Question Locked

Speed Issue - Netgear wireless router + Comcast Cable Modem

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi - I am not a technical person so please help me explain my situation better (if not already done so) and also would appreciate some layman terms when explaining.

I have a Comcast Cable modem at home. When the technician connected, he used my laptop to connect and showed that the speed is above 400kbps for downloads. My friend came and connected the Netgear WGT624v3 wireless router to the comcast modem and got the internet connectivity working but now the speed is less than half even when connected via a wired connection.

Is this common? If not how should I diagonise this issue? I have reconnected back via the modem to check and it again shows high download speeds.

Is there a wireless router that I can plug to the comcast cable modem and expect the same speed as the modem when connected directly?

Appreciate you assistance.

- SP

3 replies

by oh smeg

There are several different types starting at 411 A and going through to the G System the oldest A is also the slowest. While you can use a G Type Router if you only have a A Type Adapter in the computer the speed will not be improved.

As for overall speed wired will always be a faster option no matter what you have as the fastest Transfer speed over WiFi is 54 MBS and the current slowest with the current generation of Wired LAN's is 100 MBS which can go up to 1000 MPS.

So at best Wireless is half the speed of a wired connection and at worst it is considerably slower. So without knowing exactly what you have the WiFi Speed sounds fairly right.

Col

by nepenthe0

When your mouse hovers over the 'local area connection' applet in the system tray, and you see '100 Mbps' (or whatever), the value that appears in the 'tool tip' is a fantasy of what a hard-wired Broadband service might provide under laboratory conditions.

For a sobering wake-up, check out the following web site:

https://www.grc.com/x/ne.dll?bh0bkyd2

Take the online Broadband speed test. Typical 'download' speeds for Comcast Broadband are 4 Mbps; typical upload speeds are half that.

The Netgear router is probably capable of multi-mode broadcasting. The IEEE 802.11b protocol is optimally rated at 11 Mpbs; the 802.11g protocol at 54 Mpbs; the 802.11n protocol at 110 Mbps. However, few networks can get practical transfer speeds higher than the 'g' protocol due to bottlenecks elsewhere in the system.

Bottom line: the 'g' protocol affords fast downloads, and I am hard pressed to tell the difference between wireless 'g' and hard wired Comcast Broadband.

I once had a Netgear cable modem that burned up, and I got zero support from Netgear. So I wish you good luck on your Netgear router. If it croaks, consider Linksys when you replace it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.