Question Locked

Processors' Influence on performance

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Just a general question - perhaps it should be a discussion?

It has been said and agreed by many, that to increase the speed of a computer, the best and cheapest route is to expand the RAM.

OK, but I should like to know the impact on performance of increasing processor speeds and the "L1 and L2 caches", whatever they might be, and the "bus speed" (whatever that is).

Since the likes of Intel and AMD have been ploughing ahead with ever-faster processors for years, I imagine that there must be something in it.

Despite my undemanding computer usage I cannot help but admit that I am speed-obsessed - a speed-freak!

Paul

9 replies

by robo_dev

RAM:
More RAM does not make anything faster, but insufficient RAM will slow you down. Just like more gasoline won't make your car faster, but too little can have an adverse effect...

The issue is that RAM access is much faster than disk access so cached data will appear faster with more RAM (versus the sloooww process of retrieving data from disk).

Also, large programs or data files will need to be swapped to disk if insufficient RAM is available...this hurts performance considerably.

Processor and Bus Speeds:
Just like the horsepower and torque of an engine makes a car go faster, higher processor speeds and bus speeds mean a faster
computer.

CPU Cache:
These L1/L2 Caches are simply very fast RAM that's part of the processor...instead of having the processor access main RAM memory to get commonly used instructions, it uses it's very fast cache to get those instructions. L1 cache is ultra-fast and is part of the processor, L2 cache is on the motherboard.

Overall, with respect to getting the most performance, it's all about figuring out what the bottleneck is, based on what applications you are running.

Some graphics applications, for example, may not need the fastest processor on the planet, but may need the best video card you can buy.

Similarly a computer that's a Web server needs lots of RAM, lots of Bus speed and throughput on the disk and network subsystem, but it does not need any special video hardware, and the processing speed of the box is not super critical, for many common web applications.

by var1016

Thanks so much for that excellent summary, much appreciated.

Can I overstay my welcome and ask a "supplementary?" Your mention of graphics prompted this.

My computer contains the following (described under "video graphics":

GeForce 8400GS

* 256 MB DDR memory
* I/O Ports: HDMI, dual-link DVI , S-video

However, on another page (motherboard), also under "video graphics" I get:

* Integrated graphics using nVidia GeForce 6150SE
* Uses up to 256MB of PC memory (with 512MB or more total PC memory)
* Also supports PCI Express x16 graphics cards*

Finally under expansion slots, I have:

* Two PCI
* One PCI Express x16 graphics (for a graphics card)
* One PCI Express x1 (for cards such as network, sound, tv-tuner)

Now why would a need a "graphics card" as it already appears I have two parts "doing" graphics"!

Apologies in advance if I am taking liberties, but I am keen to know more.

Thanks

Paul

by robo_dev

Partly because you have to borrow RAM from the system and give it to the integrated video adapter.

Thus if you have 1GB of ram installed, and you want to have a 256MB video card, you now only have 768MB of RAM to use for the system.

Most dedicated video cards have significantly faster processors than integrated video on the motherboard. Think of the onboard video like having a 2.0L 4 cylinder versus a good dedicated video card having a 6.0L V8.

Also, most integrated graphics adapters don't usually support a digital interface (DVI) or support multiple monitors.

by jamesrl

It appears from the description that he has a PCIexpress video card -the 8400 GS. His onboard video - 6150, is markedly inferior.

But the 8400 has a couple of features that might come into play.
1) Turbo Cache - thats when the Video card borrows system RAM for better performance, as needed.
2)GeForce Boost - when you have a Gefore boost card in a system that also has a nVidia GeForce on board GPU, it can access the onboard GPU to offload some processing, giving it a little better performance.

Personally I hate Turbocache, on other older cards I've had with it, it does eat up RAM, but since the system RAM has to travel through the PCIexpress bus, it isn't as fast as the RAM on the graphics card.

So in this case, I think using more RAM may help your performance.

I play a game that is a performance pig. It can run with 512MB of RAM but really wants 1.5 GB of RAM, Stranegly enough the amount of RAM on the video card doesn't make that much of a difference (256 versus 512) until you play in higher resolutions like 1600x1200.

So if GeForce boost is on, and Turbocache is on(for 2 cards no doubt), your system wants a lot of RAM. You could see some improvements there.

But on the other hand a better card like an 8800 GT or 9600 GT would give you a better boost for graphics than adding RAM.

James

James

by var1016

Thanks Robo and James for more excellent solid information.

James, are 8800 GT or 9600 GT NVidia products? And if I had one would it plug straight into the spare PCI slots I am supposed to have?

Thanks,

Paul

by dumphrey

and they would replace the current video card you have installed.

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/category/category_slc.asp?Lprice=200&Hprice=499.99&Nav=|c:1826|&Sort=0&Recs=10
Several different cards here.

As a general rule, SLI is not always better.

2 Nvidia 8600's in sli usually gave less performance then a single 8800 (and cost 200 more when they all came out.) As a general rule, if you are a gamer, buy the best video card you can afford and run it for a few years. It may be better to by a single high end card, and add another of the same down the road in SLI then to buy to mid cards in sli right away. (SLI cards have to be same make/model to work.)
Toms hardware has a ton of info on video cards. Its also worth googleing to see what games are processor based and which are video card based. In some games, increasing just the vid card will not result in a huge performance gain when compare to upgrading the processor.

Also, clock speed is not everything in processor performance. You also have to look at the speed of the instruction sets. A smaller die size will have shorter buses internally, and will have newer faster instructions. A general rule is newer generations are faster, many times even if clocked lower. That being said, a 3Ghz core 2 duo is affordable these days, as is a 2.4 Ghz core 2 Quad (many of which can be easily overclocked to 2.8 or 3 and be stable).
Also, cache is very important to a cpu. A celeron was a Pentium with significantly less cache (256k instead of 1 meg say), and it was very obvious in the performance.

Figure out what you want to spend, what will work in your motherboard, and then get the highest clock speed, in the latest chip, with the most cache that you are willing to pay for (I will spend $300 on a processor, but $450-1k is out of the question).

These two sites are well worth an hour or so of reading.
http://www.tomshardware.com/
http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/

by var1016

For another brilliant and thorough reply. I shall certainly look at the sites you suggest.

HP tells me that the "best processor" that my motherboard can support is the AMD AThlon 64 x2 5600. It has a "2MB L2 cache". Despite the fact I have absolutely no need for this processor, I have ordered one anyway! With increased RAM about to be installed (total 3GB) I hope that everything will be jolly quick. As I get older I seem to be becoming more impatient!

Now to look at those graphics cards (note: I have zero interest in games!)

Best wishes

Paul

by var1016

Having a look at the following link:
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/126986
and telling me if you think that installing this card (I can afford it!) would improve my computing experience?!

I should explain that games have no interest at all for me, but I do a fair amount of photo editing (Paintshop Pro X2).

Thanks again.

Paul

This discussion is closed to new replies.