Discussion Locked

Unobtrusive employee monitoring

0 helpful
218 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am looking for a tool that I can put on the monitor port, or somewhere on my server switch segment, that can "unobtrusively" monitor the behavior of the employees. I don't want to see individual emails. I am looking for general trends type information (employee X uses web X% of the time, email x% of the time, etc.). Ideally, it will give me some sort of clue when they come into the office in the morning (cause everyone works on computers all day) and when they leave in the evening.

I have a problem with most of the tools out there. I don't want to see the detail of their conversations, etc. I just want raw, high level numbers. In addition, I don't want to install anything on their computers. If the employees found it (technology company) there would be a riot.

Any suggestions that you have would be appreciated.

William

218 replies

by dc guy

You don't manage people by observing the amount of time they spend at their desks or the amount of time they spend on breaks using the web. You manage people by observing what they produce. Timeliness, quality, cost, etc. That is a no-brainer.

The style of management you're describing is from the pre-industrial era, when all most people could put into their jobs was physical strength and endurance. Even in the Industrial Era, especially after the introduction of the assembly line, coordination and concentration became important; that's the reason the 40-hour week was established.

In the post-industrial era, creativity and autonomy have become key traits. You don't get those with MBSP (Management By Spying on People).

The prevalence of MBSP, decades after it became downright counterproductive, is the reason most Americans still have to "go to work" every day even though they all have computers, webcams, and telephones right in their own homes. Their bosses simply don't have the training, attitude, and in many cases the sheer people skills, to be able to manage people they can't physically look at. Even though today most of their work is not visible.

The time that the average American spends driving, parking, taking care of their car, schlepping their children to day care, coordinating schedules with their spouse, and just "getting ready for the office" adds up to at least two hours a day of lost time. Add to that the drain on energy and morale plus the health impact of divorces, children raised with little parental contact, and a steady diet of convenience food, and you've got a much bigger "productivity" problem than how much time an employee spends reading the news or buying his own dog vaccines online because he hasn't got time to go to the vet.

I suggest you concentrate your own creative energy on something more appropriate than reinventing the timeclock. Facilitate telecommuting in your own firm, take whatever training you seem to require to be able to manage employees you can't physically see, and watch productivity and quality soar.

by wflanagan

...but see, this is the problem that I have. I work in that type of an environment. And, in that environment, as people come in at 11am and leave at 2pm, you begin to lose whether they are working 40 hours a week. In addition, because they are all "consultants" and build the schedule, i'm not sure if they're sandbagging their time so that they don't have to work so much. And, my manager doesn't think that people are working 40 hours a week.

So, I need to justify that they are. The current solutions pry into their privacy. I don't want or need that. I just need to justify that they are substantially working 40 hours a week at least on average.

So, besides any criticisms of my "pre industrial era ways", do you have any meaningful suggestions?

William

I know, it's a matter of trust. But, I have directly been asked to getting 40 hours out of them, and because these folks set their own schedules, I need some sort of checksum to make sure the number of hours they are budgeting is adding up to at least 40 hours of working, on the clock time, on average.

by tony hopkinson

Instead of spying, just put a memo out saying internet access is being monitored.
There are loads of server side tools to monitor what urls are going through a proxy and or a firewall.
In terms of actually turning up just audit log on events.

by tonythetiger

If they're using VPN, logs should be available. I recently used it to get some OT validated. Just basics. Time logged in, time logged out, data transferred.

by mbatty

As they are "consultants" they should be aware that their time = money. In all professions the concept of bookable hours is well understood and timesheets a way of tracking hours spent is a natual result. This is a much more transparent method of time tracking than looking for electronic activity.

Alongside timesheets it is important to have project tracking with key deliverables. Using these two tools you can manage the teams output and understand how long this output takes.

This gives a couple of benefits:
1. You have documentary evidence of actviity
2. you have management informantion that can form the basis for informed discussions with team members.

I would say this would form a better overall soltuion for measuring productivity and demonstrating the value of the team. Using these tools and keeping it open with your consultants will improve the level of trust between management and employee.

Good luck.

by myron_s

I suppose it depends on the job being done, but in some cases I think you're out of touch mate.

I'm a system and I.I. administrator where I work and the last thing I want to do is watch the clock. I don't care if I work 5 hours a week, 50 hours a week, on demand or anything else.

Wjat maters to me is that the tasks I need to do get done, quality is applied to my work and everyone I serve at the company I work for are happy.

Just now the boss called me with a small problem which I solved with a remote session. Still it did interrupt me crunching into a slice of tasty slive of toast and supping a good cup of coffee.

Sometimes I even decided to have a siesta. I don't have to go to the office unless I need to do something physical, with woyk being 20 minutes deive from my house. By choice I do `usually` go to the office on Monday, Wednesday and Friday to break up the week.

What the main point is I allocate as much time as I need to get the job done and actually, on the odd occasion, burn some post-midnight oil yet I get the job done and I'm still happy. I'm also happy in how much I've saved on the cost of diesel for the car over the months!

You need to encourage the people working for you to get the job done on time and on spec and not to concentrate to put in 40 hours every week. As it is possible to be at the office 40 hours every week, but only put in 5 hours work.

Time to leave the 20th century and recognise the 21st century or simply be left behind.

by rnackerman

If you just need to track when people are there and are not, we use a sign in method. Either the arriving or departing person physically goes by a receptionist that is tracking in and out times or a phone contact is made. Management says the purpose of this is to determine if someone is available for telephone calls or not, but it does boil down to plain old time card tracking. It is easy to implement once people get use to it.

Our hourly employees do use a time clock by requiring our salaried employees to follow this procedure does help track things. There are occasions where someone will be out of the office for business reason and a simple report when they leave of "I have a meeting at Mr. 'X' this afternoon" usually is all that is needed. Management can verify information on Mr X later if needed.

by blayer

If you can't trust the consultants you have then you have the wrong consultants. Secondly, if they are producing the results you want, then there should be no issue with time. One simple way to see what they are doing is ask for a weekly report. However, the bottom line is that if they are producing the results that you (and your manager) expect or want, there should be no issue with time.

by tfazio

I was under the impression these people were salary employees.

If they are contractors then they should be submitting full reports when/prior to sending an invoice with the exact time they are spending on a particular project.

I maintain my own spreadsheet on outside consultants and always confront them with any time that I have jotted down notes of outside phone calls they take or internet research not pertaining to what they are working on.

I guess I consider myself lucky because I can be here listening and scrutinizing their behavior and I don't have to resort to spying.

by technicallyright

I would try using a help desk type software program or just plain old time sheets or work logs. It doesn't have to be to the minute but it would give you a good idea of what's happening.

I have used and would definitely recommend Surf Control to monitor what is going in and out of your network.

People who are sandbagging their hours now will just find another way to do it with what ever you put in place

by aardvarky

I agree. It all seems rather Dickensian, doesn't it?

There ARE better ways to manage work forces, that's for sure. Just because technology makes it possible to monitor people's activity, doesn't mean you have to. Output (quantity and quality) is always going to be the better measure of staff productivity.

The only scenarios I can think of where this kind of monitoring might have some value are:

1) Carrot-impaired

Carrots are better than sticks, but in some parts of the world (mine, for example, is a 3rd world country) sticks are often the ONLY way of getting ANY output from workers.

The majority of workers come to "do a job" because they need the money (yes, I know, that applies to most of us, but read on ...), and see having a job as a right not a privilege. They are not in the least bit interested about the value they add to the organisation (in the 1st world, there is generally an acceptance that this is to some degree important).

In a 1st world technology environment, such as this poster appears to come from, surely the big stick should not be required?!

2) Data analysis

Usage patterns can be useful for performance monitoring, growth planning, etc.

Fraud can also be detected by 'odd' activities at the network level.

Regardless ... your workers WILL find out you are doing this, no matter how sneakily you go about it. If you do not feel it is defensible if they became aware, do not do it! If you feel you have to do it, then be up front about it, and be able to justify to your workers why it is necessary!

by tfazio

I completely agree with this person. It is management ideology such as this that forces independent people to come to work to punch a clock in the year 2005. Take the money they spend on office space and put it into some real healthcare benefits!

by fluidtech

I'm pretty good at my job & I know I can work less hours than some of my co-workers & still get the workload handled (I was recently ill and missed quite a bit of time but no deadlines). Does this mean it's OK for me to sandbag my time slips?

I don't think so.

I agree with most of your points though, I just don't think it's quite so black & white.

by firstpeter

While, in concept, that's a good policy, it REQUIRES a foundation of trust to be there before it will work. If there is no trust in the relationship (perhaps the employees are new; perhaps there is a perception of "slacking"; whatever the reason the trust isn't there) the "you just get the job done" principle doesn't work.

Trust is a 2-sided relationship, so in no way can you put it all on management. To do so assumes that the employees are all doing what they're supposed to be doing when they're supposed to be doing it; something you don't know (because the original poster didn't say they were). In fact, based on the original post I'd say there is some breakdown on that side of the trust coin (the employees), as well.

Incidentally, to your point that there are other productivity concerns to worry about (divorce, fast food, etc.) - right on, but completely irrelevant to the poster's question. They have control over activities in the workplace; they do not have control (to a material degree) over what goes on at home. You can only manage what you can control.

NOW. All that being said, I think you're right on for the most part if there's an established basis for trust in the workplace. Micro-managing people is not the way to go, and there's a reason there would be a riot (as the poster noted) if they discovered they were being managed.

But in this situation it appears that management has a reason to suspect that things are not being done as they should, and as a result something needs to be done.

by chaos-x

I think the monitoring usage is a great idea for several reasons. But there has to be some guidelines for it so it's used in a productive way and not just as a way for a manager to get rid of the birght, hard-working guy who spens 5 minutes a day checking sports scores. And you need to show the big picture.

So have all usage and all salaries posted along with billable hours. This way the guy who is busting his ass can go in to his manager and show just cause for a raise. And the flip side? It lets the stockholders see how much the CEO is really doing to help the company. The stockholders are the owners aren't they? I'm sure upper manangement would never agree to such terms which should tip you off that they really aren't doing this to help the business across the board.

by homer4598

You know, I tend to agree with you, however, there are many many people who take advantage of trust. I could point out hundreds of examples in the government sector (being in the DC area myself) alone.

I recall in the past year instances were companies installed GPS tracking in their vehicles and found the crews out screwing around and not working.

I'm not a big fan of monitoring people -- I hate it in fact; however, sometimes there is a necessity.

by mr l

Very nice utopia you live in, DC Guy...but you certainly don't manage large groups in a large company. Trust is wonderful...absolutely, no question. But if you are being paid to do job, and hired/retained with an expectation of NN hours/week-day, then your employer most certainly can and will track, at some level, whether or not you are holding up your end of the bargain. The OPs request for high level monitoring is simply an adjunct to the existing monitoring. That being the monitoring done by team leads/managers/supervisors...and peers. Yes, peers! "Hey Boss, whyinhell can DCGuy come in at 10 and leave at 2 every day, do no more work than anyone else here, and get away with it??" "I didn't know he was doing that" "Bloody hell, you call yourself a manager and don't when your people are coming and going?"

Face it, nirvana is a nice dream...the OP is asking for practical assistance for the real world.

And, to the OP, assuming you are in a windows world, logging domain logons/logoffs should be a very simple solution for you at a high level.

by mobrien

Yeah, I feel like I am reading the collective works of Socialism by Karl Marx. Reality unlike Utopia often calls for Managers to deal with real problems like apithetic employees.

by gigs

Having read your comments, at first, I thought you were coming across as rude. But upon taking in the whole gist of your comments, I think they are great. You should seriouly consider running for president upon this platform. You would win in a landslide.

by fryque

Why can't a tech ask a question without getting a sermon? There are many reasons to monitor bandwidth usage. Get off your soapbox and answer the question!

by russell.sivyer

It may be a bit more functionality than you require, but certain software asset mgmt tools should give you the results you're looking for - like the one I work for!!!

by stdreamer

In most of the companies I have worked (developer) there is a CRM package which is used by the personel to login how they spend their work day. Each task completed must be logged in along with the time it took, a description of the problem, the solution presented, the customer, the product and a number of other informations which are specific to every company.

This has been presented to us as a knowledge base which we coold use to ask questions for common problems and situations.

It is used primarly for time schedule control by the company but we do get some value out of it as well so we can't complain really we just don't like the extra work required by us to keep this base up to day.

by gadgetgirl

It's a minefield out there. I don't know where you're from, but here in the UK, we have strict laws on the type, amount and justification for monitoring.

We have to get by such laws as the RIPA Act, Human Rights, EU Privacy & Monitoring Directives, and a whole raft of employment laws.

Because of this, most UK firms have a statement build in to the Terms and Conditions of Employment to state that we WILL retain and preserve the right to monitor all internet usage, howsoever used, by all members of staff.

Doing monitoring without their knowledge (or implied knowledge) is classed here as a covert operation, which brings yet more laws into the fray. Not the least of which is the above EU one, which states that unless justification is sufficiently proven, we can not, under any circumstances, look in a folder which the member of staff has denoted as "Private" or "Personal" in his/her documents.

As I said, it's a minefield. Having worked on this type of thing (specifically) for around 7 years, I do know a few legal work arounds, but evidence collection per se must be kept to the letter of the law.

I agree with the others who have posted - tell them what you're doing, but not why. That at least gives them a chance to clean up their acts before you start the real work.

oh - and just be careful if you're dealing with consultants. Their terms and conditions can vary widely when it comes to the law.

Hope this helps

GG

by compliance dude

This solution helped our company a ton, has very unobtrusive reporting and alerting. Monitors url's and IM and gives very robust reporting. From what I understand they are coming out with e-mail as well. Our representitive was Matt Carey. I suggest you give them a call.

by mwrmwr

my 3 cents:
For assessing resource requirements, peaks and blatent abuse of resources - this is a worthwhile exercise IMHO, so go ahead and then proceed cautiously [legal and resource-wise as indicated in other postings] on follow-up actions when info gathered.

on the otherhand...
Seems like you are being dumped in the firing zone by your boss; adopt appropriate sloping shoulder techniques when informing [you MUST inform end users] that metrics are being gathered.

Expect the automation of <> to be a high priority development - hey, why not register a cost-code for the activity ;-} to please the damn fool accountant brain that spaked this off. When I started work ['72] I was not impressed by the "jacket on the back of the chair" and "walk round carrying a piece of paper" techniques of the entrenched staff, and I wouldn't be impressed by the CPU or network access patterns of anyone. Still, if "hours on-site" and "looking busy" satisfies your masters, more fool them.

by dman02151

I work at a large insureance company and we use a tool that monitors all computer usage. The purpose of using this tool is to understand application utilization to help us in making decisions about purchasing new licenses, software upgrades and maintenance. We have saved millions of dollars by using the information to help in negoitations for maintenance and upgrades. It also allows us to move software licenses around to those poeple who need them and lets us avoid purchasing new licenses. You may want to use this reasoning as a way to get your employee's to "buy in" to the monitoring. Our IT policy states that we do monitor all activity on the network. We do not use the tool to look at content of emails. If you only want to monitor email and Inet usage that should be fairly easy from a server. However to get the whole picture and the detailed information you are asking for you may need a client piece installed. As long as the employees are informed and understand you are trying to save money with the tool they may go along with the idea.

by michael professional

The very fact that the employees would riot if they knew what you were doing indicates to me (a manager) that you or someone "over you" is out of line. Management is paid to know what its employees do and that they are working gainfully to meet the objectives set forth my them. You sound like a snoopy techie who didn't get the job in law enforcement or investigation/intelligence that you wanted.

I would not want to work with a person like you who feels the need to snoop on other employees when it may be You who is spending way too much time on Ebay or wherever you go on the Web.

by djameson

I recommend implementing a solution without alerting your offices general population. Keep the solution to as few people as you possibly can, to establish a baseline. IT WILL SHOCK AND AMAZE YOU! how much time is being wasted surfing the internet during company time. We implemented a WEBSENSE solution covertly. Then after establishing a baseline told the employees that we were implementing it. They were resentful at first, but when we did the math we were losing ~2 hrs/day/employee times 140 employees at an average of ~$18/hr thats $5000/day in lost time, that doesn't even count lost productivity. Download the trial version of websense and turn it loose, It will tell you whether you need a permanent installation

SA-

by derksens

I have mixed feelings on this topic to be sure. I agree with some of the early posts that tracking "hours" seems very draconian and in fact speaks to a larger problem with staff motivation. If management feels that the consultants are padding the hours, fire a couple and watch the others step up. If you track hours, most anyone can find a way to login to the system in order to provide what you are tracking. You will need more detail to prove or disprove the management theory that there is a problem - so if you do it, you had best do it all the way.

My strongest suggestion is to figure out why management has cunsultants that are not accountable for a result instead of defending hours. If there is a problem with the results (which there seems to be) get rid of the least productive ones and see what happens. Most people in this era want more from a career than to punch a clock - and our companies often let the good employees down by setting a precedent by allowing the underperformers to thrive, usually demotivating the ones that would really engage if it was really expected.

Your management team needs to get out of their comfort zones and deal with a little bit of short-term conflict in order to make this better.

Cheers!

by tonythetiger

of employee performance.

Some people work faster than others. Are you paying the faster employee more per hour than the slower one? Assuming you're not, if one employee gets done a half-hour before the others, why does it matter if they spend a half-hour surfing the web, or talking on the phone, or whatever?

by cq_west

Most companies require their employees to sign an acceptable use document of some kind before allowing them access to a workstation. Many times, the document points out that it is the right of the company to evaluate and plan for better usage of any of their assets, including internet browsing. As a manager, you should know that personal browsing on company time costs the company money, not the employee.

Several organizations I work for use SurfControl Web and Email filtering software to simply evaluate how much time is being spent on the internet. There are some employees who's job requires them to use the internet almost exclusively, and you can filter out their "job related" internet activity from their "personal related" internet activity. The other nice thing is that the software monitors all internet traffic transparently without any software installed on the client workstations. The firm I work for has been using this software for several years now and we have found it to be some of the best for both general monitoring/blocking and for detailed reporting (when needed).

by paul

If you have nothing to hide and do your work as per pay, why get all excited about monitoring. You are monitored anyway. In many places you don't even suspect. It all comes down to common decency and work ethics. Besides the guy didn?t ask for your comment, he asked for help. If you can?t help keep silent.

by glenp5

There are times you have to resort to "spying on your employees" . If they are using company equipment for personal use and not being productive and the only way you can prove that it is through the use of some type of monitoring software so be it . I am responsible for 15 people and as long as we achieve our goals and meet all of our deadlines then we can "play".

by yeoman

I have read all the discussion with some amazement and agree with derksens. I found it offensive that one contributor indicated that in a ?3rd world? country this covert monitoring would be necessary. I have worked in three ?3rd world? countries as well as in Australia and NZ and worked with people from Britain and the USA and other (1st world) countries. In my kind of work (IT) I have found that the 3rd world staff worked the hardest, both in terms of hours and application. The worst was in Australia where one worker insisted on taking his monthly ?sickie? (sick day off) regardless of his health. And treated me with derision because I would not emulate him. And he used to log on when he came to work and disappear for hours, so the ?logged on? time was meaningless. The other problem was with consultants who spent the whole day on the telephone making personal calls (I was also a consultant sitting next to them).
I cannot see how you can get away with covert monitoring, as it is now illegal in many countries and I cannot see what the monitoring will achieve (do you have people who do not log off at night?) Where I worked we had open monitoring. Across the board monitoring of emails and internet access. In one department we wrote our own application monitoring to assess the usage of different business applications.
As a project manager I would recommend clear definition and estimation of tasks for all, including consultants. Everyone would have a list of what they need to achieve and the estimated time effort. The consultants will submit their estimates and you or your manager assess and agree to or vary the estimates. Put this into some tool like MS Project using a 40-hour week and that tells you what each person is expected to achieve and when. Get each one to complete timesheets as well as submit reports on what they have achieved. Your management should be monitoring the outputs and yes, get rid of those who are not getting the results!

by keith.desilva

We use Websense and not only can you report on usage but block unappropriate sites from the general user. This will remove the temptation from people, if you can't see how your team did last night you won't try and continue working.
I am not 100% in agreement with Timesheets, the issue with timesheets is that anyone can put anything down and present it to you. I worked 4 hours on a project but little results. It is hard to track people's time unless you are watching them the whole time, as commented before you should not have to watch people if the work that they produce is on time and of quality. If these slip then by all means you should watch them more closely.

by jasmith

Buy yourself a laptop and get the software called Little Brother. Set a switch port to monitor your telco port that your t1 is plugged into. You will capture everything coming across. You can set filters to ignore your inhouse trusted site. This really works. Have documented acces to porn sites and the staff just resigned. It captures on IP adress so if you are DHCP, you need to have other monitoring or recording methods to not falsely track an ip to a user. Need to record MAC info as well. It is not cheap but does the job. Also, put the responsibility for this in you security officer ot chief lan administrator. Cuts down the flack in a grievance.

by adnikauto

And what else....Would you like to know what I had for breakfast, what I sheet out and how many times I had sex??? If I know you had install anything like that on my network I would kick your ass... and fire you, not from job but fire you to the MOON!It's a right place for guys like you!!!
Adam N. network administrator

by firstpeter

Before one spouts off about Orwellian Time one should probably make sure one has read Orwell's writings and understands them.

There is absolutely nothing Orwellian about the issue on this one. We're not talking about an invasion of privacy unless you're going to argue that you have a right to privacy while on the job and at the workplace. If you're going to walk down that slippery slope that's probably a different thread (and a short one - you don't have privacy at work, plain and simple).

What this poster is looking for is a way to monitor the employees activities. The issue isn't even the content (although that's certainly a legit concern, as well) but instead amount of time spent on a particular activity. I struggle to see how this is an out-of-line request. I won't argue that monitoring is the best approach, but there's nothing illegal, immoral, or unethical about it at all.

Orwell, on the other hand, spoke of the government playing "big brother" to the extreme - a complete lack of privacy.

There is, and should be, a big difference between COMPANIES and THE GOVERNMENT, just as there is a big difference between Orwell's writings and the poster's solution.

by johanv

....tend to complain about being monitored. My suggestion is to implement a solid Internet/E-mail policy and then implement monitoring software that goes right down to who visited which web-site. This would cover any legalities around monitoring (please search the Internet for articles of where companies where held responsible for the actions of staff because no policy existed).
Further more, if I had to employ staff, I'd expect the maximum productivity out of them and award them accordingly. I work exceptionally long hours, but at the end of the day I also reap the benefits which I plow back into my home life.
To everyone who exibited the kneejerk reaction and took apart the OP, please realise that business & management is a cut-throat arena and management of IT is a mutli-discipline (legislation, accounts, H.R., business processes, etc.).
To the OP, depending on what network environment you use, try SurfControl (you can configure it for broad range of reporting or specific areas).

by chaos-x

Because it's a cut throat arena we should all just sit back and accept it? On the contrary, we should expect business to act as morally as they expect us to be, maybe more so. We all know the bad that can come out of this type of activity and we all know how it's application is selectively used. Your line of thinking justifies spyware, hey, it's a cut-throat world out there.

by leonmcnamara

We have developed Desktop Auditor as an IT asset management tool. One of our features is software metering where we measure the time an annplcation was open as well as the time that the application was actually in use. eg. start playing sol.exe at 7:30, minimise at 8:00, continue playing at some point for another 30 minutes and close the game at 5:00 - we record that the game was running for 9.5 hrs and was active for 1hr. Our website is www.latitudesoftware.co.za.

by djameson

you can use the software policy in AD and just prevent it. There is no place for games at the office. and it works a little better then most software auditing tools because I can just rename the executable winword.exe and then run it and the software wouldn't know that I wasn't running microsoft word, if there is no MD5 hash of the .exe header.

by paul.beaudoin

Secret monitoring is immoral if not illegal. If what you want is legitimate, be open, explain the purpose (and what it won't be used for). If you can't do this openly, perhaps you should consider if you should be doing it at all. Business has a legitimate concern on what the people they are paying for are actually doing however, doing this surreptitiously sows mistrust and rebellion.

by darinhamer

I agree that this isn't the best way to lead people, but you can't be serious. These people are paid for their time and are using company equipment. It isn't secretly spying. It is monitoring. Anyone who has a job should understand that an employer has a right to monitor employees' activity and use of equipment. They aren't living in reality if they see it as spying.

by bob_steel

In my company usage of the internet (including
email) for private use is forbidden. Everything
is logged and monitored (as the law requires).

We provide an unmonitored 'cybercafe' facility
that can be used during breaks and before and
after work by any employee.

I can't say I've ever had a single complaint or
comment about our policy in over 5 years.

Deg.

by avid

sounds like a witch hunt to me. if you are trying to be sneeky about what you are doing, then you will make your workers think that there is a witch hunt going on and that you are immune from the hunt. this will create problems. they will begin to see you as the enemy. if you simply tell them a new policy has been implemented they will be more likely to understand. sure, they may not like it, but if you are upfront with them it will be easier on you than if you get caught sneeking around on the network sniffing their usage stats.

by Member 20632069

If you are merely trying to establish your employees' start and end times, you should already have the data you need for that - your domain controllers' security logs. They will contain each users' login and logout times. Any number of server log analysis tools out there can extract that for you.

Alternately, install card access in your facility. Easily justified on a physical-access control level, and gives you actual on-site time for each person.

Of course, neither of these methods tells you how much of that on-site or logged-in time each person wastes..

by graemedixon

We can do this for you, no matter where you are on the planet; we do it every day.
It's good responsible management practice for many reasons - if you don't manage your network, if you don't know what's going on, before you know it the network will start managing you!
Check out http://www.csintel.co.nz/
Contact me at GD@csintel.co.nz.

Cheers - Graeme

by tpernas

Given that we as Americans have the right to expect a reasonable amount of privacy (thanks to the 4th amendment), you don't have the right to monitor user's activity. The exception to this is, if you have a banner that states that users agree to monitoring by signing on to the network. There should also be a written policy supporting your that as "normal course of business". With this in place your users would have no cause to riot.

by dimbulb

I am one of the most liberal people around but you are Wrong. Whoever owns the network, provides you the access to that network, has every right to know what goes on in that network. If you invited me into your home, would you mind if I re-arranged your furniture, knocked down a wall or two???

by bradley.king

You could get an overall view of the web/mail traffic with the added benefits of reducing their exposure to spam, unproductive sites,indecent material & sites,by using Surfcontrol email & web filter products.

by torstein

Microsoft's ISA Server allows you to monitor web usage by creating reports. With these reports you can see what kind of program that is used to access the Internet and by what computer (name and/or IP adress). This happens on the server, and so the user will not that the Internet behaviour is being logged. However, you should definately inform your employees that there is such a tool running on the server!

by vterm-bbd

We have used Surf Control for several years and it can give you the high level info you want, it also works as a spam filter.

by kraken_

Hi.
I'm REALLY happy NOT to work for you. Your type of management seems to be right out of the 19th century. It may apply to some degree to 1st/2nd sector employees (raw materials and manufacturing) but it definitely doesn't apply to 3rd sector (services). It is a "baseball bat" approach to management and always shows well on paper, but the true cost is often underestimated.

Low employee's morale, high absenteism, need for medication or therapy, commitment to the company and finally a qualified employee quitting the job for (possibly) better heavens add an incredible cost to the operations. you have to keep that in mind.

I've worked under the "stick-type" management and under "carrot-type" management, and frankly, both types lack a certain amount of:
1 - humanity (establishing a BILATERAL TRUST)
2 - idea of the real costs involved

I've also worked with a formidable person, who really cared for her employer's benefits (sometimes more than her employer's himself), and who really cared about her staff. Result: before she got the job, people were rushing out of the company. The company lost a huge lot of very qualified employees. As soon as she got the job, she reestablished trust, checked every employee's felings (what they did, versus what they wanted to do) did some reafectations and morale grew immediately up, productivity soared, people began coming back instead of leaving, and incredible projects were put on the table sand realized in an incredible short amount of time, with happy, overproductive employees.

This is just the contrary of your fire-a-few approach. This type of management doesn't fit in any "durable development" view. Americans (and I mean inhabitants of the American continent) usually focus too much on the short-term, whereas europeans focus more on mid-term, and Japan (well in some parts of Asia) focus on long term.

Being long-term focused is a good approach, but as I said earlier, it's still better to keep a global view; short-term, mid-term and long term. This way you're flexible (short-term) but well organized and have a clear goal (long term), and you take a step-by-step approach to get there (mid-term).

My 2 cents

by mudgie

I believe a good manager owes it to his or her employer to make sure employees are not pi$$ing away valuable company time surfing porno and ebay. Calling this spying is off-base.

That being said, you do owe it to the employees to inform that internet usage can (and will) be monitored. It should be in the form of an addendum to the employee manual, and should include the same message about email.

I have been using Surf-Control with my clients. The first weekend of use resulted in a firing - a security guard had a particularly raunchy pornography habit. He was adept in covering his tracks, but SurfControl kept a running log of his surfing. It was all he did, actually. 8 hours of porno every weekend.

Anyone want to defend him?

by praetorpal

Contrary to the view that one does not have right to monitor employees work due to privacy concerns, Sarbanes-Oxley and other privacy/governance legislation requires monitoring of business processes to ensure accuracy of financial statements. If an access control/auditing product meets thoses needs and can also provide extra performance for forensic use, policy enforcement or whatever, than so be it.

Trustifier can be set up transparently on any Linux server to provide what you want, or as a black box appliance in any non-linux shop.

by homer4598

That's absolutely true, BUT then don't bill for 40 hours. I don't think the point was that these guys are getting the job done and only billing 10 hours a week. The point is that they are billing 40+ hours a week and appear to only be putting in 10 hours per week.

Sure, appearances are deceiving, but often not so much.

by hangin_online

If you don't trust the people working for you/with you/under you, why are they still employed/managed by you? Have you approached the consultants with your/management's doubts? Spying is a gutless way of avoiding confruntation and possably exposing your own inabilities to manage, direct and empower those around you to work hard and honestly.

by jck

about time arrived at work...

If you're in a Windows environment, focus on using logs from the client or server aspect. They are a built-in feature of OS.

If you are going to consider using traffic logging behind their backs, I'd make one suggestion:

Don't.

The minute you start logging productive employees (which are probably your majority) and they find out, their morale and productivity will suffer. Even worse...if you start to do it behind their back, they will start to abhor you. They will think you a sneak.

I can vouch for this. I was a contractor at a multi-state power company writing software for them, and our manager was always writing little emails about "internet use", "office chit-chat", etc. to us (staff and contractors), even though we were meeting or beating our deadlines.

If you have contractors billing for time not in the office, that is one that. That is fraud.

If they are in the office though and meeting schedules set by management, don't give them grief or track their "high-traffic" usage. Only track things like adult websites, gambling sites, etc., or anything prohibited by company policy.

by kraken_

Hi!
I fully agree with you. Time is relevant only if there's a constant between employees. A blowtorch cuts 1-inch steel at a determined speed, so an employee can't rush the job. We are working in a domain where every person has different interests, different forces and different capabilities.

So, I may be faster at programming a bash-script than someone else, or I may be slower at administering an Exchange server than others. Interests and personnal knowledge has to be taken into account when evaluating an employee's "productivity". Sometimes it's the manager's "productivity" (or lack of) that could be in the way of a particular employee.

by david_scott

Hey William,

If you happen to have sonicwalls---Viewpoint is an inexpensive solution which will provide reports on mail,internet,vpn,bandwith,etc use.

If you don't have Sonicwalls, then I would highly recommend Websense. I evaluated it and its much better than Viewpoint but more expensive. If you have remote sites you have to put a "box" (not a pc or server, its sold through websense) at those sites.

With either solution there is nothing to install on user's machines and they won't know they are being monitored unless you tell them (which you should).

I'm surprised that people jumped all over you about internet monitoring with all the security concerns these days. I normally use Experts Exchange if you want to try it the 9.95 membership is well worth it

David

by cfrankel

At home I use a product called PC_Tattle tale, it lets you tailor and block content, record keystrokes, instant messageses, take timed screen shots, an record program usage.

Its perfect, if you want to treat your employees as children use software designed to monitor and protect children.

Or you can trust your hiring process, include employee profit sharing and give "trusted" associates a stake in the operation.

by breadtrk

I'm not working with any of you slackers who want to hide behind some false sense of privacy on my company network.

It is my network, my hardware and I sign the paychecks. You signed an agreement when you were hired that everything you do on my network would be monitored.

Put a policy in place and enforce it. WEBSENSE

by itengineerguy

I have used timesheets. Consultants use them to track their time they spend on a project. This includes research and installation time. Also it included training. This was effective tracking tool. You could use a spreadsheet. Plus the other part of the equation is trust. Trust what them that they are tracking time properly. Simple!!

by slurpee

I suspect that that is similar to what has been done but wflanagan says it is his boss who wants this proven - I would say that wflanagan's boss needs to set parameters on the work - goals, progress reports, deadlines - rather than spying on the employees to see if they are working. After all, I usually come into my office and open e-mail and leave it open all day. When am I using it? Just when I send an e-mail or when I happen to check if there are any in or...?
Good luck wflanagan

by indianacadadmin

As with everyone else, this is IMHO...

We use a corporate version of MSN messenger here. They recently wanted to see how the tool was being used. They had our IT guys pull the logs that are kept and had every line of messages that had been sent since it was implemented. It was pretty embarrassing. My boss had to read through a month's worth of IM's before he was sick to his stomach at the tone of most of the conversations. They also track/record our emails, our internet usage and our phone call logs. Knowing this keeps you pretty honest about what you choose to do, if you care about your job or your reputation at all.

We had abused it pretty badly for a while until they pulled up some specific data to demonstrate to us that it worked and that they knew what was going on. It was given with a silent warning that it would not be tolerated. It had the desired effect. We work now knowing that nothing we do is unobservable.

Some still choose to continue doing what they were and will have no one else to blame when the axe finally falls.

I personally have no issue with being monitored. With all of the legalities companies face for allowing porn to circulate within their email circles and such, it only makes sense these days.

I get paid to work. If I can get the same amount of work done in half the time, then I should do twice the work and expect management to see that and reward it accordingly. If I choose to do half the work just because I can do it quicker than most and still meet the expectations, then I'm a slug and not worthy of drawing a paycheck. That's as offensible as just walking out of the store without paying for something, if not worse. Stealing is stealing.

Here, if we try to visit sites that our internet filter has been programmed to reject, it tells us that the site is blocked because it belongs to such and such a category such as mp3/entertainment/online shopping/etc. If we feel we're being blocked from a site that should be accessible, all we have to do is send our loveable net nazi's an email and they'll investigate it. I've never yet seen fit to do so. :>)

In summary, as a worker who is under such an environment, I think knowing that we are being monitored doesn't foster resentment (except by the ones who would rather get paid for screwing off) and that it is just good business to ensure the tools provided are getting used effectively. I agree with the posts on putting a log in banner up that states clearly that all activity on company resources will be monitored and that violation of corporate policies will be handled in accordance with corporate disciplinary guidelines. That leaves everyone on the same page.

My supervisor likes to state it this way: "I expect everyone to come to do a decent day's work. This isn't meant to be a sweat shop, nor is it a country club. An honest day's work for an honest wage." I respect that.

Again, all IMHO.

by wdoliver

Many of your respondents have good points in being extremely careful when using the term monitoring. Keep in mind system usage is not a good gage. For example I log on and off my computer throughout the day especially when attending meeting. Computer usage is a poor way of verifying time spent on the job.

If I hire someone to specifically produce x,y and z then time is not a concern as long as I am not paying for each hour worked. Example: a fix price contract to produce a tool in x months. I do not care how many hours spent since I will only pay x dollars.

Normally I hire consultants to provide support services and what they produce depends on their labor category and the current organizational priorities. These consultants are hired to provide a maximum of xxx hours and the prime consultant's company is paid for hours worked. If maximum is reached then additional monies and time has to be renegotiated. In this situation I am concerned if they are actually working the hours they report.

Now some suggestions. Keep in mind if you put them in effect it needs to be accross the board not just for a certain segament of the organization eg consultants only, department only,... To further protect yourself you should be open about what you are doing.

[1] First if you do not trust your consultants or staff to accurately report their time I think it is time to think about replacing them.

[2] Second, hold your managers accountable. Your project, section, ..., group managers and leads are suppose to be 'leading'. They should know who is working when and what they are producing. They should also be signing off on timesheets. The first people I would focus upon is not the consultants or staff but the leaders and managers. After all you are paying them more for these responsiblities. Regardless it is obvilous you have some leadership problems.

[3] Not good for morale or personnel retention in the IT field, but another try and true method is using time clocks or automatic logs. IRT logs the policy is employees sign in and out, record off site meetings etc... The automatic log should apply a read only date/ time for the entry. These programs usually work off a repository so various reports can be generated.

[4] Activity Based Costing (ABC). ABC programs have been around for a while so they are mature. Essentially the organizations list activities normally performed for a labor category and organizational element. One of the activities are "other". Personnel logs onto the ABC program each day and identify the amount of time spent on various activities. To be successful the individuals need to be trained in what each activity entails. Do not forget to add internal meetings, external meetings and my favorite adhoc tasking. Yes, they can fudge this as well as the timesheet; however, they will realize that a comparison can be made. The main benefit is when you do summary reports. If you see that your DBAs are spending 80% of their time installing equipment or programming then it is obvilous you need less DBAs and more system support and programming personnel. You may also find that individuals in your department are spending a lot of time doing another department work. It is a great tool for tracking how much time is spent for different activities.

by opuskrocus

In most organizations management knows who is working at substandard levels. Instead of monitoring everyones activities, monitor only the slackers. You can monitor the smtp logs for amount and types of email they send and receive. you can check their temp internet folder for types of sited they access. And as already stated, you can monitor firewall/VPN logs if they access remotely. These things can take little of your time. The allstars don't need your time. Generally, I use that sort of data only when we are looking for supporting data to terminate a serious offender. Their performance usually speaks for itself.

by sgregory217

In addition to blocking inappropriate content, this product can provide high level as well as detailed reporting relative to internet activity.

by mintyboy - it manager

In the company I am IT Manager for we use firewall and Email server software and keep logs of who is doing what, this recently proved usefull for a person who was complaining of being over worked and stressed, but was on MSN Messenger most of the day.
All employees including myself signed our contract of employment in full knowledge that for our industry we have to log all of the emails both in and out and web activity is logged and stored.
Just my 2p worth.
A lurker, listener and learner.

by jerman

You need to first set a policy outlining clearly what is acceptable and what is not acceptable online behavior. Then, instead of skulking in the background, announce that you will be implementing an internet filter such as Websense or Surf Control or somesuch. Them block sites your management team finds not-work related, such as porn or gambling. It's much better to be up-front in your methods rather than putting people on double-secret probation, and settin them up to inadvertantly break rules.

by Member 32186421

A tech company I was once involved with decided to secretly monitor network activity. The superstars just set up ssh tunnels to their own external servers and kept a constant amount of data going across the tunnels - hence no statistically significant data.
Management did not get the point - (its just plain wrong to covertly monitor people) the superstars went else where and the company folded.

by deway2

Well actually you want to have a signed Internet/Network use agreement. Keep it general to cover just about anything. With a proxy server in place there are many options available. I am currently using Spectorsoft CNE, it does not require a proxy server but does install on the clients machine. Unless the individuals were monitoring ports they would not see it, but with personal firewalls, etc... who knows. We use the software to track web usage in an event of a performance problem and also to archive email. We are not required by Sarbanes-Oaxley yet, but better to be proactive than reactive. This software will record laptop user on or off the network, it will also take screen snapshots, record keystrokes, file copys to disk, etc... This is probaly not the solution your looking for but may be a solution if you do not wish to use a proxy server.

by lee.sleeper

We implemented an Internet filtering/traffic management device by Lightspeed. One of the upsides to it is the ability to look at all traffic by IP, port, user, etc. It is transparent to the user, server-based, and gives me the data I need to see what is happening on my network.

by macint2002

www.vericept.com

This solution can provide url filtering and additionally traps and graphs emails, chat, ftp, telnet (both sides) by defined/self-defined categories. As with any log/report system has to be reviewed meaning time will be spent to hone and properly use the system for targeted areas of concern. A reseller should be able to give you a free trial. This is not a time clock device, but monitors compliance with corporate directives which should be the main focus. Some web blockers allow time of use (ie., lunchtime) for employees classified as no-need during business hours. Note: I did have a chuckle when the help desk recieved a call as someones on-line banking would not work to pay their bills when first implemented. As with any solution you are researching find at least three products meeting your needs (within present and future budgets) and evaluate them. Do recommend you give this one at least a look.

by cadman53114

I work for an automation machine manufacturer. We are a small company. All the employees here, hourly and salary physically punch a time card when they enter the building and leave the building. At first, being on salary I was offended by this. But I came to realize that I benefit from this as does the company. First, they know when I arrive and when I leave. Which means when I bill hours to a project I am working on and I put down 2 hours for purchasing, 3 hours for design work, 5 hours for detailing, they cannot come back and say did you really do that? They have the time clock as proof that I was physically here for at least eight hours, usually it is more like 9-10 with 8 hours of actual work. But the time card reflects when I am physically in the building. It sounds like you have contract employees who are billing for hours worked when they are not actually there. If they are telecommunting, they must have to log into your server to access data on the network. There must be some log which shows when they logged in, and logged out.

I know the time card thing is kind of primative and yes, some will be offended at first. But if you tell them in as a group, that management is questioning the time billed versus the time worked, the time card shows management when they are there, and when they are not. With the time card they will not have to worry about management saying "we are not paying for 1/2 of the time you bill because we feel you are not really working." Maybe find some electronic time card where they just punch in an employee code when they enter and when they leave. Then you can use that software. Perhaps you put a keypad on the only door they can leave or enter from which will not open without their pass code. There are time recording tools in simple programs like QuickBooks, which has a simple timer file, you enter your name, a billing code for the project, a project number, click start and it keeps track of the time right on their computer. Granted, they can start the time and walk away for two hours, or surf the net for an hour. But at least there is a record of time, not just their word.

It also comes down to how much does management trust the contract workers. I have worked doing contract environments. I have seen first hand how people bill for time when I KNOW they were not even in the building for three of the five days they are billing for.

Good luck.

by rknrlkid

I work at a school with many individuals who have schedules like you are talking about. The solution the school has come up with has nothing to do with computers, but with tracking. They developed a "Time and Effort" form that enables the management to visually see what the employee is up to. The employee fills it out and submits it at the end of the month. If you would like a copy to look at, send me an email.

by michael.techrepublic

If you are looking at monitoring active browsing sessions then this product (From SurfControl) has a BrowseWatch feature (among others) that would do the trick. NO client to install and totally transparant to the end user.

by lcoone

If your general Information Security policies include a statement that the organization reserves the right to monitor all systems access, including Internet usage, then you provide a means to gather and analyze the traffic. If you choose to use this information to drive behavior, that's your decision. If you use some sort of proxy or firewall, look at Cyfin Reporter from WaveCrest Computing. You may find the level of information you seek in one of the reports.

by shraven

We've all had these concerns with employees. Let's face it, you can't make them work unless you're willing to provide one on one monitoring. You could have every control and monitoring system in the world, but what are you going to do if an employee spends all day just staring into space?
Try a simple forced log off: 30 mins of inactivity logs them off. Then monitor login attempts.
You should be focusing on whether they are getting their job done. Hours spent don't matter if the work isn't being done. If the employees aren't meeting deadlines either they aren't working and montoring is the least of your problems... or the management expectations are unrealistic and you've got an even bigger problem.

We've done various monitoring schemes and we've tracked phone usage mins, entry card scans etc. In the end even though we had evidence, it didn't help productivity. Any good manager knows without these tools whether their employees are working or not and evidence from these tools doesn't help justify your complaint even in court ((at lease in Michigan, USA.)
What will result is a great deal of stress for you as you attempt to monitor activity and bring the hammer down on slackers. Trust me, I've been there and the only fix was to let the employee go and hire a replacement. (Who turned out to be excellent and all my "issues" vanished!)

by tfazio

It depends. I am paid salary so I don't have to enter time. I was completely honest when I worked in consulting and only put in time that it took me to complete a project. It was what seperated me from a tech that took too long.

So no of course I don't agree that you should overcharge people but if you can get your work duties done in 4 hours vs 8 hours for slower people why should you be penalized for that?

The way I look at it is if you can get your job done in 1/2 the time they will ask you to do more work which gives you ammo when you ask for your next raise ;)

by mobrien

That is why somepeople get paid more than others. I agree with you totally. Just because Employee A is better than Employee B doesn't give him a buy from coming into work. That talent just gives you negotiation power at raise time.
The thing that bothers me about this thread is nobody really seems to be answering the question. The poster is being attacked for asking the question and the thread has been hijacked to "what is the proper way to manage people" It appears that his needs are out of his control and he really cannot "trust" the contractors to report their own time accurately. I was a contractor as well, so I have an interest in this topic.

by johanv

You are obviously missing the point regarding "Business is cut-throat". Let's see how long you stay in business if your staff is unproductive and your business is losing money to a competitor who is actively managing their staff.
I would like to clarify one very important point, if a business purchases a desktop computer for you to use, does that make the said computer your property? No, indeed it does not. I agree with running a business morally, but in my opinion and experience, you have to be firm at the same time and lay down the groundrules of employment (which may change in time due to changes in markets/processes/technologies).
And as it seems you need furhter explaining....I do not agree with monitoring without staff not knowing that it takes place, hence my reference to having a policy in place. And hence my opening line, if you feel threatned that your e-mails (property of the business) & internet usage (property of the business) is getting monitored, then my advice would be for you to set up your own business to the idilic standards you seem to think exist.
Let's assume the average salary of member of the salesteam is $40 per hour and this person is spending 8 hours each week on the Internet on non-work related browsing. That is $320 a week loss on productivity, whereas a sale of $1000 could potentially be made for each hour spent on the Internet. With performance bonuses & KPI being the norm, staff are a lot more positive if they know they will get a sizeable bonus for actual work instead of not getting any due to loss in company profits, potential layoffs, fines for harassment suites borne out of visiting unacceptable web content.

by chaos-x

If your staff is being unproductive there are deeper issues than monitoring their computer usage and until you address those issues the slacking off will only manifest itself in other ways. And one does not need to run a business to be informed. That's like saying you wouldn't know if you liked something until you tried. I've never cut my hand off with a chain saw, but I'm pretty sure I wouldn't enjoy it. Believeing that any policy put in place will only be used for the best intentions and apply equally to all is very idilic. We all know there's one set of rules for the upper management and another set for the people on the floor. And as for maximizing profits, how much money is going to be spent purchasing software for monitoring usage and how much time will be spent doing it?

I'll agree that giving people a reward for good work is a great idea. But trying to squeeze every minute of everyday out of your employees is a bad idea. Treat the problem, not the symptoms.

by kawa.baha

Hi William,

I have read what you are really looking for and the tool that i am using for getting an everyday report of our internet users is an excellent. If you are in a Domain Environement you better use WebMarshal and MailMarshal in your Proxy Server and you can visit this website www.marshalsoftware.com if you want to install a trial version of any these softwares.
If i can be of any help dont hasitate to contact me at any possible time.

Regards,

Kawa Baha

by spiket

Our IT department has just implemented Surf Control Web filter (http://www.surfcontrol.com/). it is a very powerful product that provides monitoring and blocking capability. The reports are extremely flexible. I would recomend Surf Control without hesistation!

by unhappyuser

Websense does seem to be the package that sticks out. There is probably no one package that will fit perfectly but I believe it will do the trick.

This part is my standing on the podium. I usually don't do this but am tired of hearing the whiners.

I can just about tell a respondent?s age by their "political" response to you question. Not only did they not give you an answer but they also spewed out political rhetoric that shows their true mentality (spelling was a big indication too). The offspring of the Baby Boomer Generation have been brainwashed into thinking that they get to make all the rules and dang the rest of us. Considering their intelligence quotient in comparison to other generations they are, by far, the least intelligent generation so far. I see it in their work ethic whether it is government or business (big or small). With this generation, the "few bad apples" have become almost the whole basket. Businesses are responding the way they are because employee theft is at an all time high along with staff receiving training and immediately leaving for another job. If an employee's pc gets infected with malware and it causes the company money, who's responsible? The employee would say the company is because they didn't have the appropriate software installed. The software asked about in this discussion falls under that category.

Instead of always being mistrustful and making do by putting in the minimal amount perhaps this next generation can be more like their grandparents (America?s Greatest Generation)? They grew up with nothing and still put their kids through college so they could have a better life. What did that generation do? The ?ME? Generation (Baby Boomers) became the most decadent and self-serving group of Americans ever and has taught their kids even less (good).

I could go on but I won?t. Look inside yourselves young Jedi?s and see what?s really important in life and follow the path that will truly make a difference. MAKE something of yourself, DON?T EXPECT IT!

by albin.moroz

Use event viewer for remote computer. Set up profile using Mircrosoft Management console. It can then be viewed using control O.

by plumley9

Two part solution - ethereal, LanHound, Sniffer to monitor network traffic. Do not need packet level analysis. You need network statistics on what traffic, what ports, what addresses. Then you can tune your fetwork filter/firewall to block traffic the management deems inappropriate. Then if the users complain they can talk to management about why they need grokster, bit torrent, the latest news from 'DanniLive'. You have not infringed on the individual users. You have proactively protected the workspace. P.S. if you have never done this before, you will be shocked by the systems currently compromised and acting as spambot.

by hubbard

William, I sell a product called GlobeServer/FW that is an Internet access and email management control system with a builtin firewall. You can get daily, weekly, and monthly usage report totals for everyone and for each user. Reports include number of connects, time connected, and Mb's of transfer. It also includes number of emails, the bytes used, inbox size and when email was last checked. If you want more detail on Internet usage you can setup transaction tracking that gives full details of surfing habits of users. This products also has a front end firewall, easy setup of users and email addresses, works with almost any email program and has webmail, can be used to setup secure VPN connections with remote offices, and even has maillist capabilities. There is an option for site blocking and for email virus checking. It is quite a powerful software tool at a reasonable price. You can get information on our web site, www.csot.com or call me at 865-483-4373.

by tmcal

I continue to be amazed at the IT mindset and outlook as it relates to the role in a company. IT provides and performs a service to the company and its end product and bottom line just as other employees do. Comnpanies do not exist because of IT, any more than any other individual group. Companys are in business to make money and they do that through its people. The IT person here spends a significant amount time on the internet also, much of it is researching for personal issues like writing his own books, etc.
So should IT activities also be monitored?

by kenep

We use sonicwall here as our firewall, and there is a software called viewpoint that you can use that monitors the top sites that are visited per user, web usage, etc. The new version even has a ROI (return on investment) category. It is very unobtrusive.
We got this software because we were going over our usage limit with our ISP. We needed to know why.