Question Locked

TechRepublic is one of the useless site, how many of you agree?

0 helpful
46 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I posed a technical question on 3/01/08. But no one has replied either through the forum or sent a mail to my e-mail. Where as it is claimed that most of the talented members will reply to the questions asked. That's how I came to this conclusion. How many of you agree?.

46 replies

by tig2

I fail to see how you posted a question two months in the future. We haven't GOTTEN to 3/01/08 yet.

I have no idea if I saw your question or not. But I will remind you that anyone here who answers a question is taking their own time to do so. This is a volunteer effort and there is no guarantee.

A lot depends on the time of day that you post. If there is a lot of activity on the site, your question may well fall off the front page before it is seen by a person with expertise in your problem area.

If you post a question and you see that it has fallen off the front page, simply edit your question, add the line "Edit to bump" to the bottom and try again. And you may need to do that several times.

Most folks won't send you a peer message unless they know you. The reason is that their email address will be revealed to you. Most prefer to post their responses to the board unless you both agree to take a discussion off line.

Sorry you had a bad experience. Try again.

by cmiller5400

The format of the date is DD/MM/YYYY. There are only a few countries that use the format we do MM/DD/YYYY (I had to look it up to see how few do use it! I was surprised!). The rest of the world uses the DD/MM/YYYY format. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calendar_date

by kjell_andorsen

Look, this is a community forum, none of the members here are paid or receive any kind of compensation for helping others. Most of us reply to questions because we like helping other people out and sharing our knowledge.

That being said, there are questions that go unanswered. Sometimes questions just get buried under a flood of new posts, sometimes the question is obscure or poorly worded. Sometimes the people who may know the answer just overlook it. It happens.

RIght now you're coming off as whiny and frankly pretty rude. If your question hasn't been answered yet, try bumping it to the top by replying to it. This might give people a chance too look it over again and you might get an answer.

Coming in here and insulting the members of the forum by calling the forum worthless is at best just going to generate ill-will towards you.

by bart777

Some things you need to keep in mind;
Is the question worded in a fashion that is easy to respond to?
Is there anyone online at the time who can respond to it?
Did anyone see the question or did it get pushed down the list due to high volume of questions at the time?

I've used this site many times to ask for additional help over the years and had good luck. There have been times when I've stumped everyone here but the problem even stumped Microsoft so I didn't feel bad about it.

Don't just give up. Maybe you just stumped us all.

by the maverick phantom wanderer (formerly macoza, nodice, kp, etc.)

"I've used this site many times to ask for additional help over the years and had good luck. There have been times when I've stumped everyone here but the problem even stumped Microsoft so I didn't feel bad about it."

Stumping Microsoft isn't an accomplishment- it's inevitable.

by bizzo

If anyone should get uppity, I should.

I posted a question yesterday, and bumped it because it fell off the bottom, and no-one has answered it.

I even posted one on 04/04/2007, and alas, no reply :(

Maybe I should agree with him? ;\
And get mad at all you slackers!!! X-(

by maniacman

We have yet to reach March of 2008, so you'll have to wait for the rest of us without time machines to actually see your question materialize. :^0

by bart777

Day/Month/Year

Many countries use this format.

by kjell_andorsen

In his defense, most countries outside the US, including India post dates in DD/MM/YYYY format.

The US as usual just has to be different than the rest of the world in that respect ;)

by maniacman

I know about the date format and I was making yet another joke. Sheeeeesh!

by bart777

Thought you were just in a bad mood and forgot.

Glad to see you ahve a sense of humor.

Have a great day.

by maniacman

I made a joke not long ago on the thread about how to stop overseas hackers and got accused of being a racist and bigot by DanLM because I gave a firewall a human personal and said that the firewalls will be calling one another bigots because they refuse to communicate with other firewalls from certain countries. I think it was funny giving a human persona and character to a firewall, but somehow DanLM took it out of context and accused me of calling him a bigot. People, read the jokes for what they are and note the emoticons. Arrrghghhh..I give up!

by bart777

Some of us just don't have the same sense of humor.

Keep the zingers coming.

by beth blakely

sloppy, I would ensure that my shirt was neatly tucked in, my hair was combed and my face was shiny and clean. I would combat the reputation and over time it might fade. You seem bound and determined to provide further evidence of your alleged bigotry.

Your reputation has been firmly established, whether or not you believe it's true or warranted. Stay out of discussions regarding race/nationality/H1B/offshoring, etc. and you won't have this problem.

My patience is wearing thin.

by kjell_andorsen

One of the nasty side-effects of having worked so long in IT is that I've gotten really bad at detecting when people are just feigning ignorance. There just to be a time when I'd go "Wow, there's no way he can be that ignorant, he must be pulling my leg", but then after dealing with end-user after end-user after end-user my default response has morphed into "Gods, he really doesn't know this, I guess I should be nice and explain".

I should have known better in Maniac's case since in all fairness he has demonstrated an intelligence and knowledge level well above average ;)

Sorry dude

by maniacman

I always take the opportunity to make a joke when I can, but it takes a keen sense to detect the humor in it sometimes. Yes, I can be sarcastic in my humor at times, but if you really analyze it, you'll see the humor and sometimes irony in the jokes. I'm a bit enigmatic that way.

by maniacman

Otherwise, it gets too stagnant and boring in a corporate tightwad kind of way if we can't laugh and poke fun at ourselves once in a while.

by maniacman

Post a silly question about password cracking and watch how quickly everyone jumps on it and flames you. You'll certainly get attention, but not the kind you're looking for. :^0

by bizzo

Just going to get the standard password template thing telling everyone not to reply. Not much of a flame thing that is it. Maybe I could talk about offshoring? ;)

by maniacman

because my contract expired. That will be one hell of a royal rumble discussion with a lot of people getting vocal and barking at one another like rabid dogs because they'll be on opposite sides of this debate. If you think political mudslinging is bad enough, discussing offshoring here will get ugly very fast. I'll simply abstain from any such involvement here.

by thechas

I find Tech Republic to be a very good and useful site.

Keep in mind that all of the answers posted to technical questions are posted by other members of the site. Not the staff of TR.

I do not recall seeing your question. It is possible I was too busy that evening to log on to TR, or that enough questions came in that day that your question was off the bottom of the list when I did log on.

Also, most of the members active members here are IT professionals and not developers.

It would have helped if you had included a link to your question in todays rant.

Looking through your profile and at your question, I can understand why no answers were posted.

First, the task of video rendering is pretty specialized and beyond what most of us work with. No answer is better than a wrong answer.

Second, we have been getting a lot of questions posted from people in India that read like people trying to have us perform their class work or even their job for them. Often, when I see a peer location as any of the countries from India to the Pacific Ocean, I am apt to skip the question.

Your question is one I might have at least thought about if I had seen it.

My best advice to you would be to post your questions either late or very early in your normal day to increase the number of TR peers who will see it.

Chas

by jiminpa

It is all about timing sometimes and the difficulty of the question and who happens to be logged on. There are alot of questions posted here and sometimes your question will rapidly move down the list. Sometimes you have to "bump" your question. I wouldn't go so far as to call it useless or it would have fizzled long ago.

by maniacman

Show me where I made a racist/bigot/nationality/etc/etc remark here, other than to poke fun at the different date format used? So I made a joke about time machines and such...big deal. Who did I offend specifically? I beg to hear the reasoning behind your assumption of my "reputation".

On another note, why are you dictating to me which discussions I should stay out of? As long as I remain civil and not offend anyone (DanLM overreacted and the issue is now closed), which I don't seem to have done, what is the problem in this as long as I am not violating the terms of service?

If anyone is being discriminated against, I feel that it's me and it is unwarranted.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I think that:
1) March 1st isn't here yet. On what planet do you live?
2) If you in fact mean January 3rd, you might consider that given the holidays and the beginning of many fiscal years, many of the 'ubertechs' that answer questions are hugely busy and don't have time to get out here at the moment.
3) Sometimes posts disappear quickly enough that they are not seen before they drop off the radar. In that case, return to your original post and 'bump' it back into the lineup by adding another post to it.
4) I have never found TR to be useless. Over the course of the years that I have been a member here, whether simply lurking or participating, I have learned more than I can easily bring to mind at any one moment. If not for this site and the friendliness, acceptance, and willingness of the members here to try to help any and all, my PC's would still be running my life. Instead, I control my PC's thanks in very large part to the good people at TR.
5) Patience is a virtue. Your mommy likely preached that - or some variant thereof - to you all your life for a good reason.

edit the usual dang typo

by maniacman

Our collective flaming of the OP for such an asinine statement got our point across quickly.

I think TR needs to do a better job on its home page of stating that this is a site consisting of volunteers and not paid employees who are not obligated to provide anything.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

caught on to the apology after posting.

This freaking slow-a** dialup is killing me. I will be VERY (eny) happy to be home and back to the broadband soon!

Sorry, OP. I love this place!

by thumbsup2

so we can see when you're grinning while making one of your "jokes"! ;)

by beth blakely

You came to this site under SEVERAL different aliases, which I can prove. You said horrible things about Indian people, posed as people from India and then ranted at them, made the site a mess for a couple of weeks all before you became "Maniac Man."

Some members may not realize that you are Why Me Worry, Big Ole Jack, to name just a couple of your previous identities.

You are on my list and will continue to be. And when, if I finally lose my patience with you, and I'm thisclose, I will boot you.

Got it?

by jdclyde

So you didn't get your free answer. If you want a rapid response to your tech questions, pay for support somewhere.

What have you done to contribute? Nothing.

by maniacman

Dan and I have settled the slight misunderstanding and if you haven't noticed, I am not using racial or prejudiced terms against anyone. I'm playing nice and intend on showing you that I am not the person you think I am, regardless of past incidents. Let bygones be bygones and live in the present, not the past.

by beth blakely

Keep my name out of your mouth and your posts. Exercise extreme caution when posting. I am done talking to you. Next time that *I* judge a post to be offensive or even anywhere NEAR the line, you're out.

You've been warned time and again. I'm done with you.

Got a problem with that? I'll give you the direct email addresses of my superiors and you can take it up with them. Be forewarned, however, that they're well aware of who and what you are.

by bcrawford2769

I have found everything about TechRepublic to be excellent. In the time I have been frequenting this site, I have learned more than I ever thought possible in such a short time, and I also have developed an excellent, broad-based library of resources that myself and others in my company find very useful.

Now, if you're just here to talk and expect someone to be sitting around waiting for you to ask a question so they can jump on it in .5 seconds, well, you'll probably be disappointed. Go find a BB where people sit around and complain - I guarantee someone there is waiting for your post so they can jump on it!!

Or, take some initiative and look around and find whatever it is you need. I would bet good money that it is not only here, but that it also is explained thoroughly, well, and in an easy-to-understand format.

-One VERY satisfied TR and TR Pro user

by david.wallis

Its a good site for basic - average difficulty questions..

but if you ask something complex your best googling it :)

by david.wallis

you should also have your current skill level on your profile such as MCSE, CCNA etc so people know whether to listen to your advice and know if your qualified or just another numpty

by thumbsup2

Lack of certifications showing doesn't mean they don't know what they're talking about. It just means they haven't found a need to GET certified or, if they are certified, wish to show that information. Conversely, having a certification doesn't mean they know what they're talking about or that they can explain it in terms the OP would understand. The ability to communicate is far more important in a site of this nature.

If you find TR to be below your standards, then don't use it. Nobody is forcing you to be here.

Besides that, some of us even know proper English grammar. Your use of the word "your" (possessive) instead of the word "you're" (short for [b]you are[/b]) in [b]your[/b] two posts above, demonstrates to me that you do not. Being from the United Kingdom where the English language supposedly originated, I would think that you should know that. ;)

by david.wallis

I wasn't complaing about your site, I was merely stating my opinion which I am entitled to do. I hope my grammar is up to your high standards. Being from the United Kingdom and all, one should know how to speak and type correctly :)

by bizzo

Did you notice that the guy apologised?

by david.wallis

no sorry i didnt see that, was a few too many there for me to read :)

shall we consider the hatchet buried? :)

This discussion is closed to new replies.