Discussion Locked

The new face of GM, reality or just another mask?

0 helpful
246 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

GM has been hitting the media hard with some really brazen marketing campaigns that they are not going out of business but 8 brands was just too much, that they are rebuilding and recreating a 'smarter GM' for tomorrow, yada-yada, gee haven't we heard all their promotional lies before?

"Reinventing the automobile and our company" ??

"General Motors expanded its significant battery research and development capabilities today by opening the largest and most technologically advanced battery lab [b]in the United States[/b] on its Technical Center campus in Warren, Michigan. "

Since when has the US been known for battery technology at all? Would it take a facility more advanced than a 7-11 store to actually be "the largest and most technologically advanced in the United States"? Not a shot at the US but seriously, since when was battery technology a strength of US manufacturing?

How about Germany, Japan, Canada? THEY all have massive battery technology development plants. Plants such as Ballard, Better Place are massive and have been developing the most advanced battery technology is MASSIVE plants, often in several countries at once.

"GM has the most models with 30mpg EPA HWY fuel economy" ...based on 2009m "estimates"
(Of course that includes Saturn, Chevy and Pontiac brands combined).

"Best warranty in America"
While they have a LIMITED 100,000km/5yr warranty, the actual base warranty (which is not even close to being comparable to competitors) is 36,000km/3yrs. FAR below the standard others offer.

It just goes on and on, more garbage from America's worst vehicle manufacturer to date.

In the 80's we saw similar horrors from US manufacturers, GM and Chrysler. We were promised improvement through the 90's. After Chrysler BARELY keept their heads above water through the 80's, due to Iacoca's decision to make K-Cars and Lebarons, Horizon's and Luxury Dynasty's from identical parts (just with a bigger tag for their 'luxury cars') they managed to stay out of bankruptcy and continue into the 90's.

In the 90's all the 3-5 year econo-boxes that were sold by them in the 80's fell apart, including thei rluxury models that sold at nearly twice teh price but also used the same parts as econo-boxes.

Instead of improving vehicle quality, manufacturing quality and safety, as they had previously PROMISED the public, Chrylser went on a marketing campaign with cab forward designs of the Mitsubishi built Intrepid and the clone bodies that again used the same parts, whether an entry level model or top of the line.

GM stayed alive because of Buick and Cadillac products living on former merits which were selling well in the orient also.

But seriously, they are trying to show they are a good car manufacturer in TODAY'S competitive industry, while their past shows us just how well they have competed against the same companies in the past.

Onmi, Horizon, Firefly, need I say more? US manufacturer's have failed the public and failed themselves time and time again.

Sure people have built lemons like that before, Ford had the Pinto, Hyundai had the Pony, but they BOTH came back to build some of the best in class. Hyundai's Genesis has been voted car of the year by countless mags, industry shows, pros etc. It's a Lexus at sub-Honda pricing. Ford now makes some of the most advanced and evolved compacts on the market, while STILL deominating the truck segment, as they always have, they were unstoppable in he midsize market with the Taurua, while GM was playing with mid sized pigs and Chrysler pushed cab forward marketing games in the 90's too.

NOW, we are supposed to believe that this has all changed, GM's failure to live up to promises or compete in the last 3 decades is to be forgotten, they are now new and improved. But all I hear are empty promises, judging by their restructuring promises, nothing is changing, it's all just more of the same, smoke and mirrors with no actual substance to support it.

GM should e left to simply perish, they are not Ford, they are definitely not anything capable of Japanese competition or European cars.

I always understood capitalism as survival of the fittest, while I despise the practices of companies like WalMart, I still must accept that they are a result of capitalism, mixed with some questionable/unlawful business practices, but they initially got strong due to fair merits and fair business.

Why is it that GM, can fail, be beaten by FAIR competition time and time again, show that they are simply unable to compete or keep up to a market and then still get bailed out?

I don't get it, it's almost like principles are on a sliding scale for some. One company is justifiably closed due to competition, another in a different marketplace is bailed out to help when fair competition wins their share of the market.

246 replies

by charliespencer

Is this about GM or Chrysler?

"After BARELY keeping their heads above water through teh 80's, due to Iacoca's decision to make K-Cars and Lebarons, Horizon's and Luxury Dynasty's from identical parts ... In the 90's all the 3-5 year econo boxes that were sold in the 80's fell apart, including their sister products from Chrysler's higher end. ... they went on a marketign campaing with cab forward designs of the Intrepid and the clone bodies ... They stayed alives because of Buick and Cadillac products living on former merits which were selling well in the orient also. ... Onmi, Horizon, Firefly, need I say more?"

You need to edit your post. By combining the names of multiple GM and Chrysler brands and products, it reads like you think Chrysler and GM are the same company.

"GM should e left to s]imply perish, they are not Ford, they are not Chevy, ..."

Actually, yes, they ARE Chevy.

I agree that GM should be allowed to fail if it cannot market a product that appeals to consumers, but your original post is all over the map.

by oz_media

Mistitled, I'll reword it, I was looking at an article form GM last night and was posting about eth GM/chrysler bailouts.

Back to teh drawing board, when I typed it it made sense, reading it doesn't.

by jdclyde

thanks to high union overhead and slow union mentality on the line, I am only surprised they lasted this long.

I have known many GM employees over the last few decades, and they are far from overworked. Something that all these changes will not address.

And because it all goes by seniority, it is the oldest and most set in their ways that will be left to man the lines.

I do not see them coming out of this tail spin.

And yes, and almost all of my cars have been either Chrysler or Chevy, with ONE mazda in the mix.

by oz_media

Robots increased quality in manufacturing.

In every other nation they have increased quality of the finished product and reduced overall costs.

Once again, it's not the union per se, but the stipulations of the UAW contracts. Either way, the resulting failure of these companies goes light years beyond the unions that they were built upon.

If unions were a key issue, GM could have closed their US doors and moved all operations to Japan, as many other companies do to sidle their union obligations.

They just thought they could do better and were invincible.

by oz_media

The American consumer saw the subcompacts of the late 70's and early 80's and laughed, gas was also cheaper than water.

By the time we hit the mid 80's consumers were starting to believe in subcompacts but nto Japanese pricing.
Why buy a Civic or Tercel when you could buy a full sized Buick with a V8 for the same money? Size and power means better, doesn't it?

By the time the Us manufacturers' jumpe don board, they had no choice but to copy the subcompact but do it for less money. Anyone interested in such cars wanted to pay less for them and were trained to think they SHOULD cost less because they were smaller.

The US manufacturer's made such a mess of the compact segment that it turned into an 'entry level' segment and thus was constantly a matter of price war.

Cheap price = cheap car.
Cheap car = no revenue
No revenue = building even cheaper cars
Continued low revenue = cheap mid sized cars and eventually full sized cars.

They just couldn't compete with a compact Japanese and European market that was built on providing high-quality engineering, excellent fit and finish, quality and craftsmanship at a premium price.

the result is pumping out cheap crap to try and stay alive while hoping your full sized market keeps you alive. It was a horrific business model.

Ford was saved in teh mid 80's, despite teh Pinto woes (which are NOTHING like most people think they were) the Explorer turned out to be the top selling vehicle bar none. Built on their Ranger truck platfom and tweaked with 3 finish groups (XLS, Eddie Bauer and LImited) they took off and help strong. Ford's truck reputation les them into the 90's and kept them alive, with the release of the Taurus, there was no looking back. (Bias? Yes I am a certified Ford tech, but that's besides the point, i don't work for Ford). Facts are facts and Ford simply left Chrysler and GM in the dust.

Today, there are FAR better Ford's available in Europe than in North America. The European market understands paying a premium for quality and engineering efficiency, thanks to Germany. The Japanese understand that mass manufacturing and speed does not have to mean sacrificing quality.

IN North America all we see is the bottom line, TOO MUCH MONEY FOR A 4 CYLINDER!!

They don't sell well here, they aren't built well here and they dont' do well here.

If GM was a European manufacturer, they jutsmight have had a chance. But as long as they just lie to consumers and produce garbage, he mighty buck will see their demise, and well it should.

Unions? Yes that's part of it, but a very small part, it is only that way due to a poor business model and lack of focus. Being 'unionized' isn't the issue, union contracts are an issue and the way they are aplied in the automotive workers union is a major issue. The manufacturer's focusedon capital gains, which is a proven success model for US corporations, but these are companies competing and failing in a global market, not just the US.

by jdclyde

then continuing to make full sized trucks is not the problem, despite the sniveling from the econuts.

Would it be nice to have more options? Of course.

Another problem is the over regulation by the US government that causes extra weight because they focus on survival of a crash instead of the European focus of AVOID the crash. The same reason we can not have a bullet train here in the US.

Get government the phuck out of the car business completely. That includes bailouts. If a company goes out of business, it will just serve to make the rest of them shape up.

"Ford. Built WITHOUT your money". B-)

by jamesrl

GM developed its battery technology through the production of the EV1. Yes they killed it because they learned what they needed to learn, and because it was cost prohibitive to try and sell the cars at what they cost to make, but they gained valuable insight into what it takes to run electric cars in the real world. That work means that GM with the Volt will be the first mainstream manufacturer (Tesla isn't mass market) to make an all electric car.

As for the worst manufacturer, what about Chrysler. I owned an Intrepid, and spent more in repairs than I did for the car, over 4 years of ownership. GM definately made better transmissions.

As for the current lineup, the Chevy Malibu/Saturn Aura, built from a Vauxhall Opel Platform is IMHO better than a Ford Fusion it competes against, and a worthy rival to a Camry/Accord. But I'm not alone, the automobile journalists association thought the same thing.

The new G8 sedan, with engineering by Holden is a great rear wheel drive performance sedan. Too bad its a Pontiac.

I'm not sure why you are mentioning K Cars, Horizon/Omni when talkinbg about GM, cause those were Chryslers of lesser quality than their rivals. The Firefly, which was a Suzuki which GM rebadged (made at a joint plant) was a good car, I drove alot in one, and it went to 350,000 kms with only a battery, tires and brake replacement.

I'm not saying that there aren't problems with GM. Its a slippery slope. Chrysler has its issues as well.

But one of the reasons for the bailout is that if GM goes down, so do a number of parts manufacturers etc. Many have said that if GM went down, they couldn't survive until new orders come on line from other manufacturers. So we could lose not only assembly but parts as well. Thats hundreds of thousands of jobs.

The Intrepid by the way was in no way built by Mitsubishi. It was built in Brampton about 2 miles from my house, in what had been an AMC plant before Chrysler bought them and Jeep. The engines, the 3.3 and 3.5 are all Chrysler designed.

Mitusbishi did build the Colt and 2000 GTX for Chrysler, and the Talon was a joint venture. Chrysler, Hyundai and Mitsubishi still co-operate on small motors, the 2.4 being a recent example (Calibre).

As for your truck sales comments, you do know that GM sells more light trucks (pickups) than Ford. Its just that Ford sells more than Chevy, but not more than Chevy and GMC combined. This is an age old debate and obviously by sales not everyone agrees with you.

While I'm not a fan of my tax dollars going to Chrysler, GM or any of the banks I understand that it was done to forestall the panic that would happen if they went under. I think GM can survive, it made great strides in reforming over the past few years, but it needed a big push before it could drop as many brands and focus itself.

James

by charliespencer

"But one of the reasons for the bailout is that if GM goes down, so do a number of parts manufacturers etc."

We've heard the phrase 'too big to fail' tossed around a lot lately. Is there such a concept as applied to investment banks and automobile manufacturers? If so, does the government have an obligation to break up such a company for the good of the economy BEFORE it fails?

All I know is that the US government dumped a lot of money into GM before it went into bankruptcy anyway. Wouldn't it have been better to keep the money and let it file Chapter 11 in the fall of 2008, instead of stalling the inevitable?

by jamesrl

Because they thought it was the only way to get GM to shed assets and focus on core business.

AIG was considered too big to fail because it was the insurer for so many financial institutions that if they went down, so would a number of banks.

In the fall of 2008, the government didn't have leverage to make GM do what was needed. It could not have forced them into bankruptcy at that point without changing the bankruptcy laws. It took that investment in them to give the feds the leverage they needed.

James

by jaqui

Sorry, but bad management / business decisions need to be paid for by the management / business.

bail out companies with bad management? no way.

yes, it would hurt, with the suppliers losing sales, but in the long run it will make a stronger economy, with better leadership in business.

by oz_media

Mitsubishi's MiEV is a fully electric car that should be availale to the comsumer through Mitsubishi dealers across canada in the next 4 years.

Canada is also slated to start full production runs in 5 years, as far as benchmarks go, Canada should be the first north American country to mass manufacture a fully electric car.
_________________________________
"what about Chrysler"

I mentioned Chrysler, in fact the Intrepid specifically, I couldn't agree more.

Cab forward sales pitch and forget about all your promises to the industry and consumers.

I know two people that bough Intrepids, after asking me and ignoring my advice of course. After about three years I refused to fix them anymore, just garbage products and too much hassel for what hit was worth.
____________________________________

Opel has been a GM product for over 80 years now, and has been a lackey's car in Europe ever since they bought it. Though it DID nearly edge out Ford in the late 90's and early 21st century but sales still didn't top Ford.

The key I think you need to consider is that these are EUROPEAN cars, which as I have mentione dcountless times, are built far better in Europe, as are the same Fords, than in North America. We just don't get their craftsmanship from our industry. That's why I bought my truck with a German built Ford V6 engine 'Cologne motor'.
___________________________________

P.S. The Malibu was 2nd to the Ford Fusion in most reports I've read. and it is built on GM's 112" Epsilon AWD platform. Former models, the previous versions with the 105" wheelbase were BASED on the Opel platform but did not offer the same steering and suspension system at all, just footprint dimensions. Those past models were lemons and failed miserably in the market though.

BC Auto Dealers Assn. ranks it poorly, US News auto ratings have it set behind th eFusion too. As far as Japanese, it is too expensive, gets poor fuel rating, the 4-cylinder is low powered ("gutless"), they are dropping the Hybrid for 2010 (which was a waste anyway) and it has a terrible resale value.

Its main merits are large interior size and .....large interior size ....and yeah that's all.

I was actually looking forward to that car after seeing the protos, but after driving one, nah, I'll stick with the Camry or Accord, 10X the car for less money and with FAR better resale.

___________________________________------

"I'm not sure why you are mentioning K Cars, Horizon/Omni when talkinbg about GM, cause those were Chryslers of lesser quality than their rivals. "

Probably why I mentioned they were Chrysler products. Though my initial post was a bit misleading, as pointed out and quickly edited this morning, long before your post showed up though.

_________________________________

"Many have said that if GM went down, they couldn't survive until new orders come on line from other manufacturers. So we could lose not only assembly but parts as well. Thats hundreds of thousands of jobs."

That's also cpaitalism, the business model that america and massive corporations like GM and Chrysler are built upon.

________________________________________

As for Mitsubishi,the Intrepid's and Concords initially used the 3.3L and 3.5L engines, which were complete garbage, up until around 1997/98, I think.

They then used Mitsubishi's 2.7L and transmission was indeed built by Mitsubishi (also used in the Concord and Sebring) and used a evised Kbody frame called an LH (jokingly the Last Hope for them), .

It was also one of the most useless and problematic motors Chrysler ever put into a car besides their 2.0L in the late 80's or their first shot at the Intrepid with the 3.3L.

Daimler Chrysler owns 34% controlling interest of Mitsubishi (as well as Hyundai which builds Chrysler badged cars in Mexico), they are all one and the same really.

As both Mitsubishi and Chrysler build mid-sized cars and mass market to a similar segment, they decided to simply 'share two models' and the rest are quite individual, same goes for Hyundai in the compact car segment.

A compact Chrysler badged car may have actually been built by Hyundai in Mexico, passed electrical quality assurance testing in the US and tagged with the "US Union built" sticker.

Plant location and badging means nothing these days.
______________________________________

by jamesrl

Car of the year, North American International Auto show - the Detroit show is the most important to the industry.

Kelly Blue Book Best Redesigned Vehicle

Car and Driver 10 Best cars of 2008 (not a single Ford on that list)

Automobile Magazine's All Star list for 2008 (not a Ford on the list unless you count the Volvo C30

Consumers Digest Best Buy

JD Power 2008 Highest Ranked Mid size car in initial quality
US News and World Report - #1 out of 23 mid size cars(for 2008, 2009 it was the Fusion Hybrid #1, Malibu #2, Fusion #3)

As for milegae, according to the Automotive magazine website, the Malibu gets slighty better mileage in the city than Accord or Camry, the same highway milegae as the Accord, and slightly worse highway mileage than the Camry.

Regarding Mitsubishi, Chrysler sold 90% of its Mitsubishi shares in 2005, they don't have much left at all.

NONE of the Intrepid engines were Mitsubishi, including the 2.7. You can find it in Wiki if you don't believe me. But hey what would I know, the plant where Intrepids/300/Charger etc were/are made is a couple of miles from my hosue and some of my neighbours work there. The 2.7 was designed and built by Chrysler in Kenosha.

And now you are going to get all huffy and accuse me of all kind of crap and being pedantic etc.

But the truth is facts matter.

When you try and show that GM is all crap and Ford can do no wrong, thats an opinion. When you back it up with facts that aren't true, you don't help your argument.

James

by oz_media

Light trucks, are but a small portion of the truck segment. I was referring to full sized trucks in my comments. Though the Explorer was built on the Ranger frame with IFS instead of the i-Bar used in their larger trucks.

"For a number of years, the 1/2 ton full-size Ford F150 has been the best-selling vehicle in the United States, [b]outselling all other trucks and all passenger car models."[/b]

"Ford F-Series tops its own all-time truck sales record with more than 912,000 units sold in a single year. During the past 25 years, F-Series has been the only nameplate to cross the 800,000 annual sales mark in the U.S.

28 Years and Counting: On Dec. 31, F-Series will extend its winning streak to 28 years as the best-selling truck in the U.S., along with [b]claiming the title of best-selling overall vehicle for 23 consecutive years.[/b]

TWENTY THREE YEARS!

Now technically ANY vehicle manufacturer can claim to be the #1 seller, as vehicle classes are so infinitely defined now.

Top selling small car of all time**
Where the ** details, 'with a centre mounted ashtry, a bump just left of the drivers console etc.'

But as far as sales, TRUCK sales and North American cars of all makes and models, Ford has outsold them all for decades.

Let them go teets up if they can't stay in business, providing good products at affordable prices, while competitors can.

Parts dealers will just start making aftermarket parts for the garbage they've sold for the last 30 years. Chrysler hasn't been worth a bag of spit since the days of Mopars, and GM hasn't been worth a bag of spit since....well, I'm not quite old enough to think that far back.

I didn't see Woolco get bailed out when they couldn't afford to compete with US WalMart.

Will WalMart get bailed out if Americans wake up one day and realize what a lot of garbage they sell?

These are car manufacturer's not small countries or governments, they build substandard products for North American consumers and build their best products on other continents.

Sure lets give them a helping hand, why not maybe they can improve on their European models and screw us some more, maybe they'll listen and start giving US the good stuff too! Don't hold your breath.

by jamesrl

In manufacturers terms ALL pickups are light trucks - Medium/heavy trucks are not sold in car dealerships.

According to the data in the Wall Street Journal, for 2008, GM sold 744,872 light trucks. Ford sold 603,230. Both sold far fewer in 2008 than 2007, but the proportion is almost exactly the same.

http://online.wsj.com/mdc/public/page/2_3022-autosales.html#autosalesE

Here are numbers for 2003 through 2006.

http://www.ic.gc.ca/eic/site/auto-auto.nsf/eng/am02068.html

You may disagree with me, and every other organization that gathers stats.

But the truth is the F150 is the best selling truck. But the truth is also that GM also sells more pickups - under 2 brands. And of all the brand differences in GM, one of the least significant is between a Chevy truck and GMC truck. Is one more luxurious than the other - depends how you option it and which model. And if you go back 23 years of stats you will see the same thing. Ford isn't lying, exactly. But I wou;dn't call it the whole truth either.

Woolco was a Canadian subsidiary of an American company that went out of business(Woolworth).

I'm not arguing that GM doesn't build better cars elsewhere, but then again so does Ford.

And I wouldn't argue that Ford management was better at managing cash and paying off debt. At the same time they failed to make Aston Martin, Jaguar or Land Rover into a profitable venture, and Volvo is only slightly better off under Ford than they were as an independant.

James

by oz_media

Didn't the federal government and Ontario Provincial government, as well as the US government give them a big handout in 2008 to counter dropping sales?

by jamesrl

It wasn't until GM and Chrysler negotiate this spring that the government took an ownership stake. Thats when they had the power to force rather than coerce.

James

by jdclyde

The contract is what makes the union.

When the union will not allow the phasing out of a job to make way for a new job, it is just one more reason that the union is behind a lot of the decline of the US manufacturing power. This goes well beyond UAW.

by oz_media

Fair enough. It is an important factor, especially as far as production speed and standards are concerned.

Your first comment seemed to pass the whole blame simply to a lazy union mentality due to seniority. While that is a key issue, there's a lot more to it than just the union, contracts, workers etc.

by jdclyde

Becoming extremely top heavy with excessive management was a major issue.

And no, I don't believe for a second it has anything to do with making trucks. They made what people bought.

by oz_media

Your opening statement is ridiculous. "trucks" is a term that encompasses a massive market and I think it's clear that we both know that. Light trucks are a segment of that market, full sized trucks are another segment of that market, heavy duty/commercial trucks are yet another segment and so on.

"In the United States and Canada "truck" is usually reserved for commercial vehicles [b]larger than normal cars, and for pickups and other vehicles having an open load bed."[/b]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truck

"an automotive vehicle suitable for hauling"
http://www.google.ca/search?hl=en&defl=en&q=define:truck&ei=m_E2SuiHH4mwsgOUg92nDg&sa=X&oi=glossary_definition&ct=title

So hopefully it is clear now that "trucks" encompasses many segments of a market. The reference I offered and statistics I was speaking of point directly to that market segment.

The light truck of which you speak is yet another, which was not part of my discussion. Get it? Light truck argument irrelevant.

My mistake was probably just not being more specific and forgetting I was speaking to a computer technician.

Semantics? What for? There's no purpose or point to be defended by it anyway.
You state:
[i]Medium/heavy trucks are not sold in car dealerships[/i]

The Ford F-550 is available at all local Ford dealers for retail consumers, I have a few pictures of my friend's if you like.
The Ford F-550 is also used as a light armoured car, for 3 and 5 tonne delivery vans, welding and street workers work , light dump trucks and many other commercial applications. I think it would definitely be considered a medium or heavy truck by any automotive standards.

FORD, GM,CHRYSLER, CHEVROLET, HONDA, TOYOTA et al. are all brand names.

In the case of this comment, it was clearly a qualification of brands. Ford also makes trucks under other names all over the world, but just because one brand shares the corporate name, it doesn't make it 'sly'.

If you are looking at trucks sold, GM sells X number of GM trucks, Chevrolet sells X number of Chevrolet trucks, Ford sells X number etc.

It's just like anything else; if Phillips was to say they were the leading brand for selling the most over-ear, stereo headphones, it wouldn't mean Phillips and Magnavox and Sylvania's sales. Perhaps at a corporate level but not at a consumer level, it is branding and selling a brand.

Woolco (which I didn't say was Canadian):
"a retail company that was one of the original American five-and-dime stores"

"Despite growing to be one of the largest retail chains in the world through most of the 20th century, [b]increased competition led to its decline beginning in the 1980s."[/b]

Woolco:
"While the American stores were closed in 1982, the chain remained active in Canada until it was sold in 1994 to rival Wal-Mart.

Did you miss the point of what I was saying while using your fine comb?"

Point is, fair competition and a long time corporation is taken down by a company that has equal right to competition due to capitalism. I thought that would have been really clear considering the context of the discussion.

Regardless of Ford's decisions, or success with past brands, they made changes on the fly. GM is just now promising the same, as if it is some unique business plan to save the world. Car manufacturer's have been selling and trading each other since day one. With over 3000 small shop cars looking for production in the UK alone, this is part of an auto business. Fail at that business and you should rightly be taken over just like any other of the hundreds or thousands who have failed in the industry.

It's like restaurants and hotels, a very unstable and unpredictable industry.

by jamesrl

Light trucks - I did not make up the term. Everyone, including the manufacturers, the retaillers, the government, the economists know what we mean when we say light trucks. But just in case you continue to be dense on the subject, they would include the F150/F250/F350 (what you call full size)as well as smaller trucks. The F450/550 are cnsidered medium trucks. Can you order them in every Ford dealership? I can tell you from my working experience that you can't. They are sold by dealerships who have a Truck franchise. They get different parts lists. They use different software for sales and service. They have different equipement to service them. Are some Ford auto dealers also Truck dealers - yes. But it is a separate franchise.

And the government, the economists and the manufacturers, JD Power all agree the same thing. GM, the corporation, sells more light trucks than Ford, the corporation. The numbers are all there, the wall street journal and the government of canada aren't making them up. When you combine the sales of GMC pickups and Chevy pickups(which are the samer except for a few options and some badges) more of them are sold than Ford pickups.

You think you can insult me by calling me a computer technician. I'm proud to say I have been one. I'm also heavily involved in the automotive industry as well you know, in marketing as well. And my customers are every manufacturer, including Ford, GM, Honda etc. etc. I don't think any of them are perfect, you seem to think Ford can do no wrong and GM can do no right. You have a blindspot as big as the moon.

James

by jamesrl

From the links I already provided:

2003
GM Light Trucks: 2 756 023
Ford Light Trucks: 2 175 880

2004
GM Light Trucks: 2 780 735
Ford Light Trucks: 2 162 057

2005
GM Light Trucks: 2 711 602
Ford Light Trucks: 1 971 780

2006
GM Light Trucks: 2 444 623
Ford Light Trucks: 1 660 838

I found this for full size only (Light equals fulls size, medium and small trucks in industry temrs)

http://blogs.cars.com/photos/uncategorized/2009/01/07/fsttable560_2.gif

Its shows that for 2007 Full size trucks:

GM 820261
Ford 698971

2008
GM 673334
Ford 520144

I'm didn't say GM dominated Ford, you said Ford dominated the market. In my world dominates means making more sales, and domination implies at least by a sizeable amount.

But hey why let a few facts and figures change your mind.

James

by oz_media

First of all James, I am a certified F series technician. I have repaired AND sold Ford trucks, Chevy trucks and Nissan LIGHT trucks.

"Light truck or light duty truck is a classification for trucks or truck-based vehicles with a payload capacity of less than 4,000 pounds"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light_truck

Truck classes: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truck_classification

Full size truck comparison:
Ford F-150 Lariat
Chevy Silverado
Toyota Tundra
Dodge RAM 1500

All available at retail dealerships, not just commerical.

Commonly, a full size truck is a truck with a ed size of 4X8 (enough for a sheet of playwood to lay flat).

1/4 tonne and compact turcks/lkight trucks have a smaller bed, lower tow ratings and lighter payload capacity.

YOu are arguing a moot point, there is ZERO purpose or gain from yoru argument. Shall we start a separate thread looking for PERSONAL AND PUBLIC OPINIONS of what a light truck is and what a full size truck is or do you wish to continue splitting that hair too?

Again combinging sales of two brands does not ofer an accurate view of whihc brand is a best seller. Don't know how you don't se ethat, well maybe I do, you will see anything if you want ot argue it, relevant or not.

Callign you a computer technician was not intended as an insult at all, nice you take it that way though, how defensive of you. the point is, you see life as specific definitions, most other see life as reality.

Whereas MOST people woul dsee an F-350 on teh street and call it a full sized truck, which is acceptable to MOST others too, or a Ford Ranger and call it a mid-seized or light-truck, you would see them and put them both in the same classification, awaiting full towing and payload capacity figures in order to set them apart.

by oz_media

I didn't say it WAS due to making trucks though. That is just some tangent james is running on and I don't even understand the relevance or why.

by jaqui

until the governments quit bailing the companies out the bad management won't learn by losing everything.

Government should be setting up replacement financial / insurance companies for the consumer. being backed by government not stock market, they will be a stable provider until the commercial providers fail / stabilize. and the government run ones can do the same for loans / mortgages as they do for student loans, they never go away, the money does get paid back, with interest.

no free handout to companies, they have to pay it all back in the same way, the debt can only be cleared by repayment, with interest.

by jamesrl

And how Ford, according to you was "Dominating the market". When I show you the stats that prove otherwise, you try to weasel away.

The manufacturers did make big bucks with trucks, they didn't have to be made with the same safety engineering as cars and there was less emphasis on mileage as well. But no one put a gun to the buyers head and forced people to buy them. Sure many people need trucks, but I see a lot of trucks that have never ever seen a payload in the back, driven to office buildings.

James

by jamesrl

...in the US World News and Report "Affordable Sports Car" grouping.

Hyundai Genesis Coupe ranked #1.

James

by oz_media

seriously, when you show me the stats? Get bent, you showed NOTHING and I proved it.

All i did was list some VERY common stats that have been that way for ages, your little small truck rant was completely irrelevant, proved nothing and was a complete waste of effort on your part.

I mentioned truckks, I did NOT say that the reason for GM's decline was due to Ford selling more trucks, not at all, not once, not ever.

Read it again, you are horribly mistaken.

My complete comment, if yuo had read it properly was that while GM promised change and better qualirty before, they did nothign to provide it. Whereas many other companies, this is where I mentionned Hyundai and Ford, addressed their lemons and followed up with good vehicles. Hyundai has made what is widely regarded as the best mid sized sedan in 2009. " Ford now makes some of the most advanced and evolved compacts on the market, while STILL deominating the truck segment"

Ford DOESN'T dominate the truck segment is what yuo are trying to argue. Either way, whereever you want to get your stats and whatever you personally choose to believe is completely irrelevant. FORD made changes and came back, Hyundai made changes and came back as have MANY others over the years, GM is just mroe empty promises.

Perhaps now you can understand how petty and irrelevant your light truck tirade is? I could have used many other manufacturers as examples, WHO is not imprtant, the fact is that GM has done this before "we promise, we'll do better' but they don't, end of
story.

As for "And how Ford, according to you was "Dominating the market". When I show you the stats that prove otherwise, you try to weasel away."

You showed NOTHING, NIL, NADA, SQUAT F-ALL, BuggerBoo! I definitely don't weasel away, havign known me for a few years now, you should know very well that I don't weasel away from anything, especially here. I'll always stand up and be counted.

by dadspad

I would not call the current media blitz completely a mask. I seems to be more of marketing keeping the GM name alive while the, finally, let the engineers develop the product they should have been working on for years.

The lack of engineering development put in vehicles is the main problem GM has. Emphasis on design and finances seems to dominate until the rest of the automotive world passed them by.

Buying transportation is a very personal event. We tend to buy what our need dictate. Trucks are a good example. The light duty or pick up truck have been popular for many years due to their utiltarian value for both business and personal.

A young growing family needs room. After WWII, there was the station wagon, then the minivan, then the SUV, now the crossover is popular. Again, these vehicles were bought, primarily, because the family need them.

In quality, I do agree that years ago quality was an issue with all American vehicles, but not in today's world. I can only vouch for the GM and Ford products I have bought, but they all were made with high qualtiy.

by oz_media

Light duty and pickup trucks are all the same, ask James. HE knows these things, he knew a guy who worked at Chrysler and has worked in "marketing" withing th eindustry before. Of course, as a certified truck technician myself, such info is well beyond my own understanding.

'Full-sized pickup truck' is a term I apparently made up, in actuality full sized trucks are ALL commercial and not available to consumers. Light trucks includes all consumer available trucks, regardless of payload or towing capacity, regardless of what the dealers insist they are and regardless of common consumer knowledge.

Quality these dya IS getting better as it MUSt to compete with Japanese and European cars(it should have been in the 80's too though), but if you compare materials, fit and finish with the same manufacturer's vehicles made in other continents, ours pale. Just like everything ele we manufacture, we settle for lower standards than we see in other nations even by the same manufacturer. Expect less, get less.

by dadspad

Just kidding, I know a lot of GM, Ford are assembled in Canada. :D

I will disagree with you on the quality. Although, some models are/were not of equal quality, I have own autos that stand easily up to any manufacturers. I had a 70's Firebird and a Murcury Cougar (very similar cars then) that I loved and had no quality issues on mine. Only really poor quality cars I have owned were small Dodge and Chevy, both imports and not pleasant memories.

On the other hand I have met people that had bad experiences, maintenance wise, with Toyota and Nissan. There are bad cars made by all manufacturers and excellent cars made by all manufacturers. It is not fair to believe that some years US cars were very bad.

by jck

Corporate execs voted to approve all those over-paying contracts.

The boards voted all the over-compensating executive packages/golden parachutes.

You can blame all the lazy people (union or not) you want for the demise of a company.

But in the end, GM was incredibly poorly managed. Its board and executive leadership sat and fed each other huge paychecks for years while the profits were good and spent like they were US congressional members.

Besides, there is this: just how long does it take to train someone off the street how to bolt a seat into place, place a windshield into the cavity, or start the cars at the end of the assembly line?

If they would have wanted to eliminate the union and really protect the corporate well-being in the long-term, they would have told the union to go shove it in the 70s/80s and went out and found some of the thousands of unemployed in the Flint/Pontiac area who would have been more than happy to work for $12 an hour instead of $22.

Executives just didn't care as long as they got theirs.

And, that's the fundamental problem with American business: no real fundamental ethics are in place.

I say let them all bleed, take back the money the government hasn't spent, cut every tax payer a $3000 check, and watch them spending that money make the economy grow.

BAH!!!! I need a drink :D

by jdclyde

This was not in response to you Oz, nor was it in regard to James.

It was entirely to do with the current trend in the US among liberals to blame the evil SUV (out of their own ignorance/stupidity/dishonesty).

Was just putting it out there, mKay? :D

TheObama keeps trying to blame the crisis for failure to change to micro cars, which is a total lie on his part, but it helps him push his anti-progress agenda against anything that uses petroleum (which is just about everything)

Yeah, declare war on petroleum and see how much THAT helps him bury the economy as prices soar.

by jdclyde

It was a clusterphuck from top to bottom.

I did not cut the execs any slack, nor did I cut the union "workers" any slack. They all were the problem.

I personally know someone that a few decades ago was part of a ring that would take flatbeds of brand new engines out the door. A few people eventually lost their jobs over it, but most were never caught, the person I knew was one that never got caught (recently passed, ex family member).

Everyone was on the gravy train....

by jamesrl

In 2008 the governments gave them loans, in 2009 as part of the restructuring agreements the governments bought shares, thus giving them the ability to force the board to do things, but remember the companies were forced to provide an acceptable plan before the shares were bought.

James

by oz_media

if you are going to debate my comment, at least debate MY comment and not just something else as if you have an argument.

I give up with you, it doesn't matter what I say you will find something irrelevant or previously unsaid to argue about. Your just such a 'king waste of time when you stop makign sense and start grasping for straws andlooking for some kind of pi$$ing contest for reasons unknown.

To further prove how hideously lacking your reading comprehension skills are, you then went on about the new Malibu, completely disregarding that I was not referring to the same car at all.

[i]"Former models, the previous versions with the 105" wheelbase were BASED on the Opel platform but did not offer the same steering and suspension system at all, just footprint dimensions. [b]Those past models were lemons and failed miserably in the market though.[/b][/i]

BC Auto Dealers Assn. ranks it poorly, US News auto ratings have it set behind the Fusion too. As far as Japanese, it is too expensive, gets poor fuel rating, the 4-cylinder is low powered ("gutless"), they are dropping the Hybrid for 2010 (which was a waste anyway) and it has a terrible resale value."[/i]

one more time for the reading impaired

So what's wih your rant about the 2008?

As for the Mitsubishi 2.7L whihc was one of the worst engines of recent years, which WAS used by Chrysler for Intrepids, here's a run down on your car of the year.

http://dodgestories.blogspot.com/

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090615080834AAXOe1H

"Most people like the styling of these small [b]Chrysler-Mitsubishi V-6 2.7L [/b]power-horses, "

Mitsubishi built 2.7L engines are ALL over the internet, MAINLY with respect to the Itrepid and how unreliable that motor was due to timing chain and sludge issues.

Seriously James, it's like trying to talk to a 5-year old with you sometimes.

It doesn't matter where you friends worked, do they need ot be in Japan in order to install a Mitsubishi engine in a Dodge?
Chrysler was using the 2.7L FLOP of a motor, Mitsubishi designed and implemented the 2.7L and it was adopted by Chrylser and used in their second Generation Intrepids, which were horrific failures.

There are SO many websites relating to the Mistubishi 2.7L sludge issue and failed Intrepids I really though that you'd find it yourself. I've waded through them looking for comon solutions to Intrpid issues more than once.

You do know that Chrylser owns an equity share (around 35%) in Mitsubishi right?

However as you seem more interested on trying to make moot points for some irrelevant reasons, I'll let you just run amok waving your arms for a while anyway.

http://fix27engine.com/
"Most people like the styling of these small Chrysler-Mitsubishi V-6 2.7L power-horses"

How do I know these things? I didn't have a friend who worked at a plant down the road, who went out of his way to assure me they were installing Chrysler engines and not Mitsubishi engines in Intrepids.

I have worked on the friggin' things dozens of times! I worked F/T as a tech when these cars were popular, I know the engine VERY well, unfortunately.

You are not about to convince me that a famous lemon of an engine, designed and engineered by Mistubishi, then later used by a company that owns a chunk of Mitsubishi, then discussed by mechanics and car buffs all over as a Mitsubishi engine used in Intrepids is NOT a Mitsubishi engine. Especially when I have repaired them, labelled with Mitsubishi and with Mistubishi OEM replacemeent parts.

Christ, James just pop the friggin hood!

Stick to what you know James, it sure as hell isn't cars.

As for pupularity, AGAIN you are ignoring my comments in your haste to prove an irrelevant point.

"As for Mitsubishi,the Intrepid's and Concords initially used the 3.3L and 3.5L engines, which were complete garbage, up until around 1997/98, I think"

And yet your argument is some rant aout 2008 models, which i had not even mentioned in my post. However you decided to try and make a point out of it? Are you really going insane or something? Di yu have reading issues?

It would explain things if you did, but if you don't, what's your point or purpose with your unrealted arguments?

But whatever, tell me all about how Barry Manilow wrote a song in 2001 and how it proves my comments wrong.

Have fun with it.

by jamesrl

This site gives a comprehensive history of the engine:
http://www.allpar.com/mopar/new6.html

"To clarify again - the 2.7 was developed from the 3.2, which was developed from the 3.5 ? all at Highland Park and later, CTC, in the early days there were several changes, but the starting point for all was the 3.5. "

Is Highland Park in Japan? No its Chrsyler's headquarters.

You saw a Mitsubishi badge on an Intrepid engine? Really? I have opened the hood on a 2.7 L Intrepid, and gee, it didn't say Mitsubishi. By the way my Ford Duratec 3.0 L in my Mazda MPV doesn't say Ford on it.

As for the Malibu, to your original post, you claim GM is not improving. Now you say that you weren't talking about the 2008. Gee thanks for proving my point, if the 2007 was a dog and the 2008 is good, then they have improved.

And further to your original point, Saturn's lineup, with the Opel based Astra, Aura (same as Malibu), Vue (Vauxhall/Opel) are all much better vehicles than the ones they replaced.

JD Power's initial quality survey for 2008:
Highest initial quality pickup - Chevy Silverado - a much better vehicle than the old Chevy Truck.

James

by oz_media

You couldn't get a grip on reality if it landed in yuor fist.

As for your constant Ford issues, I haven't said Ford is without suchj issues, as I explaned and detailed twice now, I have used tehm as an example of a company that was making changes WHEN THEY SHOULD HAVE, while GM was still pumping out junk years after saying they wouldn't be pumping out junk anymore.

Chrysler designed the 2.7L engine?
Perhaps you should also look up GEMA and find out who designs these motors,its a joint venture of Mitsubishi, Chrysler and Hyundai.

Huundai and Mitsubishi, though designers do not use most of the engines GEMA produces, but Chrysler does. That's probably why the motors are identical and used in identical vehicles. Many manufacturer's do this, as you noted with Ford. I had commented o a mistsubishi engine that was a flop and installed in many Inrepids during their second generation. I have replaced parts on them, have seen the labelled as Mitsubishi while sitting in a Chrysler. I just don't get what your ridiculous point is or what you are attempting to achieve.

As usual, I don't care either, yuor comments have proven taht you have a single focus; you feel i am sayign Ford does no wrong, which is WAY of base if you had been ablr to read and comprehend my posts befor eyour chip fell off yoru shoulder. You seem to feel a need to defend what has become the dodgiest (sorry for the pun) and most unreliable car manufacturer in US history.
Whil ethey scramble and beg for tax money in a nation where fair competition has always seen companies come and go, people lose jobs people find jobs.

In other words, you have no point to be made. Go back to the original thread and try to make ANY sense out of your comments and you will see just how far off topic and how unrelated and irrelevant your comments are.

Or you can just put on your GM badge and touque and have a good wank while thinking about how great you are.

by oz_media

They DIDN'T get federal and provincial money in 2008?

I wasn't asking you to split hairs, no matter how much you feel it necessary to overanalyze and twist whatever I say, it was a straight comment.

They either did receive money or they did not receive money.

Apparently they did not, as you seemingly want to argue my comment that the received both Federal and Provincial government money from Canada in 2008.

by oz_media

Because North American consumrs have had little to nothing of value to choose from in a compact market for decades now and the only hope of any value for money is in a mid to full size vehicle.

They are scared to buy a compact car, and judging by our compacts compared to compacts around teh world, they are justified fears in many cases.

In other nations, where fuel costs have been an issue and pollutants have been an issue for many decades, small cars are high quality and accepted widely.

Try driving an F-250 around Germany fo rth eday and see how much fun it is. Try driving one in the UK and find your tires slahed and paint scratched for having the audacity to drive it to begin with.

WE on the other hand, have this backward mentality tha bigger is better, it it more powerful and mighty. Which is of course horse crap considering there are 4-cylinder econo cars that outrun our current muscle.

by jdclyde

Ever try taking four people and four sets of golf clubs anywhere in a compact car? Doesn't work well.

Ever taken a week long road trip with a family of four, with each kid bringing along a friend, in a compact car?

There are a lot of reasons that the compact does not/will not ever work in the reality that is North America.

No, I don't buy based upon muscle, and most people I know don't either. Size based upon need/want.

Now that my shoulder won't allow me to swing a golf club anymore and the family is going their own way more, I can get a smaller car to fit my life, but 10 years ago it was not an option.

We hear about the soccer mom with the SUV, and I often see them packed because of car pooling. dang evil suv's.....

Question, how far will the 4 cylinders of Europe keep running? I know my last few cars, I kept driving well past 250k, and the current one is at 215k. At least my work week is only 150 miles instead of 700 now.

by oz_media

Your examples are great examples for the need for a minivan or compact SUV/crossover, but not a pickup, Expedition, Hummer, Sequoia, Yukon or Armada.

Golf was originated in Scotland, I wonder how THEY do it without a large people mover?

You comments also include a particular market segment, perhaps you should note who is driving these vehicles and how many do so out of necessity.

THe reality that is North America? What different reality do we have that justifies us driving vehicles that are more than we need? of course a reality that doesn' texist elsewhere where they do not drive such large vehicles.

YOu talk about how recently yuo don't need a car but 10 years ago it was a different optin. So what about the last 10 years? You are just realizing you don't need a big vehicle now?

Soccer mom wuith the SUV, again a compact SUV or minivan is actually just as good with mileage as most newer cars, or very close to it and justified by need of course.

4-cylinder in Europe? They last ages and are priced accordingly. 250K? Pretty much anything well engineered will do that. A North American 4-cyl these days, I wouldn't bank on, the rest of the car will fall apart first.

I have had a Pinto with 743,000kms on it and it ran fine when sold to an auto student. I also had a civic ('81) with over a half million kms on it, ran fine but I scrapped it for yard room when I lived in Port Hardy.
My mother drives a 4cyl Ford, with 173kms on it, and it runs as new (but she's pretty meticulous with her stuff).

250K miles? It's not a stretch if peopl take care of their vehicles properly. I'm not suggesting a dealer visit once a month but just preventative ,maintenance and proper driving technique, will make a car last ages, again if it is properly cared for.

I have a European 1997 V6 in my SUV, 286K kms and it gets 22MPG (brand new was rated at 20mpg) and runs like a top. Sails through air care, plenty of go, plenty of life left. I was talking the other day with a guy who thinks it'll be a million miler the way I keep it. The equivalent motor made by Ford in Canada or US these days, averages 80,000kms before a complete reuild.

People can bash Europe for many things but engineering superiority and manufacturing standards are not arguable. Only a fool would think we can't keep up with them.

by jck

Is it because, lots of American car buyers are less worried about the environment and depletion of natural resources, and more worried about impressing their neighbor and having what's "cool" or the "in thing" and willing to do just about anything (including go into debt up to their eyeballs) to indulge a self-interest in their ego and narcissism??

Thanks. :^0

by slayer_

I saw it all the time in the lawn mower sales, guy wanting a 64inch deck to cut 1 acre. It is no supprise when he comes back with it later claiming it does a terriable job, leaves clumps of grass, and can't go around trees. No shit you idiot.

People have very odd expectations of things. Horsepower is also bad, everyone wants the most horsepower. Both sleds, quads, tractors, all the same thing, wanting more horsepower, then not understanding why it wears out so fast.

Why oh Why do we need 9 horse power handmowers. the 21inch deck needs 9hp now????

2 years earilier I bought a 5.5 Honda engine Mower, 21 inch, I have yet to run out of power with it, I have cut 6 foot tall grass with it and mulched it. WHY could you possibly need 9 horse power????

Even better, the manufactuer actually got sued once because the mower advertised 5.5HP but only actually produced 5.3. So they now no longer display the power, just the displacement.

The world is fked, end of story.

by jamesrl

Is how cars and trucks are getting so much bigger over the years.

The new Honda Civic is bigger than a 20 year old accord. The Toyota Tacoma used to be a small truck, then a mid size, now its pretty darn close to what a full size used to be - same with the Dodge Dakota, Nissan Frontier etc. Ask yourself why....

James

by jiminpa

It could be that I have not yet found a compact 4 cylinder car that will tow my camper. I'm just saying...

B-)

by jamesrl

I tow a popup trailer (1250 lbs empty/1600 full) with a minivan, even with 5 passengers and a couple of coolers and other gear in the van.

I have seen people with compact cars towing small trailers - around 1000 lbs - including Ford Focus, Toyota Matrix and even a Mini Cooper. They might have the torque to tow it, but I wonder if they know what they are doing to their tranny, let alone if they have enough brakes to stop with a trailer behind them. I wouldn't recommend it.

But my point is you don't need a full size pickup or big SUV to tow a trailer either.

James

by oz_media

This I have a family, I am a soccer mom, I need to tow a trailer BS is gettign tiring.

There are uses and purposes for larger vehicles. But MOSt people don't NEED a larger vehicle MOST of the time.

a) You could own a truck for towing your camper and buy a small used, compact for day to day, to and from work etc., but that wouldn't work because........?

b) For the times you tow yuor camper you could rent a full sized truck for the weekend and still com eou ton top as you are drivign a more effficient car the rest of teh time.

c) You could buy a smaller camper or a Class A or B whic is self propelled, then you are only using the large vehicle when needed, save your money the rest of the year.

Of course you will have a quick excuse for each of these suggestions, it is easy to do whan you need ot justify your own luxuries, almost preprogrammed at time of purchase. of course you will have valid reasons to NEED a large vehicle, just as other said you need a full sized vehicle if you are a soccer mom (a 4-cylinder minivan or cmopact SUV s not sufficient I suppose).

People like to make excuses for their own luxuries, people will not sacrifice THEIR luxuries but will always talk about other luxuries they DON'T have as being unnecessary.

Old hat, and I just don't buy it anymore. If you really DID care and wanted to do something about it, you would end of story.

by jck

[i]It was a clusterphuck from top to bottom.[/i]

Yep. Agreed.

[i]I did not cut the execs any slack, nor did I cut the union "workers" any slack. They all were the problem.[/i]

But you lay the majority of the blame on "lazy union people" all the time. A) Not all union people are lazy/take advantage of union rules, and B) if everyone in a union was lazy like you imply, none of those cars would have gotten made.

There are a lot of hard working union people. Just cause you know/have heard of a lot of slackers doesn't mean everyone is.

[i]I personally know someone that a few decades ago was part of a ring that would take flatbeds of brand new engines out the door. A few people eventually lost their jobs over it, but most were never caught, the person I knew was one that never got caught (recently passed, ex family member).[/i]

Sorry they passed...and that they were a criminal.

I know your pain...my sister is a big thief/scammer. And, I wish she never existed.

[i]Everyone was on the gravy train....[/i]

Yeah, and some of them (probably more than you'd admit to) earned their paychecks.

---------------------------------------------

[i]It was entirely to do with the current trend in the US among liberals to blame the evil SUV (out of their own ignorance/stupidity/dishonesty).[/i]

Actually, auto manufacturers got around the mileage mandates from Congress by lobbying the legislation to be written to apply to "passenger vehicles". Then, SUVs were classified not as passenger vehicles and didn't have their mileage rolled into the EPA numbers for them.

Shady dealings? Yep. WTG big business and government.

[i]TheObama keeps trying to blame the crisis for failure to change to micro cars, ...[/i]

I thought Obama and his administration were blaming poor management and lending practices on the state of things. He's blaming SUVs now? Wow. News to me. ;)

[i]...which is a total lie on his part, but it helps him push his anti-progress agenda against anything that uses petroleum (which is just about everything)[/i]

As opposed to...the progress of the agenda previous to his that allowed:

1) oil prices to rise skyrocket 100% in 3 years due to unregulated speculative market practices.
2) uncontrolled spending by a one-sided political system during 3/4 of the time the last president was sitting in office
3) the quieted, passive (yet still existing) approval of the use of torture we condemn used against our own people and troops, but condone for our own uses
4) the pressing of unisecular religious beliefs by institutionalized departments from "discretionary funds" to implement personal religious beliefs into governmental function and practice.

Boy...that's real progress to be metered against.

I was always taught there's nowhere to go but up when you've hit bottom.

Of course, who knows if Obama brought a shovel or a trowl.

[i]Yeah, declare war on petroleum and see how much THAT helps him bury the economy as prices soar.[/i]

Kinda funny. Prices are gonna soar anyway this summer, as the United States begins its rollout from Iraq in August that the Bush administration committed us to stand by.

Just watch. As the unstable Iraq government (who refuses to take responsibility for their own country) takes power and militants and secularists start small engagements all over Iraq, I won't be surprised if you are gonna see $4+ a gallon by October.

Declaring war on petroleum won't be necessary. Having declared war in Iraq 6 years ago was enough to send oil prices through the roof for years in the past and years to come.

That's why I'm pondering screwing the banks for $125k. I figure they got their payout of my mortgage in the federal bailout.

Now it's time for me to bailout.

Merry Christmas.

by jck

are not selling "well" compared to past numbers.

That's a no-brainer.

As for Ford doing it without your money?

Ford applied for and got $1Bs of taxpayer dollars that were labelled "subsidies" rather than "bailout" funds.

Those monies are earmarked for: "...efforts to become more fuel efficient."

Here...I have an idea: use smaller engines in cars that use less gas, and limit throttle levels that would save gas too.

Okay, I'm waiting on my check from Ford for $250,000 for a consulting fee. :^0

But I agree...get the government out of the car business. Take the stock our tax dollars bought, and sell it to whatever company wants to buy it that gets us our money back.

by jdclyde

Yeah, it took "no brain" to make that statement.....

Sales of just about everything is down, not a reflection on the auto industry at all, but the world economy. In an honest discussion that wouldn't be brought up as a slam against US automakers as ALL car sales are down. Sales of hybrids are WAY down. how does that fit in with your anti-large vehicle statement?

by jamesrl

Commercial truck classification in the United States is done based on the vehicle's Gross Vehicle Weight Rating. The classes range from 1-8.[1] It also done more broadly under the US DOT FHWA Vehicle Inventory and Use Survey (VIUS) standards, which groups Class 1 and 2 as "Light Duty", 3-5 as "Medium Duty", and 6-8 as "Heavy Duty". [2][3]

Class 1 and 2: GVWR up to 10,000 lbs.
Examples include the Nissan Titan (what you call a full size truck) and the F250 (full size).

So what the US government Department of Transportation classifies as a "Light Truck" includes all the Full size trucks you mention. Unless you want to convince me that an F250 is smaller than an F150.

Thanks for the source. I knew that to be the case. It only makes sense from the sales numbers (or did you think that Ford was making a million Rangers a year?).

Go ahead tell me I'm wrong again.

James

by jck

my lawnmower is 4.5hp and 22" cut, and i push it. the only reason it is 4.5hp is because they didn't have a 3.5 like i bought last time about 7 years before.

like Oz said somewhere...lots of people think bigger (or more) is better.

really sad. i agree. the world is phooked.

by slayer_

Frankly I am amazed my 5.5 mower will cut my grass for the year on 4 dollars in fuel :). I wonder what those new 9HP ones get for fuel economy.

by jck

but God...one of the riding mowers i looked at one day was 9hp.

a push mower that is 9hp?????

that's just silly...unless it makes your margaritas for you while you mow :^0

by oz_media

I know its quite a stretch out of line but it is teh same mentality.

I STILL get people asking about amps they have been looking at that are 100's of watts, it's complete garbage.

When you consider that I can put a 1973 20WPC amp up against today's 100W sony/pioneer etc. and have it be louder and better sounding, how imporant is wattage?

When you buy a 100W amp and have it on at a normal, comfortable listening level you are LUCKY to be pumping our 5-10 watts. You aren't listening to 100W. To get a 3 decibel gain, you pretty much need to DOUBLE the output wattage. If you get 80dB at 50Watts you need 100Watts to push 83dB.

the point is though, nobody ever considers AMP class, current etc. Just that favorite wattage spec. Wattage that doesn't MOVE (amperage/current)is useless.

Horsepower that doesn't reach the road is also useless. When you consider how cheaply built our cars are, with thin, tin heat shields to dissipate heat away from the motor, it's no wonder people need/want more and more horse power.

An identical motor engineered by European standards will have better efficiency, reducing teh need for such heat shields as they are wasting less fuel energy as heat and delivering more to the road.

A 16' Zodiac needs about 7hp to plane properly, yet people always want a 25 horse motor as that is the top capacity and MUST be faster, but not necessarily.

It all boils down to marketing and people actually believing the BS they are fed.

by jck

Americans of this and future generations are spoiled rotten.

I'm glad I was raised around people like my father who grew up in a 2 room house, my mother who was born in a house with dirt floors and was made to butcher chickens and wash other peoples' clothes for money, and my uncle who was a decorated survivor of the attack on the Arizona at Pearl Harbor who always taught me to not only have dreams but to go after them with as much passion as you have about them.

Nowadays, most people here are only interested in self but they will sure wave the flag and act like their interest are in community and country.

It's sad. I bet most people here would throw a hissy if they couldn't choose what night they eat beef on. They wouldn't know how to deal with the stresses of a Great Depression and a real war.

What is worse: the American-based companies are, rather than finding ways to help make it better, exploiting the situation for all the profits they can make of it...and often right under the nose of the government who is supposed to make sure they aren't being the "fox raiding the henhouse".

Sad, I tell ya.

by jck

It's just people either being ignorant or obtuse, for the most part.

And I know what you mean about tuners. I still have a Panasonic tube amp/tuner somewhere that kicks butt.

Oh well...maybe some day i can find a way to exploit ignorant people and sell them more than they need. :^0

by jamesrl

I said they received a loan in 2008. That was not enough to be able to force anyone into bankruptcy.

In 2009 the governments bought shares, making them part owners, which did give them a say in whether or not they would file for bankruptcy protection.

Thats all I said, and it was to Palmies point. You seem to be the one nit picking this one.

James

by jiminpa

My pop-up is actually 3200lbs loaded and I pull it with a 6 cylinder Envoy. Most of the rest of my family has 5000-6000lb campers and tow them with diesels. I don't think that is over kill in either case.

I also definitely agree that you shouldn't be towing any sort of trailer with a compact (I also own a Focus). My grandpa used to always say don't worry about pulling it, worry about stopping it and those types of vehicles were never intended to tow.

by oz_media

Trucks are all the same, anything larger than a Tacoma is a commercial truck that must be sought out through a commercial dealer. What do you mean, small truck, mid sized and full sized?

HOGWASH! I tell you, HOG....WASH!

by jiminpa

"People like to make excuses for their own luxuries, people will not sacrifice THEIR luxuries but will always talk about other luxuries they DON'T have as being unnecessary."

I get so tired of people looking down their nose at the things others are doing when they themselves could hardly be considered perfect. Do you do EVERYTHING you can for the environment? The great and powerful Oz has no little indulgence that he could curtail for the good of the planet?

In case you missed it I also own a Ford Focus. :p

by jamesrl

Lets be clear. I work every day with all manufacturers of vehicles including Ford. I drive a Mazda with a Ford engine. I have a father who has always had a Chevy truck, and a brother who has always had a Ford truck. I've driven them both.

I'm well aware of GEMA, I was told about it by marketing people at a business lunch years ago by people who work at Chrysler. It was well after the Intrepid though.

Did you even go to the Allpar link ? More credible than a link to Yahoo answers, but hey. The allpar link, as well as the wikipedia link are both unanimous that the 2.7 is a derivitative of previous Chrysler designed and built V6s.

I'm not a Ford hater, I've actually never owned a GM car, but I have owned a Ford Mustang. I owned a Hyundai Pony for crying out loud, I've had my time in hell.

I will give Ford credit for managing its assets better than GM.

But before you trot out the old Ford has done it without subsidies mantra, know that Ford threatened to close down the Oakville Truck plant in 2002 unless it got subsidies from the government, and thats not the first time. It actually announced the closure, and were convinced with subsidies to keep it open. Today it makes the Flex and the Edge.

I am not saying that GM is golden. But they started to make significant changes years ago.

So lets say that none of the recent subsidies happen and GM and Chrysler close their doors. Do you think someone will simply buy the assets and start hiring workers, ordering parts and building vehicles right away? It could take months or years for production to resume, in the mean time we the taxpayers pay out unemployment insurance and the parts makers go under. Many parts makers started to go under last year, before plants were shut, just because production was down.

I know in sunny Vancouver you couldn't give a crap about the Ontario economy. But my livelihood, my paycheck is directly affected by these things.

James

by oz_media

I just automatically thought that if you were replying to Pamie, you would have replied to/below Palmies comments and not right below mine.

Yuo replied under Palmetto initially, then I added that they HAD been given some money in 2008.

You then replied TO ME, describing what they had received, which didn't dicount my comments but did detail the money given to them.

As you are dead set to argue any point I make, including this one I'm sure, I asked if that was not the same thing.

You again replied directly to me and under my post, stating again LOANS vs SHARES, so I again asked if that was to deny my comment or simply add to it.

To THAT reply you then AGAIN posted to me, and underneath my question, that you were talking to Palmie.

LOL How convenient for you.

So any time you post, regardless of where, you can simply say you were talking to someone else?

YOU do know that you can post right below the person you are replying to and it makes it easier for everyone to follow. You don't need to reply under my comment to you and pretend it was for someone else.

Look at the thread, there's plenty of room to post your comments to Palmie right under Palmetto's comment. You chose to debate with me again instead, nice try though, but you really underestimate the intelligence of users here who can see for themselves that you are way out of whack on that one.

by jamesrl

Oz knows, as do I, as does anyone who watches Top Gear regularly that Jeremy Clarkson's stock in trade is over the top hyperbole. He continually tries to top himself in outrageous statements.

In fact the Toronto Star, which has a weekly automotive section, started to carry Jeremy's columns, and received a torrent of hate mail. Once those nasty letters were published another torrent started, people who understand dark sarcasm.

Actually the best example of how Top Gear feels about US cars is in the "Top Gear goes to America" episode, when they buy cheap junkers in Florida and drive to New Orleans with much hilarity along the way.

James

by oz_media

"...in the world!" I love Clarkson, the Top Gear UK bunch are excellent! Can't wait for the new season to start showing up for download...I mean, er, purchase.

by Member 25348569

we DON'T buy US cars in any quantity. The UK view of US car build quality is that it's bad - and it's not just Jezza saying that.

:)

by jamesrl

When I hear Jeremy and the gang talk about the UK price for an american car, its a huge gap, far more than one can justify for a right hand conversion. You gotta be a little loonie to spend that kinda $$ on an american import.

James

by oz_media

I know a couple who just moved from Germany to St.Albans as they both bought used Ford's (Probe's if I remember right) upon arrival. Loving them too, but you have to remember, even though they are not the quality of a lot of European or Japanese cars, THOSE North American cars are still more reliable than our own. Now THAT'S sad!

by jamesrl

Palmie suggested that the governments should have/could have forced them into bankruptcy in 2008 before all the money was spent. My point was they didn't have the means, because they didn't own the shares.

You seem to want to get me to say I said something else. I replied to you, cause you replied to me. Nothing more or less.

James

by oz_media

No, I am sure I could do more. But I walk to the store instead of driving, I take the skytrain or bus when I can, I am part of the 1 tonne challenge that David Suzuki's website sets our for personal waste responsibility and I do well with it. I do what I can, not always what is most convenient and I am a lot more concious of my carbon footprint than most others I meet.

On a whole I do more than most, with the exception of the over zealous tree huggers who think that exhaling is going to kill off the planet.

Do I do my part? Yes.
Do I do everything I possibly could? Within reason of course, nobody expects you to live by to candle light and sewing your own clothes from your trappings.

If you are so proud to drive a compact car, what was the relevance behind your statement of needing a bigger vehicle for towing a trailer?

Everyone knows that some vehicles have a purpose, you use yours for that purpose and not for day to day driving, so what was your point if not just for the sake of argument by not mentioning your more economical habits?

by oz_media

I asked a question and your reply was "... Thats all I said, and it was to Palmies point"

If it was to Palmies point, why do you now say it was to me?

by oz_media

First of all I am VERY familiar with Allpar, I have contributed to and helped visitros to the Allpar site many times with respect to Cuda's. You seem to feel it has great credibility, its just a user forum though, no different than Ford 4X4 owners forums etc.

"But before you trot out the old Ford has done it without subsidies mantra"

Now you are even arguing points that are not made, just DYING to get a point in, aren't you?

I know very well that Ford has been helped in the past, your defense is unwarranted, as usual.

And nwo the reality of your ranting comes to light: "But my livelihood, my paycheck is directly affected by these things."

You are justifying the government bailing out a capitalist corporation in a free market because it effects YOUR paycheck.

That's no different than any union worker saying they approve of the bailout because they will keep their job. Not exactly a compelling reason to spend hundreds of millions of everyone else's money though.

by dhcdbd

I have a 94 Nissan Sentra that was made in Japan (First three on vin JNE) rather than the Canadian make of this vehicle. The Vehicle runs fine and averages 33 MPG combined. It has 173,000 miles on it without full or partial rebuild. I am just getting around to a partial rebuild of the motor, i.e. check and if needed spin in oversized main bearings, replace crankshaft seals, check and shim or replace valve lifters, etc. There is currently no need for a full rebuild (bore cylinder walls, replace valves, valve springs, valve seats, valve guides, bore and hone main bearing seats, mill head, replace oil pump, etc).

On a few of these posts I see that a rebuild needs to be done at 80,000 km. A kilometer is .69 of a mile, so that post reads that an engine needs a rebuild at appx. 40,000 miles. Another post reads that an engine needs a rebuid at 173,000 km which is apprx. 80,000 miles.

Just who am I to believe: the 80k km, the 173k km, or my completion of an apprentice auto mechanics program in my teens at the Clark County, Nv County Motor Pool in my teens during the early 70's?

by oz_media

It depends entirely on your driving habits and routine maintenance.

Now in your case if you feel that replacing cap bearings, and lifters is good enough, which it very well may be and that's your decision. But why pull a motor apart and replace one thing wihle skipping over the rings, head gasket (plane), cam etc? Why SHIM a lifter when you can replace it for little money? Why shim a lifter when the cam is most likely worn below or near to tolerance? Or better still why SHIM a lifter period? Doesn't that car use a pushrod system? I thought it was an OHV not an OHC?

A full recondition makes a lot more sense to me, not a full rebuild but at least a proper reconditioning before buttoning it up again.

by dhcdbd

1. Compression test reveals no compression problems, thereby indicating no ring sealing problems or valve seating problems.

2. The ga16de engine that this car has uses solid lifters driven by dual overhead cams, solid lifters need shimming not replacement to correct for wear unless the camshaft is excessively worn. The camshaft is withing specs.

3. the milage is at a point where prudence indicates checking the wear on the mains. This requires removing the oil pan and the main caps and then checking with plastiguage.

4. The principle is de-minimus work, not replacing parts that do not need it. This is one of the things that was drilled into me repeatedly during my apprenticeship so many years ago.

5. The ga16de is known for two things: high oil consumption without burning oil, and 300k miles before partial rebuild is needed under normal maintenance conditions. You check the timing chain at 80,000 (it is withing spec at 173k, check front oil seal at 60k to 80k intervals [in my case, when the seal was replaced I sleeved the crankshaft rather than replace it or the harmonic balancer, both equally effective solutions to the groove that a worn seal creates]) you check lifter clearance at 60k to 80k.

6. The solution that you propose is analogous to tearing out the walls in your home and replacing all the wiring because a wall socket is defective. It does not make sense. Just replace the defective socket.

As a side note: a few years ago the ECU on this car failed. Because I wanted a warranty on the ECU I took the car in to a mechanic along with my work notes in isolating the problem. The dealer wanted to replace almost everything that had anything with engine performance. I walked out. I located a mechanic that agreed in writing not to charge for anything that did not require replacement, gave him my notes. He replaced almost everything that had anything to do with engine performance. In the end it cost me $600 for a new ECU and he ate almost $1200 in parts that did not need replacing such as MAP sensor, O2 sensor, anti knock sensor, and temperature sensor. Once the ECU was replaced all those problems were determined to be due to a faulty ECU. I determined the problem before hand by replacing the MAP sensor and then checking the ECU voltages.

by oz_media

Obviously teh government will consider ANY truck used for work purposes as a commercialvehicle. My EXPLORER is a commercial truck by governmnt standards, however by personal insurance standards it is a WAGON and not even a truck at all. Use it for business purposes and require commercial plates to park and move around downtoan and it is a commercial vehicle.

Again though, I welcome you to start an individual thread simply asking, by listing a group of specific models, which are considered lightweight, which are considered full sized and which are considered commercial trucks. You obviously couldn't pull it off and BS that many people though.

by jdclyde

I clearly said my life situation changed over the last 10 years, changing what my vehicle NEEDS are.

And I didn't bash Europe, just asked a question that I didn't know the answer of.

And no, not everyone NEEDS the vehicle they have.

The same can be said for European sports cars, do you NEED to be able to go +160mph? Do you NEED to go zero to 60 in X seconds?

Do people NEED blahblahblah.

Always get sick of when people pick and choose what OTHERS "need" or don't. Like many other things, when you start bitchen about your neighbors lawn, he will bitch back about your garage or whatever.

by oz_media

That was over 30 years ago. I had a rock solid Charger and a die hard Cougar and a killer Cuda too, but then we saw the 1980's and then we saw the 1990's and now we see bankruptcy.

by oz_media

If you are happy with tha for a reply, you go for it.

When you decide to figrue out what I had said, why you piped in and why you got the reply you did, then you may have a worthy comment.

by jamesrl

My paycheck is not tied to one manufacturer or another, unlike the guys on the line. I'm concerned about the health of the industry as a whole. So you don't care about your paycheck and the health of the business segment you are in?

As for allpar, I'm familiar with it from my years of owning and constantly repairing my Intrepid. I give it alot more credence than Yahoo answers where there is no come back. The wiki listing also confirms it.

I'm no fan of government intervention, I wish it wasn't necessary, and I know we will take a bath over it in taxpayers dollars. But have you considered at all what would happen to the economy if both GM and Chrysler just failed, and then many parts makers fail. In Canada alone thats hundreds of thousands of jobs. What will that do to confidence in the stock market? Will that give consumers confidence to go spend money? I can survive with a lowered paycheck, but the cuts to our company's staff and the impact that has are huge.

James

by oz_media

"So you don't care about your paycheck and the health of the business segment you are in?"

not particularly, if the bottom falls out and there are no more homes built anymroe, c'est la vie, I'm not a one trick pony I'll do something else. I get bored too easily to rely on any particular industry for my livelihood.

"from my years of owning and constantly repairing my Intrepid"

No need to say more about such a great American car.

as for your links or disqualification of my own, I couldn't give a rat's.

I am a technician, I have removed a Mistubishi engine from an Intrepid and replaced it with a used Mitsubishi engine from an Intrepid. Link 'til your little heart is happy, it makes no difference nor does it validate your claims.

Chrylser/Mitsubishi collborated on many cars and built many engines together, MOST were used in Chryslers as Mitsubishi and Hyundia rarely used teh engiens they developed together with Chrysler. Chrysler may rebrand them in Ontario, down the street where your friends worked and confirmed that they installed only Chrysler deisgned and engineered motors. However I have seen many with Misubishi motors and support systems and not one with a fully Chrylser badged engine of support system in it.

OU simply cannot change or argue that, I have seen it and spent a lot of time repairing their garbage. You may also want to note the formidable list of "Chysler/Mistubishi" 2.7L engines that have entire websites decidcated to them full of PO'd owners too.

I suppose all those owners are simply wrong for not reading Wiki before they looked under the hood too.

"the cuts to our company's staff and the impact that has are huge"

And you thought that the industry was stable and guaranteed for how long? Just like teh guy who says he is irreplaceable in teh office, who comes in one day to see his desk filled by someone else.

by maxwell edison

1. I have a 22 year old 4x4 Chevrolet pick up with over 200k miles (one that was 6 months old w/10k when I bought it). It's still going strong, and I'll probably put another 100k - 200k on it before it's over. Hands down, it's one of the most dependable vehicles I've ever owned.

2. The government didn't bail-out GM to bail-out GM. They did it to bail-out the union membership that was working at GM.

3. The government didn't bail-out GM, they nationalized the company.

4. They should have let them fail - period - not given them a dime, and let the chips fall where they may - unionized chips, corporate chips, and otherwise.

by oz_media

Your Chevy runs great, the government didn't bail out GM, they helped the union and that costs you a lot less as a taxpayer and means that GM builds a great product line and has earned the right to stay in business.

I agree they don't deserve a dime. Just like ANY other company big or small, you live in a country built upon capitalism. THIS is not capitalism though. They are beaten out by fair competition in their own market segment, they lose.

Unfortunately it seems that this stupid fear/loathing of "the Japs" has not really gone away since the mid 20th century but it has changed it's face a bit. There's no way a Japanese company should be able to win over a US auto market, but of course the opposite is faiir game.

by sleepin'dawg

The fact that their QA and QC are extremely poor just adds to the problem. Your old truck might be a keeper but would you want to bet that it wasn't built on a Monday or Friday??

The politicos took one look at the employee numbers and figured they didn't want to have them voting against them come the next election. Would Obama have been so quick to offer bail out dollars if he were in his second term of office? I seriously doubt it but right now he is running for that second term.

Or am I just too damn cynical.

[i][b]Dawg[/i][/b] ]:)

by j-mart

Because Ford has had a long and committed approach to motor sports, for example, several times winners of World Rally Championship, they have had a big advantage over GM and other US Manufacturers when it comes to making good small / medium size cars. The technology and knowledge gained from this form of motorsports has always been used by the Auto Manufactures involved to advance their production models.

by oz_media

I just don't know where. Probably in a different part of the thread, someone's gonna get all PO'd and think it means something entirely different i guess.

Actually you have a good point, Ford has doe very well in motorsport over the years, as did Chrysler in the 70's or Honda and Ducatti do for motorcycle racing.

Ford also runs C.A.R.T. cars too as well as powerboats etc. pretty diversified.

Honda even has a CART team, though never expected to win a single race, they iddn't even hire a decent driver at first. It was strictly a wasy to test parts and steering innovations in a real world setting. They blow up and don't finish races often but that's not their goal, their goa lis real time testing in high performance conditions, what a buzz of a job that would be.

"You don't have to win, just go out there and fly around until it quits."

by oz_media

Ford has a plant in the UK, they build different cars than those built in North America, with a few similar models but also soem that are very different.

UK models have far more engine options and driver preferences than our own, a far greater selection.

A Ford Focus starts at a base of 11,995 UK Pounds MSRP. Converting that to US dollars, depending on teh variance in daily rates, you are lookign at about $19,600 US dollars.

The Ford US MSRP for the base Fusion is $19,270.00 so they are almost the same price.

That same UK car in Canadian dollars would cost: $23,313.00

The Canadian MSRP for a base Fusion is : 21,449.00

So there is a difference of about $2,000.00

Where is this horrific gap you speak of for "converting" to right hand drive?

They are actually engineered as right hand drive and built wihting teh UK as right hand drive, what coversion took place taht cost so much more that it becomes unappealing?

Despite a grat slump, the top selling cars in the UK?

TOP 10 SELLING CARS IN THE UK - APRIL 2009

Ford Focus: 8,974
Ford Fiesta: 8,395
Vauxhall Corsa: 7,808
VW Golf: 4,814
Vauxhall Astra: 4,549
Vauxhall Insignia: 3,262
Peugeot 207: 3,136
Audi A3: 2,439
Ford Mondeo: 2,356
Vauxhall Zafira: 2,140

Neil, wih Ford holding the top 2 slots for new car sales, it kinda debunks the 'nobody buys American cars' issue doesn't it?

I agree nobody wants a Caddy or F-250, or even an Impala for that matter, but subcompacts seem pretty popular as always.

on teh flipside I agree that until mroe recently American cars have been avoided like the plague.

I rembemer in the summers right before Cowes week, we used ot get Americans who would ship their cars into the IOW and park them in teh car park behind our house. These were not yoru ordinary Americans cars but big Cadillacs with the US flag painted on the roof, flashy mags all shined up and sheepskin interiors. (tacky as all hell!)

At that time, American cars were just a laughign stock, for some reason these guys would spend lots of money to park their cars on UK soil where they got laughed at all day.
You never saw an owner drive hem they just sat in the parking lot for a week or so then were trailered out again. (yeah, smart, I know) :p

But the American companies building in Europe these days have a somewhat different line up than we do here, a much more comprehensive set of choices, engine sizes, trim packages etc.

We just get base econobox garbage that does nothing or top of the line econobox garbage full of bells and whistles that break.

by oz_media

1) Compression is okay MAY mean rings are sealing properly, could also mean rings are embedded and not flexing with the taper, how do you know where the compression if from? top or bottom of stroke? It says VEry little regarding valve seats though, you would need to do a leakdown test for that.

2) Even with a DOHC "shimming" is cutting corners ( I hav yet to see someone justify shimming a lifter or even bothering to do so to begin with), why not just replace faulty lifters? You can do so with compressed air and a pickle fork, it only takes minutes and costs little for a much greater end result.

3) You said replace main bearing caps, not platiguage them. if they needed raplacing as well as lifters and other work like water pump, oil pump etc. It's a lot easier to bench the motor than do an in car, you know that though. that's what they teach you in fourth year, when and when not to pull it.

4) not replacing parts when they don't need it? That would probably be why I recommended a recondition (not rebuild) of all worn parts, Plane a head, replace teh gasket, reseat teh valves, new rings bearings and gaskets, you know the $150.00 rebuild kit, not the full pull.

6) YOU are so far off base, as you are suposedly a mechanic and know better, why would you not see teh difference between a rebuild and a reconditioning? Why would you feel it easier to do such repairs in car and nto just pull it and do it all in less time and with less effort?

So yuo beat out a guy who you thought scammed you? Don't get teh point of that part though, perhaps proof of something I haven't said either?

by dhcdbd

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=311297&messageID=3096742

Me:"check and if needed spin in over sized main bearings"

All solid lifters are shimmed in some form, whether via valve adjustment set screw, or shims. In this case shimming is what is done at the factory, therefore in checking and perhaps correcting valve lash shimming is what is called for.

If a cylinder holds over 120 LBS of pressure at my altitude, then it does not matter because the valves are sealing as are the rings. Therefore that is a moot issue.

You ask why not replace faulty lifters? The point is addressed above, but again. The manufacturer of the motor (Nissan GA16DE) shims the lifters at the factory because of manufacturing variances involved. The factory recommends shimming or checking the valves every 60 to 80k miles. Why do they do so? The shims are of a softer metal than the camshaft and they are primarily what wears. Nissan, for this car, manufactures 50 sizes of shims just for adjusting valve lash.

No, I did not beat out the guy who I took my car to when I wanted the ECM replaced. He got his money back. What happened is that based on knowledge of computers and experience with cars I diagnosed the car independent of the on board OBDC1 based upon reading the code and replacing what the OBDC indicated was wrong. When that part was replaced and the OBDC indicated that the new part was bad, I used my head, experience and knowledge to look for a common issue to the problems indicated. It would be extremely rare for all the performance (read emissions) parts to fail at the same time. This in turn led to checking voltages at the ECM (computer). When those voltages read incorrectly, I built a module that interfaced with the ECU and overrode the settings selectively via laptop until I isolated the problem. If you wish, I will take photo's of the module and email them to you; you can tell the module is hand built because it is bread boarded on perfboard and because the port connection is cut off paper clips that were inserted into the port slots. I used Nissan's DataScan program as the controlling program for the laptop. This professional mechanic assured me that he had the proper tools and equipment for the job. I simply took a proactive approach and refused to pay for unneeded repairs or replacement parts; which by the way is common in the auto world.

You wish to speak of cylinder wall runout? Then, of course, you must know that the only ways to correct that are to either replace the block or bore it because honing is not the correct solution.

You, of course, also know that if you remove an aluminum head, then you are virtually guarantying that you will have to mill it.

Then, of course, you know that if a cylinder holds compression that the cylinder is not leaking via the valves when they are seated.

You know, again of course, that there is only one way to check for main bearing wear and that that is with plastiguage; that this is what is done at the dealer and what any Chilton's or Mitchell's, and the dealers service manual will tell you. A micrometer in this application is useless. Why? because when you untorque the main the crankshaft drops and a micrometer will only inform you of the wear on the bearing and not that of the crankshaft, but the plastiguage gives you both in one shot.

The difference between the specialist and the generalist is that the generalist knows more and more about about less and less until he knows everything about nothing. This was the purpose of this thread, not to argue the specifics of repairing a car.

To leave you with one question: how is it easier to remove three motor mounts, 16 transmission mounts, all the fluid, vacuum hoses, and the hood of the car and then lift the motor out of the car to do the work out of car than it is it is to remove 16 bolts each on the oil pan and valve cover and 8 on the main caps to do up the work in car?

by tonythetiger

[i]But you lay the majority of the blame on "lazy union people" all the time. A) Not all union people are lazy/take advantage of union rules, and B) if everyone in a union was lazy like you imply, none of those cars would have gotten made.[/i]

There were just more of them than there was work to keep them busy. In the early 60s, UAW members staged numerous sick-outs and work slowdowns to protest the implementation of robotic assembly line. In theory, tens of thousands could have been let go, but because of union tactics (the above plus some not-so-nice tactics like intimidating management employees and in some cases even threatening their families!) robotics were delayed, and where they were implemented not as many workers were displaced as should have been. Upwards of a third of auto workers had little or nothing to do, and they got used to this, and when they retired, the union again used their threats to make sure the retiring do-nothings were replaced.

(mis)Management's part was bad too, don't get me wrong, but their biggest mistake by far was caving to the union in the 60s, 70s, and 80s. If they hadn't, there would have been a little pain, spread over decades, instead of a lot in 2008 and 2009; there would be fewer retirees needing supported, and today's cars would be 25% cheaper and a larger share of the market.

The robotics, and the UAW's resistance to them, started the ball rolling, however.