23 replies
by dafe2
This is a fairly common event when using lower quality CD's. Different, more permanent Dyes are used in high end CD's. Usually, the silver color of a CD is a visual indication of quality.
If your using high end media try cleaning the lens.
by apotheon
It's probably a combination of lower quality CDs and lower quality optical drive. Lately, we're getting to a point where even the cheap drives will read all audio CDs, but for a long time they didn't. They'd be made so that all they had to read reliably were data CDs, because that was the primary use for them. That has changed, now.
Reading an audio CD requires a lot more attention to detail on the part of the optical drive, because a close approximation of analog-quality sound has to be saved in a digital format. If any of that is not perfectly clear, an optical drive of low enough quality will find itself getting lost as it tries to read. Keep in mind that when dealing with a data CD, you have to skip around a lot more, and when dealing with an audio CD stuff is read in order pretty much all the time from beginning to end. As such, audio CD players and CD-ROM drives are sorta "optimized" for different tasks. One is better at staying on a steady course, and the other is better at minimizing seek times.
by dafe2
Thanks for taking up the slack.
DAFE2
by willcomp
It's possible that you have some copy protected CDs that are incompatible with you CD ROM drive. See link below for more info.
http://www.disctronics.co.uk/technology/cdaudio/cdaud_copyprot.htm
Copy protection aside, the more common complaint is that audio CDs produced in a CD-RW drive will not play in audio CD players.
Dalton
by apotheon
It was not always the case that CD-RWs were more often incompatible with audio CD players. Initially (especially before writable optical media was popular and affordable), it was a common occurrence for audio CDs to not play worth a darn in CDROM drives. Considering my understanding of the OP's issue, that sounds more likely.
Another possible problem that has occurred to me is this: the CD may simply be delaminating. If that's the case, it will not be so long before it's pretty much unplayable in anything.
by dafe2
Based on research I recently did for archive quality media & storage I found that Dye Quality is the key. Also, delaminating, more commonly known as CD Rot comes mainly from improper storage & handling. An important observation in this case.
Specifically the CD Dye qualities:
Phthalocyanine (The Best)
CD-Rs manufactured using the organic dye Phthalocyanine enjoy a better reflectivity than other dyes, since the golden color of Phthalocyanine is more transparent. These CD-Rs are available with a gold or silver reflective layer and have an excellent reflectivity. Thus, they are compatible with all commercially available CD recorders and readers.
Cyanine (Lower quality)
Those CD-Rs are green, and include an organic dye based on Cyanine.
Their quality is variable, and they have a shorter lifespan than CD-Rs using Phthalocyanine-based dye. Light reflection is lower, given the color of the dye, and the burning is less accurate.
by willcomp
Cds in question play in CD player but not PC CD drive. Problem is NOT delamination. If such was the case, wouldn't play properly in any drive.
Mention of CD-RW DRIVES was to emphasize that more common problem is burned copies (CD-Rs) that will not play in CD players. Media has an effect, but most critical parameter is burn speed. Needs to be less than 12x.
Delamination is definitely a problem. Am experiencing with some older CD-RW discs. They are iMation and Fuji which are both "high quality" manufacturers.
Have been using CD drives since 1x SCSI drives and have yet to see a non copy protected audio CD in good condition that will not play in a good quality, properly operating CD-ROM, CD-R, CD-RW, DVD-ROM, or DVD-RW drive.
Dalton
by house
I agree with you on that one. Copy protection techniques are used to hamper the ability to read a disk on the PC. I have not had much experience with audio cd protections, but I have seen it myself at home. Some of these protection methods are stretching the limits regarding the rights of the owner to backup his/her music, as well as the ability to even play them using their pc.
Of all the protection methods, my arch-enemy appeared on the gaming front a couple of years ago. [i]Safedisk 2.9[/i] - mother@#%$. There is a trigger within the first few sectors that redirects the autoplay to another location, usually somewhere between 10,000 to 20,000. The first 10,000 or so are full of bad sectors that are ignored by using this trigger. If you ever wanted to "backup" this data with a cheap non-two-sheep burner/reader, the image creation will destroy the motor inside your cd writer. Everytime it reads a bad sector, it'll stop, causing a vroooom, vroooom, vroooom, vroooom kind of activity during the first few minutes. There was quite a fuss over this one, but let's be honest, who is interested in backing up their cd for personal use? The audio cd argument, I can understand, but software is a fair game. If I buy music, I would like the ability to make a copy so that the original is not damaged in the car.
by dafe2
Unless something's changed recently, AUDIO CD copy protection was (Far as I know) only implemented in Europe.
Phillips & Sony tried to do this in 2001. EMI, Virgin Records & other distributors backed down due to (Audio) quality concerns.
There was some more talk with regards to doing something with the TOC a while back.
Do you know if they snuck that through?
Ok, yes it's been 'awhile' since i've actually bought a CD. :-) so forgive me if I sound like I've been in a cave for a few years.
by apotheon
by apotheon
Please forgive me a moment of utter pedantry:
Actually, "delamination" and "CD rot" refer to two slightly different, but very closely related, phenomena. They are pretty much interchangeable in conversation most of the time, because one leads to the other and the end result is an unreadable CD.
Delamination is where the layers of the CD begin to separate. This is more common with CD-Rs and CD-RWs than with pre-pressed CDs. The process used to write to the CD is different, depending on which process is used: in one case, they are commonly referred to as "cut", and in the other they are "burned". Even most CDs you get in the store these days are "burned", though, despite the lower cost, because it is so much cheaper to produce them in that fashion.
In any case, CD rot is what happens after delamination begins. Because the record(ing/ed) surface is exposed to air, it begins to oxidize (corrode, similar to rust). When that happens, pinholes can begin to appear in the recording surface, and the disk becomes basically unreadable, and any data thus lost is now unrecoverable (unlike simple surface scratches in the plastic, which can sometimes be temporarily "fixed" with a little floor wax).
Ultimately, though, you're right: The problem is delamination leading to CD rot. The actual problem, to be most precise, is the CD rot, and that's the term most commonly used in reference to the breakdown of recordable optical media.
There ya go. Pedantry done.
by dafe2
Nice job.
I thought they where still cutting/pressing commercial CD's though..........
Frightening thought - Commercial Burning to save very LITTLE $$$. From what I understood, delaminating, leading to CD Rot, is quite common with cheap burned CD's. It's not easily noticed, at least till the contents of the CD or DVD are in the toilet.
It can & will affect cut/pressed CD's and DVD's if the Polly coating is not applied correctly or of poor quality. It's RARE.
It can happen when these same cut/pressed CD's and DVD?s are poorly cared for or used as coasters. In some offices, they where also used to implement the wireless network......AKA the Frisbee.
whodda thunk it?
by apotheon
Audio CDs are not commonly burned, though some labels are producing high-quality burned CDs. Software vendors, on the other hand, are almost universally using burned CDs only. Companies like Mirosoft, though, do tend to use far higher-quality burned CDs than you can get at your local Best Buy, and they use professional burning equipment that is far better than your Sony (or whatever) CD-RW drive.
The consultancy I work for is actually a VAR for the company that makes the best professional quality CD and DVD burning and "labeling" (it uses dyes, not labels, on CDs and DVDs designed to take the dyes directly rather than with a cheap label that will just peel off) equipment on the market. The last time I was at a LUG meeting, I passed out some free MEPIS CDs, and was pleasantly surprised to note that a couple of the guys there actually recognized that the CD production was exceedingly high quality just by looking at them.
In any case, burned CDs have, at the high end, advanced quite a bit, and are very cheap. They (thankfully) haven't caught on as much in commercial audio as they have in commercial software, but give it time, and they probably will.
by dafe2
by dafe2
**This assumes use of North American PRODUCED audio CD's***
Question:
I thought AUDIO copy protection went out the window. Are you saying that new Audio CD's are now copy protected?
I know it's been implemented on DVD (Region). The only thing "new" in Audio (That I'm aware of)is SACD? There was no mention of copy protection in that case either.
SACD could be unreadable on SOME older CD ROM's, which, come to think of it fits the symptoms as well.
Just a question. I've never heard of this being implemented, I'm a die hard audiophile and it surprises me that no "audiophile trade rag" has ever mentioned it.
I could have missed it, so what's up?
by apotheon
"Have been using CD drives since 1x SCSI drives and have yet to see a non copy protected audio CD in good condition that will not play in a good quality, properly operating CD-ROM, CD-R, CD-RW, DVD-ROM, or DVD-RW drive."
You're lucky, if that's the case. I've run across two or three drives, back in the day, that had problems with some (even brand new, straight out of the wrapping) audio CDs.
by dafe2
by willcomp
You are assuming that questioner is located in North America, doesn't purchase CDs manufactured overseas, and that US manufacturers have not implemented copy protection (which they have at least in a few well known instances).
Since this is a global community, we cannot assume anyone's whereabouts unless they post it in peer directory listing.
We also don't know origin of CDs.
CDs are exhibiting sysmptoms of copy protection schemes. Check my original post for a link.
Granted, other factors cannot be ruled out and problem could be drive and not media.
A thought: have any of us recommended trying CDs in another CD-RW drive to see what happens? Feel rather foolish right now myself. Should have been first recommendation.
Dalton
by house
Yeah, I forgot to recommend trying another PC too. Sometimes these simple troubleshooting tips escape you when you are used to dealing with the issues that arise within a certain topic.
I know for a fact that there have been copy protections released here in North America that will hamper the ability to play the music usig a PC. ie: Velvet Revolver, Jane's Addiction, Nora Jones, etc. These artists (just to name a few) have had their latest albums protected. The most controversial protection method is not yet flying around NA, but some of the older methods still cause problems too.
I won't recommend (via url) any of my regular sites regarding the various protection methods, because you will be showered with spyware. CdMediaWorld, GameCopyWorld, CdFreaks. Here you will find the various methods, what they do, and how to bypass the issues that arise.
by dafe2
Thanks, I did check the link but it was referring Europe...and as you say, my mind was in North America...
So, I'm still curious as to copy protection here.
Guess I have a hate on for copy protection. At least in the Audio World.
by apotheon
by dennis.rhine
by dennis.rhine
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Desktop posts
Sort by Trending