing in Tottenham Court Rd (as any Brit will tell you, the tech place to go) with some printouts from my dad in hand I enquired about different makes etc.
I was assured that Brother was going out of business and therefore their printer cartridges were going to soon become unavailable and that all the big companies used HP. Sure enough, most shops were pretty much only selling HPs, with a few Canons thrown in. Although the thing that convinced me was the online reviews.
Anyway, in the end I opted for the HP 1510, which wasn't the top of the range at the time but had very few differences, unlike the 1410 which my dad had used at work and was pretty flimsy and useless.
To cut a long story short, I've had brilliant photo-standard printing and have had no complaints with the scanner which I'm using more now, even though I scan at high dpi and resize down. It has the function to take not only the single colour cartridges but the tiny 5 colour cartridges, although the print is fine with the 3-colour-cartridge.
The only thing is that it is usb and not a print port, so I lose one of my usb ports, and they don't supply you with a cable but that's minor.

by workit9

work best for me as most have easily refillable individual tanks-- saving lots of money. I've been refilling for years. My low-end i560 produces gorgeous glossy prints and sharp b&w text. HP socks it to the consumer because our huge newspaper-size industrial ink jets at work have individual tanks because industry wouldn't stand for the waste and extra cost. As a rule, the yellow runs out first, at work we replace the yellow. HP makes the poor consumer replace the yellow, magenta and cyan. Unthinkable for me.

Also, I prefer individual comonents 'cause when one goes, just replace or repair the one-- not the whole thing. Good luck and beware HP!

by nick linenberger

I use an all-in-one HP at home and am satisfied with it.

When a user at work wanted to buy one I thought, sure great cost savings. After reading the posts and with some experience I agree it does not save money. My biggest concern was when I discovered the network card was not designed to be used with a server based print spooler. I had to load all the software (30 min. on new fast PC's) and then all the users had to be local administrators to make the connection work. There goes my security and now the problems begin.

Users need lots of training if they have never used a network scanner or fax.

by lists

>Staples is going to have a wireless HP all-in-one >on sale next Sunday for about $300-$400.

I bought an HP7410 All in-One over a year ago and have been very satisfied. The copies,scans and prints look good and unlike my previous Epsons, I'm not using all of the ink cleaning print heads. The FAX works over Time-Warner's voIP (receive and send) and the unit is quiet. The wireless is very handy with 2 notebook users around the house. I like this printer and have never regretted my purchase.-k-

by buland.a.mahmood

I had a Brother 3 in One Machine, it was 100 bucks, w/three color and one black cartridge. Cartridges are 12+ each, and run out quickly. Printer cannot be networked. Scanner software was so-so.

Bought a Canon MP500, it works with Mac and windows, the color prints are very good, and the scanner software is excellent. On photo paper pictures are almost like professional, and the cost of $169; but the ink cartridges are $17+.

My son finds his graphics art images print great.

I have been very disappointed with HP's new inkjets. Their Quality in printer ruggedness is gone, and ink is too high.

Printers are sold at cost, while HP and most other make money on ink cartridges.

by customsunlimited

I am 55 years old, and been into computers since 1984, so my experience is as follows:

I perfer a full size scanner, legal document size with a very good OCR(optical character recgonition) software. Zerox has a top quality OCR. The newest HP OCR was barely acceptable. Their legal size scanners are dependable though. Finding a full size scanner is a bit of a problem in the last couple of years. This is a mistake the manufacturers are forcing us consummers to accept. Used to be the other way around, when full size scanners were the norm.

My Brother MFC 420CN($125.00), a 4-in-one, (letter size), bought at Staples, does OK. The ScanSoft PaperPort 9.0 software, that comes with it, is a bummer. ScanSoft hijacks your photo rendering software,(such as Adobe)and makes photos that cannot be modified(nasty!).It is not user friendly, and is SLOW. It has not been a shining example for editable scans, to Word documents either.

Good thing, is that this model can "stand alone". It is an excellent stand alone copier, fax, and PhotoCapture Printing Center.

Inkjets have their place, but they suck ink with a passion. I perfer to have separate color and b&w printers. I and my daughters, do a lot of printing, mostly b&w. Using ink got expensive, so we now use two printers.

My older HP LaserJet 2100M, does most excellent black & white printing. I haven't had to do anything except feed paper to it in the last 3 years. I clean it out twice a year to get out any foriegn stuff that may get into it. It has been the best, dependable printer I have ever had.

Fax capability is good with the Brother unit, but I very seldom use it. I perfer to e-mail with an attachment, as a document(s) can be scanned and saved as a photo copy of the original document(legally better than a fax). Larger files are uploaded to a remote site for downloading. This is handy for those 5 meg to 100 meg files. I can send a high resolution fax, but if the receiving fax is a low resolution model (or set to low resolution) - I have wasted my time.

Lastly, The computer system I use is not an off-the-shelf unit. I hate machines that are proprietary. The computer system is not the speed problem with the Brother unit.

You will get what you pay for in the long run. My old HP 2100M printer was used for years in a business LAN before I got it. Still spits out the goods though. The Brother color aii-in-one units seem to give better resolution than the HP's I've tried, at equal price range. That is just my observation though.

I am NOT a fan of the ScanSoft OCR/Twain. HP's was much more user friendly and did not hijack your other programs. It also worked well with Windows Office programs. Roxio software was another hijacker I, and my brother(also an engineer), had problems with, when needing to render photos/graphics. ScanSoft and Roxio hijacked our Adobe programs and produced uneditable graphics/photos. It went through the hard drive and changed every photo and graphics work we had to an uneditable format. This was costly to us both, and we were MOST UNHAPPY!

If your all-in-one is going to be working with your personal computer, these are issues to concider BEFORE installing the OEM software.

Rex Berry

by wdewey

I purchased an epson printer. It worked great for 6 months to a year then it started making all sorts of squeaking noises. It still worked, but it was annoying.

Bill

by a_chief

I think you've just answered your own question:
- keep the LJ4 - service if necessary
- buy a scanner and hook it up
- press "copy" button on scanner to copy to printer

you have it all.

by edward perez

my needs:
+ great color photo printing [fairly often]
+ great scanning [less often]
+ ability to read digital memory cards [very often, every time i finish shooting photos]
+ fast b/w printing [often, my hp officejet 720 from '98 is dependable but sloooooooooow].

i bought a hp3210 photosmart all in one last nov [from hp shopping - no interest 90 days, no shipping, no state tax; was $300, now around $224]. it prints great b/w & color [text and/or images, photos], does a great job on copying text/images [even OCR, but that's not much of a need for me], does a good/great job scanning text/images/negatives/slides, accepts 5-6 memory card types. i had problems installing the drivers and software but eventually got it all going. s/w includes a control center, an image editing/printing pgm, album maker, etc. [hp image zone]

my first test print was a photo i took in cusco, peru. lots of color, lots of detail, wide range of lighting. excellent 4x6 from the photo CD jpeg i had!!

i've used the memory card transfer many times [so as to not use up batteries in camera] and it's very easy to use.

when i have a long document to print or a page that has lots of text [even airline boarding passes], and i dont want to wait on the slow hp officejet 720, i use fast draft mode and it works great.

since the oj 720 has fax capability, i keep it around for that [my wife faxes stuff several times a week]. hp offers a hp 3310 photosmart that adds networking and fax capabilities [around $430].

it uses 6 ink cartridges [seems a bit much to me] that run $10 for color ones, $19 for b/w. go to hpshopping.com and get all 6 plus 150 4x6 sheets for $35. [HP Custom 02 Series 150-Sheet Photo Value Pack (Q7964AN#140)]

best of luck. just remember, after you but it, it WILL go on sale somewhere. dont even think about beating yourself up about that.

by lazerous200

I see nobody even mentions the Brother series of printers. They have anything you want in a printer. Just check out Brother.com. I repair brother printers and they are a very good midrange printer with a wide range of capabilities at an affordable price. I can tell you from experience that they do have a very good track record as far as longevity. The company I work for has several thousand of them in operation. Everything from the old MFC 8300 to MFC 6460 printers. From a repair stand point they do hold up rather well. We also have HP laser printers, from the 4mv's to the 8150 models. These are a more expensive printer but they do with the proper maintenance last virtually for ever. We have had cannon printers but scrapped mostt of them as being to expensive to repair. One thing you will note is that most of the laser printers on the market use cannon laser's, since cannon holds the pattent on their design.
If you are looking for an MFC printer with a small footprint then I suggest you look at the Brother MFC 8460DN or the brother8640DN. They are both upgradable to wireless. They both have networking built in and are duplexing machines, wich means that they print on both sides of the page in one operation. They also have a 30 page per minute print speed with a first page out in under ten seconds in all print modes from 1200 X 1200 dpi down to 300 dpi. They also have a very high resolution scanner that does excellent color scanning.
Brother also has a very good color laser jet printer that is not to expensive.
Toner cartridges ar as a rule notto expensive,($40.00) range but the Drums are fairly expensive, about $85.00. You can however use four toner cartridges to one Drum. A high yield toner cartridge can print up to 7000 pages at five percent coverage. My best advice would be to check out Brother.com and see what is available that suits your needs.

by wcosales9

The only thing i have found with Brother is that the Laser machines have a toner and a drum cartridge. When you have to replace the drum cartridge you might as well buy a new machine as that is what the drum will cost you. Have had several business's throw them all out

by rahbm

Glad to hear that things are becoming clearer, but please note that Canon does NOT make any HP printers. They make the raw engine for HP LaserJets (which is why the toner carts are the same), while HP makes everything else including the formatter etc. HP inkjets and scanners are wholly HP. Note that HP wrote PCL, which is the language used by most printers these days. HP invented inkjet printing and licenced the technology to Canon (a pretty dumb move!) to keep the supply of Canon laser engines.

I totally agree with all the others here who suggested adding a scanner to your current printer. This will give you the copy capability, while maintaining separate boxes, and keep your print costs low with the LaserJet. My ScanJet 5000 (6+ yrs) and LaserJet 4L (10+ yrs) just keep on going and going.

by wcosales9

What ever you use. Here are a few points to ponder. How many pages per month do you do. That is called the Monthly duty cycle. Also the capacity of PPM is based on only 6% of the page being covered with toner or ink. Will you be doing any color printing or all black? The price of the unit is not all to look at either. You also need to compare the price per page of the consumables. Some times a more costly unit with lower cost consumables is better for ROI. On a all in one when one part of it goes out then the whole thing is shut down usually. My wife has one of these at work and it was not big enough and is constantly breaking down and is only two years old. They have a Ricoh. You are wise to stick with HP. I would not use wireless as the transfer speed is still slow and need to be secured so no one else can get into it and print to your printer.

by biglittleather_1

I have used HP products for almost 20 years and have never had a service problem. Yes I have had mechanical problems but as soon as I contacted HP they immediately took care of the situation. This included everything from an el cheapo printer to a PC and a commercial Copier.

With that said, I also agree with the separate unit theory, for the same reasons that were stated by several others. If one aspect of All in One breaks, they all are boken. Save yourself time, money and stress; buy the separate units. Whether it be Cannon, HP, Lexmark or whatever!

BC

by atsincfl

Issues:
Cost / Speed / Reliability / Brand
Ink Jet/ Laser / Laser / HP (all the way)
If buying Ink-Jet type, buy one that the ink cartridge has the heads and ink in the same module.(more expensive cartridge, but more reliable. Color printers are a lot more expensive than B&W. We seldom use color in our business daily tasks.
RAR

by jewels_by_jade

I too have used HP for years. They're always reliable and seldom have problems. I have two printers, a vintage HP LaserJet 4Plus that just "keeps on ticking" and a newer (relative) HP LaserJet R80xi printer/scanner/copier/fax. I luv my all-in-one. The only gripe is printer cartridge cost. But I think that all the printing companies get you when you are sucked into one of their incredible printer deals and then find out what the cartridges will cost. It's a money maker... buy stock!

by Former member

I purchased a HP officejet V40. I had no problems until now.I uninstalled my printer because of errors, reinstalled then I got an error which told me that the application Java Virtual Machine was unable to start because the class was not registered. I am still not resolved on this matter, i tried officejet support but no help there. Do you have any suggestions?

by phuveldt

that ever inkjet printer you buy, make sure that you look at
the amount of ink in the cartridges and the cost... You'll be
surprised at that it will cost you over time.. And the more
you print the higher the cost in ink.........

by phuveldt

that ever inkjet printer you buy, make sure that you look at
the amount of ink in the cartridges and the cost... You'll be
surprised at that it will cost you over time.. And the more
you print the higher the cost in ink.........

by waylon.karr

If you are looking for pricing have questions on any type of MFP or wide format please contact

Waylon Karr

Oc? Canada
Corporate Printing Division

Tel: (905)564-0195 Ex232
Fax: (905)564-0155
1625 Courtney Park Dr.E.
Mississauga,Ontario L5T 1V9
Email: waylon.karr@imagistics.com
Remote Email: waylon@rogers.blackberry.net

by waylon.karr

I am wondering what your volume is? If you are doing a small amoun then i think the hp is a great product but your overall cost in cartridges is what makes it expensive. The cartridges are based on 5% coverage on the page. There is not a document out there with 5% black on it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.