...does it make sense for Toshiba to pursue a law suit for brand image? I agree, Sony screwed up and it seems like they should pay anything that can be quantifiably related to their massive blunder. But, I don't think it makes good business sense for Toshiba to pursue other damages based on a perceived hit to their brand image. Here's why:
1. If Toshiba's brand image suffered due to the battery recall, it would be better to get the issue behind them as quickly as possible. Dragging it out will just cause greater damage to their brand image.
2. Because these batteries were used in many computer manufacturers' computers, Toshiba did not suffer a real hit to their brand image. If they had been the only ones who had batteries recalled, then I could see it, but because it also affected Dell, Apple, Fujitsu, and others, I think anyone who thinks about the problem will see the problem as Sony's and not Toshiba's.
3. The fact is, for all the stupid things that Sony has done, they seem to have stepped up here, taken responsibility for the batteries and are working closely with manufacturers to get them replaced timely. Of course this makes good business sense for Sony for a number of reasons, but it makes it much harder to prove Toshiba's claim.
4. I may have a differing opinion than others affected by this recall, but I have a Dell notebook that had one of the recalled batteries. Because it took much less time to get the battery replaced than they said, it really just didn't make any difference to me at all. In fact, it was kind of nice to get a new battery after a little over a year of use. It seems to perform better too. I certainly do not have any hard feelings toward Dell over this deal. I will likely purchase another notebook from Dell when the time comes. My point here is that if there is any brand image suffered, it may not be because of Sony's batteries because recalls happen and they seem to be handling this one pretty well. But if Toshiba is not handling the logistics of the recall itself very good, this could be the cause of the decline toward brand image. That would be a result of poor customer service and poor contingency planning (not saying theirs is bad, just that a hit to brand image might be due to these things).
I don't have any bias for or against any of these companies. If Sony's battery problems were a result of trying to cut corners, then hopefully Sony is learning a valuable lesson. But from a business standpoint, it seems like it would be better for Toshiba to replace the batteries quickly and seamlessly and then get it behind them. Instead it seems like perhaps they are claiming a hit to brand image that just doesn't exist in an effort to increase their cash flow. And if that is the case, they may really suffer a hit to brand image. In the long run, that could cost more than any money they can get out of Sony now. This is why I say they need to drop it.